1917. As the Great War rages, Everest Macdonald is summoned to her father’s deathbed and entrusted with a final urgent she must uncover the truth behind the murder of her uncle, the celebrated Victorian actor William Terriss.
In 1897, Terriss was stabbed to death outside London’s Adelphi Theatre, a killing that shocked Victorian society. The murderer was swiftly arrested and confined to Broadmoor, the case declared closed. Yet years later, a sealed package of evidence passed to Everest by her dying father casts doubt on the official verdict and the haste with which it was reached.
Drawn back to London, Everest begins her investigation, following a trail that leads her into the world of late-Victorian theatre, where fame and fortune mask obsession, envy and cruelty. With time running out and her father’s strength failing, Everest must uncover what really happened on the night Terriss died.
I was lucky to arrive at the library as this was being unboxed from a collection of brand new books! Crisp clean pages & the most beautiful sprayed edges made me want to give this historical mystery book a try.
Everest’s father is gravely ill and desperate to find out exactly what happened, some years before, when his beloved brother William was stabbed to death outside the Adelphi Theatre. He tasks his daughter with finding out the truth behind her uncle’s infamous murder and hands her a sealed parcel of evidence which casts considerable doubt on the official verdict.
Based on a true story, we rely mainly on Everest’s narration but this is peppered with various diary entries and letters and with a large cast of flamboyant characters, several of whom are pretending to be somebody else, at times it was complicated!
But wow! I’m glad I persevered. Part mystery, part Victorian adventure story I found this a gripping, twisty, atmospheric tale which was hard to put down. It was beautifully written and full of historical detail; I loved it. I hope to read more of Everest MacDonald in the future!
With this, the author has produced another magnificent work of historical fiction that draws heavily from fact. The lives of several real people are dramatized, to which is added an engaging ‘what if’ scenario that turns the real-world narrative of its head. This makes for an entertaining and engrossing read.
Two men of Empire, Thomas Herbert Lewin and younger brother William are in India. Thomas is the superintendent of the Chittagong Hill Tracts and trying to befriend the mountain tribes. This task is going well until circumstances require them to flee and a curse is made against them. This curse will follow William for the rest of his life. He does all in his power to avoid it coming true, until he is eventually murdered by fellow actor Richard Archer Prince. Twenty years later, close to the anniversary, the near to death Thomas sets his daughter Everest the task of unearthing the truth.
This is a story of wronged, neglected women, who ultimately discover their inner strength and vain foolhardy men, ruled by their egos and libidos, which probably sums up the world of stage and film.
Everest assumes a role familiar to crime fiction lovers, that the amateur or accidental detective; she is so engaging it becomes a joy following her exploits. The storyline is the investigation into the murder of William, her interviews with the living being interspersed with extracts from Isabel’s diary (once she obtains it) and extracts from newspapers (in her father’s files). It’s certainly absorbing and hard not to find some sympathy for Isabel as we discover the life William made her endure. Everest has quite a talent for detecting, though not quite the polished real thing, she can be taken in and is surrounded by talented actors. Readers are going to love Everest and her direct, forthright approach to dealing with these lovies. The world of theatre, the stage is a setting for make-believe so naturally there is deception and role playing, thanks to creative makeup and effects. Add to the mix a touch of the supernatural; the ghost of William Terris is said to haunt the Adelphi Theatre and the Covent Garden tube station, so it seems fitting to be included. The traditions of the stage, the bickering actors, the vanity and debauchery are convincingly imagined and add a layer human baggage that brings additional complexity to the plot.
The story builds up to a theatrical finale the setting demands, with a reveal deserving of a Golden Age Mystery. The library or drawing room are forsaken for the stage, where a specially written piece is to be performed by the main characters, secrets are revealed and actions explained. Everest is cast as the narrator and she discloses the truth; it’s very cleverly constructed and beautifully written.
It is difficult to imagine the research and attention to detail, required to produce such a work. The result is a story that feels as much lived in as told.
Takes historical murder mystery to another level, more artistic than a mere crime fiction.
Inspired by the real events, this book follows Everest as she picks up the trail of one of victorian Londons most scandalous murders twenty years after it was supposedly solved.
Now, any book set in Victorian London is bound to reflect some views that we realise are just gross, but AJ has clearly put so much research into what the sensibilities, the opinions of the time were and wrote it with such care to make sure it’s not irresponsible or reflecting these ideals as truth. Overall you can see the research and care that went into this, the setting is so full, so vibrant that it feels like a walk through time, full of small details that make it absolutely beautiful.
The language feels like time travel, it’s old, formal, proper — but after a page or two, all stiffness fades away and you find the flow, in this rich, descriptive writing that really lets you into Everest’s mind, her life after the incident and the mystery she sets out to solve. It jumps back and forward in time, searching through old records and diaries that span the dark backstage of the theatre, the locked doors of broadsmoor to the colonised towns of India under Victorian regimes to dig up all the secrets of Everests family, and how they could all be part of William’s violent and bloody end. It’s more than just a murder mystery, it’s a story about each characters lives, about generations of secrets and the way pride can be one of the most dangerous sins. Each character was so perfect, but of course Everest has completely stolen my heart.
This book sits on that boundary of being rooted in truth and reality, but skirting the border of magic, curses and the unseen — it’s eerie, unsettling but never outwardly scary, AJ instead keeps us suspended in that terrifying place between fact and fiction that makes it so compelling.
I love historical fiction, so I could not resist The Deadly Inheritance of Everest MacDonald.
While I was reading, a short video by A.J. West popped up in my Instagram feed in which he shared some of his source material: the murder of actor William Terriss outside the Adelphi Theatre in 1897 was headline news and so West had an abundance of sources from which to evolve his story.
In the novel, 20 years after her uncle’s death Everest MacDonald is given a bundle of primary sources like West’s bundle in the real-world 21st century, and asked by him to reinvestigate the murder. Perhaps the wrong man has been in prison all these years.
The tale that unfolds takes us from Colonial India to Broadmoor (where the convicted man is held), and back and forth between the places that make up the lives of the two brothers - Everest’s father and uncle. Despite having received an eARC for this tour (🙏 Orenda Books and Random Things Tours), I chose to buy and listen to the audiobook, and that definitely heightened the atmosphere of a world of privilege that was punctured not only by World War I and all the changes that brought, but also by the fracturing of Everest’s understanding of her family’s identity.
I liked the exploration of colonialism, which formed a major subplot to the whodunnit. I’m not sure how much or how little the real Everest MacDonald engaged with this, given her choice to marry into a tea plantation family - that’s the question I would ask the author if I had the chance. His research seems sound and a backbone of it is the diary of Everest’s father. So I assume he thought long and hard about how Everest would have viewed her life in “the colonies”.
In any case, the version of Everest he has given us in this novel is a bold adventurer with a rip-roaring tale of the theatre, her uncle’s murder and the 1857 Sepoy Uprising.