Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Mothers: A Thriller

Not yet published
Expected 11 May 27
Rate this book
A gripping debut in which a woman struggles to adapt to motherhood—but before she can, her baby vanishes—perfect for fans of Ashley Audrain’s Good Morning America pick The Push.

Maggie Fergason has dreamed of having a family of her own her whole life. But in the first few weeks after her daughter Rosie’s birth, that dream becomes a waking nightmare. She finds things rearranged with no memory of ever touching them. People are seeing her in places she’s never been. And she’s the only one who seems to hear a haunting lullaby echoing through the baby monitor.

Everyone reaches the same Maggie is falling apart.

When Rosie disappears from her crib in the dead of night, no one believes her when she says she wouldn’t hurt her child. But Maggie is certain she would never, ever put Rosie in harm’s way.

Now Maggie must fight to prove her sanity and find her daughter before it’s too late. But the closer she gets to the truth, the more lies and secrets she uncovers, reaching all the way back to a childhood she barely remembers. Because the ugliest and most dangerous truth is the one hiding in her mirror.

With the tension of Gone Girl and the emotional gut punch of Then She Was Gone, The Mothers is a heart-pounding exploration of memory and the shattering cost of family secrets.

Kindle Edition

Expected publication May 11, 2027

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Natalie Banks

7 books312 followers
Natalie Banks is a best selling & award-winning author, including, Best Indie Book of 2024 and The North Carolina Governor's Writing Award. She weaves characters with relatable humanity and stories that touch the heart and soul. She is currently working on a suspense novel set to release in 2025. When not writing, she spends time on the beach in North Carolina with her husband and dogs.

To find out more about Natalie Banks, visit her website NatalieBanks.net

And be sure to sign up for her newsletter to receive short stories and sneak peeks into her future novels!

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
22 (28%)
4 stars
30 (38%)
3 stars
21 (26%)
2 stars
2 (2%)
1 star
3 (3%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 60 reviews
Profile Image for The Chapter Belle.
146 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 15, 2026
Maggie Fergason has always wanted to be a mother. But when her baby, Rosie, is born, motherhood isn’t quite what she imagined. Her marriage has changed, her hormones are out of control, she hasn’t slept in what feels like forever, and postpartum depression is weighing heavily on her.

To make matters worse, everyone - from her husband to her mother to her neighbor - keeps asking the same question: Is she sure she’s okay?

And then strange things start happening.

Items are moved from where Maggie knows she left them. Purchases appear that she doesn’t remember making. People claim to have seen her in places she definitely wasn’t. A creepy lullaby comes through the baby monitor. And the bizarre occurrences just keep piling up.

Maggie begins to wonder if everyone else is right. Maybe she really is losing her mind.

Then baby Rosie disappears.

Maggie is sent to a psychiatric ward, but she realizes something terrifying. She isn’t the one who’s insane. Someone is doing this to her.

But who? And why?

Full of twists, turns, red herrings, tension, and secrets, The Mothers was absolutely unputdownable. And dare I say…I think it finally got me out of my reading slump. HALLELUJAH.

Beyond the mystery itself, Banks did a phenomenal job capturing what new mothers can experience in such an empathetic and realistic way—the exhaustion, isolation, hormonal changes, self-doubt, and the feeling that everyone around you is questioning whether you can trust your own instincts. I also really appreciated the way she explored some of the unthinkable situations mothers may find themselves in and how a single decision or moment can continue to affect someone far into the future.

The mystery kept me guessing, the tension kept me reading, and I genuinely did not want to put this one down. This was my first book by Natalie Banks, but it definitely won’t be my last! Solid 4.5 stars rounded to FIVE!

Huge thanks to NetGalley and Crooked Lane Books for the ARC!
Profile Image for KBeansbook.
201 reviews6 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 15, 2026
Natalie Banks has written a story that is harrowing captivating and will literally knock you off you feet! Maggie, a new mother to Rosie is struggling through postpartum, severe exhaustion from lack of sleep and and overwhelming hormones that she had no control of. Feeling like a failure for giving up breastfeeding because she was in too much pain, feeling inadequate as a Mom when Rosie can’t settle down and constantly misplacing and forgetting things. Everyone from her mother, her husband Cameron and even her neighbor Bertie compound her inner doubts and insecurities, making her feel as if she’s losing her mind.
Soon things around her home are being moved, yet she swears she isn’t doing it. On advice to get out of the house for awhile and use a sitter named Erin, Maggie starts to volunteer at a shelter and she loves it. She sees a doctor and is beginning to feel so much better but neighbors are telling her that they see her places and she knows she wasn’t there, her husband is telling her she did or said things she swears she hasn’t and Erin even asks continuously if she’s okay and questions her about incidents she says happen yet Maggie wracks her brain and has zero memory of anything of the sort going on.
When she begins to hear singing on the monitor, voices in the babies room, footsteps at night and her back door wide open when she knows she had double checked the locks and shut it, she begins to unravel. Her husband and mother grow increasingly concerned when Bertie tells Cameron she saw Maggie with Rosie outside in the middle of night and the baby in a onesie with no blanket or jacket her husband and mother become more concerned and refuse to believe she’s not lying about any of these alleged incidents yet soon she begins questioning her own reality and mental state. When Cameron wakes her up one night asking her where Rosie is, she is confused, she knows she put her in her crib before going to bed yet she is gone, The police are called in, Maggie is sent to a psych ward where her psychiatrist thankfully believes Maggie and after evaluating her sees no evidence of psychosis or suicidal tendencies or violent ones she is released, yet Rosie is still missing. Naturally, everyone even the police suspect she’s behind the baby’s disappearance. When the police show them video from a neighbors Ring footage of Maggie running down the street with Maggie on the night of the disappearance Maggie knows she must figure out who has her child and why they’re doing this to her and how before it’s too late.
I’m still reeling from the dizzying plot twists and the cunning, clever and thrilling nature of this story, For the mystery and suspense and THRILLER loving genre fans, THIS IS THE BOOK OF THE YEAR, hands down!
Thank you so much to #Netgalley for this advanced reading copy of #TheMothers and to #NatalieBanks for writing such a phenomenal book and a huge thank you to #CrookedLaneBooks for trusting me with my opinion of this book and the opportunity to read it before it is published to the masses. I’m extremely grateful.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for BookSloth.
78 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 16, 2026
A huge thank you to Natalie Banks, Crooked Lane Books and NetGalley for the advance copy.

It has been a very long time since BookSloth has willingly stayed up past her bedtime for a book.

BookSloth likes sleep.

BookSloth considers sleep one of life’s major achievements.

And yet there she was, far later than any sensible sloth should be awake, telling herself, Just one more chapter.

The Mothers is so good.

Maggie has always wanted to be a mother, but after the birth of her daughter, Rosie, motherhood looks nothing like the life she imagined. She’s exhausted, struggling with postnatal depression and increasingly unsure whether she can trust her own mind.

And Natalie Banks captures that strange fog of those early days of motherhood so well.

BookSloth remembers it.

Putting the Marmite in the fridge. Walking into a room and having absolutely no idea why you’re there. Never being able to find your phone.

Actually, that last one still happens.

But beneath those little moments is something much darker: the exhaustion, isolation and frightening sense of no longer quite trusting yourself. And when other people begin questioning Maggie too, it becomes increasingly difficult to know what—or whom—to believe.

And this book becomes almost impossible to put down.

BookSloth had theories.

Several theories.

BookSloth was extremely pleased with her theories.

BookSloth was wrong.

Because THE TWIST.

Oh, the twist is fantastic.

The Mothers is the kind of thriller that makes ‘just one more chapter’ a terrible idea. Compulsive, unsettling and brilliantly twisty—and then the epilogue made me cry.

After all that tension and second-guessing and frantic page-turning, Natalie Banks somehow found one last emotional button to press.

I repeat: This book is SO good.

Five BookSloths in pyjamas under a duvet at 2 a.m. One is reading. Three are arguing about the twist. One has already reached the epilogue and is sobbing into a pillow.
🦥 🦥 🦥 🦥 🦥
Profile Image for Javierthearcnovice.
387 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 15, 2026
I was on edge from start to finish. The writing and story is engaging which makes this one heck of a thriller. It was tough to get through as a father, who has lost a child, but I’m glad I finished it. Things are not always what they seem.

Thank you Natalie for fighting to keep your original ARC team.
60 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 16, 2026
This book had me questioning everyone — and I mean EVERYONE!

Natalie Banks is a new author for me, but after reading this book, I can honestly say I’m a fan, and I’ll definitely be looking for more of her work.

Poor Rosie’s new mom is exhausted, overwhelmed, and beginning to wonder if she’s losing her mind. Her baby is still just an infant, she isn’t sleeping, and she can’t figure out whether what she’s experiencing is postpartum depression or something much more sinister.

And then the paranoia starts.

Her new babysitter. Her husband. Her crazy neighbor. Her mother. It seems like everyone has an agenda, and I found myself wondering right along with her: Who can she trust? Is she imagining all of this? And what is really happening?

I’ll admit that, because I’ve read A LOT of mysteries and thrillers, I started to figure out what was going on toward the end. But surprisingly, that didn’t take away from the story at all. The tension, the emotions, and the sheer creepiness kept me completely invested.

This book took me into some seriously dark places. It was creepy, emotional, unsettling, and had me second-guessing what was real and what wasn’t.

If you love mysteries and psychological suspense that make you question everyone, add this one to your list.

And the best part? I think I just discovered a new author that I really, really like! I’ll definitely be reading more Natalie Banks.
Profile Image for Staci.
26 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 19, 2026
I really enjoyed this one! I loved the characters, and I thought the author did a great job portraying the main character’s postpartum depression. It felt realistic and added a lot to her character.

I wanted to keep reading and find out what was going to happen. The ending was not something I guessed, but once I got there, I was kind of like… oh. 😂 It felt a little too easy for me, but overall I really enjoyed the book!
Profile Image for Lauren Ateyeh .
208 reviews11 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 17, 2026
This one messed with my head in the best way. Maggie's convinced she's losing her mind after her baby vanishes, and nobody believes her, the twists just kept coming. Could not put it down. 4/5 stars! Thank you, NetGalley!
Profile Image for Stephanie Peterman.
230 reviews4 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 18, 2026
The Mothers had me on the edge of my seat and questioning everything from the jump, especially our FMC maggie who's POV isn't as unreliable as it initially appears to be. i really appreciate thrillers that constantly keep you guessing, and even as i got closer to the end, when i thought the author might veer into a post-partum psychosis territory and it seemed like a really promising thriller-turned-social-commentary on the real pressures many new moms face, but then... the twist. and then... the double twist. the reveal certainly caught me off-guard, but not in a satisfying way... more of a convenient scapegoat kind of way with too much exposition to neatly wrap everything up at the very end. overall, the writing is great and the story itself is absolutely gripping! i do think it needs an alternative title though... and i have some ideas :)

- The Mother in the Mirror
- The Other Mother Is Me
- Mother Maggie
- Trust Me, I'm Her Mother
- Rock-a-Bye Rosie

Book review image
#alternativetitles
Profile Image for Stephanie.
1,261 reviews1,050 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 20, 2026
Okay (cracks knuckles) I had to pull out the laptop for this review so I could type my review like that Kermit the Frog GIF.

Rant incoming.

THIS IS THE MOST CLUELESS GROUP OF PEOPLE I'VE EVER ENCOUNTERED IN MY ENTIRE 49 YEARS.

Skip this part if you don't want spoilers.

.
.
.
.
.
.
I warned you
.
.
.
.
.

What. Is. Wrong. With. These. NUMBSKULLS.
The gaslighting, the repetition, the absence of critical thinking...
MAYBE BELIEVE YOUR EFFING WIFE?
MAYBE GET A CAMERA if weird things are happening?
MAYBE CHANGE YOUR LOCKS as soon as someone starts coming in your house?
MAYBE remove your baby from the room if you hear someone in there?
MAYBE don't sell your five year old?
MAYBE THINK your sold child still exists and if your other daughter is being told she did things she swears she didn't do, perhaps it is her IDENTICAL twin?
MAYBE don't be a douchecanoe husband that sleeps with the identical twin multiple times without noticing a single difference- even if she has a tattoo that your wife never had?
MAYBE HAVE A SINGLE BRAIN CELL BETWEEN ALLLL OF YOU?
AND YET AGAIN maybe change your locks when you realize your psycho twin sister (but I can't blame her her idiot mother randomly picked a twin to sell at 5 years old to an abuser for cold hard cash without even knowing his last name) is on the loose and has your baby and a key to your house?

Sorry that's it. I'm done. Promise. I would give this less than one star but I was hooked and locked in at the beginning before it became the most ludicrous, unbelievable thing I'd ever read. You have gottt to be kidding meeee.
14 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 20, 2026
First, I have to say, since I’m a guy, I didn’t relate to the post-partum part of the story. But that being said, I really enjoyed it. The writing was clear, dialogue crisp, and the characters were alive on the page. This story actually reminded me of a 90’s thriller-easier to digest, which I enjoyed. The twist at the end- not the first twist, the one inside the twist actually really took me by surprise and I thought it was a brilliant yet heartbreaking move. Fast read for me. Half a day. Thank you to Crooked Lane Books for the early copy in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Danielle.
138 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 20, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley and Crooked Lane Publishers for a copy of this ARC.

I really enjoyed The Mothers for most of the book. The story pulled me in, and I was invested in the characters and the mystery. The pacing kept me turning the pages, and I was genuinely curious to see how everything would come together.
Unfortunately, the reveal didn’t quite work for me. Without giving anything away, it felt a little too far-fetched and made the ending less satisfying than I had hoped. I could see what the author was going for, but I had a hard time buying into it.
Overall, still a good, engaging read—I just wish the big reveal had felt a little more believable. The journey was definitely more enjoyable for me than the destination. Rounded up 3.5 stars.
Profile Image for ReadingHamster.
19 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 21, 2026
A very suspenseful story that will keep you guessing till the end. Maggie was such a complicated character. I didn’t know whether or not to trust her. She was very entertaining and her love for her daughter was beautiful. I didn’t much trust Erin. But it was great how she was there for Maggie. I kind of suspected the twist considering how things seemed so confusing. I did like the reveal though. Even though it seemed unlikely. A great story which shows how hard being a mother truly is.
Profile Image for Lilly.
28 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 18, 2026
I went into this thinking it was going to be a full on thriller .. and it was sorta. It was actually more of a cozy mystery with some darker twists. I really enjoyed this book overall. I feel the thriller tag is wrong… I’d reclassify it as a suspense. But well worth the read.
6 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy
September 22, 2026
I received this book as an ARC in exchange for an honest review. I am a huge Natalie Banks fan so I jumped at the chance to read her new one. And I was not disappointed at all. It had the same heart pounding thrill with a positive spin that I was expecting. So happy I got to read it.
Profile Image for Mike.
1,586 reviews94 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 22, 2026
A thriller mystery tale, The Mothers (2026) by Natalie Banks is a tale of a new mother battling sleepiness and strange occurrences. Maggie Fergason is fatigued and begins to hear rock-a-bye baby playing on her baby monitor. She then discovers things are rearranged, without her touching them and she is seen in places she wasn’t. Her mother and husband Cameron are concerned about her strange behaviour, and the hiring of a babysitter only seems to exacerbate things. As rising tensions and questions of Maggie’s sanity grow, her baby Rosie disappears, and she is blamed and hospitalised. A gripping thriller, if a somewhat dubious twist, with a four star read rating. As always, the opinions herein are totally my own, freely given and without any inducement.
Profile Image for Carrie Shields.
1,905 reviews243 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 21, 2026
𝑰 𝒅𝒊𝒅𝒏'𝒕 𝒌𝒏𝒐𝒘 𝒃𝒆𝒊𝒏𝒈 𝒂 𝒎𝒐𝒎 𝒘𝒐𝒖𝒍𝒅 𝒃𝒆 𝒕𝒉𝒊𝒔 𝒉𝒂𝒓𝒅. 𝑷𝒆𝒐𝒑𝒍𝒆 𝒕𝒆𝒍𝒍 𝒚𝒐𝒖 𝒊𝒕'𝒔 𝒕𝒉𝒆 𝒎𝒐𝒔𝒕 𝒃𝒆𝒂𝒖𝒕𝒊𝒇𝒖𝒍 𝒕𝒉𝒊𝒏𝒈 𝒊𝒏 𝒕𝒉𝒆 𝒘𝒐𝒓𝒍𝒅, 𝒂𝒏𝒅 𝒊𝒕 𝒊𝒔. 𝑩𝒖𝒕 𝒕𝒉𝒆𝒚 𝒇𝒐𝒓𝒈𝒆𝒕 𝒕𝒐 𝒎𝒆𝒏𝒕𝒊𝒐𝒏 𝒉𝒐𝒘 𝒍𝒐𝒏𝒆𝒍𝒚 𝒊𝒕 𝒄𝒂𝒏 𝒇𝒆𝒆𝒍.

Unfortunately, this book also reminded me how lonely it can feel when you’re halfway through a thriller and realize you have absolutely no idea where it’s going, but you’re fairly certain you won’t like the destination.

Maggie Fergason has always dreamed of motherhood, but after her daughter Rosie is born, she begins experiencing unsettling lapses in memory, strange occurrences, and a haunting lullaby coming through the baby monitor. When Rosie disappears from her crib, everyone assumes Maggie is responsible. As she fights to prove her sanity and uncover what happened to her daughter, long-buried family secrets begin to surface. I went into this expecting a psychological thriller centered around postpartum psychosis, a subject I’ve read about in several compelling books recently. Initially, everything seemed promising.

Then the eyerolls and dramatic sighs started. Soon, I had rolled my eyes so many times I genuinely feared for my safety. And when THAT tired, overused, trite twist arrived, I wanted to scream. Okay, I actually did scream. From there, I proceeded to hate-read the remainder of the book, hoping something would redeem the experience. It did not help that nearly every character made one baffling decision after another, leaving me wondering how an entire cast of people could collectively possess so little common sense. I appreciate the effort to explore motherhood, memory, and family secrets, but the execution simply did not work for me. Respectfully, this was not the thriller I thought I was getting. Thank you to Crooked Lane Books for this early copy that will publish May 11, 2027.
Profile Image for Tiffany Haineault.
144 reviews6 followers
October 28, 2026
Thanks to NetGalley for an advanced readers copy

I had a fantastic time reading this book. And when I say fantastic, I mean u was extremely angry for about 70% of this book. Just livid for what Maggie was experiencing.

She’s a new mother, experiencing a lot of postpartum feelings. Leaning a bit towards depression. Then things start to happen around her house, time slips by and things aren’t adding up. When she believes she was out and about, her nanny or husband advise her that she was home with them. When she believes she’s sleeping in bed or taking a nap, everyone around her tells her she wasn’t even in the house. They tell her she’s missing periods of time. She tells them she remember everything clearly. Something isn’t adding and suspicion falls into Maggie when her newborn goes missing in the middle of the night.

I was getting so mad for Maggie and what she was experiencing. Especially with the specific theory I had in mind with what was happening. I was furious for what she was being put through, how people believed she was losing her mind. Especially being only a few months postpartum. I felt for her in so many ways. I wanted to tell her that I was on her side when no one was.

I till said, there’s a twist in here that I honestly never saw coming. Looking back at the beginning of the book and how it made references to certain things, I can see where the twist came from. But it wasn’t obvious to me and I would have never seen it coming.

I just had such a fun time with this read. I’d highly recommend it!
Profile Image for Christine M in Texas (stamperlady50).
2,285 reviews290 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 24, 2026
As mother of two this story gripped my attention. When a mother is questioned about simple daily activities like ignoring her child or a neighbor and her husband is worried about her that is crippling.

I went to post-partum depression and so many other scenarios. You don't get to find out what is truly happening until 3/4 of the way through and I was so shocked at the twist. I love books in where I have no idea what is happening throughout the story.

Way to go Banks!
Profile Image for Linda Ayala.
Author 4 books9 followers
October 16, 2026
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5 Stars (ARC via NetGalley)

Now THIS is how you write a psychological thriller!

The Mothers by Natalie Banks had me hooked from the very first page, and I mean that quite literally. The prologue immediately grabbed my attention, and from that moment on, I was completely invested in figuring out what the hell was going on.

Honestly, I would have finished all 290 pages in one sitting if I didn’t have to go to work. 😂

The story follows Maggie Fergason, a new mother who has spent her entire life dreaming of having a family. But motherhood isn’t exactly turning out the way she imagined. She’s struggling with postpartum depression, questioning herself constantly, and trying to navigate the overwhelming emotional and physical demands of caring for a newborn.

And honestly, who can’t relate to that feeling of being completely overwhelmed, second-guessing yourself, and wondering whether you’re doing anything right?

But Maggie’s situation takes a much darker turn when strange things begin happening around her.

Objects are being moved without her remembering touching them. People insist they’ve seen her in places she doesn’t remember visiting. And then there’s the haunting lullaby coming through the baby monitor that apparently nobody else can hear.

Excuse me?!

As if being a new mother isn’t stressful enough, now Maggie has to question whether she can even trust her own mind.

And the worst part?

Nobody believes her.

Everyone around Maggie seems convinced she’s unraveling, and the more she tries to defend herself, the more suspicious everything becomes. Then her baby daughter, Rosie, disappears from her crib in the middle of the night, and suddenly Maggie finds herself fighting not only to find her child but also to prove she had nothing to do with her disappearance.

I absolutely loved how Natalie Banks handled the atmosphere in this book.

There’s this constant feeling that something isn’t right, but you can never quite put your finger on what it is. Every conversation, every strange occurrence, and every missing memory adds another layer of uncertainty.

And because we’re experiencing everything through Maggie, we’re just as confused and suspicious as she is.

Is Maggie actually losing her grip on reality? Is someone deliberately making her believe she is? Or is there something much more sinister happening?

I went back and forth so many times.

One minute I was completely on Maggie’s side, frustrated that nobody would listen to her. The next, I was questioning her myself because some of the things happening were just too strange to ignore.

And that’s what made this book so addictive.

Banks does an excellent job of making you sympathize with Maggie while simultaneously making you question everything she says, remembers, and believes. The tension never really lets up, and the atmosphere becomes increasingly unsettling as the story progresses.

Then, about three-quarters of the way through…

BAM. THAT TWIST.

I genuinely did not see it coming.

And I love when a thriller manages to do that! Not just throw in a random revelation for shock value, but deliver something that completely changes the way you’re looking at the story.

Suddenly, I was mentally revisiting everything I’d already read, questioning what I’d missed and how all those little details fit together.

Chef’s kiss. 🤌

What I also appreciated was how the story explored the emotional vulnerability of new motherhood. Maggie’s postpartum depression isn’t just some convenient plot device. Her exhaustion, insecurity, isolation, and constant self-doubt make her situation feel incredibly unsettling because she’s already struggling to trust herself before everything begins falling apart.

And when the people around you keep insisting you’re doing things you have absolutely no memory of doing, how long before you start believing them?

That psychological element was easily one of the strongest parts of the book for me.

I loved the pacing, the atmosphere, the mystery, and the way Banks kept me guessing right up until that unexpected revelation. At 290 pages, this book never overstayed its welcome. Every time I thought I might finally understand what was happening, something else made me reconsider.

And can we talk about how perfect this was for spooky season?

Although The Mothers isn’t scheduled for publication until March 2027, reading this ARC in October was absolutely the right choice. It has that eerie, unsettling atmosphere that makes you want to curl up under a blanket, turn on every light in the house, and keep reading until you finally know the truth.

Five stars. No hesitation.

If you enjoy psychological thrillers with unreliable perspectives, unsettling domestic settings, complicated motherhood, family secrets, and twists that genuinely catch you off guard, put this one on your radar.

Natalie Banks absolutely delivered with this debut, and I’ll definitely be watching for whatever she writes next.

Because if a thriller can make me resent having to go to work instead of staying home to finish it, it’s doing something right. 😂

Tropes & Themes:

* Psychological thriller
* Domestic suspense
* Unreliable narrator
* Missing baby / child abduction
* Postpartum depression
* Motherhood & identity
* Psychological manipulation
* Questioning reality
* Memory gaps
* Family secrets
* Childhood trauma & buried memories
* Isolation & vulnerability
* Nobody believes her
* Atmospheric suspense
* Gaslighting themes
* Twists & shocking revelations
* Nothing is as it seems
* Maternal love & desperation
* Mental health representation
* Creepy, unsettling atmosphere

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an advance reader copy in exchange for my honest review.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Mathter Works.
69 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 16, 2026
Great premise, and the main point-of-view character carried the story. However, the writing was a little too formulaic. Certain structures were reused so often that it went from effective to near annoying. There were also some very underused plot points as well.
Profile Image for Marlei Faull.
Author 1 book5 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 9, 2026
I have mixed feelings about this one!

I was invested from the beginning, and the pacing was consistently good. The mystery kept me turning pages, and I was genuinely curious to see how everything would come together.

One aspect I particularly appreciated was the portrayal of postpartum depression. Maggie's exhaustion, vulnerability, isolation and struggle to trust herself felt incredibly believable. I really sympathised with her, particularly as the people around her began questioning her experiences rather than offering the support she so desperately needed.

That being said, I struggled with some of the characters' decisions. Particularly the husband's response to what he believed was his wife's deteriorating mental health. If you genuinely thought your partner was struggling that significantly, surely your first instinct would be to get them proper support? I found myself questioning his behaviour more than anything else.

As for the twists, I genuinely didn't predict the biggest reveal, but I'm not entirely convinced I liked it. It felt a little clichéd, and the more I thought about it, the harder certain aspects of the story became to believe. I love a twist that catches me off guard, but I also want it to make sense when I look back at everything that came before it.

The characters themselves were fine. I didn't particularly love or dislike anyone, although I certainly felt for Maggie. I think that lack of connection with the wider cast also contributed to the ending feeling a little underwhelming.

And that's probably my biggest takeaway. The ending wasn't bad, but it didn't leave much of an impression either. I enjoyed the build-up considerably more than the eventual payoff.

Overall, The Mothers was an engaging, well-paced psychological thriller with an interesting premise and a believable portrayal of the emotional challenges of early motherhood. While I wasn't completely sold on the final reveal, I still enjoyed the reading experience and would be interested in picking up more from Natalie Banks.

Thank you to NetGalley and Crooked Lane Books for providing an advance copy in exchange for my honest review.

Profile Image for Megan Magee.
1,060 reviews5 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 27, 2026
Maggie Fergason is a new mom, constantly on the brink of exhaustion and forgetting things in the typical way new moms might. When Rosie is born, Maggie starts hearing sounds and furniture she knows she isn't responsible for rearranging. These forgetful instances magnify before we, the readers, are forced to confront the inevitable: is Maggie losing it, or is someone setting her up to look like an unhinged, flimsy at best mother? I love how the author wrote each twist to seemingly coincide to force me to believe one way. I'd have to say the most riveting aspect of The Mothers was that I equally debated Maggie's ferociousness as a mother as well as how close she was to losing her grip on reality. Despite delivering nothing truly groundbreaking for a thriller book, Banks keeps one on the edge of their seat the entire time, and delivers on the prose front to where you feel like you're not reading run of the mill drivel. Thank you to NetGalley and Crooked Lane Books for the eARc. All opinions are entirely my own.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Katie Dorsey.
55 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 23, 2026
This one started out really strong for me but lost me a little bit along the way with some major plot holes and unrealistic twists, but the suspense definitely kept me hooked. I loved the guessing game of whether Maggie was experiencing postpartum psychosis or if the things happening around her were actually real. Everyone was a suspect in my mind. I trusted absolutely no one.

The twist was something I never would have guessed, although it was definitely pretty out there and felt a little wild for my taste. It did, however, completely change how I felt about several of the characters. Overall, this kept me turning the pages and not wanting to put it down until the very end, which is always a win for me!
Profile Image for Dawn.
411 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 28, 2026
This was a surprising and fantastic book. Absolutely loved Maggie's character as she unravels after having her daughter, Rosie. Her relationships are greatly challenged, especially with her husband. Her post-partum blues and sleepless nights cause issues that also spilled out on her mother, daughter and community. As Maggie insist "she isn't crazy", things around her become more and more unreal until she ends up "having to deal with her mental health issues". I was engrossed in the story and finished it in a weekend because I couldn't put it down. Is Maggie really falling apart or is someone being extremely cruel and messing with her? Are things really as they seem and who gets to decide? Read the story and find out.
301 reviews14 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 2, 2026
The Mothers by Natalie Banks is a masterpiece of keeping the reader on edge with the characters.

The characters in this book were unpredictable, but they kept you guessing what they were really like with each other and the secrets that held.

What I really enjoyed about this book, was that the main character of Maggie gave off two personas and I was captivated by the way the author used the ability to make the story believable with this character.

I found the storyline of a newborn and the struggles of motherhood to be quite satisfying, as it gave the reader an insight into a life we all see as rosy.

I devoured this book in a couple of hours and throughly loved how it made me want to keep turning the page.
Profile Image for Kylee.
330 reviews4 followers
October 7, 2026
The first 75% of this book had me absolutely captivated. The writing style was intriguing and I could not guess what was going on. I was loving it!
But then the twist came and I couldn’t believe the author went with THAT trope. And not in a fun, interesting thriller way but more of a “oh no, the book was just ruined for me” kind of way.
I would consider reading other books by this author because I really was sucked in - just disappointed with where it went.
Thank you so much to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read this ARC!
Profile Image for Ashley Shirah.
179 reviews1 follower
September 22, 2026
The Mothers by Natalie Banks is an absolute must-read! Right when you think you have things figured out, the story completely flips on its head—I literally gasped out loud and was left breathless by the twist. It delivers every single thing you could want from a top-tier psychological thriller: tight pacing, eerie tension, and constant suspense. This was my first time reading Natalie Banks, but it definitely won’t be my last. 5/5 stars!

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the e-arc
Profile Image for Katlin Stokes.
602 reviews8 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
November 8, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley for a copy of this book. This book was an absolute whirlwind! I did guess part of it but I was still in shock! Very well done.
Profile Image for Heidi Sandiford.
489 reviews4 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 20, 2026
I had to skim through this book as there was just too much "fluff" around the main story. I feel that I have read so many similar books with similar storylines: mother has baby, can't cope with baby after its birth, mother is sleep deprived and fears she is losing her mind. Her support network: neighbor, mother, husband also think she is losing her marbles and then the baby is taken and everyone thinks the mother has done something to the baby. The "twist" was quite predictable in this case. Why the mother never mentioned the so-called "twist" sooner is a mystery I can't solve.
2 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 19, 2026
At the beginning, I was genuinely interested in the mystery surrounding Maggie. I found myself struggling to decide whether I could completely trust her. She repeatedly insists that she would never hurt her baby, Rosie, and that she would never kidnap or harm her own child, but at the same time, there are all these things happening around her that she claims not to remember doing. She is seen in situations that look suspicious, purchases are made in her name, and people begin questioning her version of events.

That uncertainty was probably the strongest part of the premise. The central question becomes: Do I trust Maggie when she says she would never hurt her baby? And if Maggie isn't responsible for these things, then who is? Unfortunately, I didn't find the mystery itself particularly clever. The book keeps returning to essentially the same question through many different incidents, and eventually the repetition became tiring. I kept reading because I wanted to know the explanation, but I wasn't necessarily enjoying the process of getting there.

Another problem I had was that too many events seemed to happen because the plot needed them to happen, rather than because they were natural choices for the characters. Maggie is repeatedly frightened by strange noises and footsteps in the house, and there are moments when she does lock doors after something unsettling happens. But if she genuinely believed that someone might be entering her home, why wouldn't she consistently lock the doors, change the locks, or take other obvious precautions? These are instinctive things many people would consider once they became convinced that something was wrong.

The same applies to the scenes where Maggie hears a lullaby playing upstairs in the nursery. If she believes something strange is happening in the room where her baby sleeps, why wouldn't she simply take the baby into her own room and keep her close? These omissions became distracting for me because they felt like obvious actions that a real person in Maggie's situation would take. It sometimes seemed as though those possibilities had to be ignored so that the plot could continue unfolding in the way the author wanted.

This became a broader issue for me: too many elements of the story felt constructed to serve the plot rather than arising naturally from the characters and their circumstances. I wanted to believe that Maggie was behaving like a real person who was genuinely frightened and confused, but there were several moments where I found myself thinking, "Why wouldn't she just do the obvious thing?" Those moments weakened the suspense for me because instead of wondering what would happen next, I was wondering why the characters weren't taking basic precautions.

My biggest problem was the eventual explanation involving Maggie's identical twin, Hannah. I don't think the idea itself is necessarily bad—in fact, I think it could have been a good starting point for a thriller. What didn't work for me was the execution. The secret identical twin felt like a very convenient answer to the entire mystery: if Maggie isn't doing these things, then there is a hidden twin who can be responsible for them. The more I thought about it, the less clever the twist felt.

I wanted the reveal to make me look back at everything that had happened and think, "Of course. That was brilliantly set up." Instead, my reaction was more like, "Oh, it's the secret twin." To me, the twist didn't feel earned—not in the sense that there weren't enough clues, but in the sense that the actual solution felt too conventional and convenient. The identical-twin device is such a familiar thriller mechanism that I found it difficult to see it as a particularly smart or inventive resolution to the mystery.

I also struggled with how suddenly Maggie remembered everything about her twin. Her mother finally tells her that she had an identical twin, Hannah, who had been given away for adoption when they were five. Almost immediately, Maggie begins remembering details from her childhood and eventually realizes that she is actually Hannah because the twins had switched their bracelets when they were children. I found this very difficult to accept. The memories seemed to return exactly when the plot needed them to, and the bracelet explanation felt like another convenient mechanism for resolving the mystery rather than something that developed naturally.

Another issue for me was how much of the plot was explicitly explained to the reader. Maggie's mother sits down and explains essentially the entire history surrounding the twins and why everything happened. Then, later, Hannah herself explains her motives and feelings during the confrontation at the crime scene while she is attacking Erin. I generally prefer when readers are allowed to piece things together themselves, especially in a mystery or thriller. Having major characters stop and explain their histories, motives, and essentially the answers to the mystery made the final sections feel overly expositional. It didn't feel like a natural conversation to me; it felt like the story was making sure the reader understood everything before it ended.

This connects to another issue I had with the dialogue throughout the book. There is almost no profanity, which isn't inherently a problem, but in some extremely difficult situations the characters' language felt strangely restrained. The stabbing scene was the clearest example. Erin has been stabbed and Maggie is being threatened with being killed, and yet the dialogue remains remarkably calm and explanatory. I expected much more visceral reactions—fear, panic, anger, shouting, or simply the kind of language people might realistically use when confronted with something this horrifying. The absence of those reactions made the scene feel emotionally flat to me rather than intense.

I also sometimes felt that the characters sounded too similar to one another. Certain conversations didn't feel like distinct people speaking; instead, they sometimes felt as though the same narrative voice had been given to everyone. There were moments when the dialogue felt written rather than naturally spoken, which became particularly noticeable during the more dramatic scenes.


Finally, I found the resolution of the confrontation too convenient. Hannah and Maggie have already spent some time talking, with Hannah explaining her motives and what has happened, and then, at the precise moment Hannah is about to stab Maggie, Bertie suddenly appears and hits her with a shovel. I couldn't help wondering why Bertie happened to arrive at exactly that moment, especially after the two sisters had already been talking for some time. The timing felt very much like a plot device designed to ensure that Maggie survived. Erin also survives being stabbed, while Hannah dies from the blow, giving the ending a strong hero-versus-villain feeling: the villain dies, the victim survives, and the protagonist gets to live. I understand that thrillers can certainly contain dramatic and unlikely events, but here the resolution didn't feel suspenseful or believable to me; it felt as though the story was arranging the outcome it wanted rather than allowing the events to unfold naturally.

I also found it strange that the book gives attention to the legal consequences of Maggie’s mother’s actions, including her arrest, but says virtually nothing about what happens to Bertie after she kills Hannah. Even if Bertie was acting to protect Maggie, I would have expected at least some acknowledgment of police involvement or the consequences of killing someone, rather than the story simply moving on because Hannah was the villain.

Overall, I think there was a good premise at the beginning. The uncertainty about whether Maggie could be trusted gave me a reason to keep reading, and I genuinely wanted to discover what was happening to her. Unfortunately, I found the mystery increasingly repetitive, and the eventual explanation didn't feel clever enough to justify the buildup. Too many moments also felt as though they were there primarily to serve the plot, even when the characters could have taken obvious and realistic actions that would have changed the situation.

The secret-twin reveal, the sudden recovery of Maggie's memories, the extensive explanations of the plot and motivations, the restrained dialogue during extremely violent situations, and the convenient ending all contributed to my disappointment.

I wanted this to be a smart, tightly constructed psychological thriller, but ultimately, the resolution felt too convenient and predictable for me.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 60 reviews