Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

False Legacies

Rate this book
Dark romantasy fans will love the glittering social trials, rival courts, three irresistible love interests, and scandal-soaked drama of False Legacies.

Welcome to the Legacy Trials, where power is inherited, secrets are currency, and desire is a weapon.

When Penelope Grimsorrow’s twin is poisoned into a deadly sleep, Penelope is forced to impersonate her at the ruthless Legacy Trials.

Arriving with uncontrolled Legacy magic, Penelope must compete under glittering chandeliers with heirs from the five ruling Houses, their whispered scandals and smiles sharp enough to draw blood.

Her goal is simple: find her sister’s attacker, secure the antidote, and save her House from ruin before she is voted out or her true identity is exposed.

Between her sister’s betrothed watching closely and the golden heir’s charms disarming her every move, Penelope’s facade begins to unravel.

But when a handsome and seductive lord offers her a bargain as tempting as it is dangerous, Penelope finds herself deep in a game she was never meant to play, with every forbidden desire she has tried to bury, threatening to destroy her.

582 pages, Kindle Edition

Published November 12, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Amy Briar

1 book22 followers
Amy Briar is an Australian dark romantasy author who writes stories filled with dangerous magic, court scandal and complicated men who are almost certainly a terrible idea. When she isn’t writing, she can usually be found reading romance novels, drinking iced coffee, listening to Taylor Swift or counting down the days until Halloween.

False Legacies is her debut novel.

Find her on Instagram and TikTok at @amybriarauthor

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
83 (52%)
4 stars
65 (41%)
3 stars
10 (6%)
2 stars
0 (0%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 139 reviews
Profile Image for Linz✨.
285 reviews364 followers
November 13, 2026
"Because at the legacy trials, power is inherited, secrets are currency, and every favor comes with a price."


False legacies was such a fun and entertaining read. I had so much fun in this world and experiencing all the trials and these characters that had so many different personalities. I loved the concept of the rival houses and the unique legacy magic. The trials were entertaining because they were more than just physical trials. The amount of manipulation, gossip, rivalries, and alliances that were going on in this story had me glued to every single page. You did not know who to trust, who had ulterior motives, and who was being genuine. This was an addictive debut novel that I couldn't put down, and I can't wait to see where these characters go next.

The dedication alone started this book off right:
"For the vibe reading girlies
who never want the tension to end."


જ⁀➴ What to Expect
💙Dark Romantasy
🖤Rival Houses
💙Bridgerton/Gossip Girl/Phantasma Vibes
🖤Court Politics
💙Twin Sister Switch
🖤3 Love Interests
💙Forced Proximity
🖤Deadly Trials

જ⁀➴ Premise
This story follows our FMC, Penelope, whose life is turned upside down when her twin sister, Juliette is mysteriously poisoned. With her sister trapped in a deadly sleep she must take her identity and compete in the Legacy trials, where the heirs of the five powerful houses fight to secure their legacies. Under the guise of the trials, Penelope is determined to undercover who poisoned her sister and fight the antidote before it's too late.

જ⁀➴ Characters

Penelope Grimsorrow
Our Fmc, the spare heir, has constantly spent her life in her twin sister Juliette's shadow. Juliette is disciplined, composed, and controlled, everything that Penelope is not. Penelope gives off black cat energy, she is impulsive, sarcastic, outspoken, and stubborn. She makes reckless decisions, struggles with her magic, and doesn't always realize when people are manipulating her.

Gray Devereux
A morally gray, dangerous, yet intriguing rival lord who knows to much. He is calculating, mysterious, manipulative, and unlike Penelope he knows how power works. He knows the power of information and secrets and he usually several steps ahead of everyone else.

Finn Winchester
Finn is our golden retriever who is confident, charming, flirtatious, and witty. He has a teasing personality that you will see through his humor and banter. He feeds off the drama but at the same time he can be extremely loyal and protective. Finn is easily the loveable character that makes everything seem funnier or lighter.

Basian Hawthorne
Penelope's twin sister, Juliette's, betrothed and heir to the rival house. He is reserved, serious, brooding, and is always worried about appearances and what other people think. He is the quiet one that secretly has so much more to his character than what meets the eye.

Favorite Quotes
"I don't like other people touching what's mine"

"I know exactly what effect I have on you."
"Without ever laying a finger on you. I could have you begging."

"You can flirt with whoever you want. Parade them around to get my attention. It doesn't change what's mine."

Profile Image for Déirdre.
200 reviews8 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 26, 2026
Release date: 12 November 2026

✔️Morally Grey MMC
✔️Strong FMC
✔️Arranged Marriage
✔️Enemies-to-Lovers vibes
✔️Deadly Trials
✔️Forbidden Love
✔️High Stakes
✔️Reluctant Allies
✔️Forced Proximity

Thank you Amy Briar for gifting me a copy of this book in return for an honest review.
OMG, what a book! I’m calling it now, this is going to be huge, watch this space.
I absolutely devoured it. From the very first page, I was completely hooked and OBSESSED.
I had high hopes going in based off the author's post with the book vibs, and it did not disappoint. Ruthless Houses, secrets, scandal, forbidden desire, deadly trials and a really interesting magic system. I loved the whole setting.
And then we have the MMCs… 👀 There was chemistry, tension, forbidden attraction…a nice bit of spice.
What more can I say, only that I need book 2 immediately!
Profile Image for SinE. Loves Books.
48 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 8, 2026
Thanks to the author for the ARC. False legacies is a dark romantasy intended for mature readers.

1st things first, the dedication:
For the vibe reading girlies
who never want the tension to end.
I feel it suited this book so well. When "not usually deadly" trials turn deadly, the tensions certainly rise.

This was an amazing read, everything flowed seamlessly.
The power plays were amazing between Penelope and the other characters were tantalising, I was hooked!
Profile Image for Raven.
11 reviews
November 2, 2026
My first ARC and I really enjoyed it, the writing style was nice, I liked the growth of the FMC by the end but holy hell am I STRESSED 😭 I hope Gray dies a slow painful death and Finn deserves the whole world.
Profile Image for Kelly Gamboa.
963 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 25, 2026
Thank you to the author for giving me an earc.

So uh. What was that? My brain was functioning that ending! I can't think. I've been played because I was loving one of the love interest and now I'm just like? I feel betrayed. But this book was so good. We follow our main character Penelope pretending to be her twin sister for the trials and trying to find out who put her twin sister to a deep sleep. So many twists and turns that I wasn't expecting. That ending was diabolical. But Penelope we see struggling with self love and we see her coming out to be this strong female character that is sneaky and fiesty. I think it was done really well. The 3 love interests. I'm like confused on who to route for cause like I don't know anymore. I was routing for one till the ending! I'm like shocked at that cliffhanger plot twist. I really love the mystery aspects in here as well and the court politics. Everything was fantastic. I have feeling we will see Penelope be more strong and be more badass in the next one. The romance? Perfection to me. I mean it's messy since its 3 love interests but I love mess. Omg. This was just perfect. Definitely new all time favorite and one of my best books of the year. Infinity stars
20 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 30, 2026
Arc Review: False Legacies, Amy Briar.
Release Date: Nov 12, 2026
💙📖✨

I’ll start with; Thank You Amy, for the lovely opportunity to read your Debut Book, False Legacies, in Advance. I was absolutely blown away!

The story features, our FMC, Penelope, avenging her poisoned twin sister, by facing trials on behalf of her house, under the guise of her twin.

Between swooning over Gray, falling for Finn’s Charm, and loving Penelope’s wit— Falling in love with the characters is an understatement!

The Banter and Sass was truly unparalleled. Amy’s writing style is so easy to read. The political intrigue had me on the edge of my seat. I found the trials to be so creative and very well done!

The court drama and the plot pulled me in— and if it wasn’t for the busiest week of my life- I would have read this in one sitting! SO INTERESTING!

And the ENDING had me NEEDING book 2! Looking back at it now— the foreshadowing was there, but the plot twist was astonishing!

I am no writer by any means, but if you were to take away anything — it’s I’m a voracious reader, and I know a good book when I read one and this one will be a story I will be thinking about for a long time! Amazing book! 5 star read!

Again, Thank You Amy For this amazing opportunity, I look forward to reading book 2 and adding your works to my collection asap! This was one of my Favorite reads of the year!!!!
Profile Image for Ashley(burntedgesandbooks).
138 reviews8 followers
October 21, 2026
Thank you Amy Briar and her team for allowing me to read this ARC, all thoughts and opinions are my own.

OMG, What a wonderful, addicting utterly enthralling book!
I'm still trying to process, still trying get make sure that I understood what happened in this wonderful book!

It had it all!
Why choose, all the guys you start to feel feelings for along with the FMC, One has so many red flags that you should should loving him but you can't. Another is such a golden retriever, like he is fun, he is lovable and he just wants to be there for you. And you have your dark, silence brooding one, the one you just want to get to know because well he keeps himself away from you...
Perfect recipe right there.
I loved the FMC, I felt like she was really relatable. Everything she went through I felt like I could understand and see and was right there along side her. She stayed strong, staying as focused as she could with all the things she was doing. And she wasn't learning more about herself as she went through all the trails and mingled with all the other legacies.
The magic system built on what houses you were in was also pretty fun! I l loved this twice on something that was simple and good. Having the 'Legacies' along without other powerful heirs or family members. Everything was such a new take on everything that I was addicted to it all.
My mind is STILL spinning, who killed who? the secrets, the lies, the sneaking around. Who stabbed who in the back? who will survive this, even after the trails are done? It was something hat was constantly going through my mind and kept me on the edge of my seat throughout the entire book!
The way I am obsessed just like I am obsessed with all the other books that blow me away, this one is just right up there!
If this isn't ending in a why choose,... I think I will riot! But this book needs to be on your tbr because you will want to to read it over and over again.
Profile Image for tammys bookish life.
95 reviews10 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 2, 2026
I went into this expecting a typical magical trials story, but what I got was a tangled web of secrets, deception, political intrigue, and betrayals that kept me hooked from start to finish.

The worldbuilding was one of my favorite parts. Each of the five Houses felt distinct, from Grimsorrow's shadowbinding to Solareth's illusion-based lightbinding. The magic system was unique, especially the idea that each form of binding was about much more than its surface meaning.

Poor Penelope is thrown into an impossible situation when her twin sister Juliette is unable to compete in the Trials, forcing her to take her place to protect House Grimsorrow. What starts as a simple deception quickly spirals into something much bigger as Penelope finds herself surrounded by heirs who know far more than she does and secrets that could destroy her family.

The romantic drama had me completely invested. Finn won me over early with how genuinely concerned he seemed for Penelope, while Gray constantly kept me questioning his motives. Every time I started to trust him, he gave me another reason not to.

I also loved the tension between Penelope and Bastian. Even when he was being frustratingly harsh, his reactions felt believable given everything happening around him. The politics between the Houses, the mystery surrounding Juliette, and the shocking revelations near the end kept the pages turning.

I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Profile Image for ChipmunksandDandelion (Cinnamon&Pine).
288 reviews12 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 8, 2026
Penelope is forced to take part in the realm’s trials as a substitute for her sister. A noble sacrifice, sure, but I struggled with her rebellious streak through most ofthe book. If she is so devoted to protecting her sister, why can’t she keep herself in check for a few weeks?

Taking her sister’s place means pretending to be her, including being engaged. So perhaps acting like herself and charging headfirst into trouble isn’t the smartest strategy. Yet that seems to be exactly what she does.

The romantic entanglements didn’t make things any easier. We have the charming, sunny playboy, the dark and mysterious secret-keeper, and, to complicate matters further, her own sister’s fiancé. This love quadrangle felt a little over the top and didn’t do much to improve my patience with Penelope.

Despite my frustrations with Penelope, I genuinely enjoyed the book. The story, the trials, and even the guys kept me hooked. I raced through the pages, hunting for answers, only to be rewarded with a few crumbs. Needless to say, I’m already impatiently waiting for the next instalment!
Profile Image for Liz Gibson.
123 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 12, 2026
It’s Survival meets Bridgerton. Concept was interesting and that it had trials. Kind of confused on why she hated Grey so much. Like everything he was slyly doing she was okay with and semi ignored it, but then suddenly flipped? Until the very last page of the book I don’t see the real reason behind her hate for him. Call me batshit, but I can still see them ending up together in book two.

I just don’t get why she thought being quiet and reserved was ever going to keep her in a social* game? I know what her parents said and how Juliette acted, but she wanted to stay as long as possible……by going to her room all the time, not talking to anyone, making no alliances?
Profile Image for Bari Mariani.
165 reviews9 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 5, 2026
5 houses
20 legacies
6 trials
3 hot, infuriating, tempting men
2 sisters
1 mystery in need of solving

This story was addictive. I was sucked in from the beginning. Amy’s writing made it feel like you were right there with the characters.

If you know me you know my love for trials and Amy delivered. This book is truly what you get if you were to mix the regal-ness of Bridgerton with the teams and tribal council of survivor but with an audience watching them compete. They were unique, stressful, dangerous and not everyone will come out alive.

Penelope is forced to become her sister and I honestly kind of loved watching her personality slip through when it wasn’t suppose to.

Don’t get me started on our three men! Yes three ! But if you ask me my favorite … it’s Bastian. And if banter and spice are your thing, this book is for you!

There is sneaking around, and gossip, and backstabbing- I mean you can’t go wrong! The ending will leave you shocked and already wanting book 2!
Profile Image for Among The Shelves.
24 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 17, 2026
False Legacies by Amy Briar

I went into this book thinking Finn would be my favourite. I was right. He brought so much personality to the story, and his comments made me smile more than once. If you have a soft spot for Ridoc from Fourth Wing or Finnick from The Hunger Games, I think you’ll understand why I loved him.

I had a lot of fun getting to know the different houses and their abilities, and the trials were some of my favourite parts to read. Amy clearly knows her characters inside out. The banter feels natural rather than forced, and the personalities I’d come to know through her posts felt just as vivid on the page.

Penelope, though, had me wanting to reach into the book and say, “Can we please stop and think about this for a second?” She’s emotional and reactive, and Amy writes her consistently, but I sometimes wanted her to ask more questions about what was happening around her. I finished with a few questions of my own about the wider history and certain character dynamics, so I’m curious to see what the next book reveals.

And Grey? I want to like you. You’re making it difficult.

Come for the trials, stay for Finn Winchester.
Profile Image for Jennifer Ruth .
84 reviews9 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 28, 2026
This book was a dang good time! Social Trials, Rival Courts with some serious drama, and a sister who has been thrown into the middle of all of it. Quite scandalous indeed. Penelope is forced to impersonate her twin sister, who is suddenly and mysteriously poisoned on the eve of the Legacy Trials. Her goal is simple: find her sister’s attacker, secure the antidote, and save her House from ruin before she is voted out or her true identity is exposed. Penelope is witty, smart, and cunning, but finds herself in a deadly game...Think Bridgerton meets Survivor with three ridiculously hot males you should, absolutely hands down, not trust. Verdict: Dark Romantasy Addiction!
Profile Image for Teddy .
9 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 29, 2026
Thank you Amy for my ARC of False Legacies.

The story follows Penelope, who finds her twin sister poisoned and must now secretly take her place in the Legacy Trials to represent her house and find her sisters attacker.

Surviving the trials unharmed is one thing, but surviving the scheming and court gossip to avoid being voted out is another.

Holy shit, I am all in on this book. It really had my attention with the tropes and blurb AND THEN IT FUCKING DELIVERED.

I was fully immersed in the story. I love Amy's writing style. I felt the drama, I felt the tension, I felt it all.

And the last line of the book... 10/10 no notes 👌

I love these characters, I love this book, one of my favourite reads! I know I'm going to be re reading it soon because I can't get enough.
Profile Image for Jessica.
29 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 8, 2026
Thank you Amy Briar for the eARC.

Whenever I mention that I devour a book, this is the exact book that filters into that category. Being from the UK, there was a major time difference between here and Australia. Recognising that the ARC wouldn't arrive until 8pm, I altered my sleeping routing to ensure I would awaken for its arrival. I ended up losing my entire day to this book.

Our FMC is Penelope, the spare of Grimsorrow House. After her twin sister and heir, Juliette is poisoned, Penelope has to impersonate her and go undercover in the upcoming Legacy Trials. This is where the dilema for Penelope originates. Juliette is serene, restrained, but exudes nobility, power and confidence. Penelope, on the other hand, is formidable and flamboyant. She has a modicum of control over her magic. Penelope fails to listen to anyone and instead indulges in whatever she wishes. Attempting to mold herself into her sister is an obstacle for Penelope, one which is an exceptional hardship. However, overseeing her evolve and uncover the formidable, powerhouse she undoubtedly is was one of more special moments in the book. A separate ordeal Penelope had to face was managing three vastly different love interests.

The first of the three MMC's is Hawthorne; the fiancé of Penelope's twin sister Juliette's. Hawthorne radiates the strong, reserved, brooding type. He is situating all of his attention on how their relationship is observed from the outside, instead of concentrating on her. There will be instances where you will despise him, but continue reading as there is reasoning for it. As the book progresses, we discover more about Hawthorne: his past; his upbringing; and we determine how misunderstood he actually is. Amy composes Hawthorne in such a brutally honest way, it grants him so much depth to his character and makes him appear so life-like.

The second MMC is Gray, he is dark, mysterious and the only other heir taking part in the Legacy Trials. He is best friends with Hawthorne, but is the polar opposite of him. Gray emanates power and control, he uses whoever he wants to accomplish his aspirations. Gray and Penelope's relationship is built on mutually assured destruction and respect that develops as they discover more about each other. My favourite chapters featured the two of them working, scheming and being together.

The final of the three MMC's is Finn; he is the golden retriever, comedic love interest. He is hilarious, charismatic and a flirt with everyone; being the relief that's needed in tense scenarios. Moreover, for those that are deserving, he is sensitive, compassionate and protective. The relationship that blossoms between Finn and Penelope is my most treasured, I would cherish a person like Finn in my life. From his opening line, Finn stole my heart and cemented himself as my character of choice in this book.

Outside of the characters, I adored the trials. They were incredibly innovative and rejuvenating compared to the conventional trials you encounter in other books. You could ascertain that each trial was derived from something Amy is passionate about. They were fully fleshed out ideas with riveting twists to each of them. It was intriguing watching our characters trying to accomplish them.

Overall, I loved every second of this book! From the characters, to the world building, to the plot; every word had a purpose and it hit the mark every time. Due to Amy's outstanding writing, everything felt so realistic and grounded. These characters have fused themselves to my heart and have joined the list as some of my most precious FMC and MMC's. Thank you Amy for this unbelievable book and characters, I will treasure in my heart forever. Now the countdown for book 2 begins!
Profile Image for Becky.
437 reviews7 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 6, 2026
Quotes-
"Only someone with something to hide would choose patience over accusation."
"Because I'm about to make you forget just how much you hate me."
" Good Girl."

Take Bridgeton, combine it with the Hunger Games, but also add a dash of Harry Potter, but make it spicy, and you have False Legacies.
It was so good and addicting!! I couldn't put it down.
When Penelope Grimrose's twin sister, Juliette, is found poisoned and near death, Penelope is forced to impersonate her sister and participate in the Legacy Trials. With her unstable magic, she is forced to compete in deadly trials, forge alliances, and find her sister's attacker.
I liked Penelope as an FMC. The level of betrayal she felt as different points of the game hurt my heart. Her sarcastic sense of humor was so funny.
The MMCs in this story were fantastic!! Gray, depending on the chapter, I loved him or hated him. Just when you think you have him figured out, he surprises you. Hawthorne, Gray's best friend and Juliette 's fiance, is broody and stoic, but slowly becomes more. But he thinks she's her sister!! And then there's Finn- charming, funny, protective. He literally threatens to k!ll someone for her.
The side characters in this story are really well and thought out too. They don't feel two dimensional.
But that ending?!! I need to know what happens next!! I can't wait for book two.
Thanks for choosing me to be an ARC reader.
Profile Image for Laura Beth.
304 reviews11 followers
November 12, 2026
False Legacies
ARC Review
Pub date: November 12, 2026

Amy Briar makes an incredible debut with her dark romantasy False Legacies.

What to expect
💜CW drama
✨3 love interests
💜Forced proximity
✨Rival houses
💜Court politics
✨Social trials

On the eve of the Legacy Trials Penelope’s twin sister Juliette is poisoned and placed in a deadly sleep. Penelope must secretly take Juliette’s place in the trials and pretend to be her. As she competes, she must uncover who poisoned Juliette before it is too late.

This book was so addictive and had such an intriguing plot! I need all my book friends to immediately add this to their TBR.

I had seen several glowing reviews, so when arcs became available, I immediately signed up.

I really enjoyed the pacing and world building. I honestly couldn’t put this book down. It had the perfect amount of mystery, secrets, and swoon worthy tension!

Can we talk about the love interests? Penelope is caught between her sister’s betrothed, a charming golden heir, and a seductive lord who offers her a dangerous bargain she simply can’t reuse.

The tension and banter had me kicking my feet the entire time. 🤭

I’m a huge fan of trials, and I really enjoyed how they were done in False Legacies.

If you love a book that is going to keep up late into the night then this one is definitely for you!

Thank you Amy for the eARC of False Legacies, I am already desperate for the next book.
Profile Image for Gaby Vromans.
82 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 21, 2026
✨ ARC REVIEW | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

What an AMAZING book! 😭💙 But oh my god, how freaking rude is it that it’s already over?!

HELLO?! WHERE IS BOOK TWO?! I NEED TO KEEP READING. I’m not ready to let these characters go just yet! 🥹

The writing was SO good, the world pulled me right in, and THE TRIALS?! 🫶🏻🔥 Soooo unique and creative! I absolutely loved how they were written and how much they added to the story.

I was hooked, completely invested, and now I’m left here desperately wanting more. Amy Briar, you can’t just leave me like this! 😩💙

Five stars, absolutely deserved. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Loved this book so, so much! ✨
Profile Image for Emma Schissel.
190 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 22, 2026
** received as an arc and leaving this review voluntarily

may go back and add more as thoughts come to me.

i really enjoyed the premise of this. at the beginning i was annoyed by how many times penelope talked about omg juliette would not have acted like that. i can handle one or two but we got the point. you’re impulsive and juliette isn’t

i’m also a little bothered by Gray. i was hoping for a bigger twist at the end, but it felt like it had been leading us towards this outcome the entire book 🤨

either way, i thought the author wrote well and the premise was really interesting. i am excited to see what book 2 brings.
Profile Image for marie.
245 reviews
November 13, 2026
arc review

I really enjoyed this book! It kind of reminded me of bridgerton set in a fantasy world with a lot of mystery. The writing style made this a quick and easy read to binge! If you love morally grey mmcs, a strong fmc, enemies to lovers, deadly trials, forced proximity and arranged marriages, this is the perfect story for you! The ending really surprised me and I can't wait to read the next book.
Profile Image for María Camila Torres.
23 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 7, 2026
WOWWW. I need book two right now, I can't wait to find out what happens! 😭

I loved Finn, Bastian, and Gray so much, and honestly I'd love to get their POV and see them have their moment. This one had me hooked and desperate for more. ❤️

Thank you to the author for the ARC!
Profile Image for Kat Hartwell.
58 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 4, 2026
Many thanks to the author for the ARC!

I knew as soon as I saw the blurb for this book that I was going to love it, and it didn't disappoint! Right from the dedication to the vibe girlies, this was such a fun ride that I didn't want to end. It's slightly longer than I expected, but the pages absolutely flew by and I was absolutely left wanting more.

The Legacy Trials were interesting to read, woven into the court politics of the story so you never quite knew what would happen next. But where this book really shines is in the moments in between the trials - the alliances, the banter and the backstabbing are all so fun! There are so many twists and turns that I genuinely could not predict where it was going.

Penelope is a great FMC, you really feel her struggle having to live in her sister's shoes and the toll it takes on her. While she may not always make the smartest decisions, this only makes her feel more real.

I knew there would be three MMCs, and I went into it pretty sure which one would be my favourite, but boy was I wrong! All three of them are fun to read, and it will be interesting to see if my favourite changes again in book 2.

The wider cast of characters are also great fun, especially Dario, as well as some I loved to hate (mean girls anyone?)

An incredible debut, I can't wait to see where the story goes next!
Profile Image for Katsindiebookblog .
1,070 reviews33 followers
November 14, 2026
BOOK: False Legacies by Amy Briar [Format: eARC]
This debut novel was a nice change to the normal Romantasy tropes—a mix of Dark Academia with Trials set to test skills and build alliances to choose the next leaders of each of the five Houses.
Series: Unknown
Series No: [#1]
Status: Read
Rating: [4.5/5 ⭐]
Page Count: [582 Pages]
QUICK IMPRESSION
The story starts on the eve of a ball. Juliette, the favorite twin and heir to the Grimsorrow legacy, is announced to be betrothed to Bastian Hawthorne—until she is poisoned. Penelope is quickly ordered by her parents to take her sister's place in the Trials in secret to keep their House from looking weak.
QUICK NOTES
• Penelope was a bit of a wild child compared to the demure and poised Juliette. She had swapped places with her sister as a young child, but even so, Penelope was at such a handicap with her parents keeping them separate. I did wonder why the parents wouldn't have considered training both twins, but then we wouldn't have a story, would we? 😉
• The Trials start with the reader feeling the stress of Penelope having to mingle with the latest class of Legacy Heirs as they gather to create alliances for the Legacy Trials and future political gain. Penelope is navigating all of this with a stacked deck: her powers are unbound, whereas the others are bound and have been training for three years. On top of that, she's investigating who poisoned her sister.
• The pace sharpens dramatically the moment the Trials get underway. I thought they were very well written, and I could really imagine what was happening throughout these different scenarios.
• The Spice... Love Square? We have Juliette's betrothed, Bastian, and then there's Finn and Grey. It certainly gives major tension, mind games, and plenty of chemistry between them all. I really didn't like Bastian at first, but he grew on me as the book progressed. Finn was my favorite, and Grey... well, let's just say 🤐 you will have to go read and make your own decisions! 😉🤯
• The reader is pulled alongside Penelope (posing as Juliette) into a treacherous cycle of secrets, political scheming, fractured loyalties, and unexpected twists... boy, are there some twists.

QUOTES TO KEEP
“This evening marks the first formal celebration of the Legacy Trials. A gathering not of families or Houses, but of duty and what the High Realm asks of those who would shape its future.” -Chancellor Vale.
“It’s easier for them. They can shrug it off, turn rumour into bravado. Perhaps they’re even praised for it, envied or admired. A man enjoys himself and it’s expected. A woman does, and she’s either a scandal or a joke. If I lean into the rumours, I’m indecent. If I deny them, I’m frigid and a liar.” - Penelope.
“Grimsorrow!” he exclaims, as though greeting an old friend. “You’re looking exceptionally beautiful this morning. Forced social games suit you.” - Finn.
KEY CHARACTERS
• [Penelope Grimsorrow]: [House Grimsorrow/Legacy Spare]. Power - Shadowbinding (able to create shields, or use the shadows to trap or hide). Her Shadowbinding is unbound, and magic without an anchor is harder to control. Penelope is Juliette's twin—the spare, basically discarded as unnecessary and taught needlepoint! (Although that's not all she gets up to 😉).
• [Juliette Grimsorrow]: [House Grimsorrow/Legacy Heir]. Her parents ensured she got all the training and benefits, until the night of the Ball when she is found poisoned.
The Romance Interests:
• [Finn Winchester]: [House Solareth/Legacy Heir]. Power - Lightbinding (Illusion). His personality makes him hard not to like—he treats our FMC with respect and has a teasing humor. The life of the party. He was my favorite.
• [Bastian Hawthorne]: [House Wolfgarde/Legacy Heir]. Power - Forcebinding (telekinesis). He is reserved and comes across as grumpy, but once you get to know him, he's easy to warm up to. He definitely puts his House first; the political marriage with Juliette is something he doesn't want, though loyalty to his House had him complying.
• [Grey Deveraux]: [House Loxfell/Legacy Heir]. Power - Temperbinding (manipulation of emotions). He comes across as arrogant and is definitely the morally grey MMC. With a power like that, it's easy to wonder when he is actually being authentic.
(There are more, but these are the main characters.)
FINAL THOUGHTS
• The Good: The worldbuilding was a bit like a cross between a Victorian estate and an exclusive academy with Trials, which were interesting and written in a vivid style so that I could easily visualize the scenes. While the pacing slowed down in between games, it matched the atmosphere well and gave us some light moments to reset and recenter. The plot twists kept me on my toes!
• The Bad (not bad per se, just things that made me question): I would have liked more information on the social structure. The Compact Council (the name really confused me; it didn't make sense as a governing body title) gets a brief history of how it was formed and why, which intrigued me, so I hope we get more in future books! Also, Penelope often found herself losing control of her emotions and reverting to her true self—often in the presence of Grey. I wanted to shout at her to be cautious, though it made me wonder if Grey was the reason given his powers. The author definitely had me doubting my conclusions a lot—which is a GOOD THING.
• Verdict: Oh, the ending! I really can't say much about it without spoiling the book, but I definitely need Book 2! I thoroughly enjoyed this read, and for a debut novel, it shows huge promise for an interesting world. The political aspect of the story arc could really build into something big, and I hope the author has the sequel waiting in the wings soon!

I received a complimentary advance copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Selena Clynch.
38 reviews2 followers
October 20, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.75

ARC REVIEW — FALSE LEGACIES by Amy Briar
Thank you so much to Amy for the ARC. But can I have book 2 now please?🙏🥹


“Power is inherited. Secrets are currency. Desire is a weapon.”

If you’re looking for a dark romantasy filled with deadly trials, political intrigue, dangerous secrets and enough romantic tension to keep you turning the pages, False Legacies is it.

When Penelope Grimsorrow’s twin is poisoned and left trapped in a deadly sleep, Penelope is forced to take her identity and place in the ruthless Legacy Trials. Surrounded by powerful heirs, rival Houses and people who would happily see her fail, she has one goal: uncover who attacked her sister and secure the antidote before it’s too late and her deception is discovered.

I really enjoyed how the story combines the glamour and decadence of the ruling Houses with the underlying sense that absolutely no one can be trusted. There’s a constant feeling that something darker is happening beneath all the glittering balls, political games and carefully constructed alliances, which kept me guessing because I could not figure it out.

🖤 And then there’s Gray Devereux…

Let’s talk about Gray because honestly… sir. 👀

Mysterious, powerful, dangerously charismatic and seemingly impossible to read, Gray is the kind of morally grey character who immediately demands your attention regardless of what he’s doing. There’s something incredibly compelling about the way he keeps Penelope guessing — you’re never quite sure whether he’s going to protect her, manipulate her or completely ruin her plans.

And the chemistry? 🔥

Every interaction between Gray and Penelope carries that delicious “this is a terrible idea, but I’m going to do it anyway” energy. The tension is in the lingering looks, the distrust, the power struggles and the undeniable pull between them. You can practically feel the danger every time they’re in the same room.

What I particularly loved was that Penelope doesn’t simply fall at his feet. She questions him, challenges him and remains suspicious of his motives, which makes their dynamic so much more satisfying. Gray has secrets, Penelope has secrets, and neither is willing to give the other the upper hand.

But honestly?

The more Gray revealed, the more I wanted.

He has that perfect combination of dangerous, protective, emotionally unavailable and potentially catastrophic energy that romantasy readers know all too well!

I went into this book expecting to enjoy the trials and intrigue, but Gray Devereux may have been my biggest weakness. Because that mouth? Sir. Please continue🥵😮‍💨

The Legacy Trials themselves were another favourite element. A little bit hunger games vibes but also not. There’s something so addictive about watching characters compete while simultaneously trying to uncover secrets, manipulate alliances and survive the people around them.

✨ Perfect for readers who love:
• Dark romantasy
• Deadly magical trials
• Rival courts & powerful Houses
• Secret identities
• Political intrigue
• Forbidden romance
• Love triangles
• Morally grey characters
• Dangerous bargains
• Secrets, betrayal & twists
• Mysterious, morally grey love interests
• A man who is absolutely going to be a problem 👀

False Legacies has that delicious combination of a beautifully dangerous world, complicated characters, romantic tension and “I definitely shouldn’t trust you, but I absolutely do” energy that makes romantasy so addictive.

A compelling and atmospheric read with plenty of intrigue, romance and questions that kept me wanting to know what was hiding behind the next secret.

And if you happen to develop a slight obsession with Gray Devereux along the way… I certainly won’t judge. 🖤

4.5 ⭐️/5
Profile Image for Alexie.
31 reviews
October 20, 2026
Firstly, thank you so much to Amy Briar for giving me this eARC!

Truly I have no words! I could not put this down!! This was such an amazing read!! We are transported as soon as the first page starts and you can’t help but dive in and feel fully immersed into this world and story! We experience magic, trials, rival courts, and MMCs that you will absolutely love!

Our FMC, Penelope, is deeply misunderstood by her family and is ultimately viewed as the spare in comparison to her twin sister, Juliette, who holds the title of heir of Grimsorrow house. They each must uphold the utmost standards bequeathed to them since birth but while Juliette is the epitome of perfection, poise, and radiates power, we have Penelope who is headstrong, indulgent, not easily tempered and with power that is unbound and uncontrolled. Penolpe and Juliette may not be the closest sisters they used to be but she would do anything to protect her. It is with that in which we begin her story. On the eve of the Last Light Ball, Penelope has no choice but to take her sisters place and assume her identity in representing Grimsorrow house in the upcoming trials while unraveling the mystery behind the threat to Juliette’s life that has caused her to be in a poisoned slumber.

We have no idea who to trust nor do we know the reason why Juliette was targeted. Just as Penelope is thrust into this new environment so too are we. We meet our MMCs, Finn, Gray, and Hawthorne. Finn is immediately very likable, he is charming, flirtatious, and very much the golden retriever. On the opposite end we have Gray. He is mysterious, exudes power and control which he uses to garner his way. We don’t know much about him but you can’t help but be drawn in. And lastly, we have Hawthorne, Juliette’s betrothed. Hawthorne is serious, stoic, and strong. Penelope shares a connection with each of them and as the trials progress alongside the mysteries behind Juliette’s slumber, we get to uncover the secrets hidden beneath.

I truly went through all of the emotions reading this book!! I was giggling and kicking my feet up, on the verge of tears, anxious, and going through an emotional rollercoaster. My poor girl Penelope! There were so many moments that I was just praying that things went her way. She had to navigate so much in so little time and I genuinely felt like I was a part of her journey and growth. Overall, I truly enjoyed the story, the characters, the magic system, the emotions and the growth as we get closer to the end of the last page. There was never a dull moment and each page had me moving to the edge of my seat. The mysteries, the secrets, the chemistry between each of the characters, and the gossip kept me alive with attention and I genuinely think so many people are going to enjoy the world Amy Briar has created. The writing and the storytelling was incredible. She truly creates a world full of attention and detail that leaves you wanting more and is explained thoroughly throughout the book. Amy also does an incredible job in creating layers of depth within our characters that allow us to fully explore their personalities and the actions they take. I am so emotionally attached to our characters it’s not even funny! I seriously cannot wait for the next book especially after that ending; there’s just so much more to uncover!! Thank you again to Amy Briar for creating such a unique and beautiful world. 5/5 ⭐️
Profile Image for Kreela.
701 reviews26 followers
November 21, 2026
{Fantasy Trials; M/F but could be more; single POV}

I am a sucker for the ‘Body Swap’ trope. Secret sister. Person overlooked who is suddenly the main character. The underpowered heroine replacing the supposed chosen one. It doesn’t matter; I love this idea. Penelope is the opposite of her twin, who as the chosen heir is reserved and proper. But as twins may do, they sometimes have traded places just to have fun. I like that Penelope pretends to be the prim and proper sister when she tends to drink and have flings?

However, it’s a completely different scenario when your parents force you into trading places because dear sister Juliette is now Sleeping Beauty, and Penelope now has to attend a competition as the proper heir to save Juliette’s place and her prospective marriage. She is supposed to stay only long enough to make a graceful presence. Her power is limited. But of course Penelope decides to stay longer because she wants to find out what happened to her sister.

At the gathering Penelope meets three men: Hawthorne, Juliette’s fiancé, Finn, the easy-going party animal, and Grey Devereaux, the dark and mysterious character. Dark and mysterious is my favorite! Of course I suspected a Why Choose right away, but who knows? The story was finished but left a lot of room for a sequel or series.

The story has some mystery, several trials, and a steamy romance. Oh, the romance is perfect! Someone answered my prayers! I just love it when the attraction is obvious. Little touches. Crowding the girl. Slamming a hand against the wall and caging the girl. “Hm.” He leans in again, nose skimming my cheek. “I really don’t think you have a choice in the matter.” He shows up in her bed reading her smutty book 😁.

She’s unfortunately rude to him. But I love the uncertainty around whether he is using her or is truly attracted.

I should mention the other two men. Finn latches onto her immediately, which makes no sense to me, but the easy camaraderie works well. They almost have a fling. They spend quite a bit of time in bed and touching. I am not sure it’s a great idea to have sex with someone who might fool around, but they make a fun couple. Hawthorne starts out cold but later has his own sense of humor. I can see them as more friends than lovers.

😮‍💨 Writing Style:
I admit, I cringe when I detect the same elements that A.I. is known to use. There are passages that are too vague to make sense. Here is an example: “Their Legacy is the magic of light and illusion, making beauty persuasive and presence impossible to ignore.” Or “for letting myself get caught in his gravity and calling it strategy. “ Say what?

There are too many instances of threes and not this, but that. Some repetition could be removed to make the pacing flow smoother. And the beginning has too many partial sentences, but that fades as the writer gets more engaged in her writing.

Note that I am no writer and don’t have the lovely prose authors have. I loved this story despite occasionally cringing over the writing style. You may love it when I don’t.
32 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 5, 2026
Thank you to the author for the ARC!

This book is about a girl who has to take her twin sisters place in a Trial to prove her Legacies worth after her twin was poisoned. She must convince them all that she is her sister, form alliances, and pass the Trials, all the while looking for those involved in the poisoning to find the antidote.

The Characters:

We have four characters that we spend the most time with Penelope Grimsorrow being are main lead and then our three love interests; Bastian Hawthorne, Gray Devereaux, and Fin Winchester.

Penelope - Penelope is Julliette's twin, she hasn't been trained to be the heir of her house and her magic is Unbound which makes her control of shadows weaker and more unpredictable. Penelope is also said to be a lot of things. The things that she actually reads though are impatient, unbridled, and impulsive. They say she is the rebellious sister, but it doesn't really show. In fact she is led around and follows other people's lead A LOT. Throughout the story she is supposed to be pretending to be her twin and the only reason she succeeds is because no one really knows Juliette, but still she is very poor at pretending to be anything but herself. What she is good at is thoroughly tarnishing her sisters reputation by being caught alone and in compromising positions with multiple men who are not her betrothed.

Hawthorne - This is my preferred love interest. He is a Forcebinder and Juliette's betrothed. He is reserved, disciplined, quiet, and starts out rather cold. His arrangement with Juliette is arranged and neither of them were rather amenable to it. He starts out very cold and harsh towards Penelope, for good reason. He was forced into the arrangement and Penelope was doing a brilliant job of throwing his name through the mud with her shenanigans. But he warms, apologizes, and shows brilliant character growth. I truly hope she ends up with him.

Grey - Grey is my least favorite. He is the heir of Loxfell house and a Temperbinder. He is portrayed and the proverbial "shadow daddy". Cool, calculated, charismatic. His is being set up as an antagonist and spends the most sexual time with our FMC. He is also portrayed as omniscient and rather perfect and none of that is explained. I absolutely hate it.

Fin - If I must forfeit Hawthorne I would be fine with Fin. He is a Lightbinder with an abundance of sisters. The man is kind and charismatic, brilliant and playful and very willing to take a beating. In the beginning he seems rather shallow but by the end I'm not so sure.

What I liked:
- There are consequences for choices, very real consequences
- The world and magic system are dark and gritty and delectable.

What I didn't like:
- Maybe I am just fatigued by "deadly trials" but I didn't understand the reasoning for these.
- There seemed to be an unnecessary amount of smut that I think bogged things down.

Will I continue this series? Maybe
Profile Image for Tiffanyreads23.
54 reviews2 followers
November 9, 2026
Review of advanced copy received from author.

Oh my gosh, was this GOOD. I went into this with high hopes, and it didn’t take long for the story to pull me in.

Right away, we are introduced to the magical houses, divided competitors, and trials that determine which house comes out on top. The action kicks off with a ‘who done it’ mystery, a live-action game of Clue, if you will. Add in house scandals, secrets, and court intrigue. Amongst all that are the heirs competing in trials where each loss means someone gets voted out, and all five realms are watching it unfold as entertainment. Think Harry Potter meets Survivor meets Bridgerton. What more could you want?

The mystery was one of my favorite parts. I questioned everyone’s motives, revisited conversations, looked for clues, and came up with theories. Just when I thought I had something figured out, another piece of information sent me down an entirely different rabbit hole. I love when a book makes me an active participant in solving what’s happening.

The characters were a huge highlight! Finn immediately had my attention. He’s funny, carefree, and sunshine personified, but I couldn’t shake the feeling that his humor is a mask protecting a much softer heart. Gray had me questioning EVERYTHING. He’s suspicious, arrogant, and seemingly always one step ahead. And Hawthorne? Let’s just say his attitude had me wanting to throw the book more than once.

Penelope is really where my heart is. She’s trying to do what’s right for her house, uncover the truth about her sister, and hold on to herself in a world determined to tear her down. Beneath the persona everyone expects of her is someone who desperately wants to be seen for who she really is. Watching her navigate the cruelty and expectations placed on her was heartbreaking, which made seeing her recognize her own worth and stop seeking everyone else’s approval all the more satisfying.

The romantic dynamics are another thing entirely. Is it a love triangle? A square? A diamond? Honestly, I don’t even know, but between the attraction, jealousy, and questionable intentions, I was thoroughly entertained.

The trials create such an interesting dynamic. Power is a weapon, but it also makes you a target. Kindness and trust can be perceived as weakness. You have to protect your secrets, watch your back, and figure out who you can actually trust. Everyone has something to hide, and I never felt comfortable assuming I knew which side someone was on.

If you enjoy fantasy with political intrigue, house rivalries, murder mystery elements, competition, secrets, and complicated relationships, this one deserves a spot on your TBR. False Legacies had me theorizing, second-guessing, and emotionally invested from beginning to end—speaking of endings, UHM WHAT? I have so many questions. Because “it should have been impossible”…so why WASN’T it? I need the next book because I cannot be left like this. 😭
Profile Image for Erika.
64 reviews
November 22, 2026
Thank you to the author for this ARC in exchange for my honest review💫

The dedication stated: "For the vibe reading girlies who never want the tension to end".

And gosh, wasn't that the truth. From start to finish, we got to follow our FMC Penelope as she navigates the cutthroat environment of being a Legacy heir. The tension was everywhere.

And speaking of cutthroat... hellooooo the trials?! It always surprises me how authors manage to come up with such elaborate and complicated trials. I just sit there, reading in awe, over how clever and intricate these trials are.

Gonna be honest, I went into this book expecting a slightly darker romantasy with CW drama vibes. Somehow, my mind translated that into a book that was purely about the vibes, where the romance and tension would be the whole plot or at least a big part of it. Nothing wrong with that, and I was giddy to get into this book. But as I mentioned earlier, with the trials, this book is actually quite clever. It has an intricate political system, a unique magic system and rival houses with different types of magic. So the easy, breezy pacing I was expecting wasn't quite there. Not a bad thing at all, and it might just be a me thing, but I actually needed some time to settle into this book. I'd say the pacing is medium, though, because the ever present tension does keep things moving.

There's also this underlying mystery of who tried to kill her sister and I really love a good mystery. I did start to realize that I'm terrible at solving them, though, because at some point I suspected pretty much everyone in this book.

One thing the author absolutely nailed was the setting. Oh lord, was I thoroughly immersed in this book. The ballrooms, the glittering rooms, the food, the dresses, the trials... I could picture it all.

Our FMC Penelope is definitely an underdog, and that's my kind of character. She's wild and free, and she's punished for it. She's just such a fun character to follow. Then there are her three love interests and I had so much fun with that dynamic. They're all so different! We have the mysterious and charming one, the golden retriever one, and the stoic, serious one who apparently hides a softer side. And once again: THE TENSION 👀 The forbidden romance and attraction👀

Can't wait to see where the story goes in the next book, how they'll navigate everything, how she'll handle her new role and which direction her love life will take. It could go either way and I love it.
Profile Image for Sahar.a.
67 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 17, 2026
I was able to get this e book arc by applying through the authors arc sign up.
Many thanks again to Amy Briar for choosing me to read this arc, I felt so lucky to be chosen and seeing this arc in my email inbox 🤭.
I rate this book 5 stars because of how addictive this book was, it was hard put down because of the amount of drama and a lot of shocking things were getting uncovered.
I was intrigued by who Penelope would end up with, as well as what really happen with Juliette.

This was regency book with deadly trials I loved the concept of people with titles and privilege having to prove themselves in these deadly trials.
We really did get to see in this book the dynamics and the politics that were involved in taking part in these trials.
Like Juliette and other houses they did alot of scheming and forming alliances.
I found the other houses taking part in the trials were really ruthless and cruel with Penelope and I loved how Penelope stood up to them and really gave them the revenge they deserved.

I love seeing how Penelope aka Juliette was disguised as her sister for the deadly trials,
We seen Penelope had to act the complete opposite to herself, and it was interesting to see how she manages to pull it off and really get people convinced she is Juliette her twin sister not Penelope.
Having three love interest I did find excessive, but it was interesting to see in this book how three potential love interest worked.
I loved fin he was so cute,I loved how much he really had Penelope back in a lot the time of the trials and helping her out where he could . I really enjoyed Penelope scenes with fin he was interesting love interest and I was rooting for him and Penelope as a couple.

I will be honest with you I did get bad vibes from grey from the get go of this book, any time I see him get close to Penelope I was side eyeing him because he was so cheeky and rude to Penelope I just couldn’t cope with that tbh.
But of course read this book to find out if is right about him or not lol😅.

Overall, this was such a fun to read, I loved the plot it was not too predictable so was on regular surprised reading this book really guessing the direction plot would go.
omg the twist the end was best I loved the direction the book went near the end .
I can’t wait for book 2 I need it asap because it was a jaw dropping ending.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 139 reviews