Paola Cortado, a closeted Mexican-American lesbian, goes to her first lesbian bar, The Orchid, on 18+ night where she meets an alluring older woman, Nora Wilson. As their relationship gets serious, Paola is rejected by her traditional parents and pulled into a toxic love that becomes abusive.
Estranged from the people and cultural traditions that once grounded her, Paola desperately clings to Nora, determined to build a new family into one she has always wanted. But instead, it draws her further into manipulation, control, and dependency.
Before the cycle consumes her, she must find the courage to walk away—or risk losing herself in the same trauma that shaped her childhood.
This was a difficult read, dealing with some very hard topics, like intimate partner violence and homophobia. It’s an entirely appropriate book and I think a much needed one as there is not a whole lot if books about IPV in the sapphic sphere. I really appreciated the vulnerability that was written into Paola and how her family history impacted her relationships. The book is like having a front row seat to Paola’s daily life and her thoughts. It’s not easy to witness the abuse she suffers at the hands of not only her partner Nora, but also her father. But that’s the point of the book, isn’t it? To go from the “honeymoon” period, the love bombing, the apologies after abuse, and the growing confusion Paola experiences as time goes on. It’s heartbreaking as you read, but also there is hope in the form of her friends and brother, and even Paola herself as she grows and decides to choose herself. As a Latina myself, this book hit home with the family dynamics, and the unwillingness to accept another way of life. This is a well written, emotionally deep book that addresses the subjects most don’t want to talk about, and worthy of a read and a share.
thank you bookfunneral for sending me this book. i was really hoping to enjoy it, but unfortunately i didn’t. before getting into it, sorry for being harsh. i also will say that i feel like sapphic relationships seem to be romanized, so im glad this book sheds let that a sapphic relationship can still be abusive.
the whole thing was paola pining over nora after they have a 1 night stand. after that 1 night, she falls for nora super hard. eventually after months of no contact, nora invites paola to a party. at that parry, nora is drunk and kisses someone else. paola i get is upset, but nora barely even did anything at this point to even lead her on. that night, nora asks her to come over at 3 am, which i don’t like bc it’s become a repeated occurrence where paola was put in a bad place and would feel like she had to leave. i also don’t like how paola knew right away the flaws of nora. she knew nora had a drinking issue. nora literally asked paola to be girlfriends when she was in jail for drunk driving. maybe a month into being together, she knew she didn’t want marriage or kids. she just settled. paola’s choosen family didn’t like her from the beginning and she didn’t listen. which was especially frustrating bc she was with vera, someone she actually was forming a relationship with. and as a reader, i felt vera was characterized somewhat better than anyone. which brings me to my next point. i had so many character questions about everyone. like paola. who was she outside of nora? why did she just stop at getting her aa? what was her aa in? she bakes a lot outside of the bakery, but if it wasn’t for the bakery, would she even like to bake? why does she like to bake? her being a nurse was only mentioned like 3 times, then suddenly she’s in school, with little to no information about that. i wanted to know about paola but i didn’t. over the span of the 3 years, i don’t think she really even had much character development. she ultimately left nora, but that is something she should’ve done from the get go. i also think i might be a little too asexual to understand how she fall so hard after a one night stand.
and i would have liked to know more about nora, who is she outside the relationship? was she a finical employee? how did she have so much money? as for paola’s parents being homophobic, i wish we knew why. there was no justification for it.
along with that, how did paola meet sarah? what’s sarah’s story with her fiancé? how did they become so close that marco invites them to family breakfast?
ultimately, i just wish we got to know the characters better. bc it rlly did just feel like paola went after a stranger who made her feel special. and when they were in the relationship, the characters feel somewhat surface level. yes, nora is abusive, but what ticks it? what does she do for work? what makes nora nora? yes, paola has mental health issues and being estranged from her family is hard, but what makes her tick? what motivates her to keep going? who is paola?
also i’m sorry this is a lot and idk how constructive this is
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
From the beginning of She Doesn't Love You, you really feel for the FMC, Paola. She isn't able to live authentically, she has a difficult relationship with her parents, and she is seeking to be loved. The author does a great job at progressing how Paola is almost desperate for love and the progression of her relationship with Nora. Immediately you feel for Paola, and the more you get to know her, the more you truly want her to be happy and loved. At times the book does feel almost too long, and somewhat repetitive, but that also can display the relationship between Paola and Nora and the cycle they are going through. I had a lot of hope that things would turn around for Paola, and couldn't put it down at one point because it felt like she was getting so close to realizing/leaving and getting to the ending was sort of a let down as it felt abrupt. I think this book does a good job at describing DV and how it isn't always physical.
"Once again, I feel like a child, begging to be loved. And she hates kids. I'm not sure what that says about us."
5 STAR ARC REVIEW ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ "She doesn't love you" written by Fernanda Maravilla I don't think I've ever related to a book quite like I did with this. I am a queer hispanic person with family drama, religious trauma, and has been in abusive relationships before. That is exactly what this book is about. The hard and maybe hidden parts of each of those things. In my opinion these topics don't get written about as much as they should with queer representation. I was absolutely floored by this book. It was a difficult read, but only becuase it was SO ACCURATE as to how abusive situations play out. This was my first arc that I've annotated and let me just say this book is absolutely filled with my thoughts and feelings. I know I'll be rereading this in the future. Fernanda- thank you so much for the vulnerability it took to write this. I can't wait to read more from you in the future. This book will be released on Dec 12, 2026 and I urge you all to read it!
I'll start with the pros of this book. The scenarios were very real and disturbing in a way that makes your heart ache from IPV/DV victims. This book was especially hard for me because of the similarities of coming out and being disowned by your family.
Now my cons. I loved getting to know Paola on a deeper level, but the first part of this book felt like it was dragging on far too long. Then there's Vero and how Paola used her. Secondly, I understand that it's hard when your family doesn't see the error of their ways and they struggle to accept you, but chapter 78 was weird. That chapter felt real yet unreleastic at the same time. It's hard to explain but I couldn't follow the conversation clearly.
I wouldn't say this is a con, but the ending?! I mean come I felt like I was left hanging. However, I can see how the author might've purposely intended it to end that way.