First a disclaimer, the author provided me with a free copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. Also, there are some spoilers contained in this review.
OK, so first let me say that I really liked the plot of this novel. It's very different from anything that I have read so I really appreciated that. It kept me interested the whole time and I really felt like i could relate to the main character, Kay. Even though she was put into some crazy situations, I still feel that the actions she took were similar to what I would have done if I were in that same situation. I really liked the diversity and culture present in this book. It's not a cookie cutter story, some major themes are similar to other YA novels, but the environment and characters give it a whole new twist. Also, the ending really got me! I was outraged, then hopeful, then excited, and then sad because the book ended.
You may be wondering why I only gave this 3 stars when my review so far has been glowing. Well there were some issues with this novel as well.
1. The constant flashbacks and dreams are really confusing and throw the story off a bit. It was hard at times to remember if I was in the past or the present or a dream. Would have been really nice if those sections were perhaps written in italics, or a different font, just something that lets the reader know that they aren't currently reading about the present.
2. Some of the dialog seemed really unnatural or fake. For example, Kay is a university student and it really concerned with her class rank (i.e. freshman, sophomore, junior, or senior) and the university even holds a party only for students that are juniors. I don't know how her school is but this seems really strange. Yes, class rank is given a lot of importance in high school, but definitely not in college, at least not to the degree in this novel. Also, with some of the dialog, when characters are talking to each other, they constantly say each other's names. This seemed really strange to me. When we are talking to someone, we don't say their name every time we talk. Once you are engaged in conversation, it's pretty clear who you are talking to. On a kind of related note, some explanations and descriptions throughout the book were just too wordy. It really felt like a lot of things could be taken out the book as they are not needed. This would harm the story itself in no way and would actually make the flow of it improved.
3. Finally, and a big one for me, there were quite a few inconsistencies in the story. This (along with the previously stated issues) really made it feel like this book didn't have an editor. For example, on page 180 Kay's says that her mother never told her where the butterfly blanket came from, only that she received it on a trip. However, on page 75, when Kay's mom recounts the story of receiving Kay, she mentions that Kay was wrapped in the butterfly blanket when she took her from her birth mother. As another example, on page 79 Kay says that she picked up her coat and stormed out of the house. However, just one paragraph later, she says that she is cold because she left her coat at the dance the night before and never brought it with her. There are a few other inconsistencies like these that I noticed while reading as well. As a reader, this types of mistakes really irk me and take me out of the story because I have to stop and go back and check what the author wrote previously to make sure I'm not remembering it wrong. Real buzz kill.
So, overall, I did enjoy this book. My issues with it were fairly minor and could be fixed with a good editor. The story itself was extremely interesting and I enjoyed it immensely. I really hope the author comes through with a sequel (and hopefully a better editor) as I would love to read it!