Fitzwilliam Darcy and Elizabeth Bennet have shared more than fifty years of marriage when death finally parts them.
Only it does not last.
Darcy awakens decades in the past, just days before his first disastrous visit to the Meryton assembly. At Longbourn, Elizabeth opens her eyes to find herself twenty years old again, surrounded by the family she thought she had lost forever.
Neither knows the other remembers.
When they meet once more, Darcy is no longer the proud, distant gentleman Elizabeth first knew, and Elizabeth carries a lifetime of wisdom behind the same lively eyes. Familiar smiles, private habits, and strangely knowing remarks soon leave them both wondering whether the impossible has happened to more than one of them.
But finding one another again is only the beginning.
With the mistakes of their first lives still fresh in their memories, Darcy and Elizabeth are given an extraordinary opportunity to make different choices—for Georgiana, Jane and Bingley, Charlotte, Lydia, and the rest of the Bennet family. Yet changing the past carries consequences neither of them can predict.
This time, they must discover whether knowing what once happened is enough to create a better future—or whether love means allowing those around them to choose their own paths.
A romantic, emotional Pride and Prejudice variation about second chances, family, forgiveness, and a love strong enough to find its way home twice.
Okay - I'm pretty sure a large chunk of this story (perhaps all) is AI. Some scenes appear in a strange order - for example, Darcy is a doting father, and a few chapters later Elizabeth is pregnant with their first child. They're married and living at Pemberley, but suddenly Elizabeth is back living at Longbourn with her sisters before she married Darcy. Much of the dialogue has a repetitive pattern, too, regardless of the speaker. And this author has released nine books in the same month. Lots of clues point to AI at work here.
And yet...
The premise is truly poignant, and someone had to have given AI the idea. The story starts with Darcy at the side of seventy-six-year-old Elizabeth's deathbed. They've been blissfully married for fifty-five years, and they both know her time is close. They reminisce about their past, and Elizabeth especially wishes she had handled life with her sisters differently. I don't care if it was AI, I dare you to try to read this scene and not tear up when the inevitable happens. Darcy follows soon after her.
But then they wake up - four days before the original Meryton Assembly in their original young, healthy bodies, Darcy in London with Bingley and Elizabeth in Longbourn with her family. They both retain full memories of their past life, so they know what will happen before it does. But neither knows whether or not the other has the same pre-knowledge of the love and life they'd shared previously. The story goes on to explore how this affects the people around them as well as the trajectory of their romance.
It's a really, REALLY interesting basis for a story. Some of the phrasing (which I actually highlighted on Goodreads) struck me as being particularly notable - perhaps a human injected them, or maybe AI stole them from elsewhere.
Much as I dislike AI, I couldn't bring myself to hate this book.
Now that I’ve read more from this creator (and other very similar “authors”), I recognize that this was a generated story. The continuity errors, the weird dialogue that lacked tags, the unworkable timeline, and the nonsensical elements are now red flags for me when I’m reading.
The only thing about this story that seemed authentic were some of the emotional passages (the reason for 2-stars instead of 1)
Note: I downgraded from 3.5 to two. My original 3.5-4-star review follows after this note. I just read Lady Catherine’s Second Chance and can only conclude that this creator uses varying amounts of uncredited “help.” Second Chance bears all the marks, and you’re welcome to read my review of it.
Original review: I loved, loved, loved this story. Despite the choppy dialogue, I was fully invested until the plot malfunctioned. A child materialized from the ether in the middle of a chapter. Then Mrs Bennet wailed because Lydia was unmarried at 18, and claimed that a 21-year-old bride Elizabeth had married younger than Lydia? There were similar accounting errors regarding Kitty’s life. There’s also a picture of Longbourn that changes ownership twice.
It was concerning.
However.
However, the rest of the story was achingly beautiful. The author captured the small moments of a love story so perfectly. In fact, I don’t know whether I want to immediately reread this one or dive into another title by Ms Royce.
A whimsical, imaginative JAFF variation which starts with the deaths of very elderly Elizabeth and Darcy, and finds them returned to themselves four days before the Meryton assembly, back to their youthful ages, but with the memories and experiences of their former lives still in their consciousness. After they both establish that the other is also living this strange second life, they're faced with the conundrum of what to do with the knowledge they now have that they didn't have the first time around, and which situations they should try to alter.
It's an interesting and engaging premise, in spite of the fact that we never really want to imagine that ODC ever die. Although the writing is good, the book badly needs to be proofread to correct the glaring inconsistencies in the timeline. Dealing with a story like this of a second life makes timing complicated, to be sure, but not enough care was taken to keep events in their proper order. For example, Lydia's trip to Brighton is dealt with in one chapter, and then dealt with again differently in another. Events that have been canvassed and resolved are often resolved again differently later in the story. It's confusing and distracting enough to pull you right out of the story. However, the story in general is enjoyable and romantic. I recommend it, but it could be so much better if it was fixed up.
This has to be AI. It's just a long series of conversations. There are no clear events. Sequencing is jumbled at best. At one point, Elizabeth decides she will know tomorrow (doesn't matter what, you'll understand if you read it), but then the next paragraph is talking about her and Darcy's conversation after they know, with absolutely no break. However, the next chapter is them finally talking about this revelation, but the end of that conversation is slightly different. I had to DNF at a little past 50%. I should have known better than to read it when the cover is AI and so is the author's picture.
Seriously, I am about to give up on pride and prejudice variations entirely. The AI has taken over.
I made it through 29 pages before the signs of both AI and no editing became apparent. If someone can't be bothered to write a story without the use of AI, I can't be bothered to read it.
I loved this story. Two people, two lifetimes. A love so wonderful D&E experience it a second time with full knowledge of all the circumstances from their first life together. (There was one glaring error were a character named Clara is introduced before her birth scene occurs. I hope the author fixes this. It threw me for a loop)
Beautifully executed what-if based on after a long lifetime together, ODC both die and come back to life as themselves, with all their memories of 50+ years together intact, but just before the Meryton assembly, again aged 20 and 28. The style, for the most part, is short, simple, one-sentence paragraphs. If such a style offends you, don't read this book. How D and E manage their second chance at a lifetime together, and how they decide, based on their previous lifetime's knowledge, to influence or not influence their loved ones, is most satisfying.
can i give 0 stars? interesting premise!! I was so interested and excited! but its terrible. I couldnt finish it.
as with other works by this author, AI is clearly used, and BOY OH BOY does this work suffer for it. I guess that time travelling/reborn again is very difficult for AI to understand? the timeline in the beginning segment that i read is atrocious. they spend weeks signalling to each other EXTREMELY OBVIOUSLY that they are both returned, and theres not like, segments of them then thinking about how its not possible - or there are a few but its like ... a premise so thin that you couldn't see it if it turned sideways. they do this, apparently, for weeks. Weeks which are ... mostly not explained except a few awkward incidents.
their return also doesnt seem to change the way they behave other than that. no one thinks they are acting strange... its just bad. don't read it.
and to the author, please please please dont give up on writing, but please actually write!!
While the concept was original and I loved the idea of them reliving their younger selves. The story jumped around a lot and didn't make sense. I stopped reading about 50% in. One scene it would talk about Mr. Collins proposing and then several pages later he was proposing again. Also lots of times Mr. Darcy and Elizabeth were in the same room together which wouldn't make sense. Elizabeth was just hanging out at Netherfield? Or in a carriage together? They weren't married yet. I also didn't like the fact that Mrs. Bennet was still cold to Mr. Darcy or upset that Elizabeth turned down Mr. Collins. At this point Mr. Darcy has made his interest clean in Elizabeth. Mrs. Bennet would be pushing that match hard core. I did love Darcy and Elizabeth's back and forths. They did seem like an old married couple. But that was it.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
The idea was fine, the execution was terrible. There was no coherent storyline and events jumped around constantly. Lydia was in Brighton, then she came home, then she was invited to go, then she left, then she came home again. Similar jumps happened constantly. Not worth the time.
While the hand of AI is obvious (AI can't manage timelines, and this one repeats scenes as many as three times. It gives away a drawing hanging on Mr Bennet's wall for one wedding, then has it hanging there years later. They've left Longbourn, then they're back again--frequently. Darcy is holding his daughter. Then she's born in the following scene.) it isn't nearly as repetitive as much recently published AI has been, talks about the shapes of intangible things only three times, and avoids some of the more annoying sentence constructions, although not the staccato dialogue in which it's important to speak in as few words as possible. In short, while the errors made things absurd at times, it was still readable. Having read it through KU, I wouldn't kick it out of bed for eating crackers.
This was a unique and sweet story. I enjoyed the premise and the small changes that impacted the original outcomes from their first marriage. My only critique is the ordering. Some of the chapters seem to be out of order and I don’t know if it is truly by design. For example, there’s a chapter were Elizabeth has her first child and I’m reading trying to figure out who this daughter is because it was never explained. And then the author explains the birth in the following chapter. It just seems like she could have switched the two chapters and had a more cohesive story. This happened several other times. So I think a good editor would go a long way for this author.
What a premise... It is masterfully handled. Elizabeth and Darcy meet again at age 20 & 28 remembering the past. They circle eachother not trusting what they remember. When they finally figure out what is going on, they need to learn how to be their younger selves with 50 years of memories as husband and wife. Then they must make a decision of whether or not to direct the lives of those around them based on what happened before.
Especially easy to read with short, succinct conversations and not all the meandering angst in the heads of Darcy and Elizabeth that so many authors seem to love to write.
I loved this variation. I was unique and allowed a certain creative freedom to the story. The reader is given a greater incite into each beloved character which other variations have not been able to accomplish. Definitely worth reading
But it needs a good edit! I simply could not give it 5 stars because the often illogical shuffling of the timeline. It was bizarre. The reader never knows where ODC are in the new life. Characters, we did not know, were mentioned in one chapter and then we were officially given the explanation of who they were 2 chapters later?
I purchased this book earlier this evening. It is a quick read, though a wonderful story. The story was wonderful. There were surprises throughout, though the characters remained the same in essentials. What struck me most was the style of writing. It is very unique and not one I've come across in any genre. Not that this is a bad thing. Really, given this is a shorter novella, it worked out perfectly. Some may find the style jarring, it is fast paced and bluntly too the point. However the emotion remained. As I said, unique.
I read a poor review that complained of the writer's use of one sentence or one word paragraphs, and I understand their frustration. However, the wonderful dialog and beautiful sentiments made it difficult to be frustration with this writing style. It was an easy style if simplistic to read, and a truely a wonderful story. Who hasn't wondered what a do over would look like. I loved it!
Overall, this is an excellent story. I really enjoyed it. However, the timeline swings back and forth wildly. At one point Darcy is playing with their child and then in the next chapter, Elizabeth has just discovered she’s pregnant. I would give this story five stars if I didn’t have to keep trying to figure out when and where the story was at at any given point.
I rarely give book reviews but I thought this one deserved an answer for the 3 stars. The story is wonderful, Darcy and Lizzy’s courtship is sweet and unique. But the story is a bit out of order and I miss a bit with the way the dialogue has been written. If it had a bit more editing and some of the story exiting in the correct order I would have given 4 stars for the humor alone.
FIND ME SOONER….. what an interesting idea to consider. This story made me fall in love with Darcy and Elizabeth’s journey all over again. Thoughtful and touching on so many lives with better outcomes made this second chance an emotional journey. I liked how the path was “different” , bringing about both happiness for the present and somber reflection for the past. Tears experienced at the end revealed just how much this story spoke to me.
I’m a dedicated fan of P&P and I thought this was excellent. Every chapter/arc felt well rounded and like it truly hit at the heart of each “missing piece” from the narrative the first time around. The life lessons sprinkled throughout the narrative were perfectly sincere, in such a way that none of them ever came across as preachy or self-aggrandizing. Well done and 5 stars well deserved
I really like this book. It was mentioned in a JAFF FB group and I realized I already borrowed it, but hadn’t started it yet. It is a sweet second chance story that has it sad moments. I would love this to be an audiobook. There are some sections that are a little confusing. An editor may help clean it up, but I would still recommend reading this very lovely story.
One of the loveliest Pride and Prejudice variations I’ve ever read.
I rarely give 5 stars. This was worthy. It is written in a style that I had never considered but that seemed to add to the emotional punch that it packed. I wish I could read it again for the first time.
I love this creative retelling!! Very imaginative and beautifully written.
Maybe its because my own beloved husband passed 2 and half years ago. Maybe its because I believe i will find him again, hopefully sooner, in our next life. But this story resonated with truth for me. Thank you.
This variation was amazing! So unique and lovely. To love twice over for ODC was wonderful to experience. I love the style of this author, she’s direct, the story moves and doesn’t get stalled on unnecessary commentary. Well done. There were some editing snafus but forgiven because so good.
The were some contradictions in the different chapters that almost made me knock off a star but the end was so moving that I just couldn’t! A very sweet, touching story of second chances to make better decisions. Warning: make sure to have plenty of tissue on hand for the end!
Absolutely wonderful story! I'm presently on my 3rd time reading, besides purchasing the story for my Kindle Fire Library! Darcy and Lizzy are given a Chance to come back to an earlier time in their lives and change things according to their wishes and desires! Lovely story from beginning to end!
What a revelation!! This story is very thought provoking. Not only the characters in the story itself, but with what you would had done differently if you had your life to do over again. A very beautiful & emotional story, one that will remain in my thoughts and actually change life choices for the better.
A wonderful variation based off our favorite P&P characters. Knowing the story does not detract from this version. It offers greater hope and happiness. It doesn't change the characters swiftly; it allows the characters to develop due to greater understanding. Thus it gives greater hope and understanding now.