What do you think?
Rate this book
Saving Scrooge #1
Saving Scrooge
He’s haunted by the past—is love enough to save his future?
Edward Scribner is haunted long before the ghosts arrive—by family trauma, the pressure to prove himself, and the nagging belief that he's never been truly loved by anyone.
Then he meets Isabelle Salvatore.
A kindhearted marketing assistant for a children's nonprofit, Isabelle sees something in Edward that no one else ever has. Her warmth chips away at the walls he's spent a lifetime building, and for the first time, he dares to imagine a future filled with love instead of loneliness.
But the things that haunt us have a way of lingering. As Edward throws himself into building a successful business, he loses sight of what matters most. And when a devastating family crisis shatters the emotional barriers Edward has so carefully constructed, he begins to spiral.
Having already watched one relationship crumble beneath the weight of trying to "save" the man she loved, Isabelle decides she needs to walk away.
Then come the ghosts.
As he's forced to confront the choices and traumas that shaped him—and the bleak future awaiting him if nothing changes—Edward is given a chance to rewrite his story.
If Scrooge can save himself, maybe he'll get a second chance at love after all.
From the award-winning author of Ghost Writing and Beautiful Place by the Sea comes a dual-POV speculative romance about redemption, forgiveness, and the kind of love worth fighting for.
Edward Scribner is haunted long before the ghosts arrive—by family trauma, the pressure to prove himself, and the nagging belief that he's never been truly loved by anyone.
Then he meets Isabelle Salvatore.
A kindhearted marketing assistant for a children's nonprofit, Isabelle sees something in Edward that no one else ever has. Her warmth chips away at the walls he's spent a lifetime building, and for the first time, he dares to imagine a future filled with love instead of loneliness.
But the things that haunt us have a way of lingering. As Edward throws himself into building a successful business, he loses sight of what matters most. And when a devastating family crisis shatters the emotional barriers Edward has so carefully constructed, he begins to spiral.
Having already watched one relationship crumble beneath the weight of trying to "save" the man she loved, Isabelle decides she needs to walk away.
Then come the ghosts.
As he's forced to confront the choices and traumas that shaped him—and the bleak future awaiting him if nothing changes—Edward is given a chance to rewrite his story.
If Scrooge can save himself, maybe he'll get a second chance at love after all.
From the award-winning author of Ghost Writing and Beautiful Place by the Sea comes a dual-POV speculative romance about redemption, forgiveness, and the kind of love worth fighting for.
348 pages, Kindle Edition
Published November 13, 2026
About the author
Danielle Smyth
12 books69 followersDanielle Smyth is the author of bookish romances like Ghost Writing (winner of the 2025 North American Book Awards Gold Medal in Romance and a 2025 Shelf Media Top Notable Indie Book), Ghosts of Christmas Presents, By the Book, Beautiful Place by the Sea (a 2026 Shelf Media Top Notable Indie Book), Any Port in a Storm, and Saving Scrooge. She has dreamed of being a writer since childhood, and seeing that dream realized is the ultimate happy ending. When she’s not writing, Danielle runs a small business. Her favorite days are spent traveling, eating tacos, and reading with her family.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 49 reviews
November 13, 2026
4🌟 | 1🌶️
Turns out even a modern-day Scrooge deserves a little Christmas magic and, more importantly, a second chance at love.
The A Christmas Carol inspiration was such a fun touch, with the familiar ghosts woven into Edward’s journey. This man carries so much guilt and spends far too much time believing he doesn’t deserve happiness. I just wanted him to stop being so hard on himself and finally see what everyone else could.
Isabelle was lovely, with her kindness and compassion balanced by a strength I really appreciated. I also liked that she wasn’t simply expected to put Edward back together. Both had their own growing to do, and watching them navigate their feelings and find their way back to each other was so rewarding. Their chemistry and adorable interactions were a joy, and the little mathematical banter was an unexpected favourite!
Beyond the romance, I especially liked the message about forgiveness, self-worth and second chances. Seeing both characters learn to let go of the past and recognise that they’re deserving of happiness made their journey even more beautiful.
The festive atmosphere, with its Christmas magic added so much charm, making this an entertaining holiday read that left me with a smile and in the mood for more Christmas romances.
~~~~
A sincere thank you to Danielle Smyth and Beyond The Books PR for the ARC! 🥰📚
I’m so grateful for the early read. As always, all thoughts and opinions are completely my own. ✨
Turns out even a modern-day Scrooge deserves a little Christmas magic and, more importantly, a second chance at love.
The A Christmas Carol inspiration was such a fun touch, with the familiar ghosts woven into Edward’s journey. This man carries so much guilt and spends far too much time believing he doesn’t deserve happiness. I just wanted him to stop being so hard on himself and finally see what everyone else could.
Isabelle was lovely, with her kindness and compassion balanced by a strength I really appreciated. I also liked that she wasn’t simply expected to put Edward back together. Both had their own growing to do, and watching them navigate their feelings and find their way back to each other was so rewarding. Their chemistry and adorable interactions were a joy, and the little mathematical banter was an unexpected favourite!
Beyond the romance, I especially liked the message about forgiveness, self-worth and second chances. Seeing both characters learn to let go of the past and recognise that they’re deserving of happiness made their journey even more beautiful.
The festive atmosphere, with its Christmas magic added so much charm, making this an entertaining holiday read that left me with a smile and in the mood for more Christmas romances.
~~~~
A sincere thank you to Danielle Smyth and Beyond The Books PR for the ARC! 🥰📚
I’m so grateful for the early read. As always, all thoughts and opinions are completely my own. ✨
November 3, 2026
After a month of darker/spookier reads I definitely needed a light holiday romance! I loved our tortured MMC who loved math and wanted to take care of everyone around him. Our FMC was strong and confident in her worth after past relationship troubles and I appreciated that. The miscommunication was frustrating but I loved the spin on Scrooge and how Edward was able to learn about the importance of valuing himself and love the happy ending we got!
Review of advance copy received from Author
📚 ARC REVIEW ❤️🎄
Saving Scrooge by Danielle Smyth
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Some stories capture the magic of Christmas, while others remind us of the beautiful power of forgiveness, healing, and second chances. Saving Scrooge does both! ❤️
A Christmas Carol has always held a special place in my heart. I’ve loved watching Scrooge’s transformation and the reminder that no one is beyond redemption. So when I discovered Danielle Smyth was giving this beloved classic a romantic twist, I couldn’t wait to dive in!
Meet Edward, our modern-day Scrooge. Beneath his guarded exterior is a man burdened by years of heartbreak, guilt, and regret. He desperately wants to do right by those he loves, yet the wounds of his past have convinced him that he only brings pain to the people he cares about most. Oh, sweet Edward! There were so many moments when I wanted to remind him that he is deserving of love, joy, and happiness. More than anything, I wanted him to see his own worth, open his heart, and finally allow himself to receive the love he so freely gives to others.
Then there’s Isabelle, our sweet and compassionate Belle. Her generous spirit shines, but behind that hopeful heart are scars of her own. Watching these two navigate their fears, confront old wounds, and slowly find their way toward forgiveness was incredibly touching.
I especially appreciated the exploration of a fractured friendship and the emotional journey toward repairing it. It’s a beautiful reminder that second chances aren’t reserved for romance alone.
Danielle weaves the nostalgic charm of A Christmas Carol into a tender, heartfelt romance, complete with echoes of the three ghosts, emotional revelations, and the promise of redemption. The dual perspectives made their journey even more meaningful.
This isn’t simply a story about finding love again. It’s about making peace with your past, forgiving yourself, and discovering that even the most wounded hearts can heal. ❤️
A beautiful, soul-soothing Christmas romance that left my heart feeling a little fuller. 🎄✨
Available November 13th, just in time to enjoy this holiday season.
A huge thank you to the author for the opportunity to read an advance reader copy of this book! All thoughts and opinions are entirely my own.
Saving Scrooge by Danielle Smyth
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Some stories capture the magic of Christmas, while others remind us of the beautiful power of forgiveness, healing, and second chances. Saving Scrooge does both! ❤️
A Christmas Carol has always held a special place in my heart. I’ve loved watching Scrooge’s transformation and the reminder that no one is beyond redemption. So when I discovered Danielle Smyth was giving this beloved classic a romantic twist, I couldn’t wait to dive in!
Meet Edward, our modern-day Scrooge. Beneath his guarded exterior is a man burdened by years of heartbreak, guilt, and regret. He desperately wants to do right by those he loves, yet the wounds of his past have convinced him that he only brings pain to the people he cares about most. Oh, sweet Edward! There were so many moments when I wanted to remind him that he is deserving of love, joy, and happiness. More than anything, I wanted him to see his own worth, open his heart, and finally allow himself to receive the love he so freely gives to others.
Then there’s Isabelle, our sweet and compassionate Belle. Her generous spirit shines, but behind that hopeful heart are scars of her own. Watching these two navigate their fears, confront old wounds, and slowly find their way toward forgiveness was incredibly touching.
I especially appreciated the exploration of a fractured friendship and the emotional journey toward repairing it. It’s a beautiful reminder that second chances aren’t reserved for romance alone.
Danielle weaves the nostalgic charm of A Christmas Carol into a tender, heartfelt romance, complete with echoes of the three ghosts, emotional revelations, and the promise of redemption. The dual perspectives made their journey even more meaningful.
This isn’t simply a story about finding love again. It’s about making peace with your past, forgiving yourself, and discovering that even the most wounded hearts can heal. ❤️
A beautiful, soul-soothing Christmas romance that left my heart feeling a little fuller. 🎄✨
Available November 13th, just in time to enjoy this holiday season.
A huge thank you to the author for the opportunity to read an advance reader copy of this book! All thoughts and opinions are entirely my own.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I love retellings of A Christmas Carol, and Saving Scrooge is no exception! Massive personal growth from both MCs, an influencer roommate, and a sister who (VERY unintentionally) throws a wrench into everything! Add sexy math banter (who knew that could be hot?!), and I was locked in.
Edward and Isabelle have an adorable meet cute and a whirlwind romance, destined to be happy always until Edward embarks on a business venture that doesn’t go to plan. He keeps the details from her for several reasons, one of which being that he wants to protect her from the fallout. Isabelle is done trying to fix people, Edward included. What follows is years of wondering what if, and yearning. This truly is an “idiots in love” story at some points and I’m so happy they get their HEA.
The three ghosts (Christmas past, present, and future) make appearances, and of course they help Edward rethink the impact his life has had on those around him, which is more positive than he initially believes.
Thanks to the author and Beyond the Books PR for an advance copy!
Edward and Isabelle have an adorable meet cute and a whirlwind romance, destined to be happy always until Edward embarks on a business venture that doesn’t go to plan. He keeps the details from her for several reasons, one of which being that he wants to protect her from the fallout. Isabelle is done trying to fix people, Edward included. What follows is years of wondering what if, and yearning. This truly is an “idiots in love” story at some points and I’m so happy they get their HEA.
The three ghosts (Christmas past, present, and future) make appearances, and of course they help Edward rethink the impact his life has had on those around him, which is more positive than he initially believes.
Thanks to the author and Beyond the Books PR for an advance copy!
Review of advance copy received from Author
First and foremost Danielle Smyth is a wonderful wordsmith
The romantic vibes through her work is amazing and this story is exemplary.
A Christmas Carol reimagined Edward Scribner being the Scrooge, although I think it’s just because of the family issues and trauma he’s really not a bad person at all.
They definitely go through some things, but
Isabelle is the heart and hearth of the story her love knows no bounds.
Also loved her affection for the movie Love Actually-it’s one of my favorites 🤭
Highly recommended not just at Christmas, but anytime
“Life pulls us all in different directions, yes, but the connections that matter are strong enough that you can always pick up right where you left off.”
The romantic vibes through her work is amazing and this story is exemplary.
A Christmas Carol reimagined Edward Scribner being the Scrooge, although I think it’s just because of the family issues and trauma he’s really not a bad person at all.
They definitely go through some things, but
Isabelle is the heart and hearth of the story her love knows no bounds.
Also loved her affection for the movie Love Actually-it’s one of my favorites 🤭
Highly recommended not just at Christmas, but anytime
“Life pulls us all in different directions, yes, but the connections that matter are strong enough that you can always pick up right where you left off.”
Review of advance copy
Thank you to Behind The Books PR and Danielle Smyth for the e-ARC.
Saving Scrooge is inspired by Dickens' A Christmas Carol and has elements of this classic sprinkled throughout. Set over a few years we follow our MMC and FMC through Christmas seasons.
With moments of love found, love lost, self-acceptance, self-love, and self-awareness, this story was beautifully written and told in an honest way.
There were moments of joy and tears with a larger picture bringing in heavier topics that show how much these characters were able to grow.
If you're looking for a holiday classic inspired tale, with deep feelings, and an ever deeper meaning, this one is for you.
Saving Scrooge is inspired by Dickens' A Christmas Carol and has elements of this classic sprinkled throughout. Set over a few years we follow our MMC and FMC through Christmas seasons.
With moments of love found, love lost, self-acceptance, self-love, and self-awareness, this story was beautifully written and told in an honest way.
There were moments of joy and tears with a larger picture bringing in heavier topics that show how much these characters were able to grow.
If you're looking for a holiday classic inspired tale, with deep feelings, and an ever deeper meaning, this one is for you.
November 11, 2026
Danielle Smyth is an auto-read, auto-buy author for me. If she writes it, I’m reading it.
Saving Scrooge takes inspiration from A Christmas Carol, following a man whose past threatens to cost him his future with the woman he loves. Edward’s ambition and unresolved trauma pull him away from Isabelle, who has already learned how much it can cost to try to save someone else.
I like the idea that Edward’s second chance has to begin with him facing himself. Isabelle can love him, but she can’t do that work for him. Enter the ghosts, who apparently have a few things they’d like to discuss.
A great addition to your Christmas reading list, especially if you like a little emotional baggage with your holiday spirit.
Romance, redemption, and a supernatural wake-up call—with Danielle Smyth’s name on the cover.
Saving Scrooge takes inspiration from A Christmas Carol, following a man whose past threatens to cost him his future with the woman he loves. Edward’s ambition and unresolved trauma pull him away from Isabelle, who has already learned how much it can cost to try to save someone else.
I like the idea that Edward’s second chance has to begin with him facing himself. Isabelle can love him, but she can’t do that work for him. Enter the ghosts, who apparently have a few things they’d like to discuss.
A great addition to your Christmas reading list, especially if you like a little emotional baggage with your holiday spirit.
Romance, redemption, and a supernatural wake-up call—with Danielle Smyth’s name on the cover.
November 9, 2026
A modern-day Scrooge, a little Christmas magic, a second chance at love and a whole lot of festive feelings. Well, consider me thoroughly in the Christmas spirit. 🎄
Inspired by A Christmas Carol, Saving Scrooge follows Edward, a successful but emotionally guarded man whose life is about to get a rather unexpected Christmas makeover. And while the Dickens inspiration is quite apparent, I particularly enjoyed how the story uses the past, present and future to explore Edward’s relationships, his regrets and the things he’s been holding onto for far too long.
Edward was easily one of my favourite parts of this book. He’s intelligent, analytical and very much accustomed to having everything under control. Except, of course, when it comes to his own feelings. Beneath that rather composed exterior is someone who carries an enormous amount of guilt and responsibility, particularly when it comes to his family. He’s spent so much of his life trying to protect the people he loves that he’s almost forgotten he deserves to live a life of his own.
And then there’s Isabelle! She’s warm, compassionate and has a heart of gold, but she’s also someone with her own emotional baggage and reservations from a previous relationship. I appreciated that she wasn’t simply there to swoop in and fix Edward. She has her own experiences to work through and I liked the way their perspectives allowed us to understand both sides of their relationship. Edward might be the central character here, but seeing him through Isabelle’s eyes, and Isabelle through his, made their dynamic all the more enjoyable.
The romance itself is sweet, with plenty of chemistry and some rather adorable interactions between the two. I also loved the little mathematical references and banter sprinkled throughout. Their relationship does have its share of misunderstandings and impulsive decisions, and yes, a mature conversation could probably have saved everyone a considerable amount of trouble. But then again, are we really humans if we don’t make questionable decisions from time to time?
One thing I particularly enjoyed was the ensemble-like quality of the story. In a way, it parallels well with Love Actually, with its collection of relationships, personal struggles and people navigating life around Christmas. Not everyone gets the love of their life back, not everyone has their story wrapped up in a perfect little bow, but there’s still happiness, warmth and something worth celebrating. Edward and Isabelle remain at the heart of it all, while the supporting characters add to that wider festive atmosphere without taking the focus away from them.
But beneath all the romance and Christmas cheer, I think the story has a rather lovely message about forgiveness, redemption and personal growth. There’s a line about how people are flawed and always growing and changing, and that we may simply have met them at the wrong time to truly be aligned and I found that sentiment particularly meaningful.
Because sometimes people make mistakes. Sometimes they hurt us, sometimes they hurt themselves, and sometimes circumstances simply don’t allow us to understand one another. But people aren’t defined solely by who they were at one particular point in their lives. They can grow, change and become better versions of themselves. Perhaps redemption is possible, and forgiveness is a choice we get to make.
I think that’s ultimately what Edward’s journey is about. Learning to forgive others, but perhaps more importantly, learning to forgive himself.
All in all, this was a lovely start to my Christmas reading season. It gave me romance, a little introspection, festive warmth and characters I genuinely wanted to see happy. It may not be the most elaborate or groundbreaking retelling of A Christmas Carol, but it has a sweet emotional core and a message worth taking away.
Thank you to the author and publisher for the opportunity to read and review this book. All opinions are my own.
Inspired by A Christmas Carol, Saving Scrooge follows Edward, a successful but emotionally guarded man whose life is about to get a rather unexpected Christmas makeover. And while the Dickens inspiration is quite apparent, I particularly enjoyed how the story uses the past, present and future to explore Edward’s relationships, his regrets and the things he’s been holding onto for far too long.
Edward was easily one of my favourite parts of this book. He’s intelligent, analytical and very much accustomed to having everything under control. Except, of course, when it comes to his own feelings. Beneath that rather composed exterior is someone who carries an enormous amount of guilt and responsibility, particularly when it comes to his family. He’s spent so much of his life trying to protect the people he loves that he’s almost forgotten he deserves to live a life of his own.
And then there’s Isabelle! She’s warm, compassionate and has a heart of gold, but she’s also someone with her own emotional baggage and reservations from a previous relationship. I appreciated that she wasn’t simply there to swoop in and fix Edward. She has her own experiences to work through and I liked the way their perspectives allowed us to understand both sides of their relationship. Edward might be the central character here, but seeing him through Isabelle’s eyes, and Isabelle through his, made their dynamic all the more enjoyable.
The romance itself is sweet, with plenty of chemistry and some rather adorable interactions between the two. I also loved the little mathematical references and banter sprinkled throughout. Their relationship does have its share of misunderstandings and impulsive decisions, and yes, a mature conversation could probably have saved everyone a considerable amount of trouble. But then again, are we really humans if we don’t make questionable decisions from time to time?
One thing I particularly enjoyed was the ensemble-like quality of the story. In a way, it parallels well with Love Actually, with its collection of relationships, personal struggles and people navigating life around Christmas. Not everyone gets the love of their life back, not everyone has their story wrapped up in a perfect little bow, but there’s still happiness, warmth and something worth celebrating. Edward and Isabelle remain at the heart of it all, while the supporting characters add to that wider festive atmosphere without taking the focus away from them.
But beneath all the romance and Christmas cheer, I think the story has a rather lovely message about forgiveness, redemption and personal growth. There’s a line about how people are flawed and always growing and changing, and that we may simply have met them at the wrong time to truly be aligned and I found that sentiment particularly meaningful.
Because sometimes people make mistakes. Sometimes they hurt us, sometimes they hurt themselves, and sometimes circumstances simply don’t allow us to understand one another. But people aren’t defined solely by who they were at one particular point in their lives. They can grow, change and become better versions of themselves. Perhaps redemption is possible, and forgiveness is a choice we get to make.
I think that’s ultimately what Edward’s journey is about. Learning to forgive others, but perhaps more importantly, learning to forgive himself.
All in all, this was a lovely start to my Christmas reading season. It gave me romance, a little introspection, festive warmth and characters I genuinely wanted to see happy. It may not be the most elaborate or groundbreaking retelling of A Christmas Carol, but it has a sweet emotional core and a message worth taking away.
Thank you to the author and publisher for the opportunity to read and review this book. All opinions are my own.
November 13, 2026
🚨 SPOILER ALERT: READ AT YOUR OWN RISK!
I am giving Saving Scrooge (Unwritten #1) by Danielle Smyth an absolute 4.5-star review! ⭐⭐⭐⭐✨
A fresh, deeply emotional, and magical contemporary holiday romance that honors the timeless spirit of A Christmas Carol while standing completely on its own! Balancing cozy London holiday vibes with heavy, realistic emotional baggage, this story delivers an earned, heart-wrenching second-chance love story! 🎄👻🇬🇧✨
ARC Disclosure: A huge thank you to author Danielle Smyth and the publisher for providing an advance digital review copy (eARC) of this book! All thoughts, fanatical reactions, and honest reflections shared in this review are entirely my own.
The Review
Saving Scrooge by Danielle Smyth completely blew me away with how thoughtfully it reimagines a classic! Rather than a rigid beat-for-beat retelling, it honors the core elements of A Christmas Carol—including the three spirits and powerful themes of redemption—while feeling like a unique, grounded contemporary romance.
I became so deeply invested in both leads! Edward Scribner is such a reluctant genius MMC—a brilliant, driven businessman who has lost sight of what matters most, hiding behind strict emotional barriers. Watching him unfold as a "neurotic golden retriever" shaped by genuine past trauma rather than simple greed made my heart ache for him, especially since he always puts himself on the back burner. And Isabelle Salvatore? She is the ultimate FMC who knows her worth! She is so warm, hopeful, and loving, yet afraid of getting burned—refusing to lose herself trying to "save" the man she loves and holding firm boundaries to protect herself after walking away.
The Dual POV structure was a massive strength for me. Switching between Edward's and Isabelle's perspectives helped me truly understand both of their fears, motivations, and contrasting cynic-vs.-idealist outlooks. Add in actual ghosts intervening to show Edward the consequences of his choices, a family crisis that forces him to confront his past traumas to win her back, and even a fun gray sweatpants (joggers) micro-trope, and you have a holiday romance that feels deeply earned rather than overly saccharine!
The Good
A fresh and grounded take on A Christmas Carol with magical realism, deeply sympathetic leads in Edward Scribner and Isabelle Salvatore, an empowering FMC who maintains firm boundaries, effective Dual POV storytelling, cozy London holiday atmosphere, and top-tier emotional payoff!
The Not So Good
The heavy, realistic emotional baggage and past trauma give this story a noticeably weightier, more serious tone than your typical light-and-fluffy holiday rom-com—so be prepared for real feels alongside the festive magic!
I am giving Saving Scrooge (Unwritten #1) by Danielle Smyth an absolute 4.5-star review! ⭐⭐⭐⭐✨
A fresh, deeply emotional, and magical contemporary holiday romance that honors the timeless spirit of A Christmas Carol while standing completely on its own! Balancing cozy London holiday vibes with heavy, realistic emotional baggage, this story delivers an earned, heart-wrenching second-chance love story! 🎄👻🇬🇧✨
ARC Disclosure: A huge thank you to author Danielle Smyth and the publisher for providing an advance digital review copy (eARC) of this book! All thoughts, fanatical reactions, and honest reflections shared in this review are entirely my own.
The Review
Saving Scrooge by Danielle Smyth completely blew me away with how thoughtfully it reimagines a classic! Rather than a rigid beat-for-beat retelling, it honors the core elements of A Christmas Carol—including the three spirits and powerful themes of redemption—while feeling like a unique, grounded contemporary romance.
I became so deeply invested in both leads! Edward Scribner is such a reluctant genius MMC—a brilliant, driven businessman who has lost sight of what matters most, hiding behind strict emotional barriers. Watching him unfold as a "neurotic golden retriever" shaped by genuine past trauma rather than simple greed made my heart ache for him, especially since he always puts himself on the back burner. And Isabelle Salvatore? She is the ultimate FMC who knows her worth! She is so warm, hopeful, and loving, yet afraid of getting burned—refusing to lose herself trying to "save" the man she loves and holding firm boundaries to protect herself after walking away.
The Dual POV structure was a massive strength for me. Switching between Edward's and Isabelle's perspectives helped me truly understand both of their fears, motivations, and contrasting cynic-vs.-idealist outlooks. Add in actual ghosts intervening to show Edward the consequences of his choices, a family crisis that forces him to confront his past traumas to win her back, and even a fun gray sweatpants (joggers) micro-trope, and you have a holiday romance that feels deeply earned rather than overly saccharine!
The Good
A fresh and grounded take on A Christmas Carol with magical realism, deeply sympathetic leads in Edward Scribner and Isabelle Salvatore, an empowering FMC who maintains firm boundaries, effective Dual POV storytelling, cozy London holiday atmosphere, and top-tier emotional payoff!
The Not So Good
The heavy, realistic emotional baggage and past trauma give this story a noticeably weightier, more serious tone than your typical light-and-fluffy holiday rom-com—so be prepared for real feels alongside the festive magic!
November 8, 2026
What if Scrooge got his happily ever after? 🥹
A modern-day retelling of A Christmas Carol, but with second chances, a little Christmas magic, and a love story that absolutely tugged at my heartstrings!
I have loved Danielle Smyth's writing, and this story is another beautiful reminder of why. ❤️
First of all, right person, wrong time AND second chance romance?! If you know me, you know I'm an absolute sucker for both!
But don't let the Christmas setting fool you. This isn't your typical cute and fluffy holiday rom-com (and believe me, I love those too!). There is so much heart and depth to this story.
Edward. Oh, my heart hurt for this man. 🥹 He's incredibly intelligent, a little cynical, and carries so much pain from his childhood. Beneath all those walls is the kindest, most fragile heart, and he has spent so much of his life believing he's unworthy of being truly loved. I just wanted to reach into the pages and hug him.
And Isabelle! I loved her strength, her heart, and the way she knows her worth. Also, the red bows in her hair? Adorable. 🎀
These two have so much history, so many things left unsaid, and so many insecurities that lead them to make assumptions about each other. And yes, there's miscommunication. You KNOW how I feel about that trope! 😂 But here's the thing... I understood it. It made sense for these characters and their pasts, and I genuinely felt it was necessary for their individual growth.
And can we talk about the ghosts?! I absolutely LOVED how Danielle incorporated the ghosts of Christmas past, present, and future. Watching Edward confront his past, see the impact he's had on the people around him, and begin to understand that his life and his love matter was so incredibly moving.
There were moments that made me smile, moments that broke my heart, and moments that made me want to cry happy tears.
And London at Christmas?! The atmosphere, the magic, the romance. I loved it all. 🎄
At its heart, this is a story about forgiveness, especially forgiving yourself. About letting go of the past, recognizing your own worth, and finding the courage to love and allow yourself to be loved. About realizing that your past doesn't have to define your future.
It's such a beautiful reminder that we all deserve happiness, even when we've convinced ourselves otherwise. 🥹❤️
If you love holiday romances with real emotional depth, flawed but lovable characters, a little magic, and a second chance at love, please add this one to your TBR!
And truly, if you haven't read Danielle Smyth yet, I can't recommend her books enough! ❤️
🎄 Tropes & Things to Love 🎀
🎄 Modern A Christmas Carol retelling
🎀 Second chance / right person, wrong time
🎄 Cynic × idealist
🎀 Christmas ghosts & magical realism
🎄 Wounded, reluctant genius MMC
🎀 Strong FMC who knows her worth
🎄 Math genius × marketing guru
🎀 Slutty little glasses
🎄 "Let me look at you"
🎀 Christmas in London
⚠️ Content Warnings:
References to childhood trauma, an alcoholic and abusive parent, and past domestic violence (discussed through memories, not depicted on page).
A modern-day retelling of A Christmas Carol, but with second chances, a little Christmas magic, and a love story that absolutely tugged at my heartstrings!
I have loved Danielle Smyth's writing, and this story is another beautiful reminder of why. ❤️
First of all, right person, wrong time AND second chance romance?! If you know me, you know I'm an absolute sucker for both!
But don't let the Christmas setting fool you. This isn't your typical cute and fluffy holiday rom-com (and believe me, I love those too!). There is so much heart and depth to this story.
Edward. Oh, my heart hurt for this man. 🥹 He's incredibly intelligent, a little cynical, and carries so much pain from his childhood. Beneath all those walls is the kindest, most fragile heart, and he has spent so much of his life believing he's unworthy of being truly loved. I just wanted to reach into the pages and hug him.
And Isabelle! I loved her strength, her heart, and the way she knows her worth. Also, the red bows in her hair? Adorable. 🎀
These two have so much history, so many things left unsaid, and so many insecurities that lead them to make assumptions about each other. And yes, there's miscommunication. You KNOW how I feel about that trope! 😂 But here's the thing... I understood it. It made sense for these characters and their pasts, and I genuinely felt it was necessary for their individual growth.
And can we talk about the ghosts?! I absolutely LOVED how Danielle incorporated the ghosts of Christmas past, present, and future. Watching Edward confront his past, see the impact he's had on the people around him, and begin to understand that his life and his love matter was so incredibly moving.
There were moments that made me smile, moments that broke my heart, and moments that made me want to cry happy tears.
And London at Christmas?! The atmosphere, the magic, the romance. I loved it all. 🎄
At its heart, this is a story about forgiveness, especially forgiving yourself. About letting go of the past, recognizing your own worth, and finding the courage to love and allow yourself to be loved. About realizing that your past doesn't have to define your future.
It's such a beautiful reminder that we all deserve happiness, even when we've convinced ourselves otherwise. 🥹❤️
If you love holiday romances with real emotional depth, flawed but lovable characters, a little magic, and a second chance at love, please add this one to your TBR!
And truly, if you haven't read Danielle Smyth yet, I can't recommend her books enough! ❤️
🎄 Tropes & Things to Love 🎀
🎄 Modern A Christmas Carol retelling
🎀 Second chance / right person, wrong time
🎄 Cynic × idealist
🎀 Christmas ghosts & magical realism
🎄 Wounded, reluctant genius MMC
🎀 Strong FMC who knows her worth
🎄 Math genius × marketing guru
🎀 Slutty little glasses
🎄 "Let me look at you"
🎀 Christmas in London
⚠️ Content Warnings:
References to childhood trauma, an alcoholic and abusive parent, and past domestic violence (discussed through memories, not depicted on page).
Review of advance copy
First off, a HUGE thank you to Danielle Smyth and Beyond the Books PR for an advance copy of this book!!
This book had me sold from the moment I read the dedication to The Muppet Christmas Carol, one of my all-time favorite holiday movies. I had a feeling I was going to love this story, and I was not disappointed!
Growing up, I always wondered what happened between young Scrooge and his lost love, Belle. Her goodbye song in The Muppet Christmas Carol was always one of my favorite scenes, so seeing Danielle reimagine their story as such a beautiful, fun romance was truly magical. To finally get the love story I always wanted for them?! 😍
Between the adorable meet-cute, second-chance romance, holiday magic, and dual POV, there was already so much to love. But the math banter?! Oh my goodness, I absolutely loved it! Watching two people flirt through math was such a fun, quirky change from the usual romantic banter. It was nerdy, adorable, and honestly, perfection! (Especially the "I like math" line. 😂)
Isabelle, our FMC and our "Belle," was such a wonderful character. She's strong, compassionate, and knows her worth. Despite being hurt in the past, she still has such a big heart, and I loved that she refused to compromise her boundaries. (She also makes me want to buy a red holiday dress and hair bow!)
Then there's Edward, our MMC and resident "Scrooge." Beneath his intelligence, ambition, and sometimes questionable decisions is a genuinely kind, loving man haunted by his past. He wants so desperately to protect those he loves that he sometimes fails to see how his choices affect them.
I think what resonated with me most was the message woven throughout the story: You cannot change someone who isn't ready or willing to change, and it isn't your responsibility to make them. I loved how this played out for both characters. Isabelle learns that loving someone doesn't mean sacrificing her own needs or boundaries, while Edward has to confront his past and realize that protecting the people he loves doesn't mean making decisions for them.
At its heart, this was such a sweet, heartfelt story about second chances, healing, and learning that love isn't about fixing someone. It's about choosing to grow, both for yourself and alongside the person you love.
And yes, I was absolutely rooting for these two to get their happily ever after! ❤️🎄
This book had me sold from the moment I read the dedication to The Muppet Christmas Carol, one of my all-time favorite holiday movies. I had a feeling I was going to love this story, and I was not disappointed!
Growing up, I always wondered what happened between young Scrooge and his lost love, Belle. Her goodbye song in The Muppet Christmas Carol was always one of my favorite scenes, so seeing Danielle reimagine their story as such a beautiful, fun romance was truly magical. To finally get the love story I always wanted for them?! 😍
Between the adorable meet-cute, second-chance romance, holiday magic, and dual POV, there was already so much to love. But the math banter?! Oh my goodness, I absolutely loved it! Watching two people flirt through math was such a fun, quirky change from the usual romantic banter. It was nerdy, adorable, and honestly, perfection! (Especially the "I like math" line. 😂)
Isabelle, our FMC and our "Belle," was such a wonderful character. She's strong, compassionate, and knows her worth. Despite being hurt in the past, she still has such a big heart, and I loved that she refused to compromise her boundaries. (She also makes me want to buy a red holiday dress and hair bow!)
Then there's Edward, our MMC and resident "Scrooge." Beneath his intelligence, ambition, and sometimes questionable decisions is a genuinely kind, loving man haunted by his past. He wants so desperately to protect those he loves that he sometimes fails to see how his choices affect them.
I think what resonated with me most was the message woven throughout the story: You cannot change someone who isn't ready or willing to change, and it isn't your responsibility to make them. I loved how this played out for both characters. Isabelle learns that loving someone doesn't mean sacrificing her own needs or boundaries, while Edward has to confront his past and realize that protecting the people he loves doesn't mean making decisions for them.
At its heart, this was such a sweet, heartfelt story about second chances, healing, and learning that love isn't about fixing someone. It's about choosing to grow, both for yourself and alongside the person you love.
And yes, I was absolutely rooting for these two to get their happily ever after! ❤️🎄
November 14, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️️⭐️/ ️🌶️🌶️🌶️
How have I never read a Christmas Carol reimagined that puts the focus on romance? I devoured this book by Danielle Smyth and know that it is going to be a re-read for me over this holiday season. In the original classic there is a small scene of romance, but it never plays out as the story revolves around Scrooge treating other people better. In the Saving Scrooge series, book 1, Saving Scrooge, is about our MMC letting go enough to let real love in and finding happiness.
Edward is a Scrooge unlike any I have ever read. His past has caused so much hurt and pain that has caused him to be emotionally guarded. I understand the walls that have been built up around his heart, as Danielle gave readers descriptive information to his past. His genius side is what keeps him grounded, focusing on numbers rather than emotions. He doesn’t think he is worthy of love, due to everything he’s endured from his family and reading about him overcoming this had my heart in a vise.
Isabelle brings everything good into Edward’s life. She is bright where he is dark, light where he is heavy, and open where he is closed. She has her own baggage, but doesn’t let it rule her to the same degree as Edward’s does. She undeniably knows her worth and is not going to let anyone take that away that from her again. It wasn’t easy, but I loved her strength in being able to know when she deserves more and deserves better.
The messages are clear throughout the story. You cannot heal someone who doesn’t want to be healed. It starts with them and trying to get them to see that before they are ready will only cause you more pain. Seeing Edward overcome such deep hurt that burrowed into his psyche was a wonderful experience. Danielle has done an amazing job bringing this carol and making it modern and romantic. A delightful read during the holiday literary season that I thoroughly enjoyed.
As always, review any author notes before reading.
What to Expect:
🎩Holiday Romance
🎄Second Chance Romance
🎩Cynic x Idealist
🎄Genius MMC
🎩Intrinsic FMC
🎄Trauma Healing
🎩Self Worth Discovery
🎄Christmas Carol Reimagined
How have I never read a Christmas Carol reimagined that puts the focus on romance? I devoured this book by Danielle Smyth and know that it is going to be a re-read for me over this holiday season. In the original classic there is a small scene of romance, but it never plays out as the story revolves around Scrooge treating other people better. In the Saving Scrooge series, book 1, Saving Scrooge, is about our MMC letting go enough to let real love in and finding happiness.
Edward is a Scrooge unlike any I have ever read. His past has caused so much hurt and pain that has caused him to be emotionally guarded. I understand the walls that have been built up around his heart, as Danielle gave readers descriptive information to his past. His genius side is what keeps him grounded, focusing on numbers rather than emotions. He doesn’t think he is worthy of love, due to everything he’s endured from his family and reading about him overcoming this had my heart in a vise.
Isabelle brings everything good into Edward’s life. She is bright where he is dark, light where he is heavy, and open where he is closed. She has her own baggage, but doesn’t let it rule her to the same degree as Edward’s does. She undeniably knows her worth and is not going to let anyone take that away that from her again. It wasn’t easy, but I loved her strength in being able to know when she deserves more and deserves better.
The messages are clear throughout the story. You cannot heal someone who doesn’t want to be healed. It starts with them and trying to get them to see that before they are ready will only cause you more pain. Seeing Edward overcome such deep hurt that burrowed into his psyche was a wonderful experience. Danielle has done an amazing job bringing this carol and making it modern and romantic. A delightful read during the holiday literary season that I thoroughly enjoyed.
As always, review any author notes before reading.
What to Expect:
🎩Holiday Romance
🎄Second Chance Romance
🎩Cynic x Idealist
🎄Genius MMC
🎩Intrinsic FMC
🎄Trauma Healing
🎩Self Worth Discovery
🎄Christmas Carol Reimagined
Review of advance copy received from Author
A Christmas Carol retelling, a swoony romance, emotional character growth, AND math banter? Sign me up!
Saving Scrooge gives us a fresh take on the classic Christmas story while staying a little closer to the original premise. This time, it's our MMC, Edward, who gets visits from the ghosts of Christmas Past, Present, and Future. But instead of focusing solely on changing his ways, the story beautifully weaves those paranormal elements into Edward's relationship with Isabelle, a sweet marketing guru who brings her own baggage to the table.
Edward is a math genius, and Isabelle is the perfect counterpart to him. Both characters have past experiences that make opening themselves up to love difficult, and I thought Danielle Smyth did an incredible job exploring the very real challenges that come with relationships: learning to be vulnerable after being hurt, trusting someone with the parts of yourself you'd rather keep hidden, and believing that you're worthy of love exactly as you are.
This book took me on an emotional roller coaster. There were moments when my heart was absolutely breaking, followed by moments that brought tears of joy to my eyes. I loved watching these characters work through their fears and discover what it means to let someone truly see them.
But let's be honest: my favorite part might just have been the math banter! As a math nerd myself, I was delighted by it. In fact, I think I've discovered my new favorite microtrope. Give me all the math-loving characters and clever mathematical flirting, please!
Overall, Saving Scrooge is a heartfelt holiday romance that balances the magic of A Christmas Carol with a meaningful story about love, vulnerability, and learning to see yourself as someone worthy of being loved. Definitely one to add to your holiday reading list!
Thank you to Beyond the Books PR for the opportunity to read this ARC. All opinions are my own.
Saving Scrooge gives us a fresh take on the classic Christmas story while staying a little closer to the original premise. This time, it's our MMC, Edward, who gets visits from the ghosts of Christmas Past, Present, and Future. But instead of focusing solely on changing his ways, the story beautifully weaves those paranormal elements into Edward's relationship with Isabelle, a sweet marketing guru who brings her own baggage to the table.
Edward is a math genius, and Isabelle is the perfect counterpart to him. Both characters have past experiences that make opening themselves up to love difficult, and I thought Danielle Smyth did an incredible job exploring the very real challenges that come with relationships: learning to be vulnerable after being hurt, trusting someone with the parts of yourself you'd rather keep hidden, and believing that you're worthy of love exactly as you are.
This book took me on an emotional roller coaster. There were moments when my heart was absolutely breaking, followed by moments that brought tears of joy to my eyes. I loved watching these characters work through their fears and discover what it means to let someone truly see them.
But let's be honest: my favorite part might just have been the math banter! As a math nerd myself, I was delighted by it. In fact, I think I've discovered my new favorite microtrope. Give me all the math-loving characters and clever mathematical flirting, please!
Overall, Saving Scrooge is a heartfelt holiday romance that balances the magic of A Christmas Carol with a meaningful story about love, vulnerability, and learning to see yourself as someone worthy of being loved. Definitely one to add to your holiday reading list!
Thank you to Beyond the Books PR for the opportunity to read this ARC. All opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I received an advance copy from the author. This is my honest review.
If you’re looking for a Christmas read to add to your December TBR, a holiday story set in London is a pretty wonderful place to start🎄
I liked both Isabelle and Edward. Their characters were developed in a way that made their decisions, assumptions, and sometimes pretty significant miscommunications a little more understandable. They were each navigating their own histories, and I thought the author did a great job of connecting those pieces and showing how their past experiences shaped the way they saw themselves and each other.
The miscommunication trope can be a frustrating one for me. I definitely had moments of wanting to reach into the story and tell them to question things a little further, or just face each other and TALK 😂 But I could also understand why they made the choices they did, even when I wanted to shake them a little.
I especially had a soft spot for Edward. I love a brilliant mind in an equally brilliant body, with a personality to match 🤩 I think the fact that we get his POV too really helped me connect with his journey. I also really enjoyed the connection between him and Isabelle. They’re different in plenty of ways, but there’s a fun dynamic between them that I loved watching develop.
One of my favorite aspects of the story was its exploration of self-discovery and self-worth. It’s about learning to see yourself the way others see you, recognizing the good qualities you may have overlooked, and challenging deeply ingrained negative beliefs to discover a truer, kinder version of yourself. There’s something especially fitting about that kind of inner work during the holiday season.
If you’re looking for a Christmas read to add to your December TBR, a holiday story set in London is a pretty wonderful place to start🎄
I liked both Isabelle and Edward. Their characters were developed in a way that made their decisions, assumptions, and sometimes pretty significant miscommunications a little more understandable. They were each navigating their own histories, and I thought the author did a great job of connecting those pieces and showing how their past experiences shaped the way they saw themselves and each other.
The miscommunication trope can be a frustrating one for me. I definitely had moments of wanting to reach into the story and tell them to question things a little further, or just face each other and TALK 😂 But I could also understand why they made the choices they did, even when I wanted to shake them a little.
I especially had a soft spot for Edward. I love a brilliant mind in an equally brilliant body, with a personality to match 🤩 I think the fact that we get his POV too really helped me connect with his journey. I also really enjoyed the connection between him and Isabelle. They’re different in plenty of ways, but there’s a fun dynamic between them that I loved watching develop.
One of my favorite aspects of the story was its exploration of self-discovery and self-worth. It’s about learning to see yourself the way others see you, recognizing the good qualities you may have overlooked, and challenging deeply ingrained negative beliefs to discover a truer, kinder version of yourself. There’s something especially fitting about that kind of inner work during the holiday season.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Kindly received a copy from the author and beyond the books pr in exchange for an honest review.
Saving Scrooge by Danielle Smyth
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5/5
Tropes:
❤️Cynic vs. idealist
💚Second chance
❤️Reluctant genius MMC
💚FMC who knows her worth
❤️Speculative romance
💚Gray sweatpants (but make them joggers)
Review:
Danielle has done it again and made me fall in love with another one of her books! Oh Edward Scribner how I see myself in you this season. With such a long to do list and late nights staying up trying to complete tasks it often feels like he doesn't have enough time for the one whom he really wants to spend time with, Isabelle Salvatore.
Isabelle was tearing at my heartstrings through this book. She is so kindhearted and loving towards the children that benefit from the nonprofit. All the little details from making sure the kiddos have a fun bouncy castle to warm enough mittens! Isabelle I love your sweet and gentle heart. She is so patient with Edward and tries her best to be there for him. ❤️
I love the way we get to see both sides of this story through each of Edward's and Isabelle's perspectives. The love they both have for each others runs so deep despite both of them not understanding each other all the time. I was living for this second chance romance!
Thank you so much to Danielle Smyth and Beyond the Books PR for another lovely ARC to review. I have really enjoyed your books!
Favorite Quotes:
💚
Saving Scrooge by Danielle Smyth
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5/5
Tropes:
❤️Cynic vs. idealist
💚Second chance
❤️Reluctant genius MMC
💚FMC who knows her worth
❤️Speculative romance
💚Gray sweatpants (but make them joggers)
Review:
Danielle has done it again and made me fall in love with another one of her books! Oh Edward Scribner how I see myself in you this season. With such a long to do list and late nights staying up trying to complete tasks it often feels like he doesn't have enough time for the one whom he really wants to spend time with, Isabelle Salvatore.
Isabelle was tearing at my heartstrings through this book. She is so kindhearted and loving towards the children that benefit from the nonprofit. All the little details from making sure the kiddos have a fun bouncy castle to warm enough mittens! Isabelle I love your sweet and gentle heart. She is so patient with Edward and tries her best to be there for him. ❤️
I love the way we get to see both sides of this story through each of Edward's and Isabelle's perspectives. The love they both have for each others runs so deep despite both of them not understanding each other all the time. I was living for this second chance romance!
Thank you so much to Danielle Smyth and Beyond the Books PR for another lovely ARC to review. I have really enjoyed your books!
Favorite Quotes:
💚
November 13, 2026
well this was such a breath of fresh air and probably one of my favorite holiday books I’ve ever read! Edward Scribner is haunted by his past family trauma, believing he can never find love. He meets Isabelle Salvatore, the marketing assistant for a children’s nonprofit, and suddenly he can picture a future with her instead of the loneliness he’s felt most of his life. He comes face first with his past traumas and must confront them in order to rewrite his story. If Scrooge can save himself, maybe he’ll get a second chance at love.
oh my goodness I just LOVED this book. I adored Edward and Isabelle, both characters experiencing different emotions and so much growth throughout the story. when I saw this story was loosely based on A Christmas Carol, I knew it was going to be good. Isabelle meets Edward a year after a heartbreak, and knows she is never going to “save a man again.” She is such a strong character. While she was caring of Edward, she also had the strength to walk away to let him find himself.
Edward was also such a strong MMC. I was rooting for him the whole time, even though he seemed down on his luck and it felt like he wasn’t going to find himself. I absolutely loved the ghosts of christmas past, present and future, making him realize the positive impact he has had on those around him.
I just adored this book, I adored the characters and London during Christmas time?! Talk about a dreamy setting 😍🎄✨ pub day is TODAY, go add this one to your holiday TBR, you will be happy you did!
oh my goodness I just LOVED this book. I adored Edward and Isabelle, both characters experiencing different emotions and so much growth throughout the story. when I saw this story was loosely based on A Christmas Carol, I knew it was going to be good. Isabelle meets Edward a year after a heartbreak, and knows she is never going to “save a man again.” She is such a strong character. While she was caring of Edward, she also had the strength to walk away to let him find himself.
Edward was also such a strong MMC. I was rooting for him the whole time, even though he seemed down on his luck and it felt like he wasn’t going to find himself. I absolutely loved the ghosts of christmas past, present and future, making him realize the positive impact he has had on those around him.
I just adored this book, I adored the characters and London during Christmas time?! Talk about a dreamy setting 😍🎄✨ pub day is TODAY, go add this one to your holiday TBR, you will be happy you did!
November 5, 2026
Saving Scrooge by Danielle Smyth
This is a reimagined and up-to-date Christmas Carol retelling. I fell in love with this book straight out of the gate. This book warmed my Christmas heart and gave me all the cozy holiday vibes.
Edward is our Ebenezer. He is haunted by his past and how he thinks he affected his loved ones. He always wants to help others but usually thinks he screws it all up because of a painful past. I just want to hug and hold Edward constantly throughout this book.
Isabelle is our Belle. She has a more optimistic point of view. However, Isabelle has been hurt badly by her ex so that scarred her and shaped her reactions in her relationship because of that.
This is written in dual pov which was perfect.
Danielle managed to create a sweet holiday romance while sneaking in all the facets of A Christmas Carol that are important like the 3 ghosts, past personal demons, Edward’s love interest, and of course redemption.
Two themes that I loved in this book were, you can’t be responsible for changing someone or saving someone. They have to want to change and save themselves. It was also clear that Edward needed to accept support and help from his friends and Isabelle.
This is such a beautiful holiday book. Gives you all the feels of A Christmas Carol but now add romance to it. Chefs kiss.
Thank you Danielle Smyth and Beyond the Books PR for this ARC.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
5stars
This is a reimagined and up-to-date Christmas Carol retelling. I fell in love with this book straight out of the gate. This book warmed my Christmas heart and gave me all the cozy holiday vibes.
Edward is our Ebenezer. He is haunted by his past and how he thinks he affected his loved ones. He always wants to help others but usually thinks he screws it all up because of a painful past. I just want to hug and hold Edward constantly throughout this book.
Isabelle is our Belle. She has a more optimistic point of view. However, Isabelle has been hurt badly by her ex so that scarred her and shaped her reactions in her relationship because of that.
This is written in dual pov which was perfect.
Danielle managed to create a sweet holiday romance while sneaking in all the facets of A Christmas Carol that are important like the 3 ghosts, past personal demons, Edward’s love interest, and of course redemption.
Two themes that I loved in this book were, you can’t be responsible for changing someone or saving someone. They have to want to change and save themselves. It was also clear that Edward needed to accept support and help from his friends and Isabelle.
This is such a beautiful holiday book. Gives you all the feels of A Christmas Carol but now add romance to it. Chefs kiss.
Thank you Danielle Smyth and Beyond the Books PR for this ARC.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
5stars
Review of advance copy received from Author
When your past is out to haunt you, a little Christmas magic may be exactly what you need. Isabelle and Edward begin a whirlwind romance during the holiday season - but can love be enough to overcome the past? This holiday story is a modern day retelling of A Christmas Carol, with romance, heart, and a little magic.
Isabelle works in marketing for a children's nonprofit, and personality exudes warmth and kindness. Edward happens to be at her holiday fundraiser, and is instantly enamored by her. The two connect, and their relationship builds. But as changes in Edward's job, along with secrets he's keeping about his past, start to creep in, trust is broken. Isabelle wants to protect herself from tolerating a broken relationship, and they eventually grow apart. As the seasons change and Christmases come and go, their paths still cross. Edward is soon confronted by the ghosts of his past, present, and future, and hope starts to become an option.
I know people have a beef with the miscommunication trope, but sometimes that's the whole point! If they had communicated as they should have from the start, the story would've ended right away. This also allowed them to grow personally, which was important for both their characters. The Christmas vibes (family dinners, the spirit of giving, a cozy London setting) really set the tone. Edward was also obsessed with Isabelle - they were absolutely the right person at the wrong time vibes, and throw in their second chance? Magical.
Isabelle works in marketing for a children's nonprofit, and personality exudes warmth and kindness. Edward happens to be at her holiday fundraiser, and is instantly enamored by her. The two connect, and their relationship builds. But as changes in Edward's job, along with secrets he's keeping about his past, start to creep in, trust is broken. Isabelle wants to protect herself from tolerating a broken relationship, and they eventually grow apart. As the seasons change and Christmases come and go, their paths still cross. Edward is soon confronted by the ghosts of his past, present, and future, and hope starts to become an option.
I know people have a beef with the miscommunication trope, but sometimes that's the whole point! If they had communicated as they should have from the start, the story would've ended right away. This also allowed them to grow personally, which was important for both their characters. The Christmas vibes (family dinners, the spirit of giving, a cozy London setting) really set the tone. Edward was also obsessed with Isabelle - they were absolutely the right person at the wrong time vibes, and throw in their second chance? Magical.
Review of advance copy received from Author
A retelling of A Christmas Carol but including a happy ever after for the romance was high on my want to reads. Whilst the Dickens original has Scrooge’s love leave him to shape the man he becomes, it’s a tragedy that he never gets that happiness back. I’m glad this author had the same thoughts and decided to do something about it.
Isabelle is a beautiful person. I loved her warmth, compassion and resilience. She sees problems and wants to fix them, although this does lead to her risking her own happiness or well being at times. She has a pure soul though, she genuinely loves without the need for anything in return.
Edward is a deeply troubled young man but again, always thinks with his heart. Whatever he does, he does because he cares, because he loves, sometimes too much. I admired his deep sense of honesty and loyalty. His guilt haunts him though, he needs the reminders from the spirits to truly understand his own demons before he can move on.
There was a LOT of miscommunication in this story, so if you’re not a fan of this trope then it may not be for you. Personally, I don’t mind it and whilst yes, conversations should have happened that didn’t, I felt it enhanced the retelling of the original story, without the miscommunication, there would be no need for the spirits and with that, a big part of the story.
Isabelle is a beautiful person. I loved her warmth, compassion and resilience. She sees problems and wants to fix them, although this does lead to her risking her own happiness or well being at times. She has a pure soul though, she genuinely loves without the need for anything in return.
Edward is a deeply troubled young man but again, always thinks with his heart. Whatever he does, he does because he cares, because he loves, sometimes too much. I admired his deep sense of honesty and loyalty. His guilt haunts him though, he needs the reminders from the spirits to truly understand his own demons before he can move on.
There was a LOT of miscommunication in this story, so if you’re not a fan of this trope then it may not be for you. Personally, I don’t mind it and whilst yes, conversations should have happened that didn’t, I felt it enhanced the retelling of the original story, without the miscommunication, there would be no need for the spirits and with that, a big part of the story.
Review of advance copy
it should surprise no one that I’m gobbling up holiday reads right now, SAVING SCROOGE by @danielle.smyth.books out November 13th- (Thanks to @ @beyondthebookspr for an ARC gifted e-book!)
For a little background before the review, I read A Christmas Carol every year, in addition to watching every movie/tv version that comes out and reading/collecting any book even loosely inspired by this classic. Plus, I’m quite discerning, aka judgy, when it comes to stories I love, so the standards are sky-high.
My final assessment: Saving Scrooge should be on your holiday tbr this year- I’m giving it 4.5 stars! Wowza! Smyth wrote this book to give literary figures we love a happy ending they didn’t get in the books, so it’s all about giving young Scrooge an earlier chance to fix his atrocious work-life-trauma balance before completely losing the woman he loves. Complete with A Christmas Carol and other holiday references, fresh and lyrical writing, and of course, three ghosts, this book has it all- yes, including some spicy scenes.
And did I mention there are three or four Gilmore Girls references?!!! Love it when I find those in books! Anyway, I could definitely see myself rereading this in years to come and even springing for a special edition if that also came to pass.
For a little background before the review, I read A Christmas Carol every year, in addition to watching every movie/tv version that comes out and reading/collecting any book even loosely inspired by this classic. Plus, I’m quite discerning, aka judgy, when it comes to stories I love, so the standards are sky-high.
My final assessment: Saving Scrooge should be on your holiday tbr this year- I’m giving it 4.5 stars! Wowza! Smyth wrote this book to give literary figures we love a happy ending they didn’t get in the books, so it’s all about giving young Scrooge an earlier chance to fix his atrocious work-life-trauma balance before completely losing the woman he loves. Complete with A Christmas Carol and other holiday references, fresh and lyrical writing, and of course, three ghosts, this book has it all- yes, including some spicy scenes.
And did I mention there are three or four Gilmore Girls references?!!! Love it when I find those in books! Anyway, I could definitely see myself rereading this in years to come and even springing for a special edition if that also came to pass.
Review of advance copy received from Indie Reviewers
Saving Scrooge is a story about Edward and Isabelle (loved the names 👀) and a A Christmas Carol retelling. I love that movie so much, but I haven't had the chance to read a retelling of it before now. The retelling was done so beautifully, I loved it!
I loved the idea of giving Scrooge a second chance at getting things right, especially when it comes to love. With plenty of Christmas references, three ghosts and even a few spicy moments, this story has quite a bit to offer!
Edward and Isabelle made an interesting pair, and I really enjoyed seeing their relationship unfold. There was definitely a lot of drama, and the miscommunication had me wanting to shake some sense into them. Both main characters had their own baggage to work through but Edward felt like he had a LOT to unpack.
Watching him confront his past, rethink some of his choices, and slowly become a better version of himself was lovely. I also really liked the underlying message about self-worth, learning to see the good in yourself, and realizing that sometimes you deserve more than you've allowed yourself to believe.
This is a story about second chances, personal growth, and Isabelle and Edward getting their happy ending. A little chaotic, wonderfully festive, and full of Christmas charm
Thank you Danielle Smyth and Beyond the Books PR for the e-arc!!
I loved the idea of giving Scrooge a second chance at getting things right, especially when it comes to love. With plenty of Christmas references, three ghosts and even a few spicy moments, this story has quite a bit to offer!
Edward and Isabelle made an interesting pair, and I really enjoyed seeing their relationship unfold. There was definitely a lot of drama, and the miscommunication had me wanting to shake some sense into them. Both main characters had their own baggage to work through but Edward felt like he had a LOT to unpack.
Watching him confront his past, rethink some of his choices, and slowly become a better version of himself was lovely. I also really liked the underlying message about self-worth, learning to see the good in yourself, and realizing that sometimes you deserve more than you've allowed yourself to believe.
This is a story about second chances, personal growth, and Isabelle and Edward getting their happy ending. A little chaotic, wonderfully festive, and full of Christmas charm
Thank you Danielle Smyth and Beyond the Books PR for the e-arc!!
November 12, 2026
Thank you Danielle Smyth for this ARC! I think I just found my new favorite holiday book!! I absolutely loved this heart warming reimagining of A Christmas Carol.
Saving Scrooge follows the stoic, math genius Edward Scribner as he meets the bubbly and warm Isabelle and tries to find the balance between love, family, and business before he loses it all.
Edward stole my heart. He is intelligent, kind, and is such a good-hearted man, but he’s carrying a horribly traumatic weight on his soul. I loved seeing the warmth and joy that Isabelle brought into his life. Their banter was top tier. I was desperate for the ghosts to come when Scribner and Marlowe started pulling this Scrooge away. I so wanted these two to get the happily ever after they both deserve!
All the inclusions and references from both Charles Dickens original and A Muppet Christmas Carol were like holiday magic sprinkled throughout. I loved the inclusion of the staves. And if Love Actually is your favorite Christmas movie, you’re going to have a blast reading this!
As in all Danielle’s works, the writing is fantastic, the banter is perfect, the green flags are flying, and you’re promised a great read that will take you through all the emotions while leaving you happy and hopeful.
Saving Scrooge follows the stoic, math genius Edward Scribner as he meets the bubbly and warm Isabelle and tries to find the balance between love, family, and business before he loses it all.
Edward stole my heart. He is intelligent, kind, and is such a good-hearted man, but he’s carrying a horribly traumatic weight on his soul. I loved seeing the warmth and joy that Isabelle brought into his life. Their banter was top tier. I was desperate for the ghosts to come when Scribner and Marlowe started pulling this Scrooge away. I so wanted these two to get the happily ever after they both deserve!
All the inclusions and references from both Charles Dickens original and A Muppet Christmas Carol were like holiday magic sprinkled throughout. I loved the inclusion of the staves. And if Love Actually is your favorite Christmas movie, you’re going to have a blast reading this!
As in all Danielle’s works, the writing is fantastic, the banter is perfect, the green flags are flying, and you’re promised a great read that will take you through all the emotions while leaving you happy and hopeful.
November 14, 2026
A huge Thank You to Danielle Smyth who has allowed me to be on her street team for this as well as many of her other wonderful stories! I am beyond lucky to be able to read your stories and tell everyone I know they should as well!
I was so excited to see that Danielle was doing a take on "A Christmas Carol". Every year my best friend and I put up her Christmas decorations while "The Muppet Christmas Carol" plays. We will now have a new version to add to our holiday traditions ☺️
I love both Isabelle and Edward so much. Isabelle works to help underprivileged children throughout the year and makes holiday magic for children in need each Christmas. Edward is brilliant, and although he is our "scrooge", I always just saw him as a very intelligent handsome man trying to do the right thing and being impacted by his past trauma along the way.
As is so often the case, miscommunication, along with troubling self beliefs, are the cause of most heartbreak in this story. I love how Danielle incorporated the ghosts of Christmas past, present and future to help right what is wrong.
This will be a story I go back to each holiday season, thank you Danielle, for every wonderful story you bring into the world! I can't wait to see what the Halloween 2027 book will be. 💜💜
I was so excited to see that Danielle was doing a take on "A Christmas Carol". Every year my best friend and I put up her Christmas decorations while "The Muppet Christmas Carol" plays. We will now have a new version to add to our holiday traditions ☺️
I love both Isabelle and Edward so much. Isabelle works to help underprivileged children throughout the year and makes holiday magic for children in need each Christmas. Edward is brilliant, and although he is our "scrooge", I always just saw him as a very intelligent handsome man trying to do the right thing and being impacted by his past trauma along the way.
As is so often the case, miscommunication, along with troubling self beliefs, are the cause of most heartbreak in this story. I love how Danielle incorporated the ghosts of Christmas past, present and future to help right what is wrong.
This will be a story I go back to each holiday season, thank you Danielle, for every wonderful story you bring into the world! I can't wait to see what the Halloween 2027 book will be. 💜💜
Review of advance copy received from Author
A beautiful, emotionally resonant reimagining of a classic!
From the moment I picked this book up, I couldn't put it down; the story reached right off the pages and reeled me in until the very last word. I thoroughly enjoyed seeing this unique take on Scrooge play out, especially since Danielle Smyth delivers a refreshing, alternative ending that sets it apart from every other retelling of A Christmas Carol. It is a genuinely touching story about letting go of the past and learning to love in the present.
One of my favorite elements was how the author incorporated the traditional three ghosts. She pays homage to the original framework without letting the spirits overshadow the central characters' emotional growth. Even though this is a work of fiction, it brought about some very thought-provoking points for me. The only reason this isn't a full five-star review for me is the pacing of the ending. Compared to the beautifully measured flow of the rest of the book, the final chapters felt a bit rushed to wrap everything up.
Overall, this has quickly become one of my favorite versions of the Christmas classic. It’s a heartwarming story I can easily see myself rereading every holiday season, and I would absolutely love to see a movie adaptation bring it to life!
From the moment I picked this book up, I couldn't put it down; the story reached right off the pages and reeled me in until the very last word. I thoroughly enjoyed seeing this unique take on Scrooge play out, especially since Danielle Smyth delivers a refreshing, alternative ending that sets it apart from every other retelling of A Christmas Carol. It is a genuinely touching story about letting go of the past and learning to love in the present.
One of my favorite elements was how the author incorporated the traditional three ghosts. She pays homage to the original framework without letting the spirits overshadow the central characters' emotional growth. Even though this is a work of fiction, it brought about some very thought-provoking points for me. The only reason this isn't a full five-star review for me is the pacing of the ending. Compared to the beautifully measured flow of the rest of the book, the final chapters felt a bit rushed to wrap everything up.
Overall, this has quickly become one of my favorite versions of the Christmas classic. It’s a heartwarming story I can easily see myself rereading every holiday season, and I would absolutely love to see a movie adaptation bring it to life!
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
A fresh, fun, and dramatic spin on A Christmas Carol! I loved seeing Scrooge’s story reimagined with a modern romance woven into it. The three ghosts, Edward’s journey toward redemption, and all the Christmas magic made this such an entertaining read.
Now, there was definitely plenty of drama! Isabelle took a little getting used to for me. She could be overly dramatic at times, and the fainting? Girl, please. 😂 And Jeremy can absolutely kick rocks. But despite a few moments that tested my patience, I really enjoyed watching Edward’s character develop and seeing him work through his past.
What I loved most was that this story gave Scrooge the happy ending we never got in the original. A little messy, a lot dramatic, but ultimately sweet and full of Christmas charm.
If you love Christmas romances, second chances, and a creative twist on a classic tale, add this one to your holiday reading list! 🎄❤️
A huge thank you to Danielle Smyth for the opportunity to read this ARC. I truly enjoyed this festive reimagining and appreciate being given an early look at the story!
Now, there was definitely plenty of drama! Isabelle took a little getting used to for me. She could be overly dramatic at times, and the fainting? Girl, please. 😂 And Jeremy can absolutely kick rocks. But despite a few moments that tested my patience, I really enjoyed watching Edward’s character develop and seeing him work through his past.
What I loved most was that this story gave Scrooge the happy ending we never got in the original. A little messy, a lot dramatic, but ultimately sweet and full of Christmas charm.
If you love Christmas romances, second chances, and a creative twist on a classic tale, add this one to your holiday reading list! 🎄❤️
A huge thank you to Danielle Smyth for the opportunity to read this ARC. I truly enjoyed this festive reimagining and appreciate being given an early look at the story!
Review of advance copy received from Author
Saving Scrooge
Danielle Smyth
🎄🎄🎄🎄🎄/5
Saving Scrooge belongs on every Christmas TBR of readers who love a retelling of The Christmas Carol.
Edward and Isabelle have a wonderful Christmas story to share this holiday season.
They meet at a Christmas party, and their relationship blooms from there and is perfect until life disrupts everything. Edward is tortured from past events and is trying to save all those he loves. Nothing goes according to plan, and then the ghosts start to visit.
Can Edward make the changes in his life that will give him his heart's desire? Isabelle knows she can not fix Edward, but can she find her own happiness without him?
I loved the math banter, the chemistry, and the love that Edward and Isabelle share. Sometimes, opening our hearts to those we love and sharing the burdens of life is more important than protecting them from a life you can not control.
If you are looking for a Christmas love story that will have your heart melting with joy, then I encourage you to read Saving Scrooge.
Danielle Smyth
🎄🎄🎄🎄🎄/5
Saving Scrooge belongs on every Christmas TBR of readers who love a retelling of The Christmas Carol.
Edward and Isabelle have a wonderful Christmas story to share this holiday season.
They meet at a Christmas party, and their relationship blooms from there and is perfect until life disrupts everything. Edward is tortured from past events and is trying to save all those he loves. Nothing goes according to plan, and then the ghosts start to visit.
Can Edward make the changes in his life that will give him his heart's desire? Isabelle knows she can not fix Edward, but can she find her own happiness without him?
I loved the math banter, the chemistry, and the love that Edward and Isabelle share. Sometimes, opening our hearts to those we love and sharing the burdens of life is more important than protecting them from a life you can not control.
If you are looking for a Christmas love story that will have your heart melting with joy, then I encourage you to read Saving Scrooge.
November 13, 2026
I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it again… Danielle Smyth has the most beautiful way of writing a love story. The wording, the characters, the plot… EVERYTHING about her books will always make them a favorite of mine. 🥹❤️
I absolutely loved this story, especially the retelling of A Christmas Carol, with Edward taking on the role of our very own Ebenezer Scrooge. Watching him face his past, work through the things that have held him back, and ultimately learn to open his heart to love and realize that he’s worthy of it was just beautiful.
I loved how the story unfolded through the past, present, and future. It made for such a heartfelt, magical holiday romance. And the chemistry between Edward and Isabelle? Absolutely loved them together! 😍
Thank you so much, Danielle, for the opportunity to ARC read this one! And once again, I’m going to need a trophy shelf just for your books because THIS ONE is definitely going on my favorites list. 🏆
And can we talk about this cover?! Absolutely STUNNING. We all know Danielle never misses when it comes to covers! ❤️🎄
I absolutely loved this story, especially the retelling of A Christmas Carol, with Edward taking on the role of our very own Ebenezer Scrooge. Watching him face his past, work through the things that have held him back, and ultimately learn to open his heart to love and realize that he’s worthy of it was just beautiful.
I loved how the story unfolded through the past, present, and future. It made for such a heartfelt, magical holiday romance. And the chemistry between Edward and Isabelle? Absolutely loved them together! 😍
Thank you so much, Danielle, for the opportunity to ARC read this one! And once again, I’m going to need a trophy shelf just for your books because THIS ONE is definitely going on my favorites list. 🏆
And can we talk about this cover?! Absolutely STUNNING. We all know Danielle never misses when it comes to covers! ❤️🎄
November 9, 2026
"Loving you has brought me back to life"
Wow. I am completely blown away with Saving Scrooge. A Christmas Carol is one of my favorite Christmas stories ans Danielle did such an amazing job with this!
Told as a modern retelling of the Christmas Carol, it was full of heart, dual POV and ghosts of course!
Saving Scrooge follows Edward and Isabella as they navigate what it means to allow yourself to be loved while confronting past traumas.
Edward feels the need to fix and save everyone, while self sabatoging himself to feeling worthless and this definitely stems from past trauma.
Isabella has the biggest heart, is self less and and has this need to fix and help everyone. Through a serious of heart to hearts and apologies, she learns that giving second chances, shes opening her heart to forgiveness.
I highly recommend this read!
Note: alcoholism and childhood trauma is present off page but please know Danielle handled it with so much love and care.
Wow. I am completely blown away with Saving Scrooge. A Christmas Carol is one of my favorite Christmas stories ans Danielle did such an amazing job with this!
Told as a modern retelling of the Christmas Carol, it was full of heart, dual POV and ghosts of course!
Saving Scrooge follows Edward and Isabella as they navigate what it means to allow yourself to be loved while confronting past traumas.
Edward feels the need to fix and save everyone, while self sabatoging himself to feeling worthless and this definitely stems from past trauma.
Isabella has the biggest heart, is self less and and has this need to fix and help everyone. Through a serious of heart to hearts and apologies, she learns that giving second chances, shes opening her heart to forgiveness.
I highly recommend this read!
Note: alcoholism and childhood trauma is present off page but please know Danielle handled it with so much love and care.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I really enjoyed reading Saving Scrooge, the light holiday romance read is exactly what I needed after my reading funk and this one was definitely the one to pull me out of it. I just loved everything about the novel, I thought the way elements of The Christmas Carol was used was brilliant as it wasn't a direct copy and wasn't done in the way I was expecting. I really enjoyed how the storyline progressed and the way the characters were all fleshed out. I loved the realism of the events and the characters, though I think Isabelle was too nice to Evelyn after that admission. I loved how Edward was created, though frustrating at times - if only he had opened up! But I loved how that was realistic too and it really made for a great read. I loved how the storyline developed and we got to that ending - perfect!
This is a first read for me from this author and I absolutely loved her style of writing, the way she grabbed my interest and kept me reading until there were no more to read. I thoroughly enjoyed Saving Scrooge and I'll be on the look out for more novels by Danielle Smyth.
This is a first read for me from this author and I absolutely loved her style of writing, the way she grabbed my interest and kept me reading until there were no more to read. I thoroughly enjoyed Saving Scrooge and I'll be on the look out for more novels by Danielle Smyth.
November 9, 2026
Listen, the story of Scrooge is not one of my favorites if I’m honest. But if Danielle writes it, I’m GOING to read it. And… well, she has just made my brain do a 180 on this story and actually fall in love with this Christmas classic.
In a modern retelling of the Scrooge, we follow Edward and Isabelle through such an endearing love story full of trauma healing, miscommunication, and second chances. Miscommunication often feels so frustrating, especially in a dual POV book but she handled the writing so well that it was hard to not stand on the sidelines rooting for the main characters the whole way! I loved that she was able to take the ending of a story and give it the justice she wanted it to have in her own way. The perfect holiday read that doesn’t oversell you on Christmas but keeps looping you back into a cozy, holiday blanket until the very end. I want more already and I cannot wait to see what she comes up with next!
In a modern retelling of the Scrooge, we follow Edward and Isabelle through such an endearing love story full of trauma healing, miscommunication, and second chances. Miscommunication often feels so frustrating, especially in a dual POV book but she handled the writing so well that it was hard to not stand on the sidelines rooting for the main characters the whole way! I loved that she was able to take the ending of a story and give it the justice she wanted it to have in her own way. The perfect holiday read that doesn’t oversell you on Christmas but keeps looping you back into a cozy, holiday blanket until the very end. I want more already and I cannot wait to see what she comes up with next!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 49 reviews