Out of all the Maine Clambake Mysteries I've read so far, this one had the best mystery. Though it's been done before, the concept of a group of seemingly unrelated people being brought together for a nefarious purpose always intrigues me.
Julia Snowden, the protagonist, wasn't perfect in this one, either. She got some things wrong and the cops actually knew more than she did, which made it more realistic than your typical cozy, where the cops all seem to be bumbling idiots.
The one thing I didn't care for in this book was the meanness. So far, Ross's series has neatly sidestepped the cattiness that tends to creep into cozies, but in this one there is quite a bit of nasty critique of people's hair, weight, age, and general appearance. Sometimes it's in Julia's thoughts, but other times it was outwardly expressed. For example, everyone makes fun of a woman on the island who's had plastic surgery, even going so far as to pull the skin on their faces back when they talk about her. When Julia discovers the real reason for the woman's surgery, which is quite tragic, she never once feels badly about making fun of her--or if she does, it's not expressed in the novel. Another person is repeatedly thought of as 'Bozo' by Julia because of his hairstyle.
I know small towns (and women) can be like this, so it's realistic, but it would have been nice to skip it. It wasn't necessary, and it made Julia seem small-minded and cruel. Otherwise, it's an awesome book, and I highly recommend it.