“A brilliant, rollicking journey of becoming, a night out in London that I didn’t want to end. Elander is a writer to watch.”—Eliana Ramage, author of To the Moon and Back
Rippling with heat and style, an electrifying debut novel about desire, obsession, and the life-changing possibilities of our first encounters with sex.
Growing up the pixelated glow of early-2000s chatrooms, teenage Meg feverishly explores her nascent fantasies of obliteration and submission with faceless strangers, testing the limits of her emerging desire. Ten years later, living in East London with her beloved circle of friends, she chases distraction and pleasure with equal intensity, reeling through the bars and clubs and occasionally looking for brutish men to dominate her in bed.
That’s when Daniel reappears. Daniel, the username that consumed Meg’s adolescence, forging her wants and needs before abruptly vanishing. Daniel, who now wants to meet in person.
A charged and capacious novel, This Is My Idea of Fun is at once a provocative account of teetering on the vertiginous edge of adulthood and a story of forging community while reconciling with the fact that those closest to us will inevitably experience us at our worst. With the lush sensuality of Melissa Broder, the irresistible intensity of Eliza Clark, and razor-sharp prose all their own, this debut announces Georgia Elander as a blistering, essential new voice.
This was very different from what I expected, and I had quite a hard time getting into it at first. This book was certainly one of those that held on to me even when I wasn’t sure how I felt about it. Generally, the story follows Meg, a 24-year-old Londoner trying to find her place after university, and moves between her teenage years (2007/8) and ten years later, when Daniel, a name on her screen who was once the catalyst for her discovering herself, gets back in touch. The biggest strength of the book is the way Georgia Elander capturws the 2000s nostalgia. Even though I was still a baby by the time, imagining a teenage Meg racing home to hop on MSN and reinvent oneself in chat rooms was really easy during this read. The story really captured this aspect amazingly well that if you (maybe) grew up in the early internet era, it will hit home..I can tell you guys that I showed my mom (who was a teenager/young adult during the early 2000s) some parts of the story and she immediately resonated with the vibe of it. The book generally uses that setting to look at how parts of the internet shape our sexuality and the way we view sex, alongside loneliness, gender roles, online dating, and parasocial relationships etc. I also liked how the sex scenes weren’t really written to be sexy, they were quite messy actually and fairly important to the plot, which suited the book and its’ vibe. Speaking of plots and vibes, Meg, as a character, had this make-or-break element, she’s complex and very human, and I found her interesting while also thinking she is quite unlikeable as a character sometimes. She’s quite selfish and emotionally immature, especially in her female friendships but it also makes her flawed which is a thing that I really like about characters in books. It makes them human and despite having had a lot of moments where I really disliked Meg as a character, she was, as I said, written really humanly and I adore that. Still, some of her actions felt less morally grey than hard to forgive, and that made it difficult to fully connect with her at times. I also couldn’t connect with Daniel from the start, though he was intriguing as a character. And I wished I’d gotten to know Meg’s friends better (Aisling’s story for instance since it is quite important to the overall plot). But I also gotta say that the scenes between Meg and Morag were a highlight! As werre the last couple of chapters and the epilogue. Besides that, I should say that the tone turns quite dark at one point, which wasn’t what I expected from the start. There certianly were parts that were uncomfortable to read. Though these added another layer to the story and made the book hard to put down at some point. Overall, I can say that this one isn’t a book for everyone, and the unlikable characters will lose some readers. But if you like character-driven fiction that makes you think, and you’re up for some heavy nostalgia and a raw, uncomfortable look at growing up online, it’s worth a try.
Thank you to Grove Atlantic and NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This book made me uncomfortable at times, but not in the way I think it was intending to. I was really intrigued by the premise, but the execution felt like an attempt to be edgy and provocative that amounted to little more than starter-pack posturing. Just a lot of reminiscing about masturbating with strangers online, descriptions of dick pics and bad sex no one ever asked for. Sympathetic to incel culture. Nothing but the dullest, most unappealing relationships. The 2000s nostalgia wasn’t enough to carry this for me. At all.
The LGBTQIAP+ label is questionable, as is the erotica label. The main character argues several times, without pushback, that she’s queer because she’s “culturally queer,” meaning she was raised by her single mother and lesbian aunt and therefore belongs in queer spaces. Hmm.
This was very different to what I expected before going into it but there was something about this that kept me so gripped.
This was so full of 00s nostalgia with a big focus on the days of MSN & chat sites. I liked how it flitted back and forth between the timeline of Meg's teenagehood to her adulthood 10 years later. I found her very complex but very real & human with how flawed & complicated she was — I feel she may be a marmite character for some readers but I didn't hate her, I thought she was written quite well & I actually found her really interesting. Daniel on the other hand, I could not gel with from the get go but that's not to say I didn't find his character intriguing. I did like Meg's friends but I'd have liked to have seen a bit more of them or got to know them more.
Without spoiling too much, there was a big moment in this where the general vibe became quite dark which is where it became unlike anything I'd expected at the start. There was some uncomfortable reading at parts but I'm not saying this as criticism, it somehow created another layer to the story & I didn't want to put it down. The overarching theme in this is sexuality & to me it seemed like it was commentating on how certain parts of the internet can & does affect a person's sexuality & the way we view sex. I also loved the coming of age side to the plot, the way the writer does this feels clever & it really made me reflect at times. I liked how the sex scenes in this didn't seem to be written to be 'sexy' or spicy, they were messy & important to the main plot without being too much or unnecessary.
The last couple chapters were surprisingly touching, I also thought the character development was done well in this, I especially loved the scenes between Meg & Morag. Overall, if you like fictions that make you think, character based novels & some heavy nostalgia, give this a go.
Thank you Borough Press & Netgalley for my free eARC!
Going into This Is My Idea of Fun by Georgia Elander, I'd seen a fair few lukewarm reviews, particularly about the explicit subject matter and the unlikeable central character, so my expectations were modest. I was pleasantly surprised, and found myself far more engaged than I'd anticipated.
The novel follows Meg, a young woman living in East London in 2018 whose life revolves around friendships, nights out, drink, drugs and an increasingly complicated attitude towards sex and intimacy. On the surface she's enjoying the freedom of her twenties, but underneath there's a great deal of insecurity and baggage she's never dealt with. The story moves between her adult life and her teenage years in the mid-2000s, when a lonely, curious fourteen-year-old Meg begins exploring online chatrooms, where anonymity lets her experiment with her identity and seek attention from older men. Her intense relationship with a mysterious figure known only as Daniel shapes her understanding of sex, desire and relationships. When he suddenly disappears, it leaves a lasting mark, and when he gets back in touch ten years later and wants to meet, Meg is forced to confront experiences that have been quietly shaping her adult life.
There's no sugarcoating it: this is uncomfortable reading. The subject matter is raw and taboo, touching on submission, control, misogyny, exploitation and the blurred line between fantasy and reality. Meg is impulsive, selfish, vulnerable and often completely lacking in self-awareness. I frequently wanted to shake some sense into her, but I also found her fascinating and oddly believable. Elander doesn't glamorise the chaos or try to make her sympathetic, and instead leaves you to make your own judgements. Crucially, the uncomfortable material never felt like shock for shock's sake. It's central to understanding who Meg has become. I also liked the portrayal of her friendships, which feel realistic, with all the loyalty, jealousy, misunderstanding and occasional cruelty that can exist between friends who genuinely care about each other.
What stayed with me most was the book's exploration of early internet culture. Meg's teenage years play out in the era of chatrooms, MSN Messenger and anonymous conversations with strangers, when there was far less understanding of the risks. If this was what young teenagers could be exposed to when internet chat was still in its infancy, it's worrying to think what today's generation faces, with smartphones, social media, dating apps and almost unlimited access to everything in their pockets. The novel doesn't suggest technology alone is to blame for Meg's difficulties, but it does make you consider how vulnerable young people can be when the people influencing them are anonymous strangers with very different motivations.
My criticisms are minor: some of the partying and sexual scenes become a little repetitive, the story occasionally drifts, and a few supporting characters were hard to connect with, though that may be down to the narrative being filtered through Meg's chaotic perspective.
It certainly isn't for everyone, and anyone expecting a light-hearted coming-of-age story will be in for a shock. But for me it was a bold, gripping debut with far more substance than I'd been led to expect, and it's the kind of book that leaves you thinking long after the final page.
There’s something instantly evocative about This Is My Idea of Fun. It throws you straight into the deep end, tackling a subject that is both painfully contemporary and strangely under-discussed: young people finding themselves in online spaces they are far too young to be navigating, and the complicated, uncomfortable consequences that can follow.
One of my favourite things about this book is its narration. Very early on, we realise that Meg is speaking directly to her best friend’s baby - though now turned a teenager - who has had elicit photos found on her phone, and suddenly the story takes on this intimate, almost confessional quality. It’s an unusual way of telling a story, and I was completely intrigued by it. It makes the whole book feel like Meg is trying to explain how she became the person capable of making those choices in a very big sister-ly way. I also loved the writing style. There’s a very Sally Rooney-esque lack of quotation marks, with speech instead appearing in italics, which I personally really enjoy. It allows everything to flow together without awkward punctuation interrupting the rhythm of the prose. Interestingly, this is particularly used during the drunken scenes, where the writing becomes slightly messy and unkempt. I would have happily had this throughout the whole novel, but its use in those moments made them feel especially believable.
And Meg! I adored her. She makes some very bad decisions, but I never stopped understanding her vulnerability. She cares incredibly deeply about the people around her, while simultaneously being frightened of that part of herself. Her constant need for validation means that when love and care begin to demand something more difficult from her, her instinct is to run rather than repair what she has broken. She isn’t an easy character to defend, but she is an incredibly easy character to understand.
The friendships in this book were the key highlight. Meg’s two friends essentially orbit either side of her, and I thought this worked particularly well alongside the gossip surrounding Aisling’s baby. It felt uncomfortably realistic because, whether we like to admit it or not, people do change the way they speak and think depending on who they’re with. The resulting fallout is painful, but it never felt manufactured. It comes from something much more recognisable: contemporary miscommunication, insecurity and people saying and doing things they can’t take back.
Georgia Elander also handles the book’s darker themes with a lot of care. The misogyny and rape culture surrounding male fantasies and sex chatrooms are explored boldly without shying away from the uglier details. At the same time, the book never reduces its characters to simple categories of good and bad. Trauma, peer pressure, naivety, and friendship all play a part, and people can make awful choices while still being complicated human beings. I really appreciated that moral messiness.
What I think this novel is about at its heart is female friendship, the people who come and go, and, most importantly, the people who stay. That epilogue line, “I knew I had love in spades already,” is especially lovely. 🥹 I can already see this novel finding a very big audience when it publishes in February 2027.
This Is My Idea of Fun will be released in April, 2027 and I read an ARC from NetGalley. Following 24 year old Megan through the ups and downs of relationships (romantic and platonic) in your 20s, it explores the impact of the 2008 internet of her teen years on her adult life. This book is excellent for the introspective, the fans of imperfect characters, and those with an appreciation for exquisite literary prose. It also contains lots of layered and complex discussions about sexuality and kink.
This book didn’t do it for me unfortunately. I didn’t connect with the characters at all. Although the writing generally was good, the story line was unexciting to me. The book delves into some deep emotions very well and tackles some interesting topics. As a millennial, the 00s nostalgia was great and I found some parts witty and interesting. However, the pacing wasn’t quite right and it was hard to follow sometimes with the characters. I thought about not finishing and could easily have not picked it back up, but pushed through. It would be a great book for the right person at the right time. I’d recommend to millennials rather than younger or older individuals because it could be even harder to connect with the 00s references.
Thank you to NetGalley, Harper Collins and Georgia Elander for the ARC and opportunity to review.
I'm delighted to share my first ARC review for My Idea Of Fun by Georgia Elander which is due for release in 2027.
The story follows 24 year old Meg who is really trying post university to find her place in life. It's about her relationships with friends, family and with two very different men, both of whom she initially meets online at different stages of her life.
The book moves at a good pace and there's a good balance of plot and spice. I devoured this in a couple of days. The story flicks back and forth between the past and the present day, giving insight into Meg's past and the lives of the men that she's involved with as well.
It highlights themes that are real pertinent right now : gender roles, loneliness, online dating and parasocial relationships as well as themes of misogyny, kink and sexuality.
The book is well written but I personally found the character of Meg *very* difficult to connect with, as to me she comes across as very emotionally immature for a 24 year old woman, particularly when it comes to her female friendships. Some of her actions I felt weren't just morally grey, they were unforgivable! Despite her attempts at redemption.
I found it difficult to get past the lack of connection with the main character and because of that I'd give it a 3/5 but this might not affect other readers the way it did me.
It's still worth checking out when it comes out next year.
Thanks to Harpercollins and Netgalley for the opportunity to read and review it
I was intrigued by this book as I grew up in a similar age to the main character, when MSN was all the rage and the Internet was just taking off. I found it fascinating to follow Meg and her friends on their journeys of self-discovery, and the book covered some interesting themes.
I didn't personally vibe with the writing style, it felt a bit detached and too wordy sometimes, but this is personal preference and some readers will love it.
okayyy so this wasn’t bad but i also can’t say it was really good. the whole concept and premise were actually really interesting and there were quite a few things i enjoyed. some parts felt even relatable because, same girl i also grew up on the internet (don’t even ask). the way the story was written really captured that internet nostalgia of early 2000-10s and familiarity which i thought was done incredibly well.
some parts were also really weird disturbing and violent. there were moments that genuinely made me uncomfortable but in a way that kept me hooked. like what the actual fuck is going on here? the author did a really good job of making those moments impossible to look away from. side note: NEVER IGNORE RED FLAGS!! i can’t believe i fell for that loser…yuck
i also really loved the main character! i know she isn’t necessarily supposed to be likable and some of her choices were selfish and not what i would have done myself. BUT that’s exactly what made her so interesting to me. even when i disagreed with her i could always place the root of her decisions and understand why SHE made the choices SHE did. honestly nobody in this book was really likable and i think that’s probably why i couldn’t bring myself to hate her either 😭
so what did i enjoy less? well that mostly comes down to the execution. it took me way too long to get into the story and i’d say roughly 60% of the book was just not doing it for me. i found myself getting bored and struggling to care about what was happening. which is a shame because the concept had so much potential.
overall i’d say this is a good debut! there’s enough here to make me curious about what the author will come up with next. i’ll be keeping an eye on their future releases
Georgia Elander's debut novel, This is My Idea of Fun, tells the story of Megan, a young woman in London who is contacted by a boy she once knew from an internet only relationship, and who wishes to explain himself to her. What follows is a story that unfolds across two time periods in her life - Megan in the present, a young woman who lives solely in the moment almost on a diet of alcohol and cocaine, and her friendships with a core group of friends - and Meggie the adolescent, entering an online chat-world of sex, potential abuse and a possible first boyfriend in the form of Daniel - who, in the present, re-enters her life.
This is My Idea of Fun is not afraid to shy away from presenting Megan as an uninhibited, somewhat unlikeable character. Some of the things she does, and the decisions she makes leave you wanting to either pull her into a comforting embrace and tell her all will be OK, or leave her as toxic friend alone on the page. This is the true strength of Elander's novel, and central character - Meggie is real, she is flawed, she makes mistakes and doesn't always make up for them - she is then, human and living brightly on the page.
This is My Idea of Fun can, at times, be quite sexually explicit - but these displays are not for titillation of the reader, but another organic way of showing us who Megan is.
I adored this novel, and cannot wait to see what Georgia Elander does next.
Thank you to the publishers and Netgalley for the ARC.
In a nutshell: Decent prose but it couldn't decide whether it was a novel about queerness, friendship, desire, heterosexuality, incel culture and instead tried to be all of those things, which resulted in it being underwhelming.
What this novel is most of all is a novel about heterosexuality, online relationships and desire — especially desire for "bad"/taboo sex. It was at its strongest when it explored the dynamic between Megan and her housemate/best friend Ash, how online culture and porn and teenage boys can influence a young woman's sexuality, and the blurry lines of desire.
I don't know why this is framed as a "queer" novel, as it is not. Whilst the protagonist, Megan, was part-raised by her lesbian aunt and has a friendship group made up of almost entirely queer people (and there is an attempt to explore to a small degree queerness) this novel in no way felt like it.
Ultimately, though, I felt this novel was trying to do too much. And in trying to do too much it just didn't do enough. The last fifty or so pages just felt so unrealistic, the dialogue stilted. Having built up the main story around Daniel it was strange that it just got sidelined.
This Is My Idea of Fun is a raw, chaotic look into the life of Meg, a Londoner who loves nothing more than a good time. What drew me into this story was the idea that Meg has grown up on the internet, and this was done very well - I related to racing home to hop onto MSN and reinvent yourself online.
Meg’s story centres around her reconnecting with Daniel, who was once not only a name on Meg’s screen as a teenager, but the catalyst for her discovering herself. 10 years later, Daniel’s back in touch and wants to meet.
I think what surprised me about this story was the darkness of some of the aspects of the plot. It’s certainly raw and real. I also found Meg hard to relate to - she’s selfish, and I found it hard to read how she treated some of her friends. But in saying that, these flaws really do contribute to the realness of her character. It’s certainly a nuanced story and won’t be one for everyone - but if you grew up in the early 00s when the internet was new and shiny, it’s one to read.
*This is My Idea of Fun* by Georgia Elander was a tough read for me; I really had trouble staying engaged with this novel. However, I appreciated what it aimed to capture. The author does a great job evoking the experience of coming of age in the aughts—the internet, anonymity, sexuality, and the strange ways all of those things could shape how we understood ourselves and each other.
The characters aren’t necessarily likable, and I often found it hard to connect with them, but their journeys felt messy and authentic. There’s something compelling about the way the novel explores people trying to figure themselves out while carrying the experiences and choices of their younger selves.
Ultimately, this wasn’t a book that completely resonated with me, but I can appreciate its honest portrayal of a specific time and the complicated, sometimes uncomfortable process of growing up. Thanks Grove Atlantic and NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
I wish we would've had a different lens through which to look at this, not framing it as a narrative that unfolds live, but looking back at it from the other side, like the way the framing is ultimately revealed to be. It felt too close to the events to see past them, even though the narrator had, by that point, a better perspective, and was telling the story from there. I wish we had that perspective too. Also, the 2007-2008 events are so specific to the internet of that era as to be irrelevant to any audience that didn't experience them at that age, I think. It's like someone explaining taking calls on a rotary phone from a boy they were going steady with in the 1960s. There's interesting character work in this and I'd read from the author again, but it didn't quite hit the beats I was hoping for.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC.
The first problem with this novel is that it's written in the second person. What this does is put you the reader as a suggogate for the "you" the subject of the book is wrting/talking to. This is an uncomforable feeling and also distances you, the reader, from the characters in the book. Which brings up the second problem: the characters are just that - characters. They aren't people. They're flat and, frankly, uninteresting, as are all people who spend their nights (and sometimes days, as well) swilling alcohol and getting wrecked on whatever drugs come their way in clubs or in friends' flats. So uninteresting are these caricatures that I dozed off or daydreaming about happier climes that mattered several times while reading about them. Hard pass.
This one unfortunately didn't quite work for me. I found the premise really interesting, and I can definitely appreciate what Georgia Elander was trying to explore around sex, internet culture and incel ideology.
That said, I struggled to connect with the characters and found the pacing a little difficult at times, which made it hard for me to stay invested in the story.
I think there are some genuinely interesting ideas here and I can see this working really well for other readers, but ultimately it just wasn't quite for me.
However the msn, online chat took me back to a/s/l and talking on chat rooms to strangers on the school computers
So if you like books that remind you of a different age..
Megs life is complicated by her growing up online with no adult supervision. It shows how this affects her perception of relationships in her 20s with sexual partners and with her friends.
It did make me laugh and if you don’t mind lots of sex then you’ll enjoy it too, especially if you grew up on msn and okcupid..
I struggled a bit with this book. On the face of it, this book should have been quite relatable, set in an era I grew up in, however I found it quite hard to connect with any of it. I found the characters to be quite two dimensional and not very likeable at all, particularly the main character. I did however like that this was a journey of growth and self discovery.
I'm sorry, but wtf was this? I was intrigued by the premise of the book, but ultimately I was disappointed. This book made me feel uneasy; I don't think it was meant to be that way. Some descriptions were not useful and some things are no longer there. I ended up hating this book more than anything else.
If I had a nickel for every narrative about naive young things diving head first into kink relationships this year, I'd have two nickels, but it's odd to get more than one of these in the same year, generally speaking. For this one, we get a young woman who developed an intense cybersex relationship with someone who ghosted her, and his showing back up in her life again a decade on to try to explain himself, and how she deals with that. I did admittedly miss the framing of the whole thing until the last few chapters, but that's on me. I like that this doesn't flinch away from our main doing the best she can (and admittedly failing at times), but the pacing fell apart a bit for me towards the middle. Solid debut.