Considering that Bodkin published in 1934, it is very impressive that you can still use it in many ways. I had to read this book because I plan to use it for my thesis and I admit that it is a difficult read, especially for a Master's student. Yet, I learned a lot of things and I am sure I'll quote many things from Bodkin as it is a good point of start in archetypal literary criticism. However, there were parts when Bodkin went on and on and I often felt lost as not all of the book will be useful to me. After many days, I am glad I am done with reading but I'll still come back and check certain things. Overall, it is a good source for people who study archetypes and even more useful if you are also interested in poetry.
I’m not so surprised to find this to be a book filled with outdated and sexist theories of psychoanalysts such as Freud (since Jung himself was a contemporary psychoanalyst) although I am still somewhat disappointed to see how whenever Jung is mentioned the author immediately tried to connect that to Freud as if to fact-check Jung.
My biggest disappointment was the author’s continuous commentary on how all the archetypes mentioned here are specific to Europe, how only her fellow Europeans may understand her, even when looking into epics that did not necessarily come from Europe. The author refers to poets who are not European simply by their nations unlike the European counterparts who are always referred to using their names.
Finally, my personal disappointments aside, I want to WARN anyone interested in this book to keep in mind that this book is a collection of VERY personal and subjective responses to a wide variety of poems. Archetypes are mentioned in every 50 pages briefly but most of the book is how the author felt or dreamt after she read a certain poem. Oh, and if you haven’t felt the same, no worries, it’s probably because you are not a European.
Maud Bodkin's "Archetypal Patterns in Poetry" is a classic, ground-breaking exploration of exemplary arrays of psychological meaning in poetry from the European tradition from a Jungian perspective. Written in prose as deep as it is erudite, this study draws upon the works, as have been mentioned, of the analytical school of psychology. In fact, Ms. Bodkin analyzes most of the major works of Western literature, including Dante's "Divine Comedy," Goethe's "Faust," D.H. Lawrence's "The Plumed Serpent," and a wide variety of other works. And all of these works are dissected under the lens of the great Swiss psychoanalyst who is the founder of that school. However, this book is not for the faint of heart, for it suborns the dictates of traditional literary analysis to a deconstruction by which primal, elemental elements are brought to the forefront. Additionally, the prose is equal to its subject matter, with a level of complexity that is, at times, difficult to process, yet is necessary to explain the difficult material at hand. So, for a classic analytical study of great poetry from a specific psychological perspective, this is your book.