In sixteenth-century England, Ophelia Harrow has no use for God.
She’s Beswick’s apothecary, and she’s buried too many good people to believe there’s anything waiting beyond the grave. To Ophelia, death is no divine judgement. It is sickness and suffering, flesh failing as flesh always does. But when the village physician dies, leaving her the only one to tend the sick, Ophelia must go beyond the parish to seek a replacement.
She finds Doctor Iscairn standing among the mass graves of a neighbouring village.
Masked and unnerving, he refuses food, scarcely sleeps, and will not cross the threshold of her brother’s church. None of it should inspire much confidence, yet he understands sickness the way the pious understand sin. At first, that's enough for Ophelia to overlook the strangeness surrounding him. But the longer they work side by side, the harder it becomes to dismiss what she sees—and the more the earthly world she has always trusted begins to fracture.
Because Iscairn is no ordinary man.
For centuries, he’s walked through England, harvesting from the dying what disease cannot destroy. He does not interfere with death, and he has never allowed himself to truly care for the living.
Until Ophelia.
As fear and religious fervour tighten their grip on Beswick, so too does her attachment to the impossible creature at her side. And when the plague finally comes for her, Iscairn must confront something three hundred years of death have never prepared him for: the possibility of losing the woman he loves, and the terrible uncertainty of whether even he can save her.
Rachael Chadwick is a UK-based author with a fondness for the macabre and an insatiable curiosity for the peculiar. She has a habit of finding romance in the most unlikely places, filling her stories with unusual characters and happily-ever-afters that are all the sweeter for a little suffering along the way. When she's not dreaming up new worlds and putting her characters through emotional turmoil, she's usually wrangling her two sons or enthusiastically taking up another hobby she'll inevitably abandon. With a fascination for all things strange and unsettling, she firmly believes there's beauty to be found in the grotesque, and that even the most unlikely monsters deserve a love story of their own.
imma be real with you… she had me sold at plague doctor 👀
i’m absolutely convinced that there is absolutely nothing that rachael could write, that wouldn’t have me addicted.
ophelia and iscairn are the perfect duo. as always the characters are witty and entertaining whilst also having the serious elements and discussions which is what i absolutely LOVE about rachael’s writing.
everything flows beautifully and you can’t help but become entirely absorbed in the stories she writes. despite how dark, grim and puss filled it is.
absolutely recommend!!! tbh, you should just go ahead and add all her books to your tbr rn💅🏼
forever an auto-buy author for me. my absolute faveeeee🖤
Some books I go into expecting softness, humour, spice and everything nice. Some books I go into expecting trauma, devastation, and heartbreak . Even knowing the plague setting (and how incredibly emotional Rachael's other books have made me) I fully expected the former, but what I got was so much more.
As always with Rachael's writing, I was blown away by the incredible world building and just how viscerally I could imagine so much of this book - absolutely could have done without some of the buboe images and body horror but they were phenomal if a bit grim.
More than that though, I loved just how many British idioms and dialect words were sprinkled through. Reading words and phrases so familiar to me made this book so special (though I did need to look up a few that my upbringing in Cumbria didn't have)
Doctor Iscairn was full of dry humour, intensity, and a softness I did not expect from a plague doctor in a bone mask. I adored his quiet steadiness and how his history was revealed through the book.
Ophelia is unapologetic, funny, and carries a boundless empathy that made her so easy to root for. Even without the chronic pain representation, which made me feel seen, the grief and messy family dynamics she dealt with throughout were so raw and really spoke to my own experiences.
The back and forth between these two is some of the best I've read all year. They had a perfect slow burn that developed from friendship and a shared need to help others. Iscairn is unfailingly patient and steady through Ophelia's stubborn insistence to argue and disagree with him (even when she has to concede he's right).
The soul magic was fascinating and the throwback to How Not to Raise the Dead was exquisite.
I truly went through every emotion reading this book from howling with laughter to bawling my eyes out. I don't say this lightly when I say it is one of the best books I've read this year and I know this is a book that will stay with me and that I will reread again and again.
What a wonderful surprise this book was! I loved it from beginning to end.
One of my favourite things about Malady was how much more it offered beyond the romance. The historical setting, the plague, the medical treatments, the superstitions and religious beliefs of the time were fascinating. Even though the story takes some liberties with history, so many of those details were rooted in real practices, and I loved how naturally they were woven into the plot.
Ophelia was an absolute delight. Intelligent, stubborn, compassionate, sarcastic, and wonderfully independent. And Iscairn? What an amazing MMC! Mysterious and intimidating at first, but underneath all that darkness, genuinely kind, gentle, and respectful.
Their romance developed so naturally. No unnecessary jealousy, ridiculous misunderstandings, possessiveness, or manufactured relationship drama. Just two people gradually getting to know each other, building trust, sharing humour, and falling in love while dealing with everything happening around them.
And the banter! 🤣 I loved their conversations and how their personalities complemented each other.
What impressed me most was that I was so invested in the story itself that, for a large part of the book, I wasn’t even wondering when they would finally get together. I was too interested in everything else happening!
The historical elements, the supernatural mystery, the emotional moments, the humour, and the romance all worked beautifully together. And the ending was incredibly satisfying.
A beautifully written story with memorable characters and a romance that proves you don’t need a walking red flag to have a fascinating MMC.
Definitely one of my favourite reads of the year! 🖤
16th-century England, demons, apothecaries, plague doctors and a little religious darkness. Honestly, what’s not to love?
I really enjoyed this one. The setting and atmosphere were probably my favourite parts. There’s something about the historical backdrop, the darker elements and the tension running through the story that completely pulled me in.
I loved the demon x human dynamic, the slow burn and the build-up of tension. The northern dialect also added something lovely to the characters and setting, and I enjoyed the humour woven throughout.
There were a few parts of the story I wish had been explored a little more deeply. I felt there was room to delve further into certain aspects, and I would have loved a little more from them.
My only real personal gripe was some of the language used during the spice scene. One particular word just didn’t work for me and, honestly, I don’t think it was needed. It took me out of the moment slightly, but I appreciate that’s down to personal preference.
Overall, a really enjoyable read with a brilliant atmosphere, a setting I loved and the kind of slow-burn tension I always appreciate. 🖤
I've been in a terrible reading slump and this was exactly the cure. I honestly was not expecting much when I pre ordered as I have been burned too many times by books found on social media. This was such a breath of fresh air among the pile of sh!te that is preached about everywhere on booktok. I really enjoyed the writing style and there were so many beautiful lines that I genuinely wouldn't be able to pick a favourite.
This was a beautiful story, it had me feeling every emotion, fear, happy, sad, and even made me laugh, I loved the banter between the main characters and how deep their journey went. This has to be my favourite book written by Rachael as always she blew me away!
Wow what a journey! So happy I found a romance book without the cliché dialogues that give me secondhand embarrassment. It was genuinely nice to read about adults actually acting like adults. And when I say slowburn, this is exactly what I mean. This book was a pleasure to read (even with all the horrors surrounding the plague and sickness).
"A spineless, unremarkable speck of a man who contributes absolutely nothing of value to the earth he walks upon. And yet, it is men like him who break the bones of brilliant women and leave them to carry the limp."
I went into this expecting a spooky plague doctor romance with some monster spice, and while I definitely got that, I wasn't expecting just how bleak and emotional this book would be. It's properly gothic, set in a little English village being absolutely devastated by the plague, and somehow I ended up falling in love with a man who spends most of his time standing over dying people in a terrifying bone mask Ophelia was easily my favourite part of this book. She's an apothecary who knows full well that the remedies she's handing out aren't going to save everyone, but she keeps trying anyway. She's stubborn as hell, doesn't believe in God (which makes things particularly interesting considering her brother is a priest), and has absolutely no problem threatening a giant plague doctor with a fireplace poker. I loved her. She's got such a dry sense of humour, and despite this being set hundreds of years ago, I found her surprisingly relatable. I also really appreciated how her chronic pain was written. It's something she lives with every day, and the book never lets you forget how much it affects her without making it the only interesting thing about her And then there's Iscairn. Oh my GOD. I genuinely didn't know what to make of him at first. He's this enormous, unsettlingly polite plague doctor who refuses to take off his mask, and there's something so creepy about the way he behaves around dying people. But then you get these little moments where he's unexpectedly gentle with Ophelia, and then you're thinking, oh no, I think I fancy him. The whole mutton pasty thing killed me as well I think what I loved most was how naturally their relationship developed. Ophelia doesn't immediately decide that he's attractive. She's a little freaked out by him, and even when she starts to trust him, there's still that uncertainty about what he actually is. I loved watching that slowly change, especially because you get to see how much they come to understand one another before anything physical happens. And when it finally does happen? GOOD LORD. Worth every second of waiting I have to mention Gideon because I don't think I've wanted to reach into a book and throttle someone so bad in a while. He's Ophelia's brother, and the way his religious beliefs affect how he treats her was genuinely horrible to read at times. The fact that I was more frightened of him than Iscairn probably says everything you need to know. Some of the scenes towards the end had me STRESSED Definitely check the content warnings before going into this one because the author doesn't hold back with the plague stuff, and some of the religious trauma is pretty heavy too. But I genuinely loved this book so much more than I expected to, and I already miss these characters
What a beautiful story. 🥹 As beautiful as one can be when it’s dating back centuries and speaking of pestilence and buboes.
This isn’t usually a story I would typically gravitate to because I’m not good with history. Nor does it usually intrigue me. But because Racheal wrote it, I had to read it. And it did not disappoint. One bit. I honestly probably learned more reading this than I did in actual classes during my school years.
The world building and the depth that this story went into was done so well and so beautifully. It progressed easily and not once did I feel lost or confused. I was invested to say the least.
The characters I couldn’t help but love. Ophelia is unapologetically a sassy woman with the best wit and sarcasm one can have, but she’s caring and kind. I loved her from the start and I continued to enjoy her throughout. Iscairn, a mysterious man, but oh so sweet and his dry sense of humor was perfect for him.
The moment we met him, I was curious. But getting to know the man beyond the bone mask and learn truly of his life was heartbreaking and heartwarming. The connection between Ophelia and Iscairn was undoubtedly perfect. The way they spoke with each other, the way they listened to each other and the way they love each other is absolutely beyond beautiful. My heart was so full with their interactions and seeing their life develop through the years.
Beyond the romance and beyond the devastation of the plague, there was the aspect of paranormal. And it was brought in so wonderfully in fact that it FIT. I don’t know how else to describe it. It just made the story that much better and that much more enjoyable.
I loved every piece of this and I loved these characters. The ending had me practically sobbing because there was just so much warmth and love in it all.
Absolutely well done Rachael. You outdid yourself once again and we love you for it.
Please add this to your TBR. It’s definitely one to experience.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
First time reading a histrionic paranormal dark romance, and I can definitely say I’d read more of this genre!
Unfortunately, this book was heavily advertised as a dark romance, but in reality, it felt much more like historical fiction with a very subtle hint of dark romance. I think the marketing was a little misleading.
I really enjoyed the storyline surrounding the Black Plague, and honestly, if it wasn’t for that, I probably would have DNF’d the book. The romance was a VERY, VERY, VERY slow burn, and the spice was… meh. Having to wait until around 70% for anything spicy was a bit of a letdown. By the time I reached 80%, I found myself skimming just to get to the end. In my opinion, the book could have been much shorter without losing anything important.
The writing itself was good, and the author did a fantastic job of bringing the scenes to life. I could easily picture everything as I was reading. However, I have to say that this is definitely NOT a dark romance.
Overall, a little disappointing, especially given the expectations set by the marketing. That said, I loved learning more about the history of the Black Plague.
Highly recommend if you enjoy historical fiction with a little sprinkle of spice, but don’t go into this expecting a dark romance!
What a bloody beautiful book! The time period, the wording, the close to home locations (York, ect) i could throughly imagine everything as though I were there. I absolutely adored their little banter together and slow burn if beginning to get closer to one another. However I do wish there were more povs of him as I really loved the way he spoke about her and I do wish. I do also wish it was spoken about more when he killed/took that guy's soul (forgot his bame) as he basically slowly tortured him for her and it wasn't really spoken of what he did to him and why in more depth. Again moving on to her turning and them gaining a little more sexyal tension between them, I seriously loved his "May I?" Moment ughh that was good. And the ending was all wrapped up beautifuly, nearly cried when she found his long lost family for him 😭 she was searching for over a century 😢 How sweet. Highly recommended book for emotional beauty of the 16th century and banter with a demon. This wasn't my favourite book of hers but I still adored it. Not quite a 4* for me though as I wish there was a little more them time together and a little more smut/learning a bit more about his demoness.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Almost a five-star read - the world building was frankly brilliant, and I felt entirely immersed in this sixteenth century town with the devastating effects of plague, the medieval attempts to find remedies, the claustrophobic presence of religion as a cure, the narrow minds of the smallfolk... Even better was the use of dialogue, especially Ophelia's earthy banter and her wry interchanges with Iscairn. It's a very well researched book and it brings its setting starkly to life, with all the real-life concerns, mud and shit, blood and pus, that any reader could want to see.
Around two-thirds of the way in, something takes place that the book has clearly been building towards all along, and from there the narrative kind of grinds to a halt. The story has to go there, granted, but it's such a climactic moment that everything afterwards feels like an extended epilogue. Personally, I enjoyed it a lot more when Ophelia was a disabled, capable and bawdy apothecary, and Iscairn a mysterious, masked and shadowy presence by her side. I could have followed their odd couple escapades for page after page.
On the whole, I was certainly impressed enough to read more of Rachael's literature.
What a beautiful story! This one had me in tears and genuinely crying myself to sleep. 😭
I absolutely loved the concept, and the portrayal of the church was something I haven’t come across in a book before. Ophelia was everything I want in an FMC: resilient, intelligent, brave, funny, selfless and endlessly curious.
The exploration of grief, how we experience it and how we learn to live with it, was so beautifully done. And the relationship between Ophelia and Iscran? I loved it. Their connection felt so genuine, and it was such a beautiful relationship to read.
This is my second Rachel Chadwick book, and once again she did not disappoint! How have we gone from conjuring a demon in an attempt to bring your dead ex-boyfriend back to a beautifully written story about a woman making her mark in a male-dominated field? And can we just take a moment for our girl Ophelia? The best damn doctor you could ask for. ❤️
I cannot thank Rachael enough for writing what has become one of my top reads this year, and has even knocked Malachi down a place if we are being honest about it. I cannot explain how this story swept me up, I adored the small-town vibes, and even though cozy has no place in Beswick, I latched onto each and every character in a way that melted my heart by the epilogue. If you don’t mind a severed limb, and ailments aplenty, I highly recommend you dive straight into Malady and let me know when you’re out the other side… In sixteenth-century England, Ophelia Harrow has no use for God.
She’s Beswick’s apothecary, and she’s buried too many good people to believe there’s anything waiting beyond the grave. To Ophelia, death is no divine judgement. It is sickness and suffering, flesh failing as flesh always does. But when the village physician dies, leaving her the only one to tend the sick, Ophelia must go beyond the parish to seek a replacement.
She finds Doctor Iscairn standing among the mass graves of a neighbouring village.
Masked and unnerving, he refuses food, scarcely sleeps, and will not cross the threshold of her brother’s church. None of it should inspire much confidence, yet he understands sickness the way the pious understand sin. At first, that’s enough for Ophelia to overlook the strangeness surrounding him. But the longer they work side by side, the harder it becomes to dismiss what she sees—and the more the earthly world she has always trusted begins to fracture.
Because Iscairn is no ordinary man.
Iscairn, what a beautiful name to add to my collection, much like he collects teeth, I now have collected him and added this book to my shelf where it shall remain for a very good amount of time on this earthly plane.
This book is absolutely brilliant! One of the best dark romances I’ve ever read! The fascinating plot swept me into a time when religion held sway over medicine and logic, to the detriment of many souls, and Rachel’s gorgeous writing brought every moment to life. While the relationship isn't as “dark” as those in some other dark romances, the tragic story and religious themes made it completely gripping. I was swooning over the way the main MMC recognizes and respects our FMC’s autonomy and intelligence. And the banter between them? I loved it and laughed out loud! I devoured this book and couldn’t put it down!
She’s done it again! Who knew we needed a plague doctor in a mask, an apothecary obsessed with pasty’s and a hell of a lot of buboes? Because I never thought I did but how wrong I was.
This had me laughing, crying, feeling like I needed to grab a sick bucket all while being unable to put it down.
There was a hell of a lot of deep underlying messages here and honestly it hit on every level.
Though when you’ve read it if you don’t all go begging Rachael for a Malachi and Iscairn team up 👀👀👀
Absolutely outstanding as always. Infinity stars to the queen that is Rachael Crackwick as I have now renamed her to myself.
Is Horromance a thing? It is now. Rachael's writing is beautiful, haunting, horrific, hilarious and fiercely poignant.
There are parts of this book that had me laughing out loud, and parts which has me racing through the pages because of the sheer discomfort and harrowing sadness.
A powerfully character-driven story that glides through some of the most horrific things imaginable in ways I could never have imagined enjoying.
I absolutely adored this story! Rachael has such an amazing way of writing that completely immerses you in the story and you just feel swept away in the words she writes. Ophelia and Iscairn truly have a place in my heart, there were hilarious moments, stress inducing moments and moments where you truly didn’t know what was going to happen next. But I can honestly say that I am so happy with the way the book ended. I’ve loved every moment of the journey for Malady and as always the 🌶️ scenes just add to the experience! 🖤
The story of Ophelia Harrow and Doctor Iscairn had me sobbing before 9am while I finished it.
I didn’t know what to expect while reading this one. The relationship that grows over the decades between Doctor Iscairn and Ophelia Harrow is none other than captivating.
The horrors they see and treat are beautifully well written by Rachael. She delegated out on the effort and time to research the plague and many other aspects of medicine through history.
Truly surprised by the ending , highly unexpected though fantastic.
I've been waiting for this one for a well, well since Rachael mentioned it on her Instagram. I'm usually a very fast reader and could of probably finished this in one day but I wanted to savour it, I'm glad I did because it was such an amazing story. Hilarious and pretty heart breaking at the same time. Rachael is one of my favourite authors so I've already read everything she has realised so far.. patiently waiting for Folly now 🤣
That was a lot of pus Miss Chadwick and I loved it. I know I’m always going to go on an emotional roller coaster when I pick up a book by Chadwick and it’s just fantastic.
This was such an original and interesting concept, it broke the “dark romance” mold for me. The story is so genuine and tugs at your heart strings; the magical elements are compelling; the thrills and eeriness are perfect.
Yes, she's done it again! Another amazing book by Rachael. For me, Malady ticks all the boxes, a little spicy, set in rural northern England (represent 🙌), historical, a little bit supernatural and religious drama and of course the plague.
It is so well written and the story itself flows so well, there's no dips in pacing.
I love Rachael and will read absolutely everything she writes. I think my issue with this book was after reading all of her books, the characters are starting to feel a little bit interchangeable.
I love her writing and that’s not changed, I would just love to see how she can develop a world or move characters forward rather than just diving into their history
I don’t write reviews often and I have seen lots of ads for this book but I finished it in one day and I’m holy obsessed with it. It was so unpredictable and really held my attention. I loved the characters. I love the banter. I love the internal monologues.
This book was 10/10. Surprisingly tender and heart warming at points for a book based around the plague. I loved the British witty banter and I did not see the plot twist coming in the book.! Rachael is such a talented author. Also the spice was 👌🏻
This was a fun romance set during a period that the plague was making its way throughout Europe. At times I do think this could have been shortened. I'm happy Iscairn got some peace and closure, that was very sweet.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.