When I was a lonely girl, my father brought home a boy who was not quite human. He was cold, yet obedient to my every wish. He became my companion, my knight, my first love. And later on, my greatest nightmare. Now he’s the most celebrated scientist on Mars. But beneath that perfectly constructed mask, I recognize the crack I made: He’s haunted by me. By our cruel promises. By our dollhouse. He still lives there. Still crafting his perfect dolls. And I’m the only one who can free him.
When I was a lonely boy, I found my purpose in life. I wanted to protect her from this cruel world. She became my master, my salvation, my real. And later on, my biggest sin. Now a journalist, she believes she can tear down every secret on Mars. But she will never pry mine from my lips. For her sake, I’ll ravage this planet. The horrors of science. Even God. Even myself.
Everdoll is a dark psychological romance with toxic main leads, exploring identity, obsession, and moral corruption. Please review the content warnings before reading.
This is a standalone romance that opens the door to the world of Reveries on Mars series.
When I saw the comparison to Wuthering Heights x Frankenstein, I’ll be honest, I thought it was an exaggerated, heavy claim. Both are weighty gothic classics, so I went in with a bit of a hater’s eye, almost sure it wouldn’t meet my expectations. But this... was incredible. It genuinely managed to merge the essence of both classics into a single romance novel. The psychological analysis and character depth were so rich that I savored every page. If you’re looking for a plot-driven book, it might not be for you, but if you love journeying through characters’ inner worlds and growing with them, this book is a GEM, and it may be my best read of 2026. And I demand that every dark romance hero be written like Raymond. It’s a classic trope, but it’s really well-written here. It even critiques the usual tropes by asking questions like: Why did he lose his identity? Why are they so codependent? Excellent.
If codependency were two people, they would be Mina and Raymond (complimentary). Everdoll was a twisted experience that I consumed in one sitting. Iris Valen's debut is a strong offering, exploring a profoundly toxic, entirely consuming, at times downright unsettling romance that kept me reading, wondering whether they would find their HEA, or implode under the weight of their dependency. The setting of a steampunk-esque Mars was delightfully unique, and I would've loved to see more of it and its technology expanded upon (particularly in a world that has banned AI). Overall, this sci fi Gothic romance was an ARC I was so glad I was chosen to read for, and hope to see more from this author.
"Please wake up, my princess. Why are you still sleeping? If they gave me fifty lives, I’d spend all of them keeping you awake. But no one’s giving me that, Mina. No one’s coming to my aid. I’m all alone again. The vast universe is a prison cell now. Please… don’t lock me up here forever. Don’t condemn me to solitude. Please… just… Just wake up. Please, please… Why? Why don’t you wake up? Tell me, Mina… How could you be so cruel, leave me like this?"
So, I had to create a whole new tag for this book simply because it was one of those books. Everdoll by Iris Valen was something. I received this book as an arc, but my review is being left voluntary. Honestly, I was planning on DNFing this book, but I am so glad that I continued reading until I didn't. Yeah, this book was a rollercoaster. One moment you want to quit, the next moment you want to keep reading to find out what is going to happen next while still wanting to quit, until you just want to quit again. However, I forced myself to finish this book because it was an arc and I want to give both the readers and the author a fair review. Writing wise. The story is weak. The dialogue is just awkward and so is the syntax. There is a lot of explanation mark usage which really interrupts the flow and makes the main character, a woman in her twenties, sound juvenile. *“Never! Believe me, I’m fine without you! Don’t come! You, Prisne! You so-called cop! Help me!” My smile only grew bigger. “You’re so cute, Sadie!” You see what I mean by the amount of exclamation marks there are. She talks with exclamation marks. She thinks with exclamation marks. She is an exclamation mark at this point. Keep in mind, they are having this conversation in front of a stranger. It's also very cringy. Here is an example of what I mean: “What can I do? No one defies the king.” There is no king. She is talking about a man in a position of power. The FL is constantly giggling. “I giggled” this “I giggled” that. You get what I mean. It is annoying and just so repetitive. The story also lacks flow, and scenes seem to jump from one place to another. For example, Mina was apparently put in the coffin but in the next paragraph she was stepping back from the ML. Like how does that? However, then you find out that she is still in the coffin. First of all, how big is this coffin. Is this a jail cell like coffin or an actual coffin. What are we talking about here?There could definitely be more information and transitions to help even this out. The word choice is wrong at times. For example, won’t should be used instead of don’t. Or shouldn’t instead of wouldn’t. Those type of errors. There was an entire section and multiple typos in which the author clearly forgot to edit. There were several mistakes throughout the text. You can tell it is due to the switch from third person to first person. “She tugged at his coat, and he immediately took her hand into his palm. It had just occurred to him to look at the bastard’s reaction, and as he had expected, his face was down now.” Keep in mind, this is Raymond’s POV. He is supposed to be in first person, but is in 3rd person because that was how the story was originally written. This isn’t the only section or full paragraph that is written this way. The author needs to spend more time editing the story. "I questioned the validity of the scene before her.” “...so I had assumed her belongings had perished in the flames.” Raymond’s POV was actually well-written. It didn’t have the same childish tone that could be found in Mina's POV. Granted, he is emotionless which definitely helps with not writing all those exclamation marks like in Mina’s POV, but still. You know the phrase curiosity killed the cat. That is the exact thing I was thinking of every time Mina made a decision or acted. She is definitely not the sharpest tool in the shed and was making reckless choices out of curiosity even when scared. She constantly enters dangerous situations, again out of curiosity, and doesn’t value her life at all. "I didn’t see anything!” I shouted with all my might.” This happens after she stumbles upon a crime scene in the beginning. Instead of you know addressing the issue, talking, or defending herself, this is what she says and just runs without any intent of hiding. Like girl? You should at least try to hide. And then, she acts surprised that he, you know, actually followed her. What did you think he was going to do? “Pretend” he didn’t see you? The relationship between the two characters is written in a way that truly highlights the codependency developed. However, it has its flaws. There is this lack of communication that is seen in the past relationship and their current one now. It makes sense why their former relationship didn’t work out before. They couldn’t communicate and actually talk to each other. Also, she never actually tries to tell him that she’s suffocating in their relationship. She expects him to just know, and instead of giving him a chance or talking about it, she just ends their relationship. Raymond isn't an angel either, but at least he tried to make the relationship work. “How can he say he loves me if he can’t see the storms inside me?” ”Don’t do it, don’t, don’t. If you can’t see inside me, don’t love me. Don’t be so shallow.” "At his words, my heart broke a little more, if that were even possible. He didn’t see it, didn’t catch it. Even Remi no longer noticed the shift in my tone, nor the disappointment on my face." “If you won’t love me for who I really am, why did you kiss me so beautifully? Why did you let me lose myself in you? Why did you make me feel guilty for waking up from this dream?” Girl, how do you want him to love you for who you are if you refuse to show him your vulnerabilities and the person you are underneath the persona. They definitely match each other’s freak. The obsession they have for the other is of the same levels. They are crazy and own it. At least, that was how it was originally. I don't know. Mina's character never feels truly fleshed out, especially after the flashback/history montage. I liked how Mina’s depression is written in a way that can’t be ignored. It is part of who she is in the past timeline and defines who she has become. It is important to the storyline and very well-written. “I refused to bind myself to anything that wasn’t absolute, wasn’t forever.” Essentially, Mina refuses to accept her feelings for Raymond not just because she feels guilt towards her best friend, Angelica (Eli), but also because Raymond is human. She can lose him the same way she lost Eli. She doesn’t want to be with him because of he idealizes her. Instead of talking to him about this, actually having a conversation and not whatever it is that Mina attempts, she just refuses to talk and plans to leave him. If he can’t determine her mood, or see that she’s a bit off, she realizes that he isn’t perfect and can’t truly be with her. Which is unrealistic. People aren’t mind-readers. Her expectations are messed up, but it makes sense considering her past and trauma. After the end of their relationship in the past (not a spoiler as you already know this from the first 30ish pages), she says she goes to therapy, heals, and realizes why their relationship never worked out. However, we don't get to see this as we do with the evolution of their relationship. We are just told, and I really didn't like that because it just disparages everything the characters went through and rushes any growth they could've had. "She’d whisper sweet words, but the moment I made a mistake, she’d make me feel like the lowest person on the planet.” “That’s why I went so far sometimes. I could say things to him I’d never dare say to another living soul. I could do things to him I was afraid to do to anyone else. I didn’t need to wear my masks in his presence, I could stand before him in all my ugliness.” Overall, their relationship is just toxic, and I just didn't care for the story after the flashback. It was just boring and honestly not developed at all. The world-building is basically non-existent, which sucks because we are supposed to be on Mars. You would think that would be a fun element to explore, but no. The characters live on Mars, there are problems with technology, and that is almost the whole gist. Absolutely disappointing. So, main point/summary, I didn't like the story too much. It was definitely lacking and in need of some serious editing. I'm going to end this with a quote that stood out to me: "Why do we think our love is measured by how much we destroy ourselves? Why do we assume we will not be shallow as long as we sacrifice ourselves?"
This review is of an ARC I received from the author.
While the tale of a cyborg designed by a scientist might be reminiscent of "Frankenstein," this florid romance is more akin to the legend of Mary Shelley obsessively keeping Percy’s preserved heart as a memento. A supposedly immortal “doll” is willingly tasked to look after and protect Mina, a human in an abusive household. Their connection is plagued with co-dependence, and a large swath of the book is devoted to how they whiled away their time together. Remi–otherwise known as Raymond–wistfully notes how every quirk and tic of Mina is “cute” whereas Mina grows to push against his devotion as slavish. Eventually, they “break up,” which honestly seems like too casual of a term for ending their all-consuming affair. Scorned and tortured, Raymond diverts his focus to becoming a renowned scientist, whereas Mina pursues a career in journalism. Present-day Mina eventually uncovers Raymond’s secret: in an unrelenting spell of rage, he has designed (and even killed) clones of her but has been left wholly unsatisfied.
To be frank, this book required a lot of stamina to finish and neither of the lead characters are worthy of sympathy. Mina abuses Raymond as an outlet for her pent up frustrations and discontentment with life, whereas Raymond slaughters people without empathy. Both Mina and Raymond project upon each other, caught in a distinct love-hate relationship. Beyond this, any other characters seem like set dressing instead of individuals. For instance, there is a scene with a child that spans multiple pages who has absolutely zero dialogue. While he’s wired to Raymond’s back, he deeply kisses Mina despite the danger that the young boy is in. Beyond this, many other Martian citizens are left to burn to a crisp during an apocalypse. In short, every event outside of Raymond and Mina’s bubble seems to be an afterthought.
Make no mistake–Valen is a strong writer with promise; she has a unique voice that is well-suited for depicting two brooding souls. However, the ARC I received was riddled with typos and had comments like “no way,” which clashed with the neo-Victorian tone of the story. I also was a bit underwhelmed with the scarce pinpricks of steampunk aesthetics when the promos hinted at a world with aristocratic fashion and mores. The science was also far-fetched and was not expounded upon; they seemed to be whipped up in a rush. For instance, the book was padded with Raymond just sitting around listening to voice recordings from versions of himself in alternate universes. I’m no expert on quantum mechanics, but it seems like everyone would have worse case scenarios that unfold in other dimensions and/or timelines. About 20-40% of the book should have been dedicated to sci-fi elements and Martian culture to truly shine. If Valen chooses to strengthen her world building, she can truly be a force to be reckoned with.
An admirable first stab at writing a novel, and a successful examination of poisonous attachments. (Although I have to point out that Raymond and Mina pulling off heroic feats seemed very inconsistent with their co-dependent, navel-gazing outlooks on life and courtship.)
I was super excited to get my hands on the ARC copy of this! I saw the author's posts and immediately fell in love with the character's designs. The book was a pleasant read overall; I finished it in one sitting and found myself enjoying it. That said, I'd use this as a beach read; it's a fun read, but it's not one I'd heavily analyze.
I have a lot of good things to say about the book; I think the premise is interesting, I liked the characters (Remi supremacy!), and I like that I can easily tell who's narrating due to how the characters see the world. I will say, I love that their world banned all AI; it's definitely a nice way to put that stance in a world full of tech. I loved the tropes, I loved the obsession, I loved Mina's journey to self-love; I liked the overall vibes. Sadie was such a fun character, and I lowkey was desperate to see her again once we went to flash backs (Angelica, my beloved, you are also a diva). Some conversations were just dialogue, but once you learned the speech patterns, they weren't too bad to decipher. I will say that Remi is dark romance book boyfriend material if you love pathetic men; he was creepy as hell at points, but also weirdly endearing? The middle is slower, but it helps flesh out their dynamic and I find the second half worth it! To summarize, I really enjoyed the characters and the plot was individual.
My biggest issue was the grammar; some words were missing and it switched from first to third person, which was extremely confusing. With that said, they're most likely fixed in the published copy. It did make the book hard to read, especially with back-and-forth dialogue that didn't always specify who said what. There were parts that I wish I got to "see" more; I'd love more descriptions of places, of how tones change subtly, and things like that. It's the main reason I struggled to get past the first few chapters and view this as more of a beachy read; it's a "you vibe with it" kind of book. I would have also loved to see how Mina's childhood impacted how toxic she was; clearly Remi enabled it, but I'd adore a bit of the back story showing why Mina is the way she is. It's implied, but I'd love to see how she slowly declined from the sweet, loving child she was to how she is now. I would have loved it darker, but that also is just a preference!
Overall, I think this book is good and I'd love to read the author's future work! If you like dark romance or sci-fi, I would definitely recommend this for a rainy day where you have the time to read in one sitting!
I received an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.
With the promise of a dark romance set in gothic Mars, I was really excited for this story. That being said, the ARC contained significant spelling, grammar and sentence structure errors. The author switched the entire story from third to first-person POV just before releasing the ARCs which is likely the main contributor to these issues, but still, i think another round of proof-reading would have been worth delaying the send out. At times, I could see quality writing through the issues, but it was still so distracting. For example, there were issues with I versus she, singular versus plural, past versus present tense, etc. I'm going to assume that most or all of these issues were a result of last minute changes to the POV and that they will be resolved before official release. As far as the actual story, I liked the characterization of Remi the cyborg who wants to be needed/valued and Mina the lonely, neglected child who is desperate for attention. I understood why they would be drawn together in such a toxic, co-dependent way. I would have liked a bit more description of the Mars setting as this was one of the aspects I was most excited for. We got hints, but very rarely and it didn't play much into the story except to explain how clones/cyborg might exist. At time, it felt like the story was set on regular Earth with the characters driving standard-seeming cars and living in gated houses. I also would have liked more scenes with Remi and Mina's family/friends outside of each other. We spend all of the story in their POVs thinking about each other, but when it comes to other relationships, we are just told, for example, who Mina's best friends are without being shown scenes of the friendships. It would have given more emotional weight to the Eli relationship if we could see how Mina interacts with Eli as a friend separate from how she acts when Remi is around and why she values Eli. On a positive note, I did end up binge reading this and found the plot to be very entertaining. This story felt fresh and unique. I see a lot of promise from this author and am interested to see how the final edit compares to the ARC. I'm hoping that most of my points become irrelevant, and, assuming that is the case, I would recommend this book to readers looking for dark romance with some creative twists and a lightly sci fi atmosphere.
To tear her apart or lose her completely. Which madness would it be?
Thank you so much for arc!
When I saw sci-fi romance meets gothic, I practically ran to read Everdoll. And wow, what a wild ride. This book was exhausting. Not in a bad way, but the story centers around a codependent relationship between mentally ill main characters. When I say mentally ill, I mean it, because they're ACTUAL freaks with actual freaky thoughts. Living inside their heads and spiraling through existential crises with them... this was exhausting. They make you feel uncomfortable, like you're trapped in an endless loop with them. At one point I found myself thinking how on earth are these two will get a HEA? Their fucked-up dynamic got my hands cupped. I read almost every single page with my jaw on the floor because there is nooo way they're actually thinking like that. You'll see what I mean. They're freaky and tend to overthink a lot. But other than that, the relationship isn't extremely violent or anything, but still it's so dark. The setting, the romance, everything was so unhinged and I devoured every bit of it. I haven't read anything quite like this in a really long time. The cold, emotionless boy acts like a robot and steals the avoidant girl’s heart? Yeah, I’ve never read anything like this in my life actually. I feel numb and empty right now. The only thing I didn't love was that I wished we could have read a bit more of the characters' everyday lives. Or even more about the worldbuilding because it looked cool! Every single scene served a specific purpose, and while reading on alert and filled with constant adrenaline was great, a few calm, quiet moments would have given the reader a chance to catch their breath. Especially after all that yearning and angst, I really wanted to see them a little happier for a bit. Spicy scenes somehow made their reunion better, but I still craved to see them more. I wish it was a duology, at least. And Raymond!!! You guys are not ready for him. He's possessive, obsessive, jealous but he's also extremely obedient when it cames to Mina's wishes. Dream boyfriend if you ask me. (Let's ignore his psychopath side he's actually a babygirl) As a debut novel, I absolutely loved Everdoll! The author clearly has incredible ideas, though I was looking for a bit more of a gothic atmosphere; the vibe leaned much more toward thriller-style descriptions rather than eerie, haunting atmosphere.
The second I saw the artwork and what this story was about I knew I wanted to read it! Mina is a journalist on Mars who tragically has been abandoned by virtually everyone she loves in some capacity but she tries to overcome her depressive thoughts which almost took her out when she was a teen. Enter Raymond, a cyborg who was born for a very specific nefarious purpose to scientist parents. Over time he becomes devastatingly obsessed with Mina. Depression and obsession are heavy in this story but well written I loved every minute of it.
I received this book as an ARC so it is understood that it’s not the final and there may be some errors especially with the POV being changed recently that should be fixed by release. That being said the first half of the book was a challenge. In this part we follow Mina and Raymond through their younger years and do get a bit of an understanding of their early relationship however, there is not much that actually happens in this part. I honestly forgot that this was even on Mars because of the minimal mention of out of the norm things and I did not understand the reason why these early chapters were formatted as incredibly long chapters. In my opinion this part of the story could have been streamlined and shortened a lot.
However once you make it past the last hours long chapter it gets REALLY good!! The formatting is more of the standard and the content of these chapters is exactly what I was hoping it would be! The out of the norm Martian aspects, the spice, the character development, the action are all top tier.
Overall I liked this book and would recommend with the note that you will need to be patient before it gets good but it does indeed get good!!
Everdoll is a haunting, beautifully unsettling blend of gothic romance, science fiction, psychological drama, and body horror. Set on Mars, it builds a world that feels both futuristic and disturbingly familiar, where technological ambition, corruption, and the desire for control have created a society full of shadows.
At the center are Mina and Raymond (Remi), whose relationship begins in childhood and grows into something far more complicated than a conventional love story. Their connection is tender, obsessive, painful, and often deeply uncomfortable. Mina's bright personality and determination to find hope make her compelling, while Raymond's unsettling devotion raises difficult questions about identity, consciousness, and what it truly means to be human. His parents were definitely not the best people to teach humanity.
And let me tell you, this book put me THROUGH IT. There were moments I literally gasped, put the book down, walked away, and had to come back when I was emotionally prepared to continue. There were countless "What the...?" and OMG moments. Just when I thought I had wrapped my head around something, Valen would pull the rug out from under me again. It hurt a little, in the absolute best way. There were parts I had to reread to get the full effect. That's the kind of storytelling that makes a book difficult to put down, even when you desperately need a minute.
This is not a light or uncomplicated romance. Its darker themes are intense, and the content warnings should be taken seriously.
A bold, dark, unforgettable read that left me reeling—and I'm still thinking about it.
Everdoll is a dark sci-fi romance set on Mars, following Mina, a sunshine-faced reporter hiding a lot of hurt, and Raymond Loxton, the man she has spent four years running from. When a trail of mutated “sleeping pill” victims pulls her back into his orbit, nothing is what she remembered. I loved how the prologue and epilogue mirror each other, Mina’s cheerful mask and the people-pleaser theme running through the whole story, the atmospheric worldbuilding (that staircase bar!), and the flashbacks structured as stages of addiction. What held it back for me was pacing, since over half the book is flashback and the present-day mystery loses momentum, along with repeated phrases and imagery, some heavy sci-fi exposition in the middle of emotional scenes, and a manuscript that needs another editing pass ( pls keep in mind this is the un-published version so you can expect this !!!)
⚠️ CWs: self-harm, drug use, body horror, graphic violence, trauma and unhealthy power dynamics. The author’s note is very thorough I actually found this very thoughtful.
Everdoll is perfect for readers who love intense, obsessive, messy romance with a sci-fi twist and don’t mind a slow, emotional middle! Would defs recommend giving this a read!
The plot/tropes is what pulled me into the story the most. I also LOVE sci-fi romance (as well as gothic and dark romance).
The vibes were there but not as much as I thought they'd be. It almost felt like the story was not set on Mars but on Earth in some chapters. It definitely needed more world building.
When it comes to the main characters, I really like their look/style and their backstory. The banter. The agony. I got major Edward Scissorhands vibes for some reason.
But... here comes the negative side of my review.
This needed more editing. Like a lot.
And the biggest mistake was switching from first to third pov. I think this should've stayed in third because it fits the author's writing style. There were some paragraphs written in 3rd pov and I honestly liked it much better. But of course it's all up to the author and their decision.
I had to re-read some sentences twice to understand them. Especially when the "I" or "and" was missing and it was needed. I was pulled from the story a lot for this reason.
The story has so much potential to be even better. The plot and characters are super interesting, but I think it needed more time to be polished to perfection.
I want to thank the author for the advanced copy :)
this is perfect for alnst fans imagine human x cyborg mizisua but hetero... surprisingly, remi/raymond wasn't your typical romance male lead at all, he was more like a yearner lesbian and that's what made him so enjoyable to read. as an abused child, he didn't have that toxic masculinity thing going on, he was just trying to figure himself out. it's 500+ pages but still the kind of book you could finish in one sitting. the narrative is easy to follow, the plot isn't too heavy and the characters are genuinely so interesting.
if you're into yandere-ish characters and a serious analysis of "love vs obsession" this was deliciouss. it felt like the beginning of a much wider universe, so the lack of a more developed plot didn't bother me. also really looking forward to prisne x reila yuri since the author said they're the original couple of this universe 👀
Going in I knew that this was a dark romance/Sci-Fi book and I was not disappointed. Both the FMC and the MMC are very morally grey and I love that. The obsession and toxic vibes kept me wanting to read more.
My rating of three stars was given due to the world building. I wanted so much more detail about the technology, culture, and how things work on Mars. I feel like if I would of had more of that I could of understood the characters better. Iris also chose to change the POV to first person and I wish it would of stayed in third.
I really tried to finish this arc, especially since it’s an arc I was given for free. However, it became increasingly difficult to read due to the sheer amount of typos and also change from first to third person, at some point the author obviously decided to change from 3. to 1. Person but missed many sections. The idea of the story is fantastic! Human and cyborg love. Co-dependency and a strong sense of love and loathing. I’m sorry the author didn’t have a better editor or beta readers to make this book into the hit it could have been.
It’s a very messy, dark, psychological and intense romance, but I really like how the story makes you question how to see the difference between love and obsession. Its not a fluffy romance, so if you want to read it, be prepared for complicated relationships, morally gray characters and stories that leave you thinking, even after you finished the book, then this is the one for you!