S. Craig Zahler has proven himself to be one of the best new auteur filmmakers. He made his directorial debut in 2015 with Bone Tomahawk, a top notch western with an extremely effective horror turn in the last act. This put him on my radar to watch closely and his second directorial effort did not disappoint. The rule breaking, grindhouse throwback Brawl in Cell Block 99 cemented Zahler as one of my favorite filmmakers. I am eagerly anticipating his next film Dragged Across Concrete which should be coming out later this year, hopefully it gets a wide release.
Being a fan of Zahler’s work it was a pleasant surprise to learn that he had already established himself as a successful author in advance of his film career. The writing within his two feature films are absolute standouts of the years in which they were made and both Bone Tomahawk and Brawl in Cell Block 99 had some of the best dialogue and character work around. It was exciting to learn that he had more material for me to experience.
I’d like to take a moment to admire how goddamn good Zahler is at titling his works. Bone Tomahawk, Brawl in Cell block 99, Dragged Across Concrete, Wraiths of the Broken Land, A Congregation of Jackals, and the subject of this review; Mean Business on North Ganson Street, are all badass titles.
Mean Business follows Detective Jules Bettinger as he is forced to relocate from Arizona to Victory Missouri, dubbed the worst city in America. The relocation takes place after a short scene that brilliantly sets up the protagonist. Bettinger is a great detective but he’s blunt, witty, rude, and has little patience for those on the other end of conflict. A business man speaks to Bettinger at the police station about the disappearance of his wife and the blunt detective gives it to him straight that she isn’t in danger, she skipped town with his money and never loved him. On his way out the door, the businessman steals an officer’s gun and kills himself, thus Bettinger is relocated as punishment.
Our protagonist has an excellent way with language, he’s chock full of smarmy comebacks and witty jabs, but he doesn’t use this clever language to dress up or soften the intent behind his words. He is direct and to the point and doesn’t mind being seen as an asshole.
This is a character trait that could be cliché. There are a great many protagonists who are constructed with a similar formula, particularly in procedural television. The number of protagonists who can be described by the line; He’s great solving cases but he has personality issues, is a little overwhelming. A lot of these are good, but the formula is apparent, he’s great at solving cases but he has personality issues (Sherlock) he’s great at solving cases but he has personality issues (House) he’s great at solving cases but he has personality issues (Rake) he’s great at solving cases but he has personality issues (Backstrom) he’s great at solving cases but he has personality issues (Bosch) he’s great at solving cases but he has personality issues (Monk) he’s great at solving cases but he has personality issues (Psych) he’s great at solving cases but he has personality issues (Inspector Morse) He’s great at solv- honestly this list could go on and on.
This is all to say that while the Mean Business on North Ganson Street protagonist could potentially fit this mold, he never feels cliché. His personality comes across wonderfully and he makes for a really fun, well-defined character to follow through this incredibly dark story. Bettinger’s family is also well developed, especially his wife and the relationship that the two of them share. There’s a bit of characterization that I love for the wife’s character where evey time she laughs it sounds like there’s an old man in her chest having a fit, and Bettinger loves to get that oldster chuckling. Their relationship is sweet and provides an excellent balance to Bettinger’s disposition. She’s a great character in her own right as well, not just in relationship to the story’s lead. She’s a painter and as the story progresses we learn more about her as a person and an artist. The trajectory of her career, with a highly lauded gallery to feature her work, provides a good foil to the dangerous and consuming work of her husband. In many detectives stories an aside to explore the protagonist’s family can feel like little more than a distraction to the central plot, but here, every time Bettinger took a minute to call home while on the job, I was fully invested and grew to like the characters more and more.
The novel is host to a bevy of antagonistic characters, the main baddie left a mystery for a good chunk of the book, and even after the reveal they are exclusively referred to without actually being present until the very end. This isn’t an issue as there is a strong cast of secondary antagonists with a mysterious man called E.V.K being particularly menacing, partly due to his horrific actions, but also due to how little we learn about him as a reader. A great example of how to create intrigue by withholding information.
In addition to the antagonistic characters, the book is also set in an oppressively antagonistic setting. The fictional setting of Victory is easily the most engrossing aspect of Mean Business on North Ganson Street. Victory is a city comprised almost exclusively of criminals, not even police maintain order, the police that are present are largely corrupt and the entirety of the law force is a constant target to violent killers. Victory is the kind of city where the street signs have all been decapitated and you gauge which turn to take by the severed cat head nailed to the telephone pole. It’s a brutal place and Zahler’s description of it is rich and consuming in the best way. It’s a setting that I could spend much more time in as a reader. There are a few smaller confrontations between Bettinger and the cop hating locals and more of these instances would have been welcome. The world building is incredibly strong and contributes greatly for my desire to see this story as a feature film, or even the setting as a television series.
I looked into it after finishing the book and according to Deadline the film rights were actually acquired by Warner Brothers back in 2013 with Zahler set to write the script and the film set to star Leonardo DiCaprio and Jamie Foxx. I would hope Zahler would be able to direct it as well but the is no director attached and it doesn’t look like the production has moved forward. As much as I like DiCaprio and Foxx, I don’t think they fit the roles. According to Deadline, Dicaprio is supposed to play Bettinger, which is definitely not right since Bettinger is described as having skin as dark as outer space but without the stars, and Jamie Foxx is set to play his parter who is constantly described as being absolutely massive, but Foxx is only 5’9, far from a behemoth, still that’s an easier change than a complete race swap which is pretty important to the character. If I were casting, I’d go with someone like Lance Reddick or Michael K Williams as Bettinger and someone like Tiny Lister JR. or Terry Crews as his partner.
I would like to see Mean Business on North Ganson Street as a novel, the entire story is very cinematic and the short chapters, many lasting only a page or two, made the pacing feel considerably more film-like than your average book as it moved from scene-to-scene.
Mean Business on North Ganson street pulls no punches. It’s mean, it’s brutal, it’s cool, it’s witty, and one hell of a read. I was reading it quite late one night and had to put it down before I fell asleep, I had a dream in the book’s world, then finished the rest of the book first thing in the morning. A novel hasn’t grabbed me like that in a long while. I highly recommend it.