Ten women, guests at the lesbian-owned Adelheid Inn, are stranded in the Cascade Mountains after a mudslide closes the only road out. One goes missing. One is killed. More than one is not who she pretends to be, and every one of them has a secret. When another woman is attacked, it becomes clear there's a killer in their midst, and it has to be one of them.
Is it Beatrice, the judge, surly and sad after the death of her long-term partner? Or her niece, Tish, angry and sullen at being kept under Beatrice's thumb? Or is it Carmen, Beatrice's childhood friend who lured her to the Inn under false pretenses? It couldn't be the Mormon girls, Amy and Dakota. Or could it? Perhaps it's Paula, the gallant butch, or her date, the lovely and silent Veronica. A blind woman couldn't do it, but is Jess really blind? And what about Holly, the hotel manager who is just a bit too perky, or Lila, the mysterious owner of the hotel?
One thing quickly becomes clear. They'd better find out, before there are none.
I live in Eastern Washington with my wife, two dogs, and two cats. After teaching in the public schools for 14 years, I developed a case of temporary insanity and entered law school. All I really wanted to do was write stories but, despite the common misperception, legal briefs are not fiction, and my creative urge was not satisfied by my day job. I write lesbian fiction for the joy it brings me and for the joy I hope it brings others.
I have to say that I struggled through this book. I wanted to quit shortly after starting but I’ve had such bad luck with books so far this year that I felt the need to finally finish something – and it’s only a bit over six hours long.
I’ve been trying to come up with good things to say about Ten Little Lesbians but, honestly, I don’t think I can. I didn’t find a single character likable or complex. The narration didn’t help that at all. The narrator, who I’ve actually had some professional contact with and is a very nice and generous person, has a fantastic voice for broadcasting but the character voices were distracting to me. Some of the characters spoke with a very deep, slow, velvety voice and others sounded like either whiney teenagers or overly enthusiastic, overly cheerful neighbors. The use of crisp diction and pronunciation also made the dialogue feel unnatural.
Mixed in with the interpersonal drama and sex is a murder mystery. I can’t say that I was curious about who the killer was. I did, however, find myself wishing that I could pick the next victims. I particularly wanted Tish to meet her demise. She was skeevy, an incredibly immature nearly thirty-year-old, and after she made the comment “you’re really insightful for a blind person” or something like that, I wanted to punch her for being a moron. Honestly, I didn’t care even a tiny bit about any of the women in the story. Not one.
With regard to the quality of the audiobook, itself, there seems to be some editing issues. Over the past several years, I read almost solidly audiobooks and I’ve never come across one that had problems with the editing. But this one, this one has repeated lines (partial phrase at the beginning of a sentence repeated twice as if one of them was supposed to have been removed) and mid-chapter announcements (“Chapter two continued”) which happened several times. There was also the decision to have a woman singing a song spliced in which was super jarring. The sound quality of the recording was considerably different from the clear, deep narration which didn’t help. I skimmed the song which would play for a bit, then talking for a bit, then more song.
The author has several books published but this was my first read of her work. I don’t think I’ll be going back to read any of her previous releases. Sorry but there’s no way I would recommend this book to any of my friends. If I hadn’t gotten this for free from the publisher, I would have returned it for a refund hours before the end.
There is a lot that can be said about this book, not just about whether it is good or bad, but also about the style of its composition, its history, and its characters. This is true of all good books, of course, but not all books are good.
It is no secret that Ten Little Lesbians is based on Agatha Christie’s Ten Little Indians, which was originally published under a name that had more negative racial overtones. I don’t want to go into that here, but Google the book if you don’t already know the story. In Christie’s novel, a number of people are invited to an island resort in order to kill them. Each has a guilty secret.
In Ten Little Lesbians, the guests are all women who are planning a “Women’s Weekend” at a bed and breakfast many miles from the nearest town. And yes, they all have guilty secrets. The two main characters are Beatrice Stone and her niece Tish. Bea has arranged the trip for two reasons—to get Tish away from her ex before she is arrested (again), and to accompany her friend Carmen, who is trying to get over a bad breakup. The other guests—as well as the inn’s owner and her single employee—of course have their own stories. One is blind, one an ex-con, one a Mormon, and so forth.
But except for a tidbit here and there, that’s about as close to Ten Little Indians as McLachlan gets. This is not bad because Agatha Christie is not a very good writer. Ooh, have I touched a taboo subject? Too bad, because although Christie could write an extraordinary plot line, very few of her characters are realistic or interesting. I exclude Miss Marple from this because I kind of like her, but Hercule Poirot was a windy buffoon; even Christie herself disliked him. And the vast majority of her incidental characters are utterly and immediately forgettable. Her prose is generally plodding and dull.
Ten Little Lesbians is a much more enjoyable book than its near namesake. Not only is the writing more lively, but the characters are all more interesting and individual. One of the reasons for this is McLachlan’s use of point of view. The book is made up of seven longish chapters, but each chapter is further divided into sections. And each section has its own point of view character. Chapter 1, for instance has at least one section from each character’s perspective so that we get not only different voices, but deeper backstories as well.
When one character disappears and another is found dead, the fun begins. In fact, the book reminded me as much of the 1986 mystery/horror movie April Fool’s Day as it did the Agatha Christie novel. And the story really is fun, despite the suspense. Tish is a sexy, engaging character and her aunt is a businesslike no-nonsense authority figure who harbors a tragic secret. “Aunt Bea” is pragmatic and philosophic and generally is the one who moves the book along. But it is the divergent lives and voices of the other characters that keep us anxious to follow her.
My one quibble is that I found myself wishing I knew earlier who was gong to end up as the main character. Tish dominates the first two chapters, then her aunt takes over almost completely for the next two. This is not necessarily a fault; after all, a number of series, such as Penny Mickelbury’s Mimi and Gianna Mysteries, are told from two points of view. I just came away with a suspicion that all is not as balanced as it might be. Give this one a 5 on the enjoyability scale and certainly no lower than a 4 in your final rating.
I read a review copy of this book kindly provided by the author in e-book form.
Note: This review is included in my book The Art of the Lesbian Mystery Novel, along with information on over 1250 other lesbian mysteries by over 400 authors.
I truly enjoyed reading this book! There were a few less lesbians to count down to (10 little lesbians, 9 little lesbians, ...) than I'd hoped for, though. It was a mystery with some humor on the side that had me guessing till the end. Loved it!
Agatha Christie has nothing to worry about! If you are expecting a nice, classic whodunnit, this isn’t it. The characters are ok, but the story is very weak. Ok for free, but disappointing.
I have some mixed feelings about this book. It was my first foray into the Lesbian Mystery Subgenre.
I will say the characters are memorable and diverse. Big brownie points for representation are in order, especially something that will only be revealed with a plot twist. Also points go for avoiding a really icky trope. Also, this is steaming, steaming hot. The sensuality here is strong and very well-written.
The biggest downside is, well, the ending. It fell flat for me. A good murder mystery should have a twist ending that catches you by surprise, but is also obvious in hindsight. This just kinda fizzled out, despite the best efforts of the author.