True Patriot: Heroes of the Great White North introduces an exciting new era of Canadian superheroes featuring the country's premiere talents, including Adrian Alphona (Ms. Marvel), Andy B. (Kill Shakespeare), J. Bone (The Rocketeer), Jeff Lemire (Justice League), Scott Chantler (Two Generals), Faith Erin Hicks (Friends With Boys), Paul Rivoche (The Forgotten Man), Ramon K Perez (Tale of Sand), Jay Stephens (Land of Nod), J. Torres (Bigfoot Boy), and more...
Comic book writer whose credits include the Eisner Award nominated Alison Dare, the YALSA listed Days Like This and Lola: A Ghost Story, as well as Batman: Legends of the Dark Knight, Love as a Foreign Language and Teen Titans Go, which garnered him a Shuster Award.
Considering that is has only been a few decades (if that) since graphic novels have been accepted as pieces of literature, it can be difficult both accepting them and properly understanding them.
I believe this book can be quite a challenge to critique. A graphic novel cannot be read in the same way as a novel is. Nor should it be assessed (or, unfortunately, judged) by the same criteria. In the graphic novel 'format' (out of a lack of a better term) storytelling is done through two blended mediums, both through writing and pictures. Often you will not see as much descriptive writing because, let's face it, we have pictures to literally 'draw-us-a-picture'. A graphic novel is meant to be savored; to allow both its subtle and 'in-your-face' aspects to be digested. A graphic novel should be rated on its story and its telling, its art, and its use of its art in its story telling. And, on a final note, of something that I see far too often on the Internet (as well as here on Goodreads) is the confused and misunderstanding difference between one's opinion (likes and biases) vs. the actual job of a critic.
But taking all this into consideration, let's take a look at "True Patriot 2: Heroes of the Great White North". Like its predecessor, it is chalked full of cheesy, and at times even painful Canadiana, sometimes to the point of overkill. They both make me smile and laugh and at other times cringe. (One of my absolute favourite cheese-line has GOT to be “I'm Carnage du Fromage” from “Gull Girl vs. Ann Murray” by Fred Kennedy and Adam Gorham – not to mention seeing Ann Murray throw a beating on Gull Girl! LOL)
Really, this is best viewed as a collection of graphic vignettes. Fifteen loosely connect storylines (three of which are broken into more than one Act), making a collection of 18 shorts. Bear in mind, we are seeing the writings and art of over 30 collaborators here. (Although I think we could have done away with the “On Guard For Thee”, Acts 1, 2 and 3, where J. Torres and Alexander Perkins attempt to draw all of these characters together into one 'shared' universe (or maybe I should say shared nation – Canada. Okay. we get it. They're Canadian).
A few are little more than an introduction of new characters and (Canadian) Superheroes. A few begin filling what the first True Patriot book gave us as a tantalizing taste of (Dominion Jack comes to mind).
The storylines are simple. I actually like that. A refreshing change from reading DC or Marvel comics/graphic novels, where you need damn near need a Doctorate or degree; such an encyclopedic background knowledge – nay, LORE and mythos – that these top two comic books have become nearly a niche market in their herculean sizes. (Isn't THAT interesting?). I liked this where you could just sit back, read the story and enjoy them for what they are. Period.
The contents vary from the more darker and dystopian “Mask of Freedom” by Paul Rivoche to the Hanna-Barbera-like superhero, The Grey Owl (one of my favourites!) With a wide range of art styles from Raul Rivoche's “Mask of Freedom” and Scott Kowalchuk's “The Farmer and Tractor”, both of which reminds me of Jack Kirby's art, to J. Bone's “The Grey Owl vs. Dee-Dazzler”, with its younger audience Hanna-Barbera-like feel, reminiscent of Space Ghost!
There are also a few cool setting not all will appreciate. “Pat” (by Tom Fowler) is set in Kingsmere, MacKenzie King Estate, which is right here in Ottawa, where I live. I've been to Kingsmere and have seen its ruined abbey as depicted in the story. Others have the Rideau Canal near the MacKenzie King bridge (Dominion Jack in Difference) to the all too often used Parliament Buildings as a backdrop in “On Guard for Thee, Act 3”.
Ironically, this book both makes me proud and embarrassed to be a Canadian! (And maybe that's one of the beauty's of being Canadian. We can laugh at ourselves. We don't take ourselves too seriously).
Unfortuately, I cannot rate this book with any amount of stars. I have to give it 4 Maple-Leafs.