1994. In a small town where secrets sink but never disappear, a body surfaces in the river.
She looks like Penelope.
The police are quick to draw conclusions. Penelope’s boyfriend, Lee—hot-tempered, troubled, and the son of an abusive man—has violence in his blood. He nearly killed a boy once before. Now, with a dead girl in the water, history seems to be repeating itself.
Detective Ryan Hale believes the evidence points in one direction. Monsters don’t come from nowhere. And Lee’s father was one.
But Lee’s mother, Kat, knows something the rest of the town doesn’t. Twenty years ago, another girl was pulled from the same river. A tragedy ruled an accident. Another truth buried. Kat was there then—and the past she’s fought to forget is clawing its way back to the surface.
As the investigation tightens around her son, Kat must decide how far she will go to protect him. Because the deeper Detective Hale digs, the closer he gets not to Lee’s guilt…
…but to Kat’s.
Told in dual timelines—shifting between a teenage summer romance and a present-day murder investigation—A Girl in the Water is a haunting psychological thriller about love, legacy, and the lies one tells to survive.
In this town, the wrong girl is always blamed.
And the truth has been waiting twenty years to rise.
Anne Brooks is an award-winning, bestselling author of psychological suspense and Southern fiction. Her debut novel, A Lost Woman, became an Amazon bestseller and received an Honorable Mention from the New York Book Festival. Her newest psychological thriller, A Girl in the Water, explores the secrets, suspicions, and long-buried truths of a small Southern town.
Named Best Author on the Coast in 2026, Anne is also the host of the award-winning podcast, Debut Writers and founder of Brooks StoryHouse. When she isn’t writing or working with other authors, she can usually be found somewhere along the Gulf Coast with her family—or plotting her next twist.
Anne Brooks's A Girl in the Water builds its suspense around a chilling premise: in a small town, a body is discovered in the river, and the dead girl looks like Penelope. What initially appears to be a straightforward murder investigation quickly becomes something much more complicated. As suspicion falls on Penelope's troubled boyfriend, Lee, the town begins to revisit the violence and family history that have shaped his reputation. But beneath the immediate investigation lies an older tragedy, one that has remained buried for twenty years and may hold the key to understanding what has happened.
The novel's strongest source of tension is the way it makes the past impossible to separate from the present. Lee is already viewed through the shadow of his abusive father and his own history of violence. Detective Ryan Hale sees a pattern that seems difficult to ignore, believing that the circumstances point toward Lee. Yet the story introduces an important complication through Kat, Lee's mother. Twenty years earlier, another girl was pulled from the same river, and her death was ruled an accident. Kat was present at the time, and she knows that the accepted version of events conceals something far more troubling.
Kat's position gives the investigation its emotional and moral complexity. Her desire to protect her son is understandable, particularly given the family history surrounding him, but the closer Hale gets to the truth, the more the investigation threatens to expose her own involvement in the past. This creates a compelling conflict between maternal loyalty and personal responsibility. The question is no longer simply whether Lee is guilty, but what Kat knows, what she has concealed, and how much she is willing to sacrifice to keep the truth from destroying her family.
The dual timeline is particularly effective for a story built around memory and buried secrets. By moving between a teenage summer romance and the present-day murder investigation, Brooks allows the earlier tragedy to gradually acquire new significance. The past is not merely background information; it is an active force shaping the choices and suspicions of the present. The river itself becomes a powerful recurring image, representing the town's attempt to conceal its history and the inevitable return of truths that were never properly confronted.
Another compelling aspect is the novel's examination of inherited violence and the way communities assign blame. Lee's father's abusive behaviour influences how others perceive his son, while Lee's own troubled history makes him an easy suspect. The story raises uncomfortable questions about whether people are judged for their own actions or condemned by the families and histories they come from. Its suggestion that the wrong girl is always blamed also points toward a wider examination of whose suffering is believed, whose stories are dismissed, and whose secrets are protected.
A Girl in the Water is a tense psychological thriller that combines a murder investigation with family secrets, complicated loyalties, and the lasting consequences of an unresolved tragedy. Anne Brooks gives the mystery an emotional foundation that extends beyond identifying a killer. The most unsettling question is what happens when the truth finally surfaces—and whether the people who have spent twenty years hiding it can survive its consequences.
A Girl in the Water by Anne Brooks is a small-town psychological thriller set in 1994, with a young woman’s body being discovered in the local river and suspicion immediately falling on Lee, her boyfriend. He has a history of violent behavior, a troubled past and an abusive father, whose reputation for violence precedes him. But does that make him guilty? Or just easy to blame? Kat, Lee’s mother, has some secrets of her own. Twenty years before her son’s girlfriend’s body is found in the river, another girl is found in the same river. Her death was ruled an accident, but Kat knows more than the town realizes. Honey, that’s a whole lot of history for one river to hold. In this story told in two time periods, the summer that Lee was a teenager and the present day in which Detective Ryan Hale investigates the murder of the girl found in the river, Kat must deal with her fear of her son’s guilt as well as the revelation of the secrets of the past that she has tried to keep hidden for so long. Here’s the question I’d bring to book club: When does protecting your family become protecting a lie? This is a great psychological thriller that deals with the past as well as the present. Put this on your reading list.
I had stumbled across Anne Brooks’ first book A lost woman and reached out and begged for the next book! She obliged and I tore through this book within two days. I stayed up way too late at night to read one more chapter and could not put it down!
All the suspense, twists and turns and emotions. Truly a great read. So well written and sucks you deep into the story!
I really enjoyed this thriller! It had me second guessing who to trust through out & had some great twists at the end. I liked the different points of view and the character development thought out. It had me on the edge of my seat the whole time. Highly recommend adding this to your TBR!