A homesick foreign student joins forces with her posh rival to win a painting contest when her scholarship is cancelled—all while they anonymously collaborate on a magical canvas that could change the world…and try not to fall in love.
At Xenra, the world’s foremost university for studying the art of transportive painting, blending art and the arcane is commonplace. But for Ayla, a foreigner in a xenophobic country, commonplace isn’t good enough. Not if she wants to graduate with a lucrative patronage and afford treatment for her dying mother back home. When the school cancels her scholarship, she’ll do anything to stay at Xenra—including asking her privileged rival Constantine to team up with her for a painting competition that would guarantee her tuition.
But there can only be one winner and Ayla will have to face—and beat—Constantine on her own in the contest’s final test. As someone who can barely afford food or new clothes, let alone painting supplies, Ayla is surprised to discover a mysterious canvas—a canvas that can turn anything painted on it into reality. With the power to change the art market (and perhaps the world), she’s hoping to learn what makes it work and apply that to her own paintings. But as Ayla investigates the magical canvas, she discovers that she’s not the only one working on it—someone else is adding to the painting as well. If she doesn’t hurry and figure out its power, she may lose her chance to become a patron-sponsored artist and save her family.
But she isn’t the only one struggling. Constantine, desperate to rejoin his aristocratic family after being disowned years ago, is the other artist working on the magical canvas. And even as he secretly collaborates on it—and passes wordless confessions through each brushstroke—he is butting heads against the captivating and maddening Ayla on their joint project.
As Ayla’s mother’s condition worsens and Constantine’s powerful family threatens their chances in the competition, Ayla must solve the mysteries of the canvas and secure her win, once and for all. But unraveling century-old secrets risks the very fate of her people, and Ayla and Constantine must each decide if winning is truly worth selling out this magic—and each other.
Katie Wu is an author of swoony and strange books. Born stateside but raised in Shanghai, she then studied computer science and fine arts at the University of Pennsylvania, and is now based in NYC. When not writing, she enjoys skiing, feeding her sourdough starter, and her two demonic cats. Madder Lake is her debut novel.
When you start reading Madder Lake you’re like oh this is a nice cozy fantasy and then by the end you’re like wow the privatized pharmaceutical industry is actually one of the world’s deepest evils
I’ve been lucky enough to see just how much fervor and respect that Katie has for her craft. Madder Lake was written with so much passion and sincerity, and I thoroughly enjoyed my time reading it.
Also lowkey the perfect cozy high-stakes book to read while you’re sick…
Thanks to HarperCollins UK, HarperFiction (Magpie) and NetGalley for the opportunity of reading this ARC! The review is personal and unaltered by external factors.
5/5
“Madder Lake” by Katie Wu is an adult romantic fantasy depicting the tumultuous yet addictive relationship between two artists, painters, as they struggle to compete with one another for the opportunity of continuing their studies as their scholarship programmes got cancelled. The world-building and lore are fairly direct, as the magic element surrounding their university, Xenra, centres around transportive painting, a style of painting which allows, through magic, the inclusion of the painter’s feelings.
Consequently, the plot is quite direct, although it has two layers. Firstly, the competition between Ayla and Constantine, and, secondly, the discovery of a mysterious canvas by the two, which hides a different kind of magic. The removal of the scholarship represents the intrigue, nonetheless, the action is quite character-driven, Ayla and Constantine’s actions and reactions always being in the spotlight.
Before I dive into both Ayla and Constantine’s characters, I must say, I was fully aware this book would centre around artists, so I expected the nature of their experiences to be equally psychological and dramatic, as they feel everything much more intensely. Without diving into a melodramatic cliché, Wu has captured the essence of the tortured and tormented artist outstandingly well, and I am particularly impressed as this is also her debut novel. She has set her own bar exceptionally high.
Ayla is a foreign student at Xenra, her character arc focusing on her discovering whom she is after experiencing life both in her native Yzmir and the current Xendai; she is someone who struggles not only with change, but also with novelty. Ayla, as both a painter and as the person behind the artist, placed herself in her own ivory tower, using her circumstances as both a shield and an excuse to forever victimise herself, to portray herself as a forever struggling and misunderstood artist when she is most definitely not. Her realisation of the fact is excellently executed, Ayla realising her most cruel saboteur being herself having a beautiful impact upon her overall character development. It took me a while to warm up to her, I must admit — I generally do not enjoy characters who dehumanise others simply because they were born in a family or another — but Wu’s complex psychological spiderweb had made Ayla particularly well-constructed and her character development rather exquisite to read, to the point that I could gloss over this particular aspect I do not generally enjoy.
« She swallowed, then lifted her gaze to his. “I never made the effort here because I was scared. And . . . after a while it was easier to not do things than to want them and lose them.” »
From the blurb alone, before even requesting this advanced copy, I knew I would like Constantine. In fact, I am quite certain I requested this book because I knew I would absolutely adore him. And my instinct has definitely not failed me. Contrary to Ayla, who wants to stick to traditionalism, Constantine wants to escape the limits set by the trendsetters, and challenge society itself with his art, always thinking outside the box. Ayla’s talent and beauty is an element which forever consumes him, making him burn to his very core, but also forcing himself to make the art that would shatter all expectations — both good and bad. That caused his very downfall vis-à-vis his family’s situation, and Constantine is a great contrast to Ayla — her conflict is internal, caused by herself, whereas his own conflict is always caused by external circumstances which, one way or another, leave a brand of recognition on him. His character arc does not necessarily revolve around him finding out whom he truly is, but on Constantine finally accepting that external factors are not his fault; life happens and he must accept it. Constantine is an elegant, intellectual and proactive male lead, and I believe Wu did a wonderful job portraying the avant-garde artist who struggles because few can truly see his vision. To speak in looser terms, Constantine is a cinnamon roll meow meow and I personally enjoyed every single appearance of his.
« “So you don’t think you irritate me too? You’re right; you always are. But perhaps you’re wrong this time because you don’t simply irritate me, you’ve consumed me, Ayla Kita. My dreams, my daydreams, my art, my body, my everything.” »
The relationship between the two evolves at a slow pace, but has enough chemistry to keep one interested in how it will develop. The unravelling and culmination point is extremely satisfying, both characters having reached a proper and mature psychological point before accepting one another, revealing not only loyalty, but also selflessness. They both push one another to be both better people and better artists. The depth of their feelings is especially delicious to savour.
« “I chose you, Constantine. And I’d choose you again, a million times over.” »
The narration is in dual perspective, revealing both Ayla and Constantine’s inner worlds and tumultuous feelings, along with their creative process. The prose is reflective of both the state of the artist — having beautiful metaphors and subtle double entendres to reveal the complex psychological state of both painters — and of the people behind the artistic personas — the language itself becoming more raw and impactful when this switch occurs. I particularly enjoyed the third person perspective, not only because of personal preference, but also because it enhances the differentiation between the painter and the person. They are two different personas and I enjoyed the subtle changes in nuance. Again, I would not have expected this sort of finesse from a debut novel, and I have especially high expectations of Wu in the future. She is definitely a writer, an artist, whose evolution I will follow from now on.
As far as recommendations go, I will be particularly straightforward — if you’re a fan of Julian Blackthorn (from Cassandra Clare’s “The Dark Artifices”/“The Shadowhunter Chronicles”) then experiencing Constantine’s character is an absolute must. There is no maybe or in-between, you just need to have Constantine in your life as well. As far as the relationship goes, I believe fans of “Beach Read” by Emily Henry, “Bad Words” by Rioghnach Robinson and even “The Picture of Dorian Gray” by Oscar Wilde, as well as Netflix’s “Love Through a Prism”, will enjoy experiencing the world and characters of “Madder Lake”.
Wow. Just wow. I haven't been touched by a book this way in a very long time. If someone ever asked me, "Why do you read?" I would show them this book, make them read it, and tell them, "Because of books like this".
I feel so incredibly lucky to have experienced this story. Thank you so much to Netgalley and Harper Collins UK for providing me with this ARC.
“She spoke in Xendarinese, dreamed in Yzmiri, but lived the language of colors. Words were not her medium. Colors were.”
I started reading with high hopes because the premise is absolutely fascinating, but... I didn't expect this! The writing is breathtakingly beautiful, the characters feel so real, so honest, and so alive, and gosh, the romance and banter are incredible and everything I could have asked for. As someone who has always struggled to find a sense of belonging, this story touched me in ways I can’t quite put into words. I am already missing Ayla, Constantine, and the magic that they created together.
“What was art if not the power to transcend words and bodies and time and other unimportant boundaries? What was art, if not to move you to fear, grief, hope, or exuberance? What was art, if not to say hello, you, this is what it means to be human?”
I had the privilege of reading an early draft of this and YOU ARE NOT READY for the darkly lush worldbuilding, intense rivals-to-lovers romantic yearning, and exploration of colonialism and diaspora identity. Add this! You’ll want to know when it’s out!
Thank you to the author for letting me read an early draft.
I can’t believe this is a debut book! Not necessarily because the plot and characters are so developed (they are), but because of Katie Wu's ability to make us feel things. I’m not claiming only veteran authors can make emotions shine through their books, but I think the challenge Katie Wu has created for herself in her story is particularly difficult, and she faces it with astounding … ease? Although certainly nothing about this must have been easy. Maturity? Probably not the right word either - there are experienced authors out there I know could never pull this off. Brilliance? Probably plays a role, along with hard work. I don’t know which it is, but it’s marvelous. Here’s why I’m so impressed: first of all, Katie Wu uses words to make us feel things. Obviously that's the whole point of writing and reading fiction, but a big pet peeve of mine is when I’m told to feel something while reading, but I’m not made to feel it, and well! This is not a problem here. BUT THEN! As if that was not enough! Katie Wu makes it even more complicated for herself! Her magic system is based on the magical art of “transportive painting”. And how this works is quite important for the point I’m trying to make. Basically, when painters with the talent for “transportive painting” create a piece of art, anyone who touches it is transported into the painting to feel the emotions the artist imbued in it. AND if you’re still reading my blabla, this is where lies the coup de maître! The display of Katie Wu’s boundless talent! She will, through words, make you feel all the emotions of the painting, as if you were seeing it, but you’re not, because you’re reading about it (obviously). I KNOW this is the whole point of fiction, but wow. Not often is this done in such a stirring way. I think only once you’ve read it can you understand how truly impressive this feat is.
But that’s not all! Madder Lake is also an incisive exploration of the art industry, and all its downfalls, plagued as it is (as most things are), by classism, racism, and xenophobia.
AND last but not least! Oh Ayla and Constantin will steal your heart away. Both characters are so tenderly written, and their story is exquisitely romantic. This made me feel alive, alive, alive.
Thank you so so so much (sooooo much) to Netgalley and Harper Voyager for the ARC!
This debut was so vivid and romantic I LOVED it. An Art Magic school was everything I didn’t know I wanted. After having done an arts degree this felt so nostalgic and so immersive.
Would 100% recommend to anyone that is looking for a dark academia, magic school.
Missing Ayla and Constantine and being wrapped up in all their tension and messiness and surrounded by their beautiful creations! Ayla is a tough young woman who deserves it all. Constantine is the exact kind of wounded boi you want to protect. Wu did *true* enemies to lovers justice with this one!
Thank you to Harper Collins UK for providing me with an E-ARC. All reviews are my own opinion!
What to expect: 🖼️ Rivals to lovers 🖼️ Transportive art like VR 🖼️ Commentary on capitalism 🖼️ Too cry for at least three times
Upon announcement, I had high expectations from Katie Wu, and Madder Lake as her debut absolutely delivered. If I have to pitch it to a very niche audience, I would strongly recommend Madder Lake to fans of the anime 'Love Through A Prism', which was a hit earlier this year; two prodigies rivaling in the art major, trying to best one another while drawing out each other's potentials too.
What worked for me was that I love the protagonists equally, individually and as a pairing; Ayla Kita and Constantine Esse. Both of them had their own motivation which we couldn't help but to sympathize and root for. Their voices jumped out of the book and held you by the neck to resonate deeply with them. Ayla's chapters especially hit because she was a homesick girl, yearning for home after being away in a foreign soil for a long time. Constantine also had his struggles which he shielded from the narratives, until we get to peel the layers of his character by time.
I also enjoyed the discussion and description around the art here. The debate and back and forth between Ayla and Constantine really was the soul of the book. Wu's prose was also a masterclass of its own. I highlighted so many quotes that blew me away. Combined with the theme, it was a good recipe for an academia story. I finished this in one sitting because I really felt like the story was a transportive painting itself.
For romantic pairing, it's safe to say that I like the progression of our pairing. The angst did hit me so well and it's frustrating when there's an obstacle, but it's so rewarding. There's so many highlights of my favourite Constantine moment. He's so tender when he needs to be. I cried for like three different times and Constantine's treatment of Ayla was the catalyst.
My only problem (for me only) was that I was left wanting to know more about worldbuilding. There's not enough description to distinguish the difference between Xendai and Yzmir, other than rich vs poor. How is their architecture or daily society? How is their market life? What is their celebration, culture or social norms? Their physical description also felt flimsy to even draw a clear comparison between the two. What is the origin of the magic and why is there such a high demand for it? Is there nothing else happening in the country outside of our main character's bubble?
But even with my questions of the outside world, the plot was consistent and faithful to the theme. I can see Wu's passion being poured into her craft, and Madder Lake is an outstanding debut. 100% recommend.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Talented, brilliant, incredible, amazing, showstopping, spectacular, never the same, totally unique, completely not ever been done before.
This book changed me. It's a gut punch. It's a sunrise. It's a comfort. It's thrilling. It's romantic. This is what the people want! This is what we deserve! Peak rivals-to-lovers. Set in a world where a select few individuals have the ability to create art that transports the viewer into the painting, so that viewer can feel the emotions that went into the art. Ayla is a poor foreign girl on scholarship at the Xendai Royal Academy of Art (or Xenra for short). Her bitter rival, her enemy, her main competition at Xenra is Constantine Esse, the heir to one of the richest and most powerful patron families in Xendai. Ayla has always felt an outcast as the only girl from Yzmir, a colony of the Xendainese empire. Subject to xenophobia, Ayla has worked desperately to maintain the top spot at the academy with the goal of graduating and getting a patronage that will pay enough to care for her ill mother who needs medicine to fight an infection that could kill her. Ayla soon learns, however, just one year before graduation, that her scholarship has been cancelled. Her only chance to stay and graduate, and to earn money to care for her mother, is to win the Headmaster's Prize art competition. Unfortunately for Ayla, Constantine is also entering the competition and has his own reasons for doing so. While the competition heats up, and the rivalry between Ayla and Constantine comes to a head, they discover a secret about the art, and the transportive magic, that could change their lives and their world.
I don't know what else to say. This book was stunning. Ayla and Constantine are everything to me. The writing was so beautiful. Obsessed.
Netgalley and Harper Voyager provided me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
The amount of yearnology and downbadism in this book is absolutely unhinged. I gotta say that this is academic-rivals-to-lovers done right and we LOVE to see it.
First of all, the idea that certain gifted artists can create transportive paintings capable of making people experience the emotions their creators intend to convey is genuinely fascinating. It’s so magical and captivating on so many levels.
And the academic setting of a prestigious art school with a cutthroat competitive atmosphere, sprinkled with fairytale-esque magic? UGH I LOOOOVE. But beneath all the magic and competitions, there’s something much more meaningful happening. This book explores the importance of human connection, about isolation and the sense of belonging. It touches on the idea of finding a place where you feel seen and understood, and that made the whole story feel so much more personal and heartbreaking.
I fear Ayla and Constantine ate with their top-tier yearning and tension. These two have officially set the standard for angsty yet heart-fluttering academic-rivals-to-lovers. I love how their relationship gradually unfolds, and how we get to see the emotional baggage and vulnerabilities that make them who they are. They’re complicated and flawed, and I love how those layers add so much depth to their connection. They also remind me SO MUCH of Iris and Roman from Divine Rivals. Not just their dynamic, but also the way they connect through a magical object. Great day for annoying people like me.
I would happily read more of Katie Wu’s work. PLEASE FEED ME MORE.
════════════════════════
Thank you to Avon, Harper Voyager, and NetGalley for the ARC!
Madder Lake was one of my anticipated releases of 2027, thus getting to read it early from NetGalley felt like a dream come true. Katie has a beautiful way of storytelling which I fell in love with (so many quotes were highlighted). Madder Lake felt like a breath of fresh air - academic rivalry done right. The yearning (and delusion) was strong in this one. Furthermore, I really enjoyed the mystery element that was woven into this which also ended up being a critique on society (big pharma and capitalism and whatever not). The magic system in was also very refreshing to read! 100% recommend, this one did not disappoint but only exceeded my expectations!
lowkey hesitant at first given the emphasis on the romance in the synopsis but katie wu has expressed views about romantasy that i share so ok i'm hopeful i'll actually like this romance
I am in shock and awe, you’re not ready for the yearning, the artistic angst, the romantic tension, the RIVALRY.
I was so honoured to get to read an early copy of this novel and Katie hit this absolutely out of the park. This is an astonishing debut and I cannot wait to see what she writes next!!
5⭐️: Thank you to The Nerd Fam for gifting me this ARC at a local event. Also, thank you to Harper Voyager for partnering with The Nerd Fam because if it wasn't for either of you, I wouldn't have had the opportunity to experience this beautiful story by Katie Wu.
This story is timeless, the way it was written sucked you into a world you felt fully immersed and intrigued by. Katie's writing style was beautiful and easy to navigate, the world building was effortless and the connection your build with Ayla and Constantine grew quickly from the beginning. I was able to spend the day yesterday in this world and story for hours and I couldn't put this book down until I knew how Ayla and Constantine were going to overcome the challenges they faced.
I am eager to see the world experience this story, and I hope to see a book tour released for this as I must meet Katie and get my hands on a signed copy with this beautiful cover!
So what is a spoiler free overview of this book? I got you!
Ayla is a student from Yazmir a far village known for their pigment factories and unfortunately a recent illness called Blue Spider. With this comes some stereotypes of the people from Yazmir and Ayla is always battling this image as she navigates being a top student at Xenra, the world's premier university dedicated to studying the arcane art of transportive painting.
Unlike a normal painting you see with your eyes, transportive paintings allows viewers to touch and feel the emotions imbued into the artwork itself. This is a rare gift and talent, but one Ayla is very skilled with... as well as her greatest rival Constantine Esse. Now Constantine recently joined the school a few years prior... and Ayla was always a top ranked student... until he showed up.... now the two consistently battle to see who can be top ranked.
This is a challenging thing for Ayla to overcome, because she is a scholarship student from Yazmir unlick Constantine who is a heir of the famous Esse family line known for their impact in the transportive painting world. The rivalry is more than just a game, it part of Ayla's future, because she needs to be top ranked and find patronage to be able to afford to send money home to her mother and mama. Because if she doesn't, mama may not be able to afford the medicine she needs to be able to take to hold back her illness that plagues the town, blue spider.
All of this pressure, and weight piles onto Ayla, once she finds out that the funds for her scholarship are being halted and she will no longer be able to afford to attend Xenra... she would go home with nothing... the only chance she has is to win the headmasters prize in transportive art to be able to keep the funds she needs to finish university and hopefully get patronage and have funds to take care of her family while doing what she loves... the only challenge... Constantine her rival has also entered the contest... In order to win... and help her family... she will have to beat her rival... she needs supplies she cannot make and while looking through the storage closet... she stumbles on something... a hidden room with a unfinished canvas... odd... but as Ayla examines... she learns something... this canvas hold more magic than a typical transportive painting... this canvas allows you to enter the painting and bring anything you paint into a reality... she soon also discovers... after visits... that she isn't the only one to have found this room and canvas... there is another who has been adding to the painting... but who could it be? Eager to continue... she and her mysterious painter continue to build on the magic canvas... as she tries to learn more about how this magic works, all while trying to win the headmasters prize and beating her rival to save her family...
જ⁀➴ "When we paint together I feel touched by the gods, and when I'm not painting with you I'm suffering."
I'd like to introduce you all to my newest client Madder Lake by Katie Wu. I am the official self proclaimed fan club president idc who disagrees. I had high expectations going into this book, but deep down, I thought it would never meet them, no matter how good it actually was, simply because my expectations were simply THAT high. So imagine my surprise when it ended up surpassing them. Katie Wu sat down to write this book and specifically thought "hmm i wonder what Alisha likes?" and wrote this specifically FOR ME.
˚₊‧꒰ ♯ now playing ▸ About You, The 1975↻ ꒱ ‧₊˚ ⤿ 💌: It's the same damn thing that made my heart surrender ౨ৎ
• ✦ The Plot & World-building — It's a fairly soft fantasy world don't expect like high fantasy stuff and the setting works so well for this book. The plot actually gave me life so we're following our FMC Ayla who's a foreign student in this prestigious Art College and her Rivals Constantine and there's Obv a competition and it was so good I ate up every sec of it. There was also a larger plot going on throughout the whole book and I loved the conclusion of it. This type of setting for a story is actually one of my favourite things ever like very early 20th century but with magic. I actually have no complaints 10/10 no notes.
• ✦ The Charcters — Oh where do i even Start Ayla Kita you are so dear to me. She reminded me so much of myself, especially through her experiences of studying in a foreign country where people speak a different language. Even after years of practice and becoming fluent, she still feels insecure about her grasp of the language. Ahh my shayla. Constantine Esse was so well written. His relationship with his family and how it affects his view of himself. They are my actual children in taking them under my custody. The side characters were also so good, specially Dalia. Every character felt like an actual person and not just a caricature of one. They were all very well rounded and I loved it.
• ✦ The Romance — THISS is how you do yearning. Master of yearnalogy right here. Every single scene I was dying you don't understand what they did to me. The intamacy of knowing each other so well. To love is to be known and AylaConstantine are the perfect example of it. I don't know how to be normal about them. This is why rivals to lovers will always be superior.
• ✦ The Writing — Was actually so good. I loved the prose. I feel like this book has such a distinctive writing style like i could see a quote from this book out in the wild and I'd instantly know where it's from. The way the paintings were described truly captured the actual feeling of a transportive painting. I feel like this was such an important thing to nail because if the writing hadn't been on par with the plot, the whole thing wouldn't have worked. So, major props to the author for nailing that!
⤿Overall: The whole review was just me totally fangirling over the book but that's truly how i feel. It delivered everything I wanted it to deliver and i could not be happier. This is actually now one of my all time favourite books i already wanna re-read again. Madder Lake truly is the love child of "Love through a prism" and "A Study in drowning" with "Divine Rivals" being the God mother and "Barbie as Rapunzel" being the fun aunt.
⋆.˚ "I'm not sick of you, Ayla Kita. I'm sick for you." ᝰ.ᐟ
Madder Lake was sweeping, all-consuming, and heartbreaking yet hopeful. I loved following Ayla and Constantine so much as two young rival art students. Their dynamic reminds me so much of other rivals-to-lovers couples I love, like Iris and Roman from Divine Rivals Their relationship really leans into the obsession that rivals can have with each other (which I don't feel like happens as often in other books), so that was super fun to read! I really loved the romance, but also Ayla and Constantine individually. Ayla, in particular, really moved me. There were so many times I found myself crying on her behalf—I wanted to give her a hug so badly. 😭
The magic in this book was also so interesting: paintings that evoke the emotion the painter intended you to feel the moment you touch it, and transportive canvases that suck you into the painting? Sign me up!! The way Katie set up the world and seamlessly incorporated themes of xenophobia, assimilation, working tirelessly to support your family as a first-gen immigrant, accessibility to art/education/healthcare, and the true meaning of home.
Katie's writing was so beautiful and captivating. She's a natural storyteller, and I can't wait to read what she writes next!
I've been on a streak of bad books I've either DNF'd or struggled to finish, but this...
This was everything I could have ever wanted. Enemies-to-lovers-to-rivals still. Academia. Nature. The arts.
"Madder Lake" is an easy 5 out of 5 for me. The academic setting, the intelligent, romantic writing style, and the conversations about family, pride, and the choices people make are so smart and so accessible. I devoured this in less than 24 hours. The pacing is perfect, although I could see how maybe the long draws of "nothing" or art talk might be dull to some readers. For myself, the breaking up of everything happening all the time, combined with the stakes both Ayla and Constantine face, was a welcome breath of air. There's so much breathing room that it feels like Ayla and Constantine take the reader by the hand and gently guide them through the narrative.
I really can't say enough. It's such a well-constructed novel that does a familiar plot so well. The characters are dimensional and resonated with me so much that I found myself choking up more than a few times. Sometimes, you can have both.
Massive thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for facilitating this e-arc. I'll be getting myself a physical copy to adore.
My thanks to HarperCollins UK and NetGalley for a free DRC of "Madder Lake" by Kaie Wu. Magical painting competition with a rivals to lovers thrope. An adult Romantic Fantasy. The gorgeous cover illustration bu Alice Cao sold me on giving this debut a try, even if it has a thrope that rarely, almost never works for me. If you are a lover of art, particulary painting, this novel certainly delivers on that. Some gorgeous descriptive prose. Ayla is the type of characater I can relate as she knows hunger and the strugle to survive, to fight for her dreams. On the other hand, in my reading history I only cared about one protagonist from a rich family, and that is certanly not Constantine. When I heve to read from a privileged POV that feels sorry for himself for not being his family's favorite golden boy, who is selfish, ignorant and has prejudices about minorities, and I am supposed to care, then there is no chance. The relationship between this two rivals was so painfuly set up to be edgy and so obviously go towards lovers, I just could not stand it. I gave up on this novel at 20%. I am sure it will have its audience and a positive reception. If the author decides to no longer write after a formula and step out from the overdone of trends, I might give her another try.
So grateful and overjoyed to have received an early digital copy of Madder Lake and I can't wait for everyone else to get a chance to read this!
This is my No. 1 recommendation for those who like Divine Rivals and miss the enemies-to-lovers vibe it gave off.
I loved the world building, the cozy nature of the opening and how the author slowly feeds you the darker parts of this novel. By the end I was pleasantly surprised by the in depth discussion of big companies/factories and the damage they cause for the benefit of others.
Constantine and Alya were brilliant together, Katie Wu made you feel like they actually HAD a reason to be top of their class and not just for the sake of the plot to move forward. Their slow-burn was also perfect, as it left you waiting just enough to breathe a sigh of relief when they finally confess their feelings, without wanting to bang your head against the wall.[
A really enjoyable read, with a good mix of romance, magic and darker moments.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Ummm this was so good. Fantasy art school, but about the evils of big pharma??? What’s not to like? I am so sorry y’all have to wait until next August to read this but the wait will be worth it.
This book was pretty much perfect in every way. Magical painting? Check. Cool art school? Check. Enemies to lovers romance? Check. Political commentary? Check. My only complaint was the writing was a teensy bit chaotic/confusing in spots, but in a way that is super editable, and I imagine will be edited before its release.
I will 1000% be buying this for my favorites shelf when it comes out.
Thanks so much to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC.
Madder Lake is one of those types of books you will continuously think back on, whether that's for the masterfully crafted romantic relationship, breathtaking prose, or the unique magic system. I remain in awe of Ayla and Constantine for their relatability, growth, and passion and never stopped routing for them even when the world pitted them against the other. I wasn't expecting the environmental justice elements woven into the novel, but I deeply appreciated it and found it to be one of my favorite elements in this beautiful story. All in all, this is a 2027 debut you won't want to miss.