This book was such a fun, quick, easy read despite a few annoyances and a confusing beginning. There were so many people introduced within the first chapters, and so many places mentioned that I felt really lost and had trouble remembering who was connected to whom and how. It also bothered me that the heroine, who had been secluded for over a decade, referred to everyone she was about to meet by their first names. The story is set in the 1890's, so there shouldn't be any reason for everyone to call Aunt Claudine simply "Claudine". Detail, I know, but add that to the other literary pet peeves I encountered in this novel, and it was enough to drive me a bit mad. ;)
Amaryllis Brigham (love her name!!) sees her life changing drastically when she is expelled from the music conservatory where she is studying, in Boston, because of a letter. I never mind a little mystery and a little intrigue in my novels, but I HATE IT when a situation that effects the whole of the novel is not explain until almost the end, when I have totally forgotten everything about it. We never know exactly what this letter says. It's never properly explained. We know that it comes from Bram Everstone, and we know that Amaryllis detests him, but her hatred isn't explained until wayyyy later, and I found it extremely frustrating because Bram Everstone's son shows up, and it's clear that sparks are flying between him and Amaryllis, but she refuses to even get along with him because she hates his father, and we are all here left wondering WHY??? Why does she hate him?? That made the romance annoying at the beginning, because it didn't seem as though Amaryllis has a legitimate reason for disliking Mr. Everstone (who is always referred to as "Bram"), and his son. It made her seem so cocky and difficult, and at twenty-five and still on the shelf, she should have been so pleased that the wealthiest man in all of New England was interested in her. And for all the family connections she had, I wonder again, why has she not seen them sooner??? Everybody is apparently dying to meet her, and she hasn't seen her relatives in eleven years, and again, it's a case of WHY?????!?! She's been studying music in Boston, for heaven's sake, not hiking icebergs somewhere in Antarctica! Why hasn't she or her relatives ever made a move to see each other before now?
I know right now it sounds like I didn't enjoy the book, but all that ^^ happened in the beginning. As the romance progressed, I found myself so reluctantly enjoying it that I had trouble putting the book down. Truly. And I think that speaks really well for the author, because not only is this her first novel, but she managed to keep me interested enough to momentarily forget my annoyances and delight in the story. I was so caught up in the whole middle section that I was ready to give this a 5 star rating. But then the H/h started having misunderstandings and behaving like indecisive chipmunks not sure where to hide their winter stock, and I lost all patience with them. Really, for heaven's sakes, make up your mind. I hate it when the heroine agrees to marry the hero and then jilts him for a personal-reason-that-she-can't-explain-to-him-because-she-already-hurt-him-enough. NO!! Speak up and be done with it! Honesty! Frankness! Integrity! Gahhh!!!!
I understand that what made the book less enjoyable for me were strictly personal issues, and for that I still wholly recommend it to anyone who likes that genre. It's well-written, engaging, and except for the heroine who drove me batty most of the time, the whole crew of characters are really engaging, and I found myself eagerly anticipating book 2. The hero was really loveable and very dreamy, but I had a slight preference for his best friend, who comes back in the next book. :)
All in all this was a very interesting read, and the gorgeous cover certainly makes a lovely addition on my Kindle shelf!