Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Bonfire & Betrayal

Rate this book
As Harper Whitmore settles into life in the perpetually autumnal town of Fall, Michigan, Hearth & Quill is thriving, her friendships are stronger than ever, and her relationship with handsome orchard owner Gabe Sullivan is beginning to feel like something more. But as the town prepares for its beloved Autumn Blaze Festival, a mystery buried for a decade suddenly comes back to life.

Ten years ago, Thomas Pennington vanished from Maple Grove Dairy without a trace. Now his disappearance has caught the attention of Lena Cross and Theo Marsh, hosts of the popular true-crime podcast Motor City Mysteries. Their arrival has everyone in Fall talking—and not everyone is happy to see the past being dug up. When Harper discovers old documents hidden inside Hearth & Quill that may be connected to Thomas, she finds herself drawn into another investigation.

The deeper Harper digs, the more she uncovers a tangled history of loans, suspicious land deals, old romances, and betrayal. Someone is determined to keep the truth buried, and Harper must figure out what really happened to Thomas before another secret disappears into the flames.

Brimming with crackling bonfires, small-town secrets, slow-burn romance, and page-turning intrigue, Bonfire & Betrayal is the perfect cozy mystery to curl up with on a crisp autumn night.

382 pages, Paperback

Published September 1, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Jules Motschall

3 books57 followers
Jules Motschall writes the kind of books she loves to read: twisty mysteries filled with small-town secrets, a dash of wit, and plenty of slow-burn romance.
An avid reader and lifelong book lover, Jules can rarely resist a bookstore or library. She firmly believes everything is improved by a good book, a strong cup of coffee, and a fall-scented candle.

Her debut novel, Autumn & Alibis, introduced readers to the perpetually autumnal town of Fall, Michigan, and launched the Hearth & Quill Mystery series. The story continues in Bonfire & Betrayal, with more buried secrets, small-town drama, slow-burn romance, and, naturally, another mystery for Harper Whitmore to unravel.

When Jules isn’t plotting fictional crimes in Fall, she’s probably juggling her TBR pile, experimenting with new hobbies, and buying more planners (and pens!) than one person could ever use.

Originally from Michigan, Jules lives in the Chicago area with her husband, children, chickens, two cats, and a mini Goldendoodle.

Jules is also working on a spicy romance series, proving she can’t resist writing about love—be it tangled up with murder or tangled up in the sheets.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
16 (47%)
4 stars
12 (35%)
3 stars
5 (14%)
2 stars
1 (2%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 10 of 10 reviews
1 review
September 1, 2026
If you’re looking for the perfect book to end summer and get you excited for fall, Bonfire & Betrayals by Jules Motshall is it! 🍂

This book brings you right into the cozy fall season in Fall, Michigan, and I loved the small-town vibes. It just has that warm, familiar feeling that makes you want to curl up and keep reading.

The mystery had me hooked and there were definitely moments where I thought I had things figured out… and then I was completely wrong! There’s a twist I NEVER saw coming, and the ending actually left me thinking about it after I finished.

This is book two in the series, and while I had already read Autumn & Alibis (which I also really enjoyed!), I honestly think you could start with this one and still follow along just fine. But fair warning—you’ll probably end up wanting to go back and read the first one too!

There are still so many things left unsolved, which makes me even more excited for book three. I need to know what happens next!

If you love small towns, cozy fall settings, mysteries, and books that keep you guessing, definitely add Bonfire & Betrayals to your fall TBR. 🍁📚
Profile Image for Jeanne.
8 reviews
September 1, 2026
Loved this book! Fortunate enough to try as a advanced copy reader and was so glad for the opportunity!

Fall, Michigan welcomed me back like a cozy hug. With somehow MORE autumn themed everything, the story picked up right where it left off (from Autumn & Alibis), with Harper navigating a new town, found family, and somehow settling in at the BUSIEST time of year (moving to a fall-themed town in August, girl what were you thinking?!).

Adding true crime podcasters into the character mix was really fun and added depth to everything that goes on in Fall. The mystery kept me suspecting everyone, and was a surprise in the end!

Book 2 of Hearth & Quill mysteries brings beautiful prose (“smile like firelight”), a slow-burn romance that finallyyyyy might go somewhere, and a cozy mystery to start the season off right!
Profile Image for Cozy Reader Lady.
1,221 reviews151 followers
September 14, 2026
"Bonfire & Betrayal (A Hearth & Quill Mystery Book 2)" by Jules Motschall. I have to say that this one really sucked me in and had me bouncing around who the killer could be. I didn't see that ending coming but had my suspicions that particular person. They knew more than were was saying and kept popping up.

Nice fall and Halloween cozy mystery set in fictional Fall, Michigan. The characters are really feeling settled in and established. Still character growth happening but it's not rushed. I look forward to more of this series.
Profile Image for Anne.
87 reviews
September 2, 2026
A perfect Fall read as we enter the -ber months. I'm so glad I got an early preview as an ARC reader!! I couldn't wait to jump back in to Fall, MI and see what all of the characters are up to.

I loved the new mystery and the introduction of the podcast! I was certain I had it figured it out. Man, was I shocked when I was wrong. The slow burn was epic between Harper and Gabe.

This book will leave you wanting more Fall, MI, all the food, and more romance between Harper & Gabe. I already can't wait for book 3. The only thing missing is a cookbook to go along with all of the delicious food mentioned! 💕¹
Profile Image for Lisa Markowski.
1 review
September 3, 2026
I was lucky enough to get Bonfire and Betrayal as an ARC reader! And once again, she captured all the feels of Fall, Michigan…even with all the murders and mystery-I find myself wanting to live there! 🍁

I enjoyed the addition of the podcasters and thought they added an interesting element to the story! I also liked the slow-burn relationship and seeing it (finally!) develop throughout the book.

Can’t wait to cozy up with Cider and Conspiracies! ☕️
1 review
Review of advance copy received from Author
August 31, 2026
If you loved Autumn & Alibis, you are absolutely going to want to head back to Fall, Michigan for Bonfires & Betrayal!

There is just something about Jules Motschall’s little town of Fall that pulls you in. The cozy bookstore, the small-town friendships, the autumn atmosphere, the bonfires, the secrets, and of course the mystery that makes you start looking at EVERYONE a little sideways.

Harper Whitmore is settling into her new life, and I really enjoyed watching her continue to find her place in the community. Her relationship with Gabe also continues to develop, and if you’ve been patiently waiting for that slow burn to finally give us a little something- Jules understood the assignment.

The mystery surrounding Thomas Pennington’s disappearance kept me guessing, and I especially loved the way the story slowly pieced together clues from the past. What begins as a decades-old disappearance becomes something much more complicated, and much more heartbreaking, than I expected.

But what really stood out to me was that beneath the mystery, this book is about love, fear, secrets, regret, and the consequences of the choices we make when we’re scared. Sometimes the most devastating betrayal isn’t what someone does in a single moment, but what happens when they spend years choosing not to tell the truth.

And, as with the first book, the people of Fall are just as much a part of the story as the mystery itself. There is something so comforting about the friendships, the food, the bookstore, the community, and that feeling of everyone showing up for one another when life gets messy.

Jules has created the kind of fictional town that makes you want to curl up with a blanket, a cup of tea, a good book, and stay awhile.

Bonfires & Betrayal is cozy, atmospheric, emotional, and full of small-town secrets. If you enjoy cozy mysteries with romance, found-family vibes, and an autumn setting you can practically smell through the pages, add this one to your TBR!
Profile Image for Danielle.
163 reviews56 followers
September 1, 2026
After reading and absolutely LOVING Autumn & Alibis, I was beyond thrilled to be given the opportunity to receive an ARC of this second book in the Hearth & Quill series. I feel confident in saying that there has never been a setting that I have wanted to live in like the one that Jules has created with the fictional town of Fall, Michigan. I live in Michigan and fall is my favorite time of year, so she basically encapsulates everything I love most about all of it. Just like in the first book, I did not guess the mystery outcome at all, so that's always a plus. Seriously though, my favorite part about these books are the characters and the setting. I absolutely love the characters and their friendships and relationships. I also love a good slow burn romance and no spice, so I am all about the way that part is going. Oh, how I wish Fall were a real place, because I would be busting up into the Hearth & Quill bookstore and telling Harper I'll man the store while she goes out and solves the mysteries. The way the bookstore and every other place in these books are described is just perfection! Also, if you are a fan of delicious food, you are going to absolutely love these books. This book introduced something so fun, that was very different from the first book, in the addition of a podcast element. Having two true crime podcasters come into Fall from Detroit, to investigate a 10 year old disappearance, was such a cool thing to add to the story. There are still so many things to discover about the bookstore (if you're into secret passageways, you'll love this) and the people who live in Fall, and I'm already missing them and greatly anticipating when I'll get to meet back up with them again. All this to say, I loved this book, and I can't wait for the next book in the series!
Profile Image for Lea.
3,048 reviews61 followers
November 8, 2026
I love this town, I love the super fall vibes in everything. The mystery is so interesting. But I don’t love the writing. The prologue should have just been chapter 1. Writing out the podcast transcript after the previous chapter was the confession was unnecessary - it was just the same thing twice. There’s also story lines that aren’t followed up - the spooky stories, accusing a powerful man in town of murder in public, why her aunt had so much town history in the basement.
Profile Image for D Muny.
10 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 1, 2026
I received an arc of this book and I loved it. I read the 1st book Autumn and Alibis. This is a super cozy mystery series. There are fun hidden doors and gives its fall y'all vibes. Just be prepared to want all the food and drinks in this book. I want a s'more bad now! Fun read for fall!
6 reviews
October 5, 2026
Loved this book! Fall is my favorite time of year and Fall is definitely a town I would love to visit! 🍁
Displaying 1 - 10 of 10 reviews