Monroe Lockhart left Cypress Falls, Texas at eighteen and thought she’d never look back. But that plan was easier said than done with a brother in prison and his five-year-old daughter, Maisie, being raised by Monroe’s mom.
When Monroe’s mom passes away suddenly, Monroe finds herself back in a town where she never really fit in, raising a niece she doesn’t even know. And if there’s one thing that Monroe’s certain about, it’s that she has no business being a parent, even if her new next door neighbor and former high school crush, Blake Bettencourt, disagrees.
Blake is also reeling from being thrust into a life she never expected to lead. Her ex-husband cheated, got his mistress pregnant, and suddenly, Blake’s standing on the outside of a life that used to be hers.
Monroe’s not in a position to turn down help, even from someone she never expected to call a friend. But Blake keeps showing up for her, breaking down the protective walls that Monroe’s spent a lifetime building.
The lives that they’ve both been thrown into are all wrong, but they may find out that’s exactly what makes everything between them so right.
💕 Return to small (Texas) town 💕 Unexpectedly raising a niece 💕 Lesbian-awakening 💕 Lesbian x lesbian MCs 💕 A cute old pickup truck 💕 Life after divorce 💕 Found family 💕 Healing after loss
There are two things that I’ve loved about all three books by this author that I’ve read.
1) I’ve adored the main characters, including the leading ladies in The Pining Paradox and The Love Lie, but even more so with the FMCs in this book, Monroe and Blake. You can’t help but root for them, right from the start. Character development is chef’s kiss.
2) There is no 3AB*. Even better, McCallan sets up a ‘us against the world,’ situation, which again, you can’t help but root for Monroe and Blake. At various points, one of them is the champion defending the other.
The other thing I loved, seeing as I’ve had my own, is a late-in-life queer awakening. Again, how the author writes this needs to be spot on, and it was. The only negative I’d point out is McCallan tried to let the sex carry the plot too much which never works for me. But, just a half star off for that. Everything else was delightful. If sapphic is your genre of choice, give this book a shot.
I think I just found my new #1 Monica McCallan book. I seriously stayed up until 1am the night I started it because I couldn’t put it down.
It’s not for the faint of heart though, and you really get to see the reality of Monroe’s situation with losing her mom and having to take care of a niece she barely knows. I felt for her, and she truly put on a brave face that not many would be able to.
Reading through the other reviews, I’m actually shocked not everyone feels the way I do. For me, I actually appreciated the inner monologue that was added because it gave more detail and made me understand everything on a deeper level, even if it did make the story a bit longer.
The found family Monroe got was so heartwarming, and I loved this take on friends to lovers. Usually it tends to be “childhood friends turned into lovers” but instead we got to see Blake and Monroe’s relationship start as just friends and slowly blossom into something more. Plus, the sex scenes? Now that was some quality writing on Monica’s part.
Blake was just an honest-to-God special character. I probably could blabber about her for hours, but she really made this story what it is.
I say it every time, but I LOVE when there’s not a third act break-up. I find them so tacky, usually only added in for extra drama. Their relationship was so beautiful to read about, it felt so pure and honest and raw (even though there was a moment I wanted to smack Monroe upside the head).
I have been in what feels like the biggest book slump in a long time, and this one cured me.
for the reader who wants a cosy read that does not skimp on the emotional support
also there's a generous amount of spice I know that's what some of you maniacs are here for
neither Monroe nor Blake are living the life they expected to live in their small town, but they end up being neighbours so it's not all bad. my favourite thing about the author's books is the advanced, comprehensive emotional support. like yes we're going to have fake marriage shenanigans or the leads running an inn together, but that's not going to stop two women from being present, attentive, and compassionate. the book takes great pains to set up that Monroe and Blake are having really an awful time in their small town and are in a very complicated emotional place. and then we get hundreds of pages of them untangling each other's traumas and talking through miscommunications with empathy and care
also, I love a romance novel that does the small town but really dives into the good and the bad of it. Blake in particular is getting the rough end after finding herself divorced from the figurative horse of a one horse town, but the book also highlights the community that she's able to find along with Monroe
also also, I really enjoyed the pacing of the book. I will always love a romance novel that takes its time, and The Right Kind of Wrong very much lets you sit in every phase of the story and Monroe and Blake's relationship
also also also, like The Pining Paradox there's a character who feels neurospicy. it's never said whether Monroe is one way or another and it's not a big Thing, but if she is meant to be neurospicy as Brynn felt neurospicy I thought it was very well done. understated and never the core focus, but the hallmarks are there. neurodivergence as character seasoning rather than neurodivergence as drama
unless this is completely off the mark in which case she's still an excellent character
a cosy, comfortable, emotionally complex read that continues the hot streak the author's been on
Took me a bit to warm up to the story, probably a 20%, then it went faster. This is a cosy and sweet novel, with I think the most spice I have ever found in Monica McCallan's books.
I would have liked a bit more of angst and a deeper insight in the "art" theme, but I am sure readers who love low angsts books will enjoy it very much.
I am although very curious whether there will be a book about Holland...
I just finished this book and I can’t say enough. I am a huge fan of Monica McCallan, I have read all of her works and this one might be my favorite of hers, I loved these characters and it was a little racier than usual I think.👏👏👏
How had it happened so quickly, Monroe wondered, that Blake was some sort of balm that quieted all of her racing, anxious thoughts?
This was a must read for me, especially since Monica's The Pining Paradox is what got me into sapphic romance. I have been hooked on her work ever since.
It took me a bit of time to really get into the story, but wow am I glad I pushed through!
Monroe returns to Cypress Falls to raise her niece and finds out that Blake Bettencourt (her former high school crush) lives next door to her. Both women are going through difficult times in their life – Monroe dealing with loss of her mom and now having 5-year-old Maise to raise, and Blake having been through a tough divorce. They both find comfort and support in one another. They are cute and hot together and have amazing chemistry. It was so nice to see both of them become just what one another needed. I also absolutely LOVED Denny. One of my favourite side characters in McCallan's books.
I give this a 4 on the spice level. The quantity of spicy scenes and the detail – amazing!
Overall, an amazing release, which I enjoyed a lot!
Tropes: slow-burn, close proximity, found family, small-town romance, lesbian-awakening, life after divorce, life after loss, no third-act breakup
DNF I really wanted to like this, The characters are cool, really liked the set up and where the plot seemed to be going. I wanted to see their story so much but actually reading it didn't hold up. There was way too much introspection, It dragged and dragged on. My biggest issue is that all the exciting moments/points where the characters could connect were just skipped and you only get to hear their thoughts afterwards. It was really disappointing. I would get excited for something that was about to happen and then the author just skipped over it.
I enjoyed this book, but I never quite got swept up in the story as much as I would have liked. The pacing felt a little slow, mainly because Monroe and Blake spend so much time in their own heads. Their endless thought spirals sometimes went on for so long that I lost track of where the story was going.
That said, I still really liked both Monroe and Blake. They’re enjoyable characters, and there are some great supporting characters too, particularly Maisie and Denny. The storyline involving Maisie was especially lovely. On the other hand, some of Blake’s old friends and her sister were considerably less charming.
However, the writing occasionally became repetitive, both in the characters’ thoughts and in the use of certain expressions. Some phrases, including “straight to her clit” and “quid pro quo,” seemed to pop up often enough for me to notice.
There were also a few moments when I questioned the characters’ thought processes, particularly the timing of certain sexual thoughts involving an ex during an intimate moment with a new partner. Perhaps that was meant to add complexity, but it pulled me out of the moment a little. There were still enough sexy moments though.
Overall, The Right Kind of Wrong was a good read with likable characters, some lovely emotional moments, plenty of sexual tension, and a satisfying happy ending. I just wish it had been a little tighter and less repetitive. It took a bit too long to get where it was going, and while I enjoyed the journey, it never quite reached great for me.
The last 1/3 of this book saved it for me. I’ll start with the WTH…so much internal monologues. There’d be one sentence of the MCs talking and then paragraphs of internal monologue. Back story, current feelings, regrets, future hopes and dreams and then the other character would say “good morning.” I appreciate that Monica McCallan is willing to try different techniques in her writing. My favorite book of hers is Then & Now which is super different from the standard contemporary lesbian romances that I continually devour.
It is a slooooow burn for about 70% of the book. Again, so much inner monologue. Once the romance kicks in it’s great. The internal thoughts start to go away and characters really start to communicate. Speaking of communicating, can I please talk to Ms. Blake Betancourt? Cause she is a great character. Just so damn cool. Going through huge life changes and just taking it on the chin like an effing champ. If only the rest of us could be as confident as she is when facing challenges.
I love the chosen family Blake and Monroe develop around themselves and how they all support the girls. Monroe hasn’t had an easy life and I really enjoyed that there was very little outside drama for her. Monica could have done Monroe dirty and created all kinds of external conflicts for her, but luckily the journey focused on Monroe opening herself up and trusting Blake. The smut shows up strong in the last third of the book and it’s just delightful.
Monica McCallan is a go-to author for any reader looking to be immersed in a somewhat messy and extremely believable story of love and the unpredictable paths life can take. Monroe and Blake are characters who grew up in the same town, but a world apart. Monroe was quiet and artsy, she got out and became successful in the ways she dreamed, but she still wasn’t happy. Blake stayed, married her high school boyfriend with the big name and lots of money, and lived the debutante dream until it all came crashing down; only for her to realize she had never been truly happy either. The two reconnect at a time when neither has much to give, but somehow they find everything needed to be there for each other. It’s a romance book, so the reader will know how it ends, but the story of the good and the bad of small town living, and the process of slowly building a found family while falling in love will keep you hooked (never mind the many fantastic spicy scenes). This is the kind of story that generates conversations about society, from the high brow art scene to the southern pageant circuit, there is somewhere on the spectrum for everyone to carve out their own piece of happiness when they stop letting the judgements of others get in the way.
I’m a big fan of Monica McCallan but unfortunately this one fell a bit flat for me. There’s no comparison to The Pining Paradox or The Love Lie. Those two reign supreme. The characters, Monroe and Blake, were loveable but the story just seemed to drag on. I would have loved more drama with Noah or Sylvia.
Each new book Monica McCallan writes becomes her best! This review doesn't need to be filled with every positive adjective to entice someone to pick it ip...Simply just READ IT... you won't be disappointed!!!
I didn't connect with the characters. One is a trophy wife who got a bad deal, and the other a painter who slept with a sugar mommy to access the art world. Both chose a dependent relationship with a toxic partner in exchange for social status, even though they could have pursued agency thanks to their college education. The book presented them as victims of the system rather than of their own choices, which made it difficult for me to sympathize with them (and I am not dismissing their partners' wrongdoing). I gave up when the ex-trophy wife was going to have a catfight with a current trophy wife for a whole chapter.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I really wanted to love this. The Love Lie is one of my favorites, and I hoped that this author was on the upswing. But this one missed the mark for me. It felt like it could’ve been 150-200 pages shorter and still accomplished the same goals/plot points/character development. There was SO much introspection. Too much for me. At points there were only a line of dialogue per page, the rest surrounded by painstakingly repetitive soliloquies.
Also, both Noah and Sylvia felt like such two-dimensional villains, Noah especially. Blake being dumped on Christmas, told to get out of the house within a day, and not getting a dime in the divorce, all while simultaneously becoming an outcast to her family and longtime friends seemed like a story 5-year old Maisie could’ve written.
3 stars because Monica McCallan still delivers a heartfelt, touching story. It’s just a shame it felt like such a chore to get to the finish line.
Monroe returns to her small Texas hometown after her mother's sudden death, taking responsibility for her five-year-old niece, Maisie. Struggling with grief and the fear of being an unsuitable parent, she finds unexpected support in Blake, her former high school crush and newly single neighbor. As they get closer, both women begin to figure out what they really want from life.
I liked how different Monroe and Blake are, yet how naturally they fit together. Monroe is guarded, sarcastic, and unsure of herself when it comes to raising Maisie, while Blake is caring and more willing to reach out, even when she's dealing with her own heartbreak. Their relationship develops alongside their personal struggles, and I especially liked how Maisie adds warmth to their story without making everything magically easy.
Monica McCallan's writing is conversational, with plenty of humor to balance the heavier themes of grief, family, and starting over. The romance has some lovely moments, though parts of the story feel a little drawn out, and the characters sometimes overthink things. Still, the emotional side of the book kept me interested, and I enjoyed watching both women slowly find their footing.
Overall, this is a sweet, heartfelt sapphic romance about second chances, unexpected family, and finding love when life doesn't go according to plan.
The Right Kind of Wrong by Monica McCallan is a heartfelt sapphic romance about starting over, healing from loss, and finding love when life doesn’t go as planned. Monroe returns to her hometown after losing her mom and suddenly finds herself raising her young niece, Maisie. Her next-door neighbor, Blake, is dealing with her own painful fresh start after a divorce, and their unexpected connection slowly turns into something more.
I really liked how both Monroe and Blake are trying to rebuild their lives while dealing with their own insecurities and past hurts. Monroe’s struggles with being a parent feel relatable, and Blake’s journey is just as emotional. Their relationship develops alongside themes of family, grief, and second chances, making the story feel warm and heartfelt. The writing is easy to follow, with plenty of humor mixed into the emotional moments. Some parts feel a little slow, but overall, it’s a sweet, comforting read for anyone who enjoys sapphic romance with a small-town setting and a little found-family magic.
This was a cute and cozy romance with enjoyable side characters and a swoon worthy romance.
But sadly I expected more: You've got Monroe, who is in a toxic and controlling relationship with her mentor/benefector/ex/landlord and just unexpectedly lost her mom. Blake has been comp-het'ed to hell and back by her family and social circle. Maisie, the kid, has lost anyone who ever had a parental role in her life at five and now has a virtual stranger caring for her.
You'd expect that this book deals a lot more with the complicated emotions these three should be having. Maisie just kind of gets over it, Monroe easily ends the toxic relationship and Blake barely has to deal with her family. Getting custody is a non issue for a lesbian woman, in a conservative town. And the alluded to judgemental stepford wives remain a non issue.
This book just left a lot of potential on the ground, in favour of an overall lighter tone.
Whenever Monica McCallan releases a new book, it goes automatically to my TBR, but she outdid herself this time: The Right Kind of Wrong is probably my favorite book of her until now!
It is a cute and cozy romance, the couple is so great together, the niece is THE BEST, there's no third act breakup, and no back-and-forth between them, so I simply LOVED it! The side characters are also very interesting, and I'm feeling a second book with some of them as MCs (hopefully!).
And because it's a long book, there's also a lot of room for the spice -- and let me tell you: Monica creates some VERY INTERESTING scenes along the story. I usually like the way she narrates those scenes, but here she also improved what she usually delivers.
So if you're looking for a comforting reading, if you like to see kids along the story, if you want some spice, this book is a great choice for you. Don't worry about the length, the reading is easy and you will probably finish it earlier than you imagine.
I loved how this story played out. A death of her Mom brings Monroe back to her hometown. Her five year old niece is in social services, with no mother around and her father in jail for a long time. Maisie was at school but her Nana did not come so calling the cops and finding the death at the house, with no one to call Maisie was put in child services until a family member could be located. Monroe is reeling from her mother’s death and now in charge of a five year old, life suddenly took a little detour and then to find out the house next door is her former crush. Things are happening fast all while she was supposed to finishing her art pieces for an upcoming gallery show being set up by her ex. There were laughs, there were tears, there were learning to love. This was a great read.
I've already read four LGBT+ books so far this year, and this one is really great. I don't think it can live up to TJR's level, but it's still awesome.
Tbh there are so many gay people here that I'm genuinely impressed. It's funny how we tend not to pay much attention to other people and don't really know who they are or what their lives are like.
As you know, I'm obsessed with two tropes. First of all, my beloved "found family" - tick here. Secondly, "small town" - tick here as well.
The only thing I found frustrating was the length of this book. I don't like romance books that are more than 350 pages long, but I still enjoyed this one quite a lot.
All in all, there are also several ideas that I want to keep in mind for the future as a woman myself. And, as always, it's annoying to see how everyone blames women rather than men 🙄.
Such a hard beginning with sadness, leading to a fight to happiness.
Monica McCallan sure knows how to drag a person through tough emotions into solid strong beautiful endings. The characters in this story learn from situations they fall into. That learning is the important part. How they handle themselves and react to others leads to growth or downfall and knowing which way to follow is the key to a happy life. There is plenty of heat generated with the MC’s emotionally charged lives. The electricity they generate is enough to light up the whole state of Texas! A well rounded story that is well written and so appreciated, at least by me!
It's very cute, the chemistry is excellent, and the MC's lack of communication skills are actually lampshaded and dealt with (!!!).
The limits of this book are the limits of so many lesfic novels: everything is too easy and too smooth. They supposedly live in this very conservative and hyper-nosy little town, but coming out and raising a kid together sees no difficulties beyond a couple of spoilsports tutting?
One of them is a dance teacher; you're telling me none of these Stepford Wives ass women have any problem with a lesbian teaching their daughters dance? Or that Sylvia just gives up immediately?
My two favorite tropes are slow burn and toaster oven, which is what this book had. For some reason I couldn’t see the fiery chemistry between the main characters and at times the book just kind of drug on. Lots of internal dialogue and the book got very repetitive. MINOR SPOILERS!! I felt like Monroe’s ex got squeezed into the ending just to drag the story out a bit more. And speaking of ex’s, Blake’s ex needed to be dealt with. lol I have a feeling the author’s next book is going to involve Holland. I vote for Holland and Grace to get together.
Monica McCallan does it again. She weaves a good story about good people who have made mistakes and persevere to knowing themselves more and braving opening their hearts to what they really want in life. Ever since I read a book by Monica, I have been a fan of her writing. Still a fan…way to go girl!! Love ya, Satya
I have read several books by this author and it is always a pleasure to read a new one. I love all my romance HEA books but this one goes so much deeper developing characters and being others from the town along for the ride. If you want a well written book that you can savor. This is it.