What do you think?
Rate this book
The Stonewall Duology #2
A Lesson in Desire: A Spicy Dark Academia
422 pages, Kindle Edition
Published September 23, 2026
About the author
Abbey Tonkinson
3 books17 followersAbbey Tonkinson is an indie author based on the Isle of Wight, England, where she lives with her partner and their fur baby, Peanut. When she’s not writing dark romance novels, she works part-time in a bookshop – a job she loves with her whole heart.
In her spare time, Abbey enjoys reading, good food, good wine and long walks in the countryside. A Study in Ruin is her debut novel, with many more stories already in the works.
In her spare time, Abbey enjoys reading, good food, good wine and long walks in the countryside. A Study in Ruin is her debut novel, with many more stories already in the works.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 30 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
A Lesson in Desire picks up with Adora carrying the weight of everything that happened before. Then there's Theo who comes with his own baggage. But the enemies to lovers' dynamic between these two was executed well. There isn't just spice because it's a romance book, there's deep emotions, healing, and learning to deal with grief. It was beautiful to see the relationship between Adora and Theo develop throughout the book, and I enjoyed getting a little more of Iris and Archer as well.
Review of advance copy received from Author
This is the second book in The StoneWall Duology. This book pickups up where A Study In Ruin left you. Adora dealing with the aftermath after everything that happened. In this read you watch her process the stages of grief and more through anger, betrayal, and the loneliness. This added an emotional depth to the read and one of the reasons it made the a great read. This book is enemies to lovers and it gave with no remorse. The murder mystery had me on my toes guessing what would happen next. Overall this was a spicy mystery enemies to lovers that I will recommend for days to come. Highly Recommend!
September 24, 2026
I’ve enjoyed this duology sooo much! I found myself bingeing through it whenever I got the chance. It’s so good.
So easy to read, but so interesting.
I loved the characters, the twists. The dark academia setting.
Academia, murder mystery, romance, spice. It had a bit of everything
I wasn’t expecting the big twist at the end but I wasn’t blown away by it.
I wasn’t expecting this book to be based around different characters to the first book, but it worked really well.
Such a vibes read, id totally recommend this series to anyone.
So easy to read, but so interesting.
I loved the characters, the twists. The dark academia setting.
Academia, murder mystery, romance, spice. It had a bit of everything
I wasn’t expecting the big twist at the end but I wasn’t blown away by it.
I wasn’t expecting this book to be based around different characters to the first book, but it worked really well.
Such a vibes read, id totally recommend this series to anyone.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I absolutely loved A Lesson in Desire. Abbey has completely knocked it out of the park with this one.
I'll admit, I went into Theo's story feeling pretty sceptical. After everything in book one, I genuinely didn't think there was any way I'd forgive him. But Abbey handled his redemption so incredibly well. It never felt rushed or forced it felt earned. It was such an important part of the story, and by the end, I'd completely changed my mind. We all make mistakes, and watching Theo grow was one of my favourite parts of the book.
Theo and Adora were everything. Their chemistry was undeniable from the start, and although they both tried to fight it, they just fit. They complemented each other so naturally, and I found myself rooting for them every step of the way. And yes... the spice was hot. 🥵
I also loved that this book wasn't just romance. It had so much heart, plenty of laugh-out-loud moments that had me rolling my eyes in the best way, and twists I genuinely didn't see coming. I was completely hooked.
Seeing Archer and Iris again was so special. I loved catching up with them and seeing how much they'd grown, especially the love and support they have for Adora. Iris finally finding that sense of family was beautiful, and the found family aspect of this series continues to be one of my favourite things. And Boo the cat making an appearance again? That honestly sealed the deal for me.
The dual POV worked perfectly and really helped me connect with both Theo and Adora. I also loved all the little nods back to book one they made the world feel even richer without taking anything away from this story.
This is only Abbey's second book, but her writing just keeps getting stronger. The characters, the emotion, the humour, the tension... it all came together so beautifully.
I'll admit, I went into Theo's story feeling pretty sceptical. After everything in book one, I genuinely didn't think there was any way I'd forgive him. But Abbey handled his redemption so incredibly well. It never felt rushed or forced it felt earned. It was such an important part of the story, and by the end, I'd completely changed my mind. We all make mistakes, and watching Theo grow was one of my favourite parts of the book.
Theo and Adora were everything. Their chemistry was undeniable from the start, and although they both tried to fight it, they just fit. They complemented each other so naturally, and I found myself rooting for them every step of the way. And yes... the spice was hot. 🥵
I also loved that this book wasn't just romance. It had so much heart, plenty of laugh-out-loud moments that had me rolling my eyes in the best way, and twists I genuinely didn't see coming. I was completely hooked.
Seeing Archer and Iris again was so special. I loved catching up with them and seeing how much they'd grown, especially the love and support they have for Adora. Iris finally finding that sense of family was beautiful, and the found family aspect of this series continues to be one of my favourite things. And Boo the cat making an appearance again? That honestly sealed the deal for me.
The dual POV worked perfectly and really helped me connect with both Theo and Adora. I also loved all the little nods back to book one they made the world feel even richer without taking anything away from this story.
This is only Abbey's second book, but her writing just keeps getting stronger. The characters, the emotion, the humour, the tension... it all came together so beautifully.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Well… Abbey Tonkinson has officially gone from new author to me to author I’m absolutely keeping an eye on, because WHAT WAS THIS?! 😳🔥
After A Study in Ruin, I thought I had some idea of what I was getting myself into with the second book. I was wrong. So very, very wrong.
A Lesson in Desire picks up with Adora carrying the weight of everything that happened before, and my heart genuinely hurt for her. She isn’t just dealing with what happened, she’s trying to figure out how to exist after it. The nightmares, grief, betrayal, anger, and loneliness make her journey feel raw and emotional.
And yet, underneath all of that heartbreak is this incredible thread of strength and survival.
Adora doesn't magically wake up one morning completely healed. She struggles. She falls apart. She gets angry. She doubts herself. But slowly, she begins finding pieces of herself again, and watching that happen was one of my favourite parts of the book.
Then comes Theo. Oh, Theo. Irritating? Absolutely.
Cocky? Beyond question. Infuriating? Frequently.
Did I want to throw something at him while simultaneously wondering what the hell he was going to do next? Also absolutely. 😂
The enemies to lovers dynamic between Adora and Theo was deliciously complicated because neither of them is exactly walking into this relationship without baggage. Their connection develops alongside all the chaos happening around them, and somehow Abbey Tonkinson manages to balance the romance with the darker mystery surrounding Stonewall.
And speaking of Stonewall… WHY IS EVERYONE DYING?! 😂 Seriously, these people need to stop discovering bodies long enough to have a peaceful afternoon.
The murder mystery kept me guessing, and the combination of secrets, betrayal, danger, romance, and dark academia atmosphere made this one ridiculously easy to get sucked into. Every time I thought things might finally calm down, the story basically turned around and said, “Cute. Anyway…”
I also loved seeing Iris again and watching the characters come together when everything around them was falling apart. There’s a real sense of found family and loyalty underneath all the darkness, and that made the emotional moments hit even harder.
But the biggest thing for me was Adora's journey.
This wasn't simply a story about finding love after heartbreak. It was about finding yourself again when you aren't sure there's enough of you left to put back together.
And THAT hit.
The romance was spicy, the mystery was addictive, the characters were complicated, and the twists kept me turning pages because I needed answers.
Abbey Tonkinson absolutely delivered with this duology.
I came into A Study in Ruin as a reader discovering a new author.
I’m leaving A Lesson in Desire thinking:
Okay, Abbey… what are we writing next? Because I’m already interested. 😂📚
Dark academia? ✔️
Murder? ✔️
Secrets? ✔️
Betrayal? ✔️
Enemies-to-lovers? ✔️
Emotional damage? OH, DEFINITELY.
Spice? 🔥✔️
A heroine fighting to find herself again? Absolutely.
5 stars from me! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
The Stonewall Duology took me on one hell of a ride, and I am very glad I climbed aboard.
After A Study in Ruin, I thought I had some idea of what I was getting myself into with the second book. I was wrong. So very, very wrong.
A Lesson in Desire picks up with Adora carrying the weight of everything that happened before, and my heart genuinely hurt for her. She isn’t just dealing with what happened, she’s trying to figure out how to exist after it. The nightmares, grief, betrayal, anger, and loneliness make her journey feel raw and emotional.
And yet, underneath all of that heartbreak is this incredible thread of strength and survival.
Adora doesn't magically wake up one morning completely healed. She struggles. She falls apart. She gets angry. She doubts herself. But slowly, she begins finding pieces of herself again, and watching that happen was one of my favourite parts of the book.
Then comes Theo. Oh, Theo. Irritating? Absolutely.
Cocky? Beyond question. Infuriating? Frequently.
Did I want to throw something at him while simultaneously wondering what the hell he was going to do next? Also absolutely. 😂
The enemies to lovers dynamic between Adora and Theo was deliciously complicated because neither of them is exactly walking into this relationship without baggage. Their connection develops alongside all the chaos happening around them, and somehow Abbey Tonkinson manages to balance the romance with the darker mystery surrounding Stonewall.
And speaking of Stonewall… WHY IS EVERYONE DYING?! 😂 Seriously, these people need to stop discovering bodies long enough to have a peaceful afternoon.
The murder mystery kept me guessing, and the combination of secrets, betrayal, danger, romance, and dark academia atmosphere made this one ridiculously easy to get sucked into. Every time I thought things might finally calm down, the story basically turned around and said, “Cute. Anyway…”
I also loved seeing Iris again and watching the characters come together when everything around them was falling apart. There’s a real sense of found family and loyalty underneath all the darkness, and that made the emotional moments hit even harder.
But the biggest thing for me was Adora's journey.
This wasn't simply a story about finding love after heartbreak. It was about finding yourself again when you aren't sure there's enough of you left to put back together.
And THAT hit.
The romance was spicy, the mystery was addictive, the characters were complicated, and the twists kept me turning pages because I needed answers.
Abbey Tonkinson absolutely delivered with this duology.
I came into A Study in Ruin as a reader discovering a new author.
I’m leaving A Lesson in Desire thinking:
Okay, Abbey… what are we writing next? Because I’m already interested. 😂📚
Dark academia? ✔️
Murder? ✔️
Secrets? ✔️
Betrayal? ✔️
Enemies-to-lovers? ✔️
Emotional damage? OH, DEFINITELY.
Spice? 🔥✔️
A heroine fighting to find herself again? Absolutely.
5 stars from me! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
The Stonewall Duology took me on one hell of a ride, and I am very glad I climbed aboard.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Wow, I loved this second book even more than the first and absolutely devoured it! I was so excited to return to these wonderful characters and this amazing world, particularly Adora who I fell in love with in the first book, so I couldn’t wait to see where her story went! I really related to her and love her even more now (and honestly, I would die for her!)
I was hooked from the get go and loved every single second of reading this and sharing this journey with these characters. The character development is amazing and is given the proper attention it deserves. It honestly made me emotional to see the journey these characters go on and be there with them 🥹
The plot had me on edge (in the best way!) and desperate to know more throughout, I couldn’t wait to keep reading! The author has done a wonderful job of continuing the story whilst keeping things interesting and fresh. Like the first book, this was full of twists and turns and kept me guessing throughout. I love a bit of mystery and drama and this delivered and then some!
The love story absolutely had me by the throat as well, I loved it with my whole soul! Ahhhh these two are the frikkin’ cutest! I adore an enemies to lovers and this did not disappoint! It had everything I could have asked for and more. Their chemistry was off the charts with the most adorable and natural banter and I wholly believed in their love story and journey. Certain bits had giggling with absolute delight and at other moments I had to cool down! The spicy scenes were PERFECT. Wonderfully written, beautiful and hotttttttt as hell 🔥 I’ll be thinking about those for a while 👀
The level of detail and the way the author sets the scene is absolutely incredible. As with the first book I truly felt like I was there and was completely immersed in the story. The way tension is created and built is incredible and I was honestly holding my breath and on the edge of my seat at times. Some amazingly written horror elements at times too which I loved! The author is truly such a beautiful writer, it was such a joy to read this sequel and even though I am going to miss these characters soooo much 😭 I am so excited to see what’s in store next, I know it’s going to be incredible, whatever it is!
I was hooked from the get go and loved every single second of reading this and sharing this journey with these characters. The character development is amazing and is given the proper attention it deserves. It honestly made me emotional to see the journey these characters go on and be there with them 🥹
The plot had me on edge (in the best way!) and desperate to know more throughout, I couldn’t wait to keep reading! The author has done a wonderful job of continuing the story whilst keeping things interesting and fresh. Like the first book, this was full of twists and turns and kept me guessing throughout. I love a bit of mystery and drama and this delivered and then some!
The love story absolutely had me by the throat as well, I loved it with my whole soul! Ahhhh these two are the frikkin’ cutest! I adore an enemies to lovers and this did not disappoint! It had everything I could have asked for and more. Their chemistry was off the charts with the most adorable and natural banter and I wholly believed in their love story and journey. Certain bits had giggling with absolute delight and at other moments I had to cool down! The spicy scenes were PERFECT. Wonderfully written, beautiful and hotttttttt as hell 🔥 I’ll be thinking about those for a while 👀
The level of detail and the way the author sets the scene is absolutely incredible. As with the first book I truly felt like I was there and was completely immersed in the story. The way tension is created and built is incredible and I was honestly holding my breath and on the edge of my seat at times. Some amazingly written horror elements at times too which I loved! The author is truly such a beautiful writer, it was such a joy to read this sequel and even though I am going to miss these characters soooo much 😭 I am so excited to see what’s in store next, I know it’s going to be incredible, whatever it is!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Review of advance copy received from Author
6 STARS — because five genuinely isn’t enough.
A Lesson in Desire by Abbey Tonkinson didn’t just earn five stars from me — it barged straight past them and demanded a sixth.
This book was tension, obsession, yearning and chemistry wrapped up in one dangerously addictive package. The kind of romance where every interaction has you analysing the smallest look, touch or word because the tension between the characters is practically screaming off the page.
And the Yearning?! Absolutely criminal.
There’s something about Abbey's writing that makes you completely surrender to the story. I wasn’t casually reading this. I was invested. I was frustrated when they were frustrated, jealous when they were jealous, scared when they were scared and internally screaming whenever the tension got too much.
But what pushed this into six-star territory for me was that underneath all that heat was genuine emotion. The storyline was executed so well! There wasn't spice for the sake of spice — there were feelings tangled underneath everything, making those moments hit so much harder. The story that followed on from book one was integrated so smoothly the gap was unrecognisable. The twists and turns were unimaginable and the ENDING?! well hand me a book three RIGHT NOW.
This is exactly the kind of romance and thrill I love: messy feelings, questionable decisions, ridiculous chemistry and characters who completely consume each other. Choices that are made on hope, decisions that are made without rationality. Plans that are put into motion based on love rather than reason.
I finished it in just over 24hrs and immediately had that horrible little moment of:
“…well, what am I supposed to read now?”
Abbey Tonkinson, respectfully, you had absolutely no business making me this feral over fictional people nor to raise my blood pressure that high.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 6/5
Would recommend.
Would reread.
Would willingly suffer the emotional damage again.
Some books give you a lesson in romance. This one gave me a lesson in desire. 🖤
A Lesson in Desire by Abbey Tonkinson didn’t just earn five stars from me — it barged straight past them and demanded a sixth.
This book was tension, obsession, yearning and chemistry wrapped up in one dangerously addictive package. The kind of romance where every interaction has you analysing the smallest look, touch or word because the tension between the characters is practically screaming off the page.
And the Yearning?! Absolutely criminal.
There’s something about Abbey's writing that makes you completely surrender to the story. I wasn’t casually reading this. I was invested. I was frustrated when they were frustrated, jealous when they were jealous, scared when they were scared and internally screaming whenever the tension got too much.
But what pushed this into six-star territory for me was that underneath all that heat was genuine emotion. The storyline was executed so well! There wasn't spice for the sake of spice — there were feelings tangled underneath everything, making those moments hit so much harder. The story that followed on from book one was integrated so smoothly the gap was unrecognisable. The twists and turns were unimaginable and the ENDING?! well hand me a book three RIGHT NOW.
This is exactly the kind of romance and thrill I love: messy feelings, questionable decisions, ridiculous chemistry and characters who completely consume each other. Choices that are made on hope, decisions that are made without rationality. Plans that are put into motion based on love rather than reason.
I finished it in just over 24hrs and immediately had that horrible little moment of:
“…well, what am I supposed to read now?”
Abbey Tonkinson, respectfully, you had absolutely no business making me this feral over fictional people nor to raise my blood pressure that high.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 6/5
Would recommend.
Would reread.
Would willingly suffer the emotional damage again.
Some books give you a lesson in romance. This one gave me a lesson in desire. 🖤
Review of advance copy received from Author
Firstly, thank you so much to the author for sending me an ARC of this book to read ahead of publishing for an honest review!
After reading a Study in Ruin (rated 4.5 star) and absolutely devouring it, when Abbey offered me the opportunity to read her second book A Lesson in Desire as an ARC I simply couldn't resist.
A Lesson in Desire did not disappoint. I gave it 5 stars with a 4 chilli spice rating (I didn't feel like it was quite as raunchy as book 1 personally but still delicious in every way possible if spice is your thing)
As with book 1 the best thing about these dark romance books that Abbey writes is she absolutely nails the plot and gives a perfect balance alongside the spice. I actually preferred book 2 as it wasn't quite as heavy on the supernatural elements. There is still a prominent link to it but because the main focus in on Adora who is not gifted the book didn't feel quite so farfetched (farfetched is the wrong word to use really given I loved the story of book 1).
Anyway, this story follows Dora who after the traumatic events of the first book returns school anxious and withdrawn. She gets paired with Theo (we hate him) to work on a project but when the murders re-start Dora and Theo find they have to work together with the help of our beloved characters from book 1 (Iris, Archer and Boo) to find out who the heck is behind the murders once and for all.
The plot may be a little predictable in parts but I can't ever get over how well Abbey writes her characters and her dialogue. It is the kind of writing that just makes you really connect with them and makes you really feel! Likewise, the world building is simple yet effective. It is not too dramatic but you can clearly picture exactly what the world looks and feels like- it's just all perfectly balanced for a nice quick easy read in my opinion.
Absolutely loved it, can't wait to see what else Abbey creates!
After reading a Study in Ruin (rated 4.5 star) and absolutely devouring it, when Abbey offered me the opportunity to read her second book A Lesson in Desire as an ARC I simply couldn't resist.
A Lesson in Desire did not disappoint. I gave it 5 stars with a 4 chilli spice rating (I didn't feel like it was quite as raunchy as book 1 personally but still delicious in every way possible if spice is your thing)
As with book 1 the best thing about these dark romance books that Abbey writes is she absolutely nails the plot and gives a perfect balance alongside the spice. I actually preferred book 2 as it wasn't quite as heavy on the supernatural elements. There is still a prominent link to it but because the main focus in on Adora who is not gifted the book didn't feel quite so farfetched (farfetched is the wrong word to use really given I loved the story of book 1).
Anyway, this story follows Dora who after the traumatic events of the first book returns school anxious and withdrawn. She gets paired with Theo (we hate him) to work on a project but when the murders re-start Dora and Theo find they have to work together with the help of our beloved characters from book 1 (Iris, Archer and Boo) to find out who the heck is behind the murders once and for all.
The plot may be a little predictable in parts but I can't ever get over how well Abbey writes her characters and her dialogue. It is the kind of writing that just makes you really connect with them and makes you really feel! Likewise, the world building is simple yet effective. It is not too dramatic but you can clearly picture exactly what the world looks and feels like- it's just all perfectly balanced for a nice quick easy read in my opinion.
Absolutely loved it, can't wait to see what else Abbey creates!
Review of advance copy received from Author
📚 A Lesson in Desire by Abbey Tonkinson
I had high hopes for this book after reading Abbey’s first book, A Study in Ruin, and I can now say that A Lesson in Desire exceeded my expectations.
This book continues where the first book left off, but we are now following another duo, Adora and Theo.
Adora is working through her emotions, just trying to get through each day—but who exactly is Theo Whitmore? And the question they both start asking themselves is: Is everything really back to normal at the school?
I really loved the two main characters in this book. It has an enemies-to-lovers arc where neither of them can stand the other. The yearning that builds between these two is so beautifully written, and you can really feel the internal battles they’re both struggling with.
The pacing is good, and the chemistry between them really comes through to the reader.
We’ve already been introduced to this school setting, so everything feels familiar and there isn’t as much world-building needed. You do need to have read A Study in Ruin before going into this one to fully understand why everything is the way it is.
There really isn’t anything negative I have to say about this book. I only wish there were more of it because I didn’t want it to end!
Overall, this is an amazing book, and Abbey has quickly become a favorite author of mine. I can’t wait to see what she has in store for us in the future.
🖤 Enemies to lovers
🏛️ Dark academia
🌶️ Spicy
🔍 Mystery
⭐️ Rating: 5/5
🌶️ Spice: 3/5
I had high hopes for this book after reading Abbey’s first book, A Study in Ruin, and I can now say that A Lesson in Desire exceeded my expectations.
This book continues where the first book left off, but we are now following another duo, Adora and Theo.
Adora is working through her emotions, just trying to get through each day—but who exactly is Theo Whitmore? And the question they both start asking themselves is: Is everything really back to normal at the school?
I really loved the two main characters in this book. It has an enemies-to-lovers arc where neither of them can stand the other. The yearning that builds between these two is so beautifully written, and you can really feel the internal battles they’re both struggling with.
The pacing is good, and the chemistry between them really comes through to the reader.
We’ve already been introduced to this school setting, so everything feels familiar and there isn’t as much world-building needed. You do need to have read A Study in Ruin before going into this one to fully understand why everything is the way it is.
There really isn’t anything negative I have to say about this book. I only wish there were more of it because I didn’t want it to end!
Overall, this is an amazing book, and Abbey has quickly become a favorite author of mine. I can’t wait to see what she has in store for us in the future.
🖤 Enemies to lovers
🏛️ Dark academia
🌶️ Spicy
🔍 Mystery
⭐️ Rating: 5/5
🌶️ Spice: 3/5
Review of advance copy received from Author
Thank you, Abbey, for the ARC (available September 23, 2026).
This book had the perfect blend of eerie vibes, mystery, and spice!
This book picks up where A Study in Ruin left off, but this time following Adora as she tries to put the broken pieces of her life back into place. She navigates the betrayal of her boyfriend while also trying to keep up with her studies. In comes Theo, a fellow student who doesn’t have the best reputation, and is now her partner for a school project. But there’s more to Theo than meets the eye, and she finds that he isn’t as bad as she once thought he was.
Adora’s struggles were so visceral. She has been through the wringer and it’s so difficult for her to come to terms with everything that she’s experienced. She’s basically a shell of her former self, and it made me so sad because she was such a happy person before. But Theo helps her heal in so many ways, and so do Iris and Archer (from book 1). Their little group has such a great dynamic!
While Theo starts out as a pretty unlikable character, as you find out more about him and why he is the way he is, it definitely makes him more endearing. He has gone through his own fair share of struggles, and as much as he helps Adora, she helps him as well. They’re such a sweet couple!
This book has the perfect spooky vibes for this time of year, complete with some murder mystery and plot twists that keeps you on your toes the whole time. And what’s even better is that Boo, the cat companion from book 1, is back and we get to find out more about him!
This book had the perfect blend of eerie vibes, mystery, and spice!
This book picks up where A Study in Ruin left off, but this time following Adora as she tries to put the broken pieces of her life back into place. She navigates the betrayal of her boyfriend while also trying to keep up with her studies. In comes Theo, a fellow student who doesn’t have the best reputation, and is now her partner for a school project. But there’s more to Theo than meets the eye, and she finds that he isn’t as bad as she once thought he was.
Adora’s struggles were so visceral. She has been through the wringer and it’s so difficult for her to come to terms with everything that she’s experienced. She’s basically a shell of her former self, and it made me so sad because she was such a happy person before. But Theo helps her heal in so many ways, and so do Iris and Archer (from book 1). Their little group has such a great dynamic!
While Theo starts out as a pretty unlikable character, as you find out more about him and why he is the way he is, it definitely makes him more endearing. He has gone through his own fair share of struggles, and as much as he helps Adora, she helps him as well. They’re such a sweet couple!
This book has the perfect spooky vibes for this time of year, complete with some murder mystery and plot twists that keeps you on your toes the whole time. And what’s even better is that Boo, the cat companion from book 1, is back and we get to find out more about him!
Review of advance copy received from Author
Abbey!!!! I need more!!!! I don't know if you can give me more but I NEED it!
Archer and Iris were a great intro, obviously, they started the series.....but I Loved Adora!
Was I expecting Theo to be the love interest!? Absolutely NOT! But ughhhh how can you not be happy for her!!!!
Adora had gone through so much trauma it's not even funny, and then to go home and basically feel unwanted. My heart physically hurt for her! Not to mention, then getting paired to work with a guy you despise who hurt your bestie. Like can things get worse for the poor girl.
But oh man does life work in mysterious ways! You truly never know what someone is going through unless you take it upon yourself to figure it out and ask. I was kicking my feet and squealing in excitement for her when things started to look up and get all romantic and sweet.
Theo is truly caring and never deserved the hardship he went through. Yeah he made some poor choices but some weren't his choice, yet it made a bad impression on him. The fact he chose to share anything about himself and have complete honesty with Dora.....just, YES.
I was so roped into the romance going on between Dora and Theo that I almost forgot I was reading a mystery book. So I wasn't even trying to say I knew what was going to happen.
Talk about a turn of events that I did not see coming whatsoever. Honestly felt like a perfect way to add into the mystery.
Abbey outdid herself with this book.
I truly enjoyed this one So much and I think that just maybe.....there should be a third book.......just a thought ❤️
Archer and Iris were a great intro, obviously, they started the series.....but I Loved Adora!
Was I expecting Theo to be the love interest!? Absolutely NOT! But ughhhh how can you not be happy for her!!!!
Adora had gone through so much trauma it's not even funny, and then to go home and basically feel unwanted. My heart physically hurt for her! Not to mention, then getting paired to work with a guy you despise who hurt your bestie. Like can things get worse for the poor girl.
But oh man does life work in mysterious ways! You truly never know what someone is going through unless you take it upon yourself to figure it out and ask. I was kicking my feet and squealing in excitement for her when things started to look up and get all romantic and sweet.
Theo is truly caring and never deserved the hardship he went through. Yeah he made some poor choices but some weren't his choice, yet it made a bad impression on him. The fact he chose to share anything about himself and have complete honesty with Dora.....just, YES.
I was so roped into the romance going on between Dora and Theo that I almost forgot I was reading a mystery book. So I wasn't even trying to say I knew what was going to happen.
Talk about a turn of events that I did not see coming whatsoever. Honestly felt like a perfect way to add into the mystery.
Abbey outdid herself with this book.
I truly enjoyed this one So much and I think that just maybe.....there should be a third book.......just a thought ❤️
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Review of advance copy
I was excited when I received an ARC for the second book in the duology, but admittedly a little worried I wouldn’t love it the way I loved the first. The first book follows Iris and Archer’s story which I LOVED because I have a *thing* for older, moody, broody professor types. The second book follows Adora’s story. Other than being worried for Adora because she was so traumatized by the end of the first book, I really had no idea where the second book was going to go. In walks Theo, and me, like most characters in the book, went… ew, no. If you read the first book then you would say the same!! But we quickly learn with Adora that we didn’t have all the information about Theo and there was more to the story than we previously thought. So we, slowly, and in time with the other characters, begin to forgive and fall for Theo.. BUT trouble begins to pop up at the newly named Blackthorne University, testing all the relationships our characters have built up to this point.
I was worried at the start, but I enjoyed this book every bit as much as the first and would highly recommend it. Do you enjoy dark academia? Romance? Serial killers? Drama? Loveable characters? Then read this book!
Also, arguably one of the most important details- BOO IS BACK! 👻🐈⬛
I was worried at the start, but I enjoyed this book every bit as much as the first and would highly recommend it. Do you enjoy dark academia? Romance? Serial killers? Drama? Loveable characters? Then read this book!
Also, arguably one of the most important details- BOO IS BACK! 👻🐈⬛
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I had absolutely loved ‘A Study in Ruin’ and the world Abbey had created, so was very excited to see what ‘A lesson in desire’ would bring.
I was not disappointed.
Abbey took this book to a whole new level. Adora’s journey from being completely broken after the events of book one, to finding love and safety again, was so beautifully written. There is so much detail, yet does not take away from the storyline at all.
It was a joy to see new parts of the University to broaden the world I already loved, and the revisits to previous places were so incredible.
I loved the continuation of Iris & Archer’s story, and also was thrilled that they were so settled and this really was Adora’s book to shine.
I was hesitant when I knew who Adora’s love interest was going to be, however, this was handled so sensitively. The book still allowed for everyone to call out the actions from book one, he definitely was not forgiven for his behaviour, and whilst there were some extenuating factors, I still appreciated that all characters in the book needed him to earn their trust and forgiveness to varying degrees. This could not have been handled better.
I cannot wait to see what else Abbey creates. This duology has been an absolute joy to read. Thank you Abbey ♥️
I was not disappointed.
Abbey took this book to a whole new level. Adora’s journey from being completely broken after the events of book one, to finding love and safety again, was so beautifully written. There is so much detail, yet does not take away from the storyline at all.
It was a joy to see new parts of the University to broaden the world I already loved, and the revisits to previous places were so incredible.
I loved the continuation of Iris & Archer’s story, and also was thrilled that they were so settled and this really was Adora’s book to shine.
I was hesitant when I knew who Adora’s love interest was going to be, however, this was handled so sensitively. The book still allowed for everyone to call out the actions from book one, he definitely was not forgiven for his behaviour, and whilst there were some extenuating factors, I still appreciated that all characters in the book needed him to earn their trust and forgiveness to varying degrees. This could not have been handled better.
I cannot wait to see what else Abbey creates. This duology has been an absolute joy to read. Thank you Abbey ♥️
Review of advance copy received from Author
ARC Review:
Abbey, I honestly had no idea where this book was going to take me. After reading A Study in Ruin, I wasn’t sure you could possibly top it.
BUT I am so happy to stand corrected!
You completely outdid yourself with this one. The enemies-to-lovers romance had me hooked from the start, with every charged glance, sharp exchange, and stolen moment pulling me deeper into the story. The chemistry was intense, the emotional stakes were high, and I was completely invested in these characters.
And the twists? I did not see them coming. Just when I thought I had everything figured out, the story pulled the rug out from under me again. I gasped, I laughed, I bit my lip, and I was on the edge of my seat the entire time. The suspense kept building, and I couldn’t turn the pages fast enough.
This was another fast-paced, gripping story that completely consumed me. I felt every emotion, became fully immersed in the world, and never wanted to put it down.
Abbey, you truly outdid yourself once again and now I desperately need another one! ❤️
Abbey, I honestly had no idea where this book was going to take me. After reading A Study in Ruin, I wasn’t sure you could possibly top it.
BUT I am so happy to stand corrected!
You completely outdid yourself with this one. The enemies-to-lovers romance had me hooked from the start, with every charged glance, sharp exchange, and stolen moment pulling me deeper into the story. The chemistry was intense, the emotional stakes were high, and I was completely invested in these characters.
And the twists? I did not see them coming. Just when I thought I had everything figured out, the story pulled the rug out from under me again. I gasped, I laughed, I bit my lip, and I was on the edge of my seat the entire time. The suspense kept building, and I couldn’t turn the pages fast enough.
This was another fast-paced, gripping story that completely consumed me. I felt every emotion, became fully immersed in the world, and never wanted to put it down.
Abbey, you truly outdid yourself once again and now I desperately need another one! ❤️
Review of advance copy received from Author
ARC Review: 'A Lesson in Desire' by Abbey Tonkinson
⭐️⭐️⭐️.5 (3.5 stars)
I read this book in a day! It was fast paced and exciting for start to finish. I loved how it was the 2nd installment, but we got a completly new POV from existing characters, with the original characters still playing a main part in the story.
I really enjoyed watching the relationship develop between Theo and Adora, as well as watching Adora wrestle with her emotions. After her heart break in Book 1 it was so great to see her heal and put herself back together.
The paranormal mystery kept me hooked throughout, desperate to know who 'they' were, and although I had my suspicions I was genuinely shocked at the big reveal. I adored the deeper backstory we got of Boo! 🐈⬛️👻
I wish it delved deeper into the paranormal side of the plot, as I feel it just wasn't a main part of the story enough for how much the final scenes relied upon it. It has the potential to be incredible, but fell slightly short here for me, which is why I dropped it below 4 stars.
⭐️⭐️⭐️.5 (3.5 stars)
I read this book in a day! It was fast paced and exciting for start to finish. I loved how it was the 2nd installment, but we got a completly new POV from existing characters, with the original characters still playing a main part in the story.
I really enjoyed watching the relationship develop between Theo and Adora, as well as watching Adora wrestle with her emotions. After her heart break in Book 1 it was so great to see her heal and put herself back together.
The paranormal mystery kept me hooked throughout, desperate to know who 'they' were, and although I had my suspicions I was genuinely shocked at the big reveal. I adored the deeper backstory we got of Boo! 🐈⬛️👻
I wish it delved deeper into the paranormal side of the plot, as I feel it just wasn't a main part of the story enough for how much the final scenes relied upon it. It has the potential to be incredible, but fell slightly short here for me, which is why I dropped it below 4 stars.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Continuing on from the events of the previous book, we follow Adora as she heads back to campus…
I actually loved this one even more than A Study in Ruin! The plot was so good, I absolutely loved Adora, and Theo’s character redemption was SO well done. I was also completely invested in the “who done it?” mystery surrounding the murders
I loved that we got to see some of the OG characters reappear without them overshadowing the new/main characters. It was such a good balance!
The first book was a 10/10 for me, but somehow this one took it up another level. The writing flowed so well, the story was captivating, and I just couldn’t put it down. Such an easy and enjoyable read, but with enough mystery, twists and spice to keep me hooked! Who doesn’t love a spicy mystery?!🔥🔍
Abbey has seriously done it again with another amazing book. I’m so grateful to have been one of her ARC readers! You’re all going to LOVE this one❤️
I actually loved this one even more than A Study in Ruin! The plot was so good, I absolutely loved Adora, and Theo’s character redemption was SO well done. I was also completely invested in the “who done it?” mystery surrounding the murders
I loved that we got to see some of the OG characters reappear without them overshadowing the new/main characters. It was such a good balance!
The first book was a 10/10 for me, but somehow this one took it up another level. The writing flowed so well, the story was captivating, and I just couldn’t put it down. Such an easy and enjoyable read, but with enough mystery, twists and spice to keep me hooked! Who doesn’t love a spicy mystery?!🔥🔍
Abbey has seriously done it again with another amazing book. I’m so grateful to have been one of her ARC readers! You’re all going to LOVE this one❤️
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Moody, mysterious university in the PNW? Check.
Twisted mystery involving a secret society?
Check.
Adorable kitten companion?
Check.
Two whole books serving molten spice and two 'touch her and die' MMCs?
Double check 😈😈
I had so much fun reading my way through the Stonewall Duology. A Study in Ruin, book one, does a great job establishing the world and lore, while giving hot student x professor forbidden romance.
Available September 23rd, A Lesson in Desire picks up seamlessly after the events of the first book, introducing an enemies to lovers romance that certainly didnt expect, but ended up being such an emotional core to the story I couldn't get enough. Many thanks to Abbey Tonkinton for providing me the ARC to dive into the gloriously rain drenched world of Stonewall.
Twisted mystery involving a secret society?
Check.
Adorable kitten companion?
Check.
Two whole books serving molten spice and two 'touch her and die' MMCs?
Double check 😈😈
I had so much fun reading my way through the Stonewall Duology. A Study in Ruin, book one, does a great job establishing the world and lore, while giving hot student x professor forbidden romance.
Available September 23rd, A Lesson in Desire picks up seamlessly after the events of the first book, introducing an enemies to lovers romance that certainly didnt expect, but ended up being such an emotional core to the story I couldn't get enough. Many thanks to Abbey Tonkinton for providing me the ARC to dive into the gloriously rain drenched world of Stonewall.
Review of advance copy received from Author
This is a must read if you enjoyed Abbey's debut novel A Study in Ruin. After sharing the story of Archer and Iris in her first book A Lesson in Desire takes us back to Blackthorne University and Adora's story.
Just when you think Adora's world has collapsed and she has no idea how to heal ....Theo who dared to hurt Iris turns Adora's world upside down. Truly enemies to lovers ❤️
They need to work together to find out who is hunting them and their friends. And Boo returns! This is an amazing second part to this duology and there are twists and turns I didn't see coming it kept me gripped till the end... A must read
Just when you think Adora's world has collapsed and she has no idea how to heal ....Theo who dared to hurt Iris turns Adora's world upside down. Truly enemies to lovers ❤️
They need to work together to find out who is hunting them and their friends. And Boo returns! This is an amazing second part to this duology and there are twists and turns I didn't see coming it kept me gripped till the end... A must read
September 18, 2026
*review of advance reader copy*
I absolutely devoured A Study in Ruin and knew I’d need to read the next in the series asap! This book picks up with Adora after everything that transpired. I loved Adora in the first book, she was such a good mix with Iris and I was antsy to dive in to see how she handled everything.
I wanted only the best for her, and to think that would have been Theo. Never would have actually guessed that because I simply hated him after the first. But he easily became a favorite of mine as their relationship grew.
Loved this so much and highly recommend, the paranormal aspects kept me so intrigued until the very end!
I absolutely devoured A Study in Ruin and knew I’d need to read the next in the series asap! This book picks up with Adora after everything that transpired. I loved Adora in the first book, she was such a good mix with Iris and I was antsy to dive in to see how she handled everything.
I wanted only the best for her, and to think that would have been Theo. Never would have actually guessed that because I simply hated him after the first. But he easily became a favorite of mine as their relationship grew.
Loved this so much and highly recommend, the paranormal aspects kept me so intrigued until the very end!
September 23, 2026
A must read for all spicy, dark romance lovers who enjoy a story with their smut. Plus an unbelievable redemption story!!!
A brilliant next book in the Stonewall duology. Absolutely loved Adora's story. Her journey through her grief and trauma was really well written. You could literally see her healing before your eyes with the help of the sexy MMC and her BFF, Iris.
Really enjoyed seeing the charectors from the first book again, including little Boo and loved meeting the new charectors who provided some more diversity being of the older generation.
Absolute 5 star review from me as an ARC reader and another gripping read from a wonderful author.
A brilliant next book in the Stonewall duology. Absolutely loved Adora's story. Her journey through her grief and trauma was really well written. You could literally see her healing before your eyes with the help of the sexy MMC and her BFF, Iris.
Really enjoyed seeing the charectors from the first book again, including little Boo and loved meeting the new charectors who provided some more diversity being of the older generation.
Absolute 5 star review from me as an ARC reader and another gripping read from a wonderful author.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I went into this book so excited about finding how the first book would be beaten and miss abbey did not disappoint, book 2 was just what i needed the plot twists were so well written and it had me hooked by wanting to figure out how it ends! i loved the characters and how they developed and i absolutely loved the ending. this book was just all around amazing, i can’t wait to see what miss abbey comes up with next! 💗🤗x
September 25, 2026
You ever read a redemption arc that was so good it felt a bit too real? That’s how Theo’s redemption is. It was so well done. It didn’t feel rushed or forced, it was very much earned.
Book two was just as good as the first one and I really do believe that Abby outdid herself with this series.
I look forward to reading more from this author in the future
Book two was just as good as the first one and I really do believe that Abby outdid herself with this series.
I look forward to reading more from this author in the future
Review of advance copy received from Author
After reading the first, I couldn’t wait to read the second. And it DID NOT disappoint.
Following themes from the first, but from a different POV, the twists, the turns and the spice lived up to expectations.
I HIGHLY RECOMMEND
August 30, 2026
10/10 no notes 🤭 I think I might have loved this even more than the first one! I loved Adora and Theo and was so glad to see Adora get her well deserved happy ending! Shoutout to Theodore for also being the cutest guy ever, protect this man at all costs 🫶
Review of advance copy received from Author
Great continuation from book 1. Loved having some characters back while meeting new ones. The pace is fast and spice is well written and not overly done. There is suspense and longing to keep the reader hooked.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Adora & Theo
Enemies to Lovers
Dark Academia
Trauma Bonding
Found Family
Opposites Attract
I love how addictive the mystery part of this book is! I couldn't get enough and needed to know what was happening next!!
I really enjoyed this duology ❤️
Enemies to Lovers
Dark Academia
Trauma Bonding
Found Family
Opposites Attract
I love how addictive the mystery part of this book is! I couldn't get enough and needed to know what was happening next!!
I really enjoyed this duology ❤️
Review of advance copy received from Author
Hooked from the start and couldn’t put it down. The chemistry between Adora and Theo was so good, and I really enjoyed watching their relationship unfold alongside the storyline. There was plenty of tension, twists and moments that kept me guessing. Another brilliant read from Abbey Tonkinson
September 16, 2026
ARC REVIEW!
4.5⭐️
I genuinely had such a fun time reading A Lesson in Desire. Abbey Tonkinson’s writing is beautiful and so easy to get lost in, and I especially loved how she balanced the romance, friendships and all the little twists throughout the story.
The plot twists were probably one of my favourite parts. There were so many moments where I genuinely did NOT see things coming, and one particular reveal involving Theo had me completely screaming. I thought I had figured things out, and clearly I had not, lol. Tonkinson is really good at dropping little pieces of information that only make sense once everything comes together.
I also absolutely loved Iris and Adora’s friendship. Their relationship felt so beautifully written, and I really enjoyed seeing the way their friendship developed throughout the story. It was such an important part of the book and one of the relationships I found myself caring about the most.
Seeing someone 👀 come back into the story in the way it did was such a clever twist and honestly gave me some major redemption arc feelings. I did have a few questions about why certain things weren’t done sooner, though…
My only real criticism is that I felt the ending was slightly rushed. The jump from the final chapter to the epilogue felt a little abrupt, and I would have loved just a bit more time between those two moments to let everything settle.
Overall, though, I really loved this book. The writing is gorgeous, the twists kept me guessing, and there’s something so satisfying about a story that manages to surprise you when you think you know where it’s going. Definitely a very enjoyable read!
4.5⭐️
I genuinely had such a fun time reading A Lesson in Desire. Abbey Tonkinson’s writing is beautiful and so easy to get lost in, and I especially loved how she balanced the romance, friendships and all the little twists throughout the story.
The plot twists were probably one of my favourite parts. There were so many moments where I genuinely did NOT see things coming, and one particular reveal involving Theo had me completely screaming. I thought I had figured things out, and clearly I had not, lol. Tonkinson is really good at dropping little pieces of information that only make sense once everything comes together.
I also absolutely loved Iris and Adora’s friendship. Their relationship felt so beautifully written, and I really enjoyed seeing the way their friendship developed throughout the story. It was such an important part of the book and one of the relationships I found myself caring about the most.
Seeing someone 👀 come back into the story in the way it did was such a clever twist and honestly gave me some major redemption arc feelings. I did have a few questions about why certain things weren’t done sooner, though…
My only real criticism is that I felt the ending was slightly rushed. The jump from the final chapter to the epilogue felt a little abrupt, and I would have loved just a bit more time between those two moments to let everything settle.
Overall, though, I really loved this book. The writing is gorgeous, the twists kept me guessing, and there’s something so satisfying about a story that manages to surprise you when you think you know where it’s going. Definitely a very enjoyable read!
Review of advance copy received from Author
ARC Review: Twists, turns & a redemption I didn’t see coming!
I couldn’t put this book down. It had everything I look for in a romance: a powerful healing journey, love, friendship, and plenty of open-door spice.
Packed with twists and turns, it kept me invested from beginning to end. I loved seeing all my favourite characters return and see their stories continue to develop.
After the events of the previous book, I really wanted to hate him… but somehow, I just couldn’t! Abbey has officially taken my most-hated character and turned him into a new favourite through her incredible writing. His character development throughout this book was so well done, and I loved seeing the different sides of him revealed.
My only criticism is that I wanted more paranormal elements and a deeper exploration of that side of the world.
Overall, this was an emotional, addictive and captivating read that kept me guessing until the end. 4.5 ⭐️
I couldn’t put this book down. It had everything I look for in a romance: a powerful healing journey, love, friendship, and plenty of open-door spice.
Packed with twists and turns, it kept me invested from beginning to end. I loved seeing all my favourite characters return and see their stories continue to develop.
After the events of the previous book, I really wanted to hate him… but somehow, I just couldn’t! Abbey has officially taken my most-hated character and turned him into a new favourite through her incredible writing. His character development throughout this book was so well done, and I loved seeing the different sides of him revealed.
My only criticism is that I wanted more paranormal elements and a deeper exploration of that side of the world.
Overall, this was an emotional, addictive and captivating read that kept me guessing until the end. 4.5 ⭐️
Review of advance copy received from Author
Well I didn't think it was possible but I love the second book even more than the first!
As always, a second book is a little easier to get going purely because you already know the characters but this just flowed so nicely as well. I really do love Adora and now the MMC as well (keeping it a secret so no spoilers here!), how their relationship continues to play out is just beautiful as well.
I really relate to Adora as I am sure many of us do with having gone through a hard time and having changed but the old you is still there. I felt like this really struck a chord and had me welling up a couple of times.
With regards to the plot, it really left me guessing and I didn't really click till the characters did so that was a nice surprise!
Overall, if you loved book 1, you will love this just as much if not even more!
As always, a second book is a little easier to get going purely because you already know the characters but this just flowed so nicely as well. I really do love Adora and now the MMC as well (keeping it a secret so no spoilers here!), how their relationship continues to play out is just beautiful as well.
I really relate to Adora as I am sure many of us do with having gone through a hard time and having changed but the old you is still there. I felt like this really struck a chord and had me welling up a couple of times.
With regards to the plot, it really left me guessing and I didn't really click till the characters did so that was a nice surprise!
Overall, if you loved book 1, you will love this just as much if not even more!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 30 reviews