Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

When in Pine Falls #2

Frost and Found

Rate this book
Falling in love has never sounded better

In Pine Falls, no one believes in happily-ever-afters more than Lola Bennett. A lifelong reader, she owns a thriving bookstore devoted to romance. When she lands the chance to host an event with the wildly popular Kate’s Book Club, she jumps at it. Even once she learns that for the next four months, she’ll have to promote the event on social media with Tyler Cole, a romance skeptic who turns out to be the voice behind her favorite audiobooks.

Tyler wasn’t always cynical. After a devastating injury ended his professional rugby career fifteen years ago, he watched his future disappear. Now, newly sober and recovering from a painful divorce, he’s being dragged back into a world he never wanted to revisit: romance. The last thing he needs is to work alongside a woman who seems determined to find the silver lining in everything.

But as the weeks pass, their differences blur. Beneath Lola’s optimism and Tyler’s gruff exterior lie old wounds and guarded hearts. Promoting the event brings them closer, their reluctant partnership growing into undeniable chemistry.

The love story Lola always dreamed of—and Tyler stopped believing in—might just be within reach.

Return to Pine Falls with this cozy, wintery small town romance featuring an age gap relationship, tons of yearning, spice, and a happily-ever-after that’ll melt your heart.

440 pages, Kindle Edition

First published November 10, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Elodie Colliard

5 books371 followers
Elodie Colliard is a Canadian and French romance author. She currently lives in Montreal with her two very needy cats and her romance-worthy partner.

An avid reader (and dreamer) since childhood, she never gets tired of watching people fall in love. After all, she's a Cancer through and through, and emotions are her specialty.

When she’s not immersed in reading or working her other full-time job in politics, you can find Elodie crocheting, cuddling with her cats or behind her keyboard, creating the heartfelt, empowering love stories everyone can dream of.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
210 (41%)
4 stars
242 (47%)
3 stars
46 (9%)
2 stars
8 (1%)
1 star
1 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 361 reviews
Profile Image for rei ‧₊˚✩彡.
254 reviews820 followers
October 10, 2026
╰┈➤ 4 stars!

ELODIE, can you put me in pine falls, please? the more i read the books of this small-town, i fall for it more EVERY. SINGLE. TIME.

୨ৎ lola. she’s SO competitive, literally just like me omfg 😭 i love seeing a girl who takes her competitiveness seriously because, girl, SAME. i also really appreciated how much her relationship with her father revealed about her character. being fully aware of everything he had been through, she still tried her best to be present for him even though she needed him to be present for her, even if that meant putting her own needs and feelings last. it says a lot about how much she loves him and how willing she is to put other people before herself. i just hope she remembers that she deserves that same care and consideration, too.

AND SHE WON, Y’ALL. she got herself a man who literally does audiobooks for a living. SPICY BOOKS, FOR THAT MATTER. ;) IYKYK. 😏

also, I LOVE THE PCOS/PMOS REPRESENTATION!!! it’s always nice to see these experiences represented in romance books, especially when they’re something so many women deal with in their everyday lives.

୨ৎ tyler. okay, i was kinda pissed at him at first LOL, but in my defense, i didn’t know his past yet!!! so, yeah, i eventually understood him better as the story unfolded. 😭 i’m not even a huge fan of mustaches, but this man is the exception, btw. WHAT IS IT ABOUT HIM??? because suddenly, i’m reconsidering my preferences.

beyond that, the way he cared for other people genuinely moved me. you can see how much his past influenced the person he became, and it helped me understand why he acted the way he did. but what i appreciated most was that he didn’t just let his past define him. he made an effort to become better, and he actually followed through with it. growth!!! we love to see it. he earned my respect because he showed that even when your experiences shape you, you can still choose to do better.

moreover, i really loved how lola’s love for romance books was explored in this story! there are times when people make fun of me for mostly reading romance, and honestly, it really irks me when that happens. 😭 like, why are we making people feel bad for enjoying the books they love??? reading romance doesn’t make anyone less of a reader, and i appreciated how this book gave lola’s love for the genre a place in the story. sometimes, books are simply something that brings us joy, and that should be enough.

ALSO, I LOOOVE THEIR CHEMISTRY SO MUCH!!! 🤩 especially when they started getting more comfortable with each other. i love watching characters slowly let their guard down and become more open around someone they trust. those little moments when they start feeling safe enough to be themselves around each other just hit differently, and i really enjoyed seeing that develop between lola and tyler.

and, of course, the PCOS/PMOS representation. it’s not talked about enough how much these conditions can affect women and their day-to-day lives, both physically and emotionally. having that representation in a romance book matters because it helps bring attention to experiences that aren’t always discussed openly.

it’s also a reminder that we need to be more mindful of our bodies and appreciate everything they do for us, even when they’re not always working the way we want them to. living with these conditions can be really difficult, and it’s important to give ourselves grace instead of being so hard on ourselves. our bodies deserve care, patience, and understanding, too. 🥹

overall, this was such an enjoyable read for me! between lola’s love for romance, tyler’s growth, their chemistry, and the representation, there were so many things i appreciated about this book. it was also nice seeing characters who had their own struggles but still made an effort to understand others and become better. and honestly, any book that makes me kick my feet over the couple while also giving me something meaningful to think about is a win in my eyes.

・。・。・。・。・。・。・。・。・。・。・。・。・

pre-read:

can’t believe i got the e-arc for this one 🤭🩵 i’ve read book one of this series and LOVED it, so ig it’s safe to be excited for this one?! 🙈🌟
Profile Image for cat.
465 reviews264 followers
October 3, 2026
“You are the most unforgettable woman I have ever met, Lola. Even if I wanted to, I could never wipe you from my mind. It’s a privilege to know you, to be touched by your light.”


on repeat 𝄞 ࿐♬ 𓍢ִ🎧ྀི ᯓ ‎♪ˎˊ˗
“ᴡᴀʀᴍ” x ᴀʀɪᴀɴᴀ ɢʀᴀɴᴅᴇ
0:37 ──♥──────── 3:21


╭➤ the premise ────────────────────────────╮
A Christmas-season partnership between a sunshine-filled romance bookstore owner and a grumpy, newly sober former rugby player who has long since given up on love. Four months of working together, a whole lot of forced proximity, and two guarded hearts that might just have more in common than either is willing to admit.
────────────────────────────╯

I don’t know what it was about this book, but I had the GREATEST feeling going into it, and oh my goodness, it delivered. A romance-loving bookstore owner, a romance-skeptic audiobook narrator, and a forced partnership that neither of them particularly asked for? Already sold. Add Christmastime in a cozy little town (my favorite holiday, so obviously I was going to eat this up 🤭) and I was practically home hehe

i’ll be honest, I’ve been getting a little tired of the grumpy x sunshine trope lately. It feels like everyone is doing it, and sometimes the grumpy hero is just unnecessarily mean for the sake of being grumpy. BUT Tyler was different. His cynicism had actual roots in chronic pain, grief, and everything he’d been through. I could understand where he was coming from, and I never felt like his personality was being used as an excuse to make him unbearable. And Lola? This woman was such a light. As Tyler puts it,

“With every ray of optimism she radiates, she dispels my shadows and floods me with her light, reshaping my perception of a future I was convinced I didn’t deserve or wasn’t worthy of.”


And the way this man cared for Lola when she was experiencing her PCOS symptoms and flare-ups??? 😭😭😭🥹 I WAS GONEEEE. He listened, educated himself, showed up, and made it abundantly clear that she didn’t have to pretend she was okay or put on a brave face around him. I will forever be a sucker for a man who listens when a woman explains what she’s going through and makes her feel safe enough to be taken care of 🥹

Also, the HUMOR. I had so many laugh-out-loud moments. like the speed dating scene??? I literally gasped. 🤣 Tyler was so ridiculously down bad and jealous. I literally couldn’t stop laughing

Beyond the romance, I really appreciated how much depth Colliard gave this book. Tyler’s family was an absolute highlight, and seeing how comfortably he could fall apart around the people who loved him was genuinely beautiful. The exploration of unhealthy family boundaries, particularly the guilt and emotional responsibility that can come with loving a parent, was equally meaningful. It was a good reminder that loving someone doesn’t mean giving them unlimited access to you or sacrificing your own well-being to keep the peace

The alcoholism and sobriety storyline was another standout. Recovery isn’t simply deciding to stop drinking. It’s confronting the damage, rebuilding trust, taking accountability, and learning to live with a version of yourself you might not recognize anymore. I especially appreciated that Tyler wasn’t defined by his past mistakes. He acknowledged his shortcomings, including those in his marriage, and actively worked toward becoming a better person and partner 🙂‍↕️🙌🏼

One of my favorite takeaways was the reminder that we aren’t obligated to remain the person our hardest seasons made us believe we were. We can rediscover ourselves, find new purpose, and learn to love who we’re becoming, even when life looks nothing like we originally imagined.

This book made me laugh, swoon, and genuinely emotional. A cozy Christmas romance with a whole lot of heart underneath it. i absolutely loved it

favorite quotes ↓

“Whatever you’re going through right now, it’s only one part of you. You are more than the sum of your hard days. But even the strongest people need help sometimes.”

“That you knew of me before I knew you existed seems unfair.”

“She’s the air in my lungs and the blood roaring through my veins, the scent flooding my senses, and the wild beat of my heart.”

“With every ray of optimism she radiates, she dispels my shadows and floods me with her light, reshaping my perception of a future I was convinced I didn’t deserve or wasn’t worthy of.”

“A few weeks or even months don’t scare me when I’ve been waiting for you my whole life.”

“you found me when I least expected it, and you saved me. You took the broken pieces of me and believed they were still precious.”


things to know about the book ↓

❄️ grumpy x sunshine
❄️ age gap (28/38)
❄️ forced proximity
❄️ opposites attract
❄️ PMOS rep
❄️ slowburn
❄️ found family
❄️ dual POV

swearing: yes
spice rating: 🌶️🌶️🌶️
→ chapters: 12, 18, 20, 25

Thank you Love Notes, NetGalley, publisher & author for this arc in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

─────────
・❥・⁀➷ 𝕡𝕣𝕖-𝕣𝕖𝕒𝕕

...jk it reappeared???? well at least the comments did??? ignore me i'm going crazy

october 13th- not sure what happened to my pre read... 😭 this whole book disappeared from my goodreads 😒 anywayyyyy I LOVE THIS COVER SO MUCH🩵❄️
Profile Image for Fiza.
125 reviews500 followers
November 1, 2026
Them: why you so quiet? what's on your mind?

Me: the window scene


Profile Image for heart.
389 reviews151 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 1, 2026
A grumpy romance audiobook narrator who hates romance books AND a romance bookstore owner???

I’m so so so sold!!! 🤭🤭

“You are the most unforgettable woman I have ever met, Lola. Even if I wanted to, I could never wipe you from my mind. It’s a privilege to know you, to be touched by your light."

Lola, I absolutely adored her, the way she gives so much of herself without expecting anything in return, how she remembers the smallest details about the people she loves, and how despite everything she went through growing up, she still has so much love to give
Her anger towards men who look down on romance books was so valid to me, and the way it was written perfectly captured how I’ve always felt about the way people dismiss romance as a genre.
This book really showed the depth of romance books and why they mean so much to so many of us, and I’m so obsessed with that!!!

“I can’t give you up, Lola. It’s like asking me to stop breathing, or to let myself starve to death. The idea of being away from you destroys me."

And then we have Tyler, our grumpy narrator who wants absolutely nothing to do with love or romance, but somehow ends up falling for the biggest romantic ever 🤭
What I loved most about him was that underneath all that grumpiness was a man who had been through so much and was still struggling to see himself as someone deserving of love and happiness.
And Lola saw right through him, she saw the man behind all those scars and mistakes, and I loved how she didn’t let those things define him.
The way she made him want to become a better man, to work on himself and give love another chance after being so convinced he was done with it 🥹

I loved watching their relationship develop, especially how two people with such different views on romance ended up finding something so beautiful in each other. they felt so real and I loved that o much about the books as well.

And can we please talk about how stunning the cover is, It’s in my favorite color too!!! 💙💙



Thank you netgalley for the ARC

_______________
pre read
SCREAMING! I GOT APPROVED 💙

______________
Instagram
Facebook
Blog/Website
Profile Image for luna ♡.
187 reviews338 followers
Currently Reading
November 19, 2026
𑣲. pre-read

when i got approved of this arc, i haven't read the first book in the series. so i did. it was amazing, i'm ready to jump in to the second book (already 34% in) and so far loving it!

Thank you to Elodie and NetGalley for the e-arc!
Profile Image for S {Semi-Hiatus} .
1,320 reviews1,782 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
September 30, 2026
Approved and received an arc!!! 🥹

4.25 stars!

Ever since reading her debut novel, The Last Encore, Elodie Colliard has quickly become one of my favourite new romance authors and an absolute auto-read author for me. So, naturally, I was beyond excited to dive into another one of her books!

And here we are, back in the world of her When in Pine Falls series! I read the first book a little while ago, so getting to revisit some familiar faces and spend more time with characters I already knew and loved made me incredibly happy. There's just something so lovely about returning to a world you've previously enjoyed.

Now, let's talk about Lola, because this girl was the absolute cutest! I found myself rooting for her so much throughout the entire book. She's such a sweetheart who deserves nothing but happiness, sunshine, and all the good things in life. And Tyler? I absolutely adored him, especially the way he looked after Lola and showed up for her when she needed it. I also loved how he started calling her Angel. Because honestly, if anyone deserved that nickname, it was Lola.

Another amazing read from one of my favourite romance authors! The story is fast-paced, engaging, and has that special something that makes you want to keep turning the pages. Even though I was in a bit of a reading slump and it took me longer than usual to finish, once I really got into the story, I genuinely didn't want to put it down.

Honestly, Elodie's books are such bangers, and she keeps reminding me why she's become an auto-read author for me.

I'm so incredibly happy I got the opportunity to read an early copy of Frost and Found, and I can't wait for its official release in a couple of days so every romance girlie can get their hands on this delightful, holiday-themed read.

If you're looking for a sweet romance to get you into the holiday spirit, Lola and Tyler are waiting for you!

_________
Yay, finished it before midnight.
——————
I really thought that I already had written a pre-review for this book, but apparently not. :/

Anyways, I CANNOT WAIT to dive into this book!!!
Profile Image for sil ♡ the book voyagers.
1,444 reviews3,182 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 8, 2026
⸜(。˃ ᵕ ˂ )⸝♡ ONE OF THE BEST BOOKS I'VE READ THIS YEAR ⸜(。˃ ᵕ ˂ )⸝♡

Somehow my review was deleted or idk, but I'm writing it again and better because it's actually releasing in a month and Elodie has revealed a couple of things, so finally I can talk a bit more about this book lmao instead of being cryptic about it.

Frost and Found is literally the best thing ever. I loved Lola and Tyler so much, they're soooo my type of characters. Lola is lonely, a sunshine, and always looks out for everyone but herself. Of course she had to find someone who ALWAYS puts her first. And Tyler is that person. Tyler is a bit of a sad boi but also grumpy, and I loved how they started their relationship. It was PERFECT PERFECT PERFECT ♡ ︎
Profile Image for Letizia Lorini.
Author 6 books944 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 8, 2026
My favorite of hers yet 💖
Profile Image for Lina.
362 reviews111 followers
November 7, 2026
4 / 5 Stars
This book went down super easy and I had a good time reading it!

It took me a second to figure Tyler out which I think was by design. He vacillated from grumpy to thoughtful in a way that was a tad hard to track, but again, I think it was a way to show the personality he outwardly portrays versus who he really is inside. A little bit later, I settled into who Tyler really was and enjoyed him a lot.

I loved Lola and that this book was an ode to romance novels (very meta). She gave eldest daughter energy without being the eldest daughter but if you have ever felt like you’re taking care of everyone and wish there were more people taking care of you, Lola will speak to you. Tyler and Lola together really worked for me.

I have somehow read multiple books this year with emotionally immature and emotionally manipulative fictional parents and Lola’s dad is in the running for the worst one. Did I understand the purpose he served in the story? Yes. Was it pleasant to read? No.

This is the second book in an interconnected standalone series. I hadn’t read the first one but I could definitely follow everything that was going on. That being said, most of the couples in this book appeared in the author’s previous books and I think I would have loved it even more if I had read the previous books, so if you are interested in this one, maybe start with her other works first.

All in all, if you like a small town romance with a big found family and grumpy MMC and sunshine FMC who have nuance and some fun spice, you will like this book.

You will probably like this book if you like:
⭐ Small town romance
⭐ Age gap (38M / 28 F)
⭐ Forced proximity
⭐ Grumpy x sunshine
⭐ Slutty little mustache and gold chain (and shorts)
⭐ Found family
⭐ Hurt / comfort
⭐ PMOS rep and alcoholism rep

Thank you to the author and NetGalley for providing the eARC! All opinions are my own.
Publication Date: November 10, 2026

⋆ ೀ ⋆ Follow me on Instagram @book.recs.by.lina for book recommendations and general fun times ⋆ ೀ ⋆
Profile Image for Alieke .
477 reviews22 followers
November 9, 2026
This. This is 100% the giddy feeling I want from a romance book. Giggling, squealing, kicking my feet. I loved every page.

Read if you love:
Grumpy x sunshine
A very considerate swoon-worthy MMC
A relatable FMC
MCs with traumas (but who do the work to get through)
Found family
Small Town Winterwonderland vibes
Forced proximity
🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️

Honestly, it's the perfect book to start in this increasingly cold weather.
Profile Image for Lauren (lololovesthings).
1,139 reviews103 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 18, 2026
4 stars.

Elodie Colliard's "Frost and Found" is a great small-town grumpy x sunshine forced-proximity romance between Lola (FMC), who owns a romance bookstore, and Tyler (MMC), a former rugby player and romance audiobook narrator. The two of them met at a mutual friend's engagement party over a year ago, and while there was a clear spark between them, Tyler grumpily shut it down before anything could happen because he was in a bad place. Some time later, Lola has been given the opportunity to host an event for the massively popular Kate’s Book Club, which will surely put her bookstore on the map. Lola is going to have to promote the event on social media with a once very popular romance audiobook narrator named T.H. Foster, who disappeared from narrating but is set to make his comeback during this event. It turns out, T.H. Foster is *Tyler,* and he is the same massive curmudgeon he was back when they met, though he may have his reasons for being that way. The two of them reluctantly orbit around one another as they plan and prepare for the event, but there is no denying that the sparks that were there when they first met are still there. I liked the dynamic between Lola and Tyler. Lola is quite unsure of herself because she has spent her entire life pleasing everyone else so she won't be abandoned, so speaking up for herself, advocating for herself, and telling people what she wants are low on her to-do list. She has always wanted to be seen, be heard, and be loved for who she is, so when Tyler comes crashing back into her life and seemingly mocks, denigrates, and smirks at everything she loves, it puts her on edge and on the defensive. Eventually, she tells him to knock it off or kick rocks, and from that point on, their relationship really takes shape and turns into something sweet and tender. Their pairing felt natural to me, and even though I did want to kick Tyler in the beginning, he won me over in the end. I love how she called him out on his $H1T, given that he made his money from narrating romance audiobooks only to turn around and crap on it because of his own issues. Speaking of issues, I think Colliard balances all of the plot points well here, from both of their traumas, her health issues, his issues with romance/his sobriety/his ex, the romance book club and the promotion of the event, the friend shenanigans, her horrible dad, and Tyler's eventual venture back into rugby (sort of!). As with the first book in this series, I loved the found family aspect, and I liked how Lola's pals welcomed Tyler into the fold with open arms. What happened at the very end felt authentic to real life (don't want to spoil too much since it's at the veeeery end of the book and impacts the conclusion, but we all know how cesspool-y the internet can be, so what happens felt realistic to me). I absolutely haaaaaated Lola's dad. I wanted her to slap him so badly, but that's not the kind of character she is. It made me so mad that she constantly gave him the benefit of the doubt despite years of him abus1ng her! I know that it is not in her nature to be combative, but if anyone deserved it, it was her dad. ICK. Her dad and his horrendous treatment of her is why there are memes all over social media about eldest daughters having autoimmune disorders!! Anywaaaaaaaaaaays... I enjoyed this book. I think it is well-paced, if a touch long. It's got some good spice, a great commentary on women's health and how women are often not believed by doctors/$h1tty parents (usually men!!!), and an interesting plot about finding happiness again during sobriety. Can't wait for the next book in this series (please?!?).

Thank you to Elodie Colliard and Love Notes PR for the complimentary ARC of this book. All opinions are my own. I was not compensated for this review.
Profile Image for viv.
368 reviews419 followers
November 16, 2026
It was cute. Loved the pmos rep. Idk why it's not talked about more. Aannd it was a cute read. Would i reread it? Uhm no. But it was still memorable. I love how the author didnt villainise his ex wife. That's so not common in romance novels. It was so refreshing😌
br with ashlyn💗
Profile Image for Irene .
575 reviews129 followers
Read
November 10, 2026
someone @ me when they write a safety review, PLEASE BE SAFE and dont have a coward/asshole H
Profile Image for Elodie Colliard.
Author 5 books371 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 7, 2026
I might be biased, but Lola and Tyler are my favorites <3 Happy reading!
Profile Image for Anna.
324 reviews12 followers
November 5, 2026
This book was surprisingly layered. At times, it felt like watching a friend struggle through some of the worst years of their life and slowly find pieces of themselves again. It was cheesy, romantic, occasionally ridiculously hot, but also unexpectedly raw.

I enjoyed it while simultaneously having quite a few issues with it.

What I appreciated most was the attempt to give these characters genuinely complicated lives. Alcoholism, depression, unemployment, divorce, infertility, PCOS, endometriosis, people-pleasing, there's a LOT packed into this romance. And I mean a lot. At times, it felt almost too heavy for a book I had picked up expecting something cozy and comforting.

Still, I appreciate romance that acknowledges how messy life can get. People make mistakes. They hurt the people they love. Relationships fall apart, sometimes despite everyone trying their best. And I thought the portrayal of Tyler's failed marriage, his addiction, and the damage left behind was one of the more compelling aspects of the story.

Where things became complicated for me was Tyler himself.

I love a good redemption arc. I believe people can change, recover, take responsibility, and build better lives. But I also believe that kind of change takes time, consistent effort, and a willingness to confront your own patterns.

Tyler's background is painfully believable. A successful rugby player loses his career after a devastating injury, spirals into depression and alcoholism, and eventually destroys his marriage. That's human and tragic. And it's something that happens in real life.

But then we meet the new Tyler.

Suddenly, he's sober, endlessly thoughtful, emotionally intelligent, nurturing, understanding, self-reflective, and practically the embodiment of every #couplesgoals-wish list circulating on Instagram.

I struggled to buy it.

It's as though the author created the perfect romantic hero, realised he needed some flaws, and gave him a devastatingly realistic past. Except those two versions of Tyler never quite felt like the same person to me.

My issue isn't that he changed. People do change. It's how conveniently complete that transformation seemed to be.

And this ties into a trope I've never particularly liked: the idea that a man simply needs to meet the right woman to become the best version of himself.

Lola sees the real Tyler. She understands him. She loves the man behind the fame, the addiction, and the broken marriage. And apparently, she's the only person who ever truly has. This exact moment in the book was where I chucked it into a digital corner.

What about his ex-wife?

The woman who knew him before his success, lived through his downfall, endured years of alcoholism, and eventually had to walk away?

I don't think the book deliberately villainises her. In fact, I appreciated that Tyler had taken responsibility for some of the damage he caused. I loved that he owned his mistakes, kind of.

But the romantic framing still bothered me. His new relationship is repeatedly presented as proof of how much he's changed, while the woman who lived through his worst years becomes part of the background of his redemption.

I don't buy the idea that one woman simply wasn't special enough to bring out the good in him, while another somehow is.

People can absolutely inspire each other to grow. But lasting change has to come from within. Love isn't a rehabilitation programme, and women shouldn't be sold the fantasy that enduring enough suffering will eventually earn them a better man.

And then there's the speed-dating scene.

That scene made me so angry.

Tyler deliberately badmouths Lola to other men so they won't approach her. Without her knowledge... Without considering whether she actually wanted to meet someone. And despite the fact that she willingly agreed to attend the event.

That's not romantic jealousy. That's selfish, manipulative, and incredibly disrespectful.

What bothered me even more was that Lola never finds out. There's no meaningful confrontation, no accountability, and no opportunity for her to decide how she feels about it. His behaviour is essentially excused because he's falling in love.

For a character we're supposed to see as exceptionally caring and emotionally mature, that was a pretty glaring contradiction.

And it undermined the redemption arc the book had worked so hard to establish.

Now, despite all of that, I did enjoy the romance itself.

The chemistry was there, the pacing was decent, and I flew through the book. The hot yoga scene was fantastic. Easily one of my favourite moments. The steam generally worked for me, and I appreciated that the central characters had enough background and personality to feel fleshed out, even if the supporting cast remained rather forgettable.

But the progression of their physical relationship was oddly choppy.

They'd get incredibly worked up, openly acknowledge how desperately they wanted each other, and then suddenly we'd move on to some completely unrelated daily activity. Again and again.

It felt like the author was deliberately interrupting the intimacy to manufacture a slow burn.

Except that's not what slow burn means to me.

Slow burn is gradual, restrained, almost glacial. It's tension that builds because the characters aren't quite ready to cross that line. Here, they repeatedly seemed more than ready, only for the narrative to pull the brakes for no convincing reason.

And can we talk about how quickly Tyler started calling Lola angel? One moment they're getting to know each other, the next he's throwing around pet names like they've been married for five years. And Lola just goes with it. Apparently, we're all going with it!! Fine. 😂

The writing itself was another mixed bag.

There's a very contemporary, conversational quality to it, but at times it felt overly casual and unfiltered. The constant use of fuck, fucking, and every possible variation became repetitive. I don't mind profanity at all, but here it often felt like a substitute for more varied expression.

And the bookstore angle is old news. I love books and I love romance. I absolutely support defending the genre against literary snobbery.

But some of the speeches about romance novels sounded like Bookstagram posts copied directly into the dialogue.

I agreed with much of what was being said, yet the delivery felt preachy and unnatural. Characters stopped sounding like people having conversations and started sounding like they were delivering arguments to an audience. Me. I'm the audience.

I also have mixed feelings about the infertility and endometriosis representation. I appreciate the inclusion of these experiences, but I wasn't entirely convinced by their execution. With so many serious subjects competing for space, some didn't receive the depth I would have liked.

And that's ultimately my biggest contradiction with this book.

I appreciated its ambition to portray real, complicated lives, but I wasn't always convinced by the romance built around them.

There's genuine emotional weight here, and I liked that the characters weren't simply handed superficial misunderstandings to overcome. But there's also an abundance of familiar romance clichés: the gorgeous, younger bookstore owner, the impossibly attentive man, the grand declarations, the idea that she's the one who finally sees and saves him.

It was sweet and sexy. It was entertaining.

But also, at times, a little too much and too cringe.

I flew through it, enjoyed the chemistry, loved some of the steamy scenes, and appreciated the attempt to explore difficult subjects with emotional honesty.

But Tyler's transformation never fully convinced me, the romanticisation of red-flag behaviours rubbed me the wrong way, and the sheer concentration of heavy topics made this less of a cozy romance than I'd hoped for.

A book I enjoyed reading, even if I didn't entirely buy what it was selling.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Sim-fully Ever After.
1,046 reviews99 followers
November 11, 2026
4.5🌟 | 3🌶️

A little bookstore magic, a whole lot of grumpiness and a romance worth settling into.

I also adored how the story celebrated romance novels and the people who love them. Lola was such a sweetheart, always putting others first, and I was so happy to see her find someone who would do the same for her.

Tyler was such a lovely surprise. Beneath all that grumpiness was a man who struggled to believe he deserved happiness. Seeing Lola look beyond his past and bring out a side of him he had long buried was so rewarding. I adored how attentive he was with her, and their slow-burn romance had such wonderful chemistry!

Between the Pine Falls charm, the found family and all those little moments between them, I had such a good time with this one. There were definitely a few scenes that had me blushing, and I loved seeing two people with such different views on love find their own happily ever after.

A lovely addition to the series!

~~~~

A sincere thank you to Elodie Colliard, Victory Editing and NetGalley for the ARC! 🥰📚

I’m so grateful for the early read. As always, all thoughts and opinions are completely my own. ✨
Profile Image for Elena Belle.
61 reviews5 followers
November 7, 2026
Thank you to netgalley for the arc!

This is such a lovely book! It's my first of Elodie's and I will definitely be reading the first book in the series because I absolutely love pine falls as a setting. Lola is an amazing fmc and she is such a bright light through out the story. And she works at a romance book store? Literally the best job you could have. Tyler, our mc, is the perfect grumpy to Lola's sunshine. He has such a huge heart and I really admired how he was open about his struggles and embraced growth. The pair had the best love story! It was super slow burn and had such good tension and spice. The book also deals with some heavier topics but I really think they were handled with grace and care. Overall I really love Frost and Found and I'm excited to read more by this author! ❄️💙
Profile Image for Steamy Chapters.
127 reviews6 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 28, 2026
Thank you so much to NetGalley and Victory Editing NetGalley Co-op for the ARC! 🥹🫶🏻

First of all, I looooove this cover so much! 😍🩵
I also checked the author’s socials and saw the character art and I just adore it! 🥹

Lola and Tyler were amazing together, the chemistry was there! 🔥
The yoga class?? I was blushing! 🤭 And the slutty shorts 😂
And the window scene??? Excuse me?? It was so hot, iykyk ❤️‍🔥

I loved how Tyler paid attention to Lola and her health issues. He genuinely listened to her and tried to help. 🥹
And Lola was so kind and relatable!

Overall, it was so so cute and I really recommend it! 🩵
Profile Image for Gabi ୨୧.
177 reviews7 followers
November 15, 2026
AHH I LOVED BEING BACK IN PINE FALLS! It’s a place that I would move to in a heartbeat. 🩵 I loved seeing characters I already adore and meeting new ones who made me absolutely feral. 😮‍💨

I mean, a bookstore owner and her favourite romance narrator working together to bring a romance event to life?! I knew this one would require me to fan myself, and I wasn’t wrong! There were so many hot moments that had me sweating, and not just because one of them involved a hot yoga class. 👀

This book was so swoony! Tyler was a man down bad (MY FAVOURITE), and his feelings for Lola were so clear through all the acts of care (ANOTHER ONE OF MY FAVOURITES). And Lola! My favourite romance loving girlie! She truly deserves the world for everything she does for others, especially after spending so many years without the love and care she deserves.

Lola and Tyler were truly a healing presence for each other, soothing the parts of themselves that had been hurting or starving for a long time. I loved how caring Tyler was when it came to Lola, especially during her ovulation and period cramps (shout out to Elodie for PMOS representation and discussing the dismissal women face from healthcare providers, as well as from people around them). My girl deserves all the best, and all the love and care in the world!

I also loved how Lola truly saw who Tyler was beneath all the grief of losing the life he thought he would have and struggles he was facing. She gently encouraged him to work through them and become the best version of himself. I LOVE THEM BOTH SO MUCH!

I also really appreciated all the vulnerability shown by both main characters throughout this book. We got to peel back a layer after layer and discovered more of what made them who they were, especially when it came to Tyler. His depression, feelings following his divorce, and struggles with addiction made him an imperfect but incredibly realistic character. Following his healing journey as he worked towards finding happiness again and making amends along the way felt so rewarding and heartwarming. 🥺

Sooo, Elodie has done it again! She’s made me absolutely obsessed with another one of her books! I already can’t wait to be back in Pine Falls again. 🩵


Thank you so much Love Notes PR for this arc!
Profile Image for Kate Laycoax .
1,835 reviews30 followers
November 11, 2026
Oooooh, I LOVED the first book in this series (Hoax and Kisses was SO good) and I snatched this one right up when I saw it was available!

This was really, really good and I enjoyed it so much. I loved the PCOS/PMOS representation with Lola, and especially how understanding and kind Tyler was about it. I also really loved Tyler as a character. He was a former rugby player whose career was derailed by an injury, and he completely lost sight of who he was afterward. He spiraled into some really dangerous things, but was able to pull himself back up and out, even though he lost some things along the way. I really appreciated seeing an MMC who wasn't perfect and had made mistakes, but was actively working on himself and trying to be a better man. That felt so much more realistic to me than the perfectly flawless, sunshine and rainbows MMCs we usually get.

I also LOVED the audiobook narrator storyline! Tyler being the spicy audiobook narrator while Lola is a romance reader was so fun, especially when Lola realizes he's the guy behind the voice she's been listening to, hehehehe. It was perfect. I loved how they learned these little things about each other!

Their whole journey together was so good too. They had met a year before and then reconnect, and I loved how they slowly became exactly what the other person needed. They helped each other heal and find their way back to enjoying life again. I also loved them having to work together on the event because it pushed them closer and made them realize what they actually wanted.

And WOW was this book HOT in the spice department! Tyler was already a hottie based on that cover, but damn. That dual window scene was so OMG... SO freaking hot.

I really loved this book and I hope we get more from this series!
Profile Image for Eva.
898 reviews17 followers
Review of advance copy
October 19, 2026
I’m so sad it’s over, I want ten bonus epilogues!

I've never been happier that some character art showed up on my feed and led me to this book. Not only is the cover beyond beautiful, but the inside matches too. These two had the sweetest romance, and for a romance hater like Tyler, that was a wild thing to imagine when they first met. The amount of growth, change, and acceptance it took for them to fully give in made their love real and a thing to fight for.

Lola was a dream of an FMC. She was lonely, yes, but made the best of it; she surrounded herself with the best people, she was the friendliest and kindest to those around her, she fought to maintain friendships even in the busy days and never let anyone down. But she needed someone to be there for her, to push her to be fearless and imagine romance, not as a book, but as her life.

Tyler saw her, and even when time passed, he remembered her. His life hadn't been easy; he didn't believe in love like he once did, but he was fighting to regain a life he could be proud of. And what do you know, romance books and a romance convention threw him in the arms of that woman he saw once. He did fight it a bit, because he needed to like himself before he believed anyone could like him, but the slow burn paid off.

They were a LOVE STORY, capital letters, full stop. They learnt the other's love language; they admired the other's passions, and their chemistry was palpable. I for sure will need to read book one, because if it's anything like this, I know I'll love it too!

Thank you so much to Elodie, LoveNotes, and NetGalley for this arc!
Profile Image for ⟢₊ ᴀɴᴀ ₊⟢.
400 reviews7 followers
October 19, 2026
“𝙱𝚎𝚌𝚊𝚞𝚜𝚎 𝚢𝚘𝚞 𝚏𝚘𝚞𝚗𝚍 𝚖𝚎 𝚠𝚑𝚎𝚗 𝙸 𝚕𝚎𝚊𝚜𝚝 𝚎𝚡𝚙𝚎𝚌𝚝𝚎𝚍 𝚒𝚝, 𝚊𝚗𝚍 𝚢𝚘𝚞 𝚜𝚊𝚟𝚎𝚍 𝚖𝚎. 𝚈𝚘𝚞 𝚝𝚘𝚘𝚔 𝚝𝚑𝚎 𝚋𝚛𝚘𝚔𝚎𝚗 𝚙𝚒𝚎𝚌𝚎𝚜 𝚘𝚏 𝚖𝚎 𝚊𝚗𝚍 𝚋𝚎𝚕𝚒𝚎𝚟𝚎𝚍 𝚝𝚑𝚎𝚢 𝚠𝚎𝚛𝚎 𝚜𝚝𝚒𝚕𝚕 𝚙𝚛𝚎𝚌𝚒𝚘𝚞𝚜.”

I went into this book for the CUTE cover, but stayed for the sweet romance between a bookstore owner FMC and a grumpy audiobook narrator MMC 💙

As a romance lover this book felt like such a warm hug!! The FMC, Lola, also has a passion for romance books and was living my dream life owning her own romance focused bookstore. She was such a relatable & lovable character. I adored her sunshine personality + the fact she wants to take care of everyone but had no one to take care of her 🥺

At first I didn’t click with Tyler, but over the course of the book I found myself loving him too!! He was so protective of Lola and the way he took care of her was so sweet. You could tell he adored her sm, plus the yearning was sooo good.

And the yoga class…. 🤭

Read if you like / Tropes:
📚 Grumpy x sunshine
📚 Age gap (10 yrs)
📚 Small town
📚 Yearning

Thank you to NetGalley, and the publisher/author, for the E-ARC 💙
Profile Image for naomi ☾.
164 reviews12 followers
November 17, 2026
Wow! I loved this. This was my first Elodie Colliard book, but it won't be my last! Tyler and Lola were so incredibly sweet and hot and perfect for each other. If there's anything I love, it's two people who are broken and find solace in one another. All of the hurt/comfort elements were so healing for me. Their jobs were so interesting and fun, too. I loved the whole setup and it felt super unique to me in that way. Excellent pacing, mental health and chronic illness rep, the most down bad man, a whole love letter to the romance genre, and excellent tension. Can we talk about that yoga scene? The window scene? Hot damn. Definitely recommend if you're looking for something to warm you up this holiday season!
Profile Image for Dahlia .
505 reviews546 followers
Currently Reading
November 19, 2026
──★ ˙Pre-Read !!
ITS TIMEEEEE, omg I cant wait to read this , it literally has the best tropes ever so far please please please be good
Because hello a grumpy romance narrator x a romance bookstore girly + an age gap ? Cant dream of anything better 😭🤭🤭
Profile Image for ✨️ Courtney ✨️ (courtneyreads_x).
771 reviews20 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 22, 2026
Thank you Love Notes PR and the QUEEN THAT IS ELODIE COLLIARD! This was the first festive read of the year and my fave read of October! I think this might be the ulitmate fave.

ISTG, I love a man with a mustache! Thank you to the artists for creating masterpieces for Tyler! GIRLIES, be SO ready to fall in love with Tyler Cole. DARE I SAY, one of the best MMCs I've read this year! A reeeeal yearner, attentive, possessive & sensitive. Oh... And have I mentioned he's older, has a moustache and amazing RUGBY PLAYER thighs? What else could a girl ask for?! Plus, I cannot express how proud I am of this fictional character! Alcoholism is a topic treated in many books, but the way it was introduced in this story was BEAUTIFUL. He and his story made me tear up a few times, but I'd gladly cry for this man.

Lola was such a fantastic FMC; she adores romance, is stubborn and tough as nails even if her sweet exterior doesn't show it, because she's had to be to survive her rocky childhood and relationship with her dad. I loved that she created herself a chosen family with her friends, and I loved seeing all their cameos as they are characters from Elodie's previous books. I was partially scared to read this, as I have been despising FMCs who are readers/ wannabe authors- I dn't know why but I have just been struggling to enjoy the characters, but no. I loved Lola. She is the exception to my current mindset. She went abve and beyond; she showed me what a true business woman is like.

Lola x Tyler ARE a LOVE STORY, capital letters, full stop. They learnt the other's love language; they admired the other's passions, and their chemistry was palpable. I for sure will need to read book one, because if it's anything like this, I know I'll love it too!

Read if you love:
Grumpy x sunshine
A very considerate swoon-worthy MMC
A relatable FMC
MCs with traumas (but who do the work to get through)
Found family
Small Town Winterwonderland vibes
Forced proximity
Profile Image for Antheia.
163 reviews7 followers
October 8, 2026
[ARC Reciew]

Okay okay okay, GIRLS. OKAY.

We meet Lola, the owner of a romance bookstore who’s been tasked with organizing one of the biggest bookish events. The event will feature a smut narrator that literally no one knows the identity of. Except she already knows him and just didn’t realize it.

I absolutely adored Lola. She’s such a beautiful character who’s been through a lot and is terrified of being abandoned. I connected with her so much and really loved the way she is, the way she treats people, and the way she sees others. It’s honestly so beautiful.

Tyler (yum) completely won me over. He hasn’t had it easy, and I love how he’s trying to become the best version of himself, both for himself and for the people around him. He is incredibly sweet.

The town is really nice. Characters from the author’s other books make appearances, and they’re so fun and so cute.

The pacing is SO good, and it has the perfect combination of all our favorite tropes, like “hotel in the middle of nowhere + only one bed” and grumpy x sunshine.

Without a doubt, one of the scenes that made me scream the most was the yoga scene (if you read it, you’ll know exactly what I mean).

If you love second chance romances filled with romantic moments and grand gestures, this is 100% the book for you.

I’m going to be recommending this author nonstop because, seriously, she’s incredible.
Profile Image for kaila | kd.reads.
382 reviews
October 4, 2026
it was so great to be back in pine falls!! i love this little world elodie created and im giddy for any chance to go back!

just like zoey, lola also has a pos parent! it runs in the town i guess because i also wanted to hit him up side the head! why can’t parents just love their kids and why do they have to traumatize them!

tyler and lola fit together like the perfect puzzle piece. she’s so sweet and has that wild side to her but only when tyler brings it out of her. and he’s SO protective of her. i love tyler’s relationship with his mom and sisters! the found family in pine falls is so sweet and everyone is just so tight knit! always supporting one another and i love the cameos!

i can’t wait for the next book!

————————
thank you to love notes pr and the author for sending me an eARC in exchange for my honest review. all thoughts are my own.
Profile Image for Lauren⚡️.
510 reviews18 followers
October 17, 2026
I picked this up because the character art was so beautiful but then I could not put it down!! Tyler and Lola were everything. Both flawed, but both on a journey to loving themselves after such difficult pasts. They were genuinely so sweet it made me giddy.

Please pick up this book this winter, it’s so cozy and emotional and lovely! Comes out on 11.10.2026 on KU and paperback!!!

Thank you to Netgalley and Elodie Colliard for the eARC 🩵
Displaying 1 - 30 of 361 reviews