What do you think?
Rate this book
When In Doubt: An Angsty Small Town Firefighter Romance
After getting out of a relationship that almost left her in pieces, Freya Malcolm doesn’t ever want to need anyone again.
Finally able to live the life she wants, she returns to her hometown to open her dream yarn store, and begin to reclaim the parts of herself that were taken. She just didn’t expect that striking out on her own would be quite this lonely.
Oscar Murphy has been in love with Freya since they were children. The trouble is, she’s never even known his name.
Still reeling from the death of his father and struggling to handle his increasing responsibilities at the Cedar Creek Fire Department, the last thing he needs is romance. Even if it could be the chance he’s always hoped for.
But Oscar can’t ignore the shadows in her eyes, and Freya can’t bring herself to push him away. With every chance encounter and gentle word, their cautious friendship inches closer to something more. Can they untangle the strings holding them back? Or are some things better left as fantasies?
-Small Town Romance
-Yearning Man
-Firefighter x Knitting Store Owner
-Touched Starved, Traumatized FMC
-Angsty and Emotional
-Autism Rep
When In Doubt is a standalone small town romance.
Finally able to live the life she wants, she returns to her hometown to open her dream yarn store, and begin to reclaim the parts of herself that were taken. She just didn’t expect that striking out on her own would be quite this lonely.
Oscar Murphy has been in love with Freya since they were children. The trouble is, she’s never even known his name.
Still reeling from the death of his father and struggling to handle his increasing responsibilities at the Cedar Creek Fire Department, the last thing he needs is romance. Even if it could be the chance he’s always hoped for.
But Oscar can’t ignore the shadows in her eyes, and Freya can’t bring herself to push him away. With every chance encounter and gentle word, their cautious friendship inches closer to something more. Can they untangle the strings holding them back? Or are some things better left as fantasies?
-Small Town Romance
-Yearning Man
-Firefighter x Knitting Store Owner
-Touched Starved, Traumatized FMC
-Angsty and Emotional
-Autism Rep
When In Doubt is a standalone small town romance.
430 pages, Paperback
Published August 21, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 1 of 1 review
October 24, 2026
An absolute emotional roller-coaster, but a beautiful one. She's not wrong, it has a happy ending, but wow did I damn near cry trying to get there. 100% recommend!
Displaying 1 - 1 of 1 review