This heartfelt, emotional boys love drama with disability representation explores themes of grief and depression.
Ren Kisaki has lived his life alone, writing novels from his wheelchair. Suffocated by help and frustrated by his perceived helplessness, he repeatedly pushes others away to the point that his caregivers have all but given up on him. That is, until the day newbie caregiver Rintaro Maki arrives on his doorstep.
The kind and perceptive Rintaro - who sees Ren for himself, not only his condition - offers a connection Ren had long thought himself incapable of. Pushing out of his comfort zone, Ren finally starts opening up... giving him the strength to courageously confront his past and pursue, for the first time, his own story.
This manga was a lot heavier than I expected, but I still really enjoyed it. The budding romance between Kisaki and Rintaro is what draws you in, but it isn't the main focus of this volume. We focus instead on Kisaki's traumatic childhood and the trajectory his life takes after one particularly tragic event. There is a mystery element to the story that keeps you wanting to read as well as a genuine desire to see Rintaro happy. I'm not sure where the story will go from here, but I'm eager to find out. 5 stars
I'm really surprised at all the high-rating reviews because I kinda hated this. It crosses over from being angsty to just being downright trauma porn.
I hate it when stories have disabled protagonists and make them the most horribly tortured people in the world, it's just awful to read. For context: I just find that level of abusing your own character disgusting.
I think that the story had a lot of promise in the first couple chapters, but once we went into the flashback, I felt like the plot began to lose itself too much. The cliffhanger ending also pissed me off because this *100%* could have been a one-shot if we had trimmed out all of the fat. Hell, this could have been an email and I could have saved myself the suffering of watching a disabled person be kicked and spat on by the world for an hour.
There's are mystery & BL elements present, but I do recommend skipping this one. It's heavy in a bad way, and I don't really think this is the good "disability representation" that the description boasts about when it's 350 pages of humiliation and pain for your disabled protagonist.
Very intriguing plot. I couldn't put it down. For such a chunky volume there weren't a whole lot of interactions between the two MC's, but that just added to the mysterious tone. I received the alternate cover with Kisaki eating a candy apple and Maki smiling like life is great, which was a little misleading considering how dark the story is. The cliffhanger basically guaranteed that I'd be picking up the next volume.
I need the next volume in my hands immediately! This was an amazingly captivating read, it had me hooked from the beginning. Its a lot darker than i expected but the mystery elements have me so intrigued. Our MC is an ass at first but hes having a nice character growth moment by the end. This has new favorite potential. That cliffhanger was brutal though...
Wow, this was great. The mystery element is SO intriguing. Like I didn't know where any of it was going and I'm so looking forward to the next volume. The romance is not really the main focus of this and it's more about Kisaki's trauma and the mystery of what happened. I was hesitant at first because Kisaki's anger was so aggressive at first. I wasn't sure how it would go. But as we got to know him, you start to understand him and he also starts to cools down a bit. I mean he's self aware about how awful he's being and is just a truly traumatized person that has never truly coped with anything. I don't really want to say too much because I went into this not knowing anything and I think it's better that way. I was so engaged all the way through. I can't wait to read more.
Every time, I think I figured out the story, I was wrong! lol. This was more of a mystery than I thought it would be! I thought it might be sweet? Ha! No. This is filled with trauma and some pretty dark shit. Just to warn you!!! I did enjoy it. And I’m looking forward to reading the next volume.
This is a heavier read just so yall know. And be mindful of the warnings listed as well.
Having a story like this having multiple volumes that are over the normal page total for mangas is refreshing. Telling a story with all these different elements needs to be fleshed out in longer volumes and not broken up into countless short volumes. And with this being a story with love, I’m so glad that we are getting connections and buildup between the main two.
Kisaki has a lot of trauma from his childhood, so not jumping straight into romance just to push the relationship along is wonderful. And my stomach turned every time he thought about his teacher, and wanting to see him again.
I hope that the story and themes are portrayed well in the coming volumes
This was nothing I'd expected, and it was so very good.
I hesitate a bit about manga/manhwa that features a disabled character, because there's a tendency to treat the disability as a kink, or to display a fundamental lack of understanding for different lifestyles and a visible disdain for any sort of research. There's usually an able-bodied lead who "rescues" the other character, showing them a whole new world they could've never encountered on their own, and trampling all their personal boundaries in the process, in some really uncomfortable ways that are supposed to seem romantic. I've run into this with both BL and shoujo/josei. With some really, really popular stories that made me cringe and abandon early on.
With this series in particular, due to the wheelchair and the night sky cover art, I was worried it would turn out like After We Gazed at the Starry Sky, which I think is fairly popular and also very badly written. (I'm also kind of wondering now if it's a sort of knockoff of this series, since its first volume was published several years later (2017 and 2021), and the Volume 1 covers are eerily similar, while openly displaying the able-bodied savior theme in the latter.)
So yeah, I was a bit nervous. But this book ended up being way more in line with my interests than I could've expected, and far beyond what the synopsis had described.
Ren Kisaki is a 32 year old mystery novelist, writing under a pen name. He's not hugely popular, which I appreciated - he's able to make a decent living, and he has loyal fans, but he's not portrayed as "the best and most amazing and well-known author ever," which is another trope that tends to happen. So when his newest caretaker, a 26 year old named Rintaro Maki, sees a stack of his novels and is excited to meet another "fan" (not realizing yet that Ren is the author), it's a bit more meaningful.
Ren, you see, has been unable to walk since an accident 19 years earlier, during a series of events that unfold over the course of this rather thick (350 pages!) volume. There was one dialogue exchange early on where Ren's uncle (doctor? therapist? both?) tells him that his health seems fine and that maybe "the issue with his legs could be psychological." I'm not sure how I feel about that, or if Ren is going to be able to recover the use of his legs later in the series (which is apparently 9 volumes and still going??), but Ren does have a whole lot of trauma that's far more mental than physical. So it's possible that in some ways he's been holding himself back from recovery, although that doesn't seem like a storyline quite yet.
For now, he's mostly very angry, and difficult to get along with. And I liked that. Again, one of the issues I had with Starry Sky was how pure and perfect and noble and good-hearted and innocent the main character was. Ren is a lot more complex and realistic. And, as we find out gradually, his isolation and inability to get along with others was part of his personality before his accident. His trauma started a lot earlier, and the emotional scars run far deeper.
I don't think I want to get too deep into spoilers, although I feel that Tokyopop mistagged some of the content warnings. The substitute teacher we meet in flashbacks is absolutely fascinating, as is Ren's connection to him, and the huge mess that's created from a whole bunch of other adults (possibly including the loving uncle) ignoring that was happening right in front of them for years.
Ren spent his childhood largely alone, trying hard to be invisible and to please others. He loved reading about and looking at the stars, probably because that's what kept him company at night when he needed to get out of his house for a while. And once he met a young, inexperienced teacher who wanted to share his love of literature - and who really paid attention to him - Ren started loving all sorts of other books, too, which eventually turned into a career.
The book Ren wrote after a long hiatus fascinates me, and also seems like his most popular novel by far, with a lot of new fans learning about it through social media. So far none of them have realized that it's essentially the true story - I think - of what happened to him as a 13 year old who'd been kidnapped after his parents were stabbed in their home. The people at the home care facility know his real name, and I suppose could've googled him to pull up old articles, but maybe that information isn't circulating too much. They're just excited to find out that while he's incredibly difficult to deal with, he's a well-respected author!
The only person who connects the more significant dots isn't the man Ren was hoping to reconnect with...it's Maki, who seems to have a mysterious backstory and complicated family of his own. It's so interesting and I hate that I can't dive straight into the next volume.
The relationship between Ren and Maki is intriguing, too. They have palpable chemistry, with Ren throwing a lot of barriers up that become more understandable as we learn more about him. Trust and love are extremely foreign concepts to someone who's gone through what he has, and forming a bond with someone else - leaning on another person - terrifies him.
He's also deeply embarrassed about his wheelchair - as someone who is fiercely independent and hates having to move through a world that doesn't accommodate someone like him. There's a particularly devastating scene where his wheels get caught in a pavement crack while he's rushing to try to find a bathroom where he won't have to ask anyone for help...and the humiliation just gets worse from there, because he can fend for himself, but he also needs help sometimes, and asking for that help makes him embarrassed and angry.
The way he treats his home care staff is cruel and unnecessary, but also not unusual. I liked seeing his internal struggle, as he hated himself for lashing out but couldn't find a way to apologize or change.
So while Maki is going to be important for his growth and his story, Ren's also putting in so much of the work himself. Writing a book to get some answers from the man who'd abandoned him years ago, after promising to protect him, and - at the end of this volume - going out at night to find and talk to Maki, after rejecting him in a way he regrets.
It feels like it's going to be a pretty long journey, but so far it's a fascinating, thoughtfully developed one, and I'm excited for more.
Content Warnings: VIOLENCE, TRAUMA, CHILD ABUSE, MENTAL HEALTH STRUGGLES, REFERENCES TO SELF-HARM AND GROOMING
This manga surprised me in a multitude of ways–it’s more than just a BL, but a mystery and redemptive story as well. I was at the edge of my seat reading this, but also, my emotions were pulled in a variety of different directions as I read Ren’s story–his troubled present, and even more troubling past.
Ren is a hard character to love. He is constantly angry, blowing up at his caregivers, making judgements of people, and he’s also bitter. But you can’t help but feel for him, given his horrific past.
Rintaro is the caregiver who seems to partially break the spell Ren has over himself. Although Ren still yells at Rintaro, Rintaro can take it, and he also shows signs of caring for Ren despite his temper and his disability. This starts to crack away at Ren’s hard demeanor.
But Ren still has outbursts, such as breaking a teacup, and at one point violently cutting his own hair off in the shower. Rintaro bursts in to stop him, and later Ren trusts Rintaro enough to ask him to fix his hair and cut it for him. Rintaro thinks Ren is beautiful, good-looking with either short or long hair.
Rintaro kind of figures out on his own that Ren is his favorite author, dropping hints that he likes his work. This softens Ren’s heart a little. Rintaro also asks Ren to go out with him on a weekend he’s off, and the two are genuinely enjoying each other’s company until they bump into Rintaro’s friends. Ren is a bit understandably upset as he’s kind of ignored, and he interrupts Rintaro’s conversation with his friends to announce he’s going to the bathroom. After that, Ren decides to no longer hang out with Rintaro, and shoots him down when he asks to hang out again. This hurts Rintaro’s feelings, especially when Ren asks to have him taken off the roster as his caregiver.
A lot of stuff happens in between all of this, so much that I can’t share it all here. But I want to take a moment to talk about Ren’s history. SPOILERS AHEAD.
Ren has written a novel that speaks to his past, and we get it in flashbacks from the point of view of his teacher, Shinichi Mihara.
Ren was bullied terribly as a child–physical and emotional abuse. His mother looks down on him, annoyed that her child is “the type to be bullied” and doesn’t help him at all. His father isn’t really a part of his life.
Mihara is just a temporary teacher filling in for someone on maternity leave, but he’s immediately drawn to Ren because he has physical wounds regularly, doesn’t engage in class, and is the victim of bullying. It takes a while to get Ren to warm up to him, but they connect over their love of the stars and reading.
At first you completely sympathize with Mihara as someone desperately trying to support a bullied, terrorized student with an awful home and school life. But Mihara focuses a little too much on Ren, giving him preferential treatment, and eventually inviting Ren to his house. It’s meant to be a safe haven for Ren, and it is, but teachers have to be careful with how close they get to their students. There is always a line in danger of being crossed.
Mihara confronts Ren’s parents about the bullying, and Ren’s mother drives him away, mentioning that she’ll report Mihara for inappropriate behavior with her son.
So far, like I said, you feel bad for Mihara, and he doesn’t seem like a bad guy. At first.
But there’s an even earlier flashback with a disturbing panel where Mihara is with Ren in the shower room, and Ren is naked from the waist down (censored) while Mihara is washing him. ALARM BELLS GOING OFF!! They never give context to this scene, and we don’t see what happened before or after it, but it immediately reveals this relationship to have a dark, unwholesome aspect to it.
Anyway, Ren’s life is full of tragedy. One day, Ren runs to Mihara saying he doesn’t want his mother to “become a bad person” and Mihara rushes to Ren’s house, where inside he finds Ren’s mother has stabbed his father to death. It’s not quite clear if it’s self-defense or Mihara’s own feelings, but he sustains a stab wound to his thigh, and ends up killing Ren’s mother. Ren and Mihara run away together, with their final memories of each other being under the stars before Mihara disappears and Ren is rescued by his uncle and the authorities. However, Ren runs away from them, desperate to find Mihara, and is struck by a car in the process. We are left to believe that this is how Ren lost the use of his legs…only, in an earlier scene in the present, Ren’s uncle suggests that the use of the wheelchair and leg injury might be psychological. We don’t hear anything about it after that, but it plants a seed in your mind.
Back to the present, Rintaro has read Ren’s most recent book, which has an interesting ending passage:
"Let’s return to the promise that was never fulfilled. I’ll be waiting for you on that day, in that place, nineteen years later."
Rintaro horrifies Ren by figuring out that the novel is his story. And everyone is wondering about what that final passage could be about (strongly hinting that this is addressed to Mihara, who disappeared).
This is a jam-packed manga (354 pages!) and there’s so much more to talk about, but I’m going to stop here because I’ve revealed so much of the book already.
The BL is light in this volume, but you can tell it will build up to something bigger later. There is a ton of mystery to the story and you’re left asking a lot of questions, and the story pushes your emotions in all different directions. The art is particularly expressive when it comes to the facial expressions of the characters, especially Ren’s, who veers from anger to self-loathing and self-doubt to blushing at Rintaro’s words and actions.
The book ends on a cliffhanger and with some additional mysteries surrounding Rintaro and what seems to be a missing child with similar circumstances to Ren’s past.
This manga was nothing I ever could have expected, and it was so, so good. I’m giving it five stars and am eagerly awaiting Volume 2.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I picked this book up at Kinokuniya at Anime Expo, but I didn’t realize it was technically an advance copy! I enjoy reading BL and, after reading “In the Palm of His Hand” and “I Can Hear the Sunspot”, have been enjoying these stories where one of the leads has a disability since the plots tend to be more complex with richer characterization. In this story, Ren Kisaki is an author who, due to an event in his childhood, relies on a wheelchair to get around. But due to the way he is treated due to his disability, and due to his childhood trauma, he lashes out at those around him and has become a recluse, only interacting with his editorial staff and the caregivers who help take care of his cleaning. He’s fired several caregivers but one of the newest hires, Rintaro Maki, connects to Ren through a shared love of books and little by little starts to break through his walls.
There is a little bit of romance in the plot so far but the real meat of this volume comes from exploring Ren’s past including the event that led to his paraplegia, and it gets quite dark- the rating on the back specifically mentions “violence, trauma, child abuse, mental health struggles, references to self-harm and grooming.”Also, a few of the chapters are from the POV of a character who does some despicable things which I thought was a very interesting choice. While devouring this volume in one sitting I kept seeing the pages dwindle down hoping that it wouldn’t end since I really wanted to know what happens next.
Apart from the compelling plot and characterizations, I also enjoyed the art and localization. I’m really looking forward to the next volume!
Very intrigued by this first volume and have absolutely no idea where this is going. I wasn't expecting the major backstory reveal, and now I'm hooked and anxious about that cliffhanger!!!
The first half is a really hard read even though I understand why ren is the way he is, but I love the development that happens later even if the backstory is a bit intense