5 stars for the "Colorado Chapters" trilogy, where I'll definitely be rating Books 1 & 2 with the same rating but will drop (reluctantly!!!) Book 3 down to 4 stars, simply because it left some incredible story-lines hanging (the death of Ignacio, the further adventures of, well, just about anyone, etc.) and jumped a bit fast from one scene to the next (e.g. Jack is riding away from a dire situation and suddenly Jack is with Cass at their parents' home). Otherwise, at the risk of being accused of hyperbole, this is the most beautiful dystopian series I have ever read. Yeah, you don't read that sentence all the time...
I am combining my reviews for all 3 books into a repeated (copy/paste) format simply because I did not take a break from the beginning of Book 1 until the end of Book 3. Well, that's not true, I think I stopped briefly between the end of Book 2 and the start of Book 3 simply because I was emotionally exhausted. These books will leave you that breathless and spent. Anyway, if you asked me to separate the actual books from the story-lines, I wouldn't be able to do it without a lot of prompts.
Yes, I generally love dystopian tales anyway (noting as well that this series does NOT include zombies no matter what someone posted on goodreads) but find they SOMETIMES too bogged down in either the jorney from point A to point B or with testosterone laden gun-play. Sure that has its place and there are damn good tales out there that follow this structure (see Nicholas Sansbury Smith et.al.). But every now and then, you'll come across a book that gets it so right - from how humanity nearly gets wiped out to the real effects on the survivors, from grief to the violence that arises to the hope (or lack thereof) that we eventually can embrace, no matter how tenuously. Another author I can put in this category would be Alice Sabo, who's "Changed World" books were amazing!
OK but enough small-talk. Kathy Miner has put together an incredibly believable, stunningly emotional and wildly ranging set of stories that shook me to my very core. I have - with no exaggeration or whatever you want to call it - never CRIED this much reading a set of books in my life. The characters are AMAZING, from the craziest to the most evil to all in between. Honestly, if these books don't pull you in and rip at your heart strings (or make you bellow on occasion in rage or frustration) then I would suggest this isn't the genre for you. Just looking back at how these characters evolve - from Naomi to Piper, Grace, Martin and even many of the bad guys, heck even many of the animals - still makes me teary-eyed!
Conclusion? These books are extremely!!! well-written, expertly structured, with edge-of-your-seat tension and sickening horror that is at least handled with as much 'taste' as can be managed under the circumstances (yes, there is sexual violence and some gore for those that don't follow and shy away from current events). Kids, I can't do these stories justice with my own words. I truly treasured this experience and will revisit them again some day. That good. I can only stress that I hope Kathy Miner is still writing. Just wow.