To review a book of short stories is a very difficult task. Always, the book contains some very good stories and some are just too plain. And just like any other book of short stories, this book was a mixed bag. There were some really powerful stories like, The Milk is Sour, Malli, Peaceful Are The Dead, etc, and some were good but too predictable or just too plain. But, overall, the book gives you an eerie feeling and leaves you long lost in Palem among its mysteries!
This book is written by one of my favorite authors, who writes fiction and fantasy so easily, that it almost feels real. He writes so beautifully, that it is impossible to leave the book and carry on with your lives. And even after you finish reading it, and try to go on with your life, it just pulls you back and keep you rooted in the stories. I've said this before and I say this again, reading a book by Sharath Komarraju just means a lifelong commitment to his stories and characters.
Coming to the stories, it is difficult for me to review all the ten stories separately, but it is possible for me to point out why I liked some stories more than the others.
The Ace of clubs, Malli, The Milk is Sour, Round and Round are definitely my favorites, because of how the story was told, how it provoked the coward inside me and I could find myself reaching for a support to finish through the stories. Other stories like The Sitarist of Palem, No Yellow in My Rainbow, The Barber and The Milmaid and Peaceful Are The Dead were good but predictable. I enjoyed reading them, no doubt, but the ending was very clear from the very beginning. The rest of the two stories were spooky, but having read a lot of horror, mystery books, they just seemed too plain.
Yet, these stories served the purpose of not just keeping the readers on edge but also to provide an insight in to the life of a village riddled with superstitions, ghost stories and myths, which to the villagers are true stories, which they live with.
Thank you Sharath for providing me a copy of this amazing book, I cannot wait to read your other works.