Ariana Hollis believes in love. She reads it, debates it with her book club, The Read It and Weepers, and has even started writing her own romance novel. She just hasn’t quite found it for herself yet.
Macey McCormack doesn’t believe in love. As a behavioral scientist newly arrived in Everly Springs, she studies attraction, decision-making, and the patterns behind why people choose each other. Romance, as far as she’s concerned, is predictable—and rarely reliable. When her research leads her straight into the book club and opinionated Ariana, Macey proposes something A dating experiment.
Ariana agrees—on one condition. If they’re going to do this, they’re doing it right. Real dates. Real effort. No shortcuts. What begins as a controlled study quickly turns into something neither of them can quantify. Because while Macey is busy tracking variables, Ariana is starting to recognize the story unfolding in front of her—one she might not be able to keep separate from the one she’s writing.
And when the rules start to blur, both women are forced to confront the one variable neither of them accounted What happens when love refuses to follow the data?
Melissa Brayden is the multi-award winning author of more than twenty-five sapphic romance novels and is hard at work on more. She is a wine enthusiast, a fan of all donuts, and is probably staring off into space as you're reading this. You can find her at www.melissabrayden.com and on most social media sites.
The second this book popped up on my radar, I knew I had to read it right away! The idea of a behavioral scientist and an aspiring writer fake dating to prove whether love is something you can predict or control by manipulating certain variables? Now THAT's an interesting premise, and certainly not something you come across every day!
Let's talk about the characters first! Ariana was undoubtedly a ray of sunshine, but what I loved most was that she had plenty of backbone to go with it! She wasn't afraid to speak her mind, and she had this effortless way of lighting up every room she walked into. Out of the two, she was hands down the one I found easier to relate to. Macey, on the other hand, was her exact opposite. As a scientist, she was very much a woman of logic, and initially came across as introverted, rigid, and sometimes a tiny bit opinionated. But as we got to know her better, we started seeing these subtle glimpses of a much more vulnerable side. Deep down, she was attentive, adorably awkward, and even a little bashful at times. I thoroughly enjoyed discovering those softer sides of her because there was clearly so much more to Macey than the persona she showed everyone else!
Now, if there is one thing this story totally nailed, it was the found family vibe! Particularly when it came to the book club. I appreciated getting to catch up with the main characters from the previous novel and, presumably, meeting the leads of the next one too. It is always such a joy when authors bring back familiar faces like that. I utterly adored the banter between all the girls, and the way they discussed the books they'd been reading felt so natural and realistic. Their conversations were genuinely entertaining, and I found myself getting invested in their opinions just as much as I would in real reading sessions. But beyond the fun interactions, I adored how supportive they were of Ariana and Macey. These girls were always in each other's corners, and their wholesome friendship was easily one of the sweetest parts! I was also quite fond of the few moments we got between Macey and Doug. There was something so tender about their dynamic, and they seemed to understand each other on a different level, possibly because they were quite similar. I honestly would've welcomed more scenes with them because those moments gave us such a sweet peek into who Macey was underneath that more rigid exterior.
That being said, I think the novel left some of its potential unexplored when it came to the characters' personal growth, with Ariana being the biggest example. The opening chapters clearly highlight how much she cared for her aunt and how painful her passing was that I expected that grief to heavily influence the person she was becoming, but it kind of fades into the background. I think giving her more space to openly grieve on the page would have made her character arc feel so much richer! On the bright side, I sincerely appreciated that she eventually followed her aunt's wishes and picked a path that made her truly happy by pursuing her writing dreams! I just wish we’d been given a little more room to see what that decision actually meant to her on a deeper level, because those moments wrapped up a bit too quickly to let us fully live through that change with her.
To dive into Macey's individual journey, I have to start with the romance since the two go hand in hand! Something I deeply valued was the pacing of their relationship, as Melissa took her time building their connection without rushing things. In fact, it’s a slower progression than some of her other stories, which was right up my alley, though don't worry, it's not a tedious sloth burn either! Their banter was so much fun, especially when they went head-to-head at the book club, and I enjoyed getting to watch their chemistry develop over time. Still, I had one pretty noticeable issue with the fake-dating setup: it just felt kind of unnecessary in the grand scheme of things.
Ariana and Macey start planning dates to help with Macey's research into decision-making and whether love can be predicted, but I didn't feel like either of them really approached those dates as the experiment they had agreed to. Instead, those scenes felt mostly like an excuse to keep pushing them together for a little forced proximity. I was super excited about the idea of them testing their theories and trying to prove each other wrong, so I was disappointed that the scientific angle barely got any attention. And I kept thinking... wasn't that supposed to be the whole point?! Because once that part of the premise fell by the wayside, I started questioning what the fake-dating trope was actually bringing to the story.
Unfortunately, that also dulled the magic of their romantic buildup for me. The events bringing them closer grew pretty predictable, and some of their bonding moments felt a little too contrived rather than flowing effortlessly. It was such a letdown because I truly loved how authentic their connection was early on! Even the grand gesture toward the end didn't give me the swoony reaction I was hoping for.
And that brings me right back to Macey's growth. Considering how much her identity revolved around logic and researching love, I badly wanted to experience her internal struggle as she slowly realized she was falling for Ariana. Instead, her feelings seemed to hit her out of nowhere...one moment she was going about her life, and the next she had grasped the full extent of her feelings. That sharp shift made their romantic moments feel a little too neatly arranged instead of happening spontaneously. So, even when Macey finally embraced the idea that love is way more complicated than her data showed, I wasn't entirely won over by how she arrived at that realization.
At the end of the day, Can We Rewrite The Ending is an endearing opposites-attract romance with a fantastic found family dynamic, and I really liked that it gave us a deeper look at love than your standard romance novel usually offers. There is a lot to appreciate here, and I wouldn't be surprised at all if it becomes an absolute favorite for other readers. It didn't quite blow me away, sure, but I still had a genuinely great time reading it, and picking it up was definitely the right choice!
Thank you for the ARC, Melissa. This was one of those can't-put-down/stay-up-all-night-to-read books. I cried a couple of times and laughed out loud a lot. It was like I was in the book club. Haha.This is full of banter and a great friend group. I loved the main characters- two kind, unique people with a lot of depth and chemistry. There is a particular plot point related to grief that I absolutely loved because I could relate to it so much. I love a book that makes me FEEL and this hits on all notes.
I had no idea what to expect but I was sucked in very fast. I love the way Macey thinks and seeing her fall in love was fantastic. They were adorable together and I really appreicate that they never wondered if anything was for an experiment or not, they knew that they liked each other.
Thanks to Luna Literary and Melissa Brayden for the ARC of “Can We Rewrite the Ending?”
This was a worthy sequel to the first book in the series, “Can We Skip to the Good Part?” I really enjoyed that book and was excited to read the sequel.
Instead of including the blurb for this book, I wanted to spend more time mentioning what I loved about this book (and this series).
* I love Doug and Doug’s Books. Even though he’s not a Weeper, he is sort of the glue for the group. His bookstore was a big plot line in the first book, and he plays another part that helps propel the story. * The banter between all of the characters is what keeps me entertained. Everyone plays off of everyone and even the mundane conversations are enjoyable. * It was fun to read the characters take on all the different tropes we love, and kept us all guessing as to what tropes this book would utilize. * All of the side characters are so much fun. I think Bee is one of my favorites from this book. Plus the Candy land neighbors are something else, but Tamara is a joy! * The main trope we have is not exactly grumpy/sunshine, but more like opposites attract. The FMC’s are so different in how they approach love, romance, and attraction. It works really well in the novel. * I have had bosses/managers like Miriam and coworkers like Anthony. I could feel Ariana’s pain as she interacted with them and I was glad that Ariana stuck to her guns/principles and didn’t waiver.
This book is full of humor and I literally laughed out loud during the party at Rachel’s. The whole scene/situation was great and was one of my favorite parts of the book.
If you loved “Can We Skip to the Good Part?”, you will love this one as well. Brayden knocked this one out of the park and I can’t wait for the next book in the series.
First, I must say that I absolutely love the description of The Read It and Weepers book club. It would be a dream to be part of that one and get a chance to discuss books down to every detail on a weekly basis with your best friends and it’s for sure clear now that quite a successful dating scene. We had Max and Ella find each other in an We Skip to the Good Part and now we get an adorable love story between Ariana and Macey.
Macey is invited to the book club where the discussions are wild, and Macey and Ariana disagree about almost everything. Ariana is a true believer in romance but for Macey, that is a behavioural scientist, romance is just a hoax, she even runs a study on why people fall in love since she doesn’t get it. It’s clear that some chemistry between Ariana and Macey from the very beginning, but nothing really happens until Ariana’s aunt Pam tells her that she wants her to be happy just before she passes. Ariana leaves a job where she is not appreciated and decides to try to become a romance writer. However, she has not really had that much romance in her life, so she is convinced to test things via some fake dating with Macey that wants to test the whole romance idea for her study. Their objectives very different but very aligned and I loved that.
It’s awesome to follow their journey fake dating perhaps possible to be something real. However, it’s quite a challenge to know how to handle everything between a true believer that romance is real, Ariana, and a true sceptic, Macey, she really does not believe that romantic love is. It’s quite interesting that Ariana that never really has had any real romantic relationships is the believer and Macey that has had a long-term relationship is the one not believing. We find out why though and it makes total sense.
I received an ARC from the author and leave an honest review voluntarily.
I was truly surprised when I was able to read a reviewer's copy of book 2 in this Book Club series. This one took me by surprise, due to the emotional trials and tribulation the characters go through. All the characters in this story have grown strong in this second installment. Having two type A Personalties fit together well is rare, but each character learns to grow within themselves and for each other. The characters were written to play off each other and Melissa Brayden did it well. Her unique humor within her writing style just allows the characters to come into own.
I'm not sure how hard it was for the author to write this story, but there were times I was in Tears and in Aw all at once. Its the journey, that makes these romance stories flow. I loved this journey. I love this Book Club series and want to see more from the Weepers. I wish I had a book club like this one to participate in. As the series is written, you get to see each member express themselves and their opinion (some very strong opinions) about what they read that week without being harshly chastised and and thrown to the curb is just great. The friendship this group has and the way each character can play off each other really allow me as the reader to escape and just be in Aw. I know this is fiction, but it can still leave you feeling positive with those warm fuzzy feeling by the time you reach the end of the story.
I can't wait to listen to the audio version of Book 2. I want to hear the sass, the slap stick humor, the sadness and the Aw factor when the light bulb goes off in the characters head. Will the audio version hit as well as the physical written story reads.
Can't wait to see how Melissa Brayden brings book 3 to life in this series.
I nearly forgot how much I LOVE the Weepers! A good book makes you feel the whole spectrum of emotions and this one had it all! Macey McCormack- behavioral scientist looking to disprove the magic of love. Ariana Hollis- hopeless romantic that needs a HEA. No way that a dating experiment could go wrong- right? I laughed, I cried, I cheered, I gasped- literally all of it. (Where can I find a friend group like the Weepers and a Doug of my own?!?!?) The dual POV swaps kept me so entirely wrapped up in Macey and Ariana, but also gave some different perspectives of the other book club members. Sometimes flirty banter can be overdone but Melissa Brayden found a sweet spot. The writing had an amazing way of making me feel each shift between characters and the need to keep going to figure out what it means for them. I could not put this one down. The chemistry on the pages- and not just romantic- was everything! And- the office?!?!? IYKYK🥵
I love getting to be in this town with these people and this book club!!
Another wonderful love story this time between Arianna and Macey, I loved getting to read about these two falling in love despite their different opinions on it and seeing them take down the walls they’ve built in the past, with each other.
This was another cozy and easy read that I enjoyed thoroughly. I love getting to meet more characters in this universe and love getting to see the weepers and their found family/friendships!
Another ARC read from this author that I totally fell in love with!
We follow Macey and Ariana, two people who seem like complete opposites but actually have more in common than you’d think.
Love is complicated, especially when one is a scientific researcher and the other takes her research straight out of romance novels…
I really enjoyed getting to know these two and seeing how their story played out. Their differences made things even more fun, and I loved seeing them figure things out along the way.
Such a fun read, and another book from this author that I can happily recommend! ❤️
A cute romance set in the Read It and Weep universe. Ariana and Macey were well developed and their chemistry jumped off the page.
My only complaint is a couple of areas that could have done with some editing (characters that were in cars suddenly never having gotten in, etc) but overall an enjoyable read.
What do you get when you combine a woman who believes in romance and love, a woman who doesn’t believe in love and a little fake dating experiment??? You get Macey and Ariana in Can We Rewrite the Ending by Melissa Brayden. Ariana and Macey are complete opposites who deny their attraction…until they can’t. What happens when their experiment results in real feelings???
Received an ARC through Luna Literary and Melissa Brayden. Thank you!
A cute romance about how attraction sometimes happens regardless if you want it to or not (but they really do). I loved the chemistry between the two characters, seeing the relationship build and them going all in.
Definitely a great sequel to the series! I cannot wait to see what happens with Morgan.