Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Offside

Rate this book
One app. One accidental match. One line they were never supposed to cross.

Sam Karter knows better than to hook up with a teammate.

Especially his defense partner.

Especially Landon Marks.

But after a lonely night on the road, Sam downloads Mixr looking for something uncomplicated. No names. No expectations. Just a little distraction from the pressure of hockey, the endless travel, and the parts of himself he’s never been brave enough to explore.

Then he matches with Landon.

At first, neither of them knows who is on the other side of the screen. The messages are easy. The flirting is addictive. And the chemistry is impossible to ignore.

Until they figure out exactly who they’ve been talking to.

Landon should be the last person Sam touches. They share a locker room, a defensive pairing, a team, and far too much of their lives. Crossing that line could cost them everything they’ve worked for.

But wanting each other has never been the problem.

Stopping might be.

Because some lines are meant to be crossed—and once they do, there’s no pretending they never happened.

Offside is a steamy MM hockey romance about secret hookups, forbidden desire, teammates who should know better, and two men discovering that the person they can’t stay away from might be the one person they can’t afford to lose.

217 pages, Kindle Edition

Published October 1, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Marina Bennett

8 books29 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
125 (28%)
4 stars
179 (40%)
3 stars
104 (23%)
2 stars
22 (5%)
1 star
7 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 79 reviews
Profile Image for Corey.
171 reviews5 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 20, 2026


Synopsis:
Sam has been traded every year since he entered the NHL, partly because it’s hard for him to connect with anyone. Landon is his new teammate who also stays to himself. The last thing either of them expected was to find themselves chatting over a hookup app...FOR MONTHS.

❤️ MM Sports Romance
🧡 Professional Hockey
💛 Teammates
💚 Queer Awakening
💙 Secret Identity
💜 Injury Recovery

Highlights:
- Landon calling Sam, Baby
- Their usernames
- They’re both Star Wars nerds
- A surprise piercing

Recommend?
Yes. This is a short, mildly angsty romance that makes up for the yearning with plenty of sweet moments and a touch of spice.

❤️🧡💛💚💙💜

"Offside" by Marina Bennett is an MM Hockey romance between teammates Landon and Sam. However, their relationship doesn't start on the ice. It starts on a hookup app while at an away game.

With anonymity and the ability to be themselves, the pair form a fast friendship that soon turns romantic.

But in the real world? Neither of them realize that the man playing at their side, is the same one they're in love with.

Ratings:
Overall: 4/5 Hearts - I really liked this book. Dare I say, I think I liked it a little more than book one. It feels a bit more polished and put together!

Spice Quantity: 2/5 Peppers - I'm guessing that spice takes up about 10-15% of the total page count.

Spice Quality: 4/5 - The spice is really good. For me, the only thing that's preventing it from being a 5 is that most of the spice is solo action with texts, pictures, and video from the partner. Which makes perfect sense for the plot. But I would have preferred less detail/open door scenes during that portion of the plot and had more scenes of the boys physically together at the end.

But that's all personal preference.

Plot: 4/5 -
- Storyline: The storyline was going just about how I expected to until one of the characters figured out the other's identity. At that point, it felt a little convoluted for me. But I'll talk about that in a minute, because I'm dubbing that a character growth moment.

Other than little hiccup, I think the pacing was perfect, giving the reader just enough info at just the right time. The story never felt slow or rushed. I also enjoyed that this little world has been expanded outside of college hockey.

- Characters: Okay, so there's a point in the story where one of the characters realizes who they've been talking to online. They go about handling that situation in the most convoluted way possible that had me going "WTH". But then I remembered that the character is 23 years old and I also did some dumb @ss sh!t at 23. And there's consequences to that bad decision! I'm calling that characterization and growth!

Separately, both characters have different fears/expectations about their life and how they want to live it. I really enjoyed seeing them challenge those feelings and by the end, they've gotten closer to overcoming them. But they're not DONE, even in the epilogue you can see them continuing to progress. So I left the story feeling like both Landon and Sam were organic and real. Like they were two humans trying their best to understand themselves and be proud enough to shout it from the rooftops.

- Writing Style: I liked the writing a lot better in this book versus book 1. It felt smoother and more immersive. Like the words melted into my brain instead of me actually reading them.

That makes me so excited to see more of this author/series and to really appreciate the growth and improvement as time goes on.


❤️🧡💛💚💙💜

If you enjoyed this review, please follow me over on Instagram: @rainbow.reviews.mm
I share reviews with half-decent graphics, new release promos, and reading updates.

Profile Image for Jine.
560 reviews16 followers
September 12, 2026
I loved this so much! It had one of my favourite tropes in anonymous texting! I read both books back to back I love when the author includes previous couples in a new book! This book is about Sam and Landon! Sam is straight and Landon is gay but not out in public! Sam just got traded back to the sharks and Landon has been with the team for 2 years!
They don’t get off to a great start Landon is sort of standoffish but they start messaging each other on this app not knowing who the other one is! Their relationship on the app is so adorable! Landon is so reassuring to Sam who’s figuring things out and everything is very platonic until one day when Sam lets Landon say whatever he wants to him!that’s when Landon discovers Sam has a praise kink! So they are falling for each other on the app and they have plans to meet eventually but everything crashes down for Sam when he goes to see Landon because he got hurt in a game and he sees Landon’s leg tattoo and he knows that’s who he’s been talking too! So of course he panics and he deleted the app for a full month but he has to see Landon suffering and Ash gives him some advice to try and get Landon to fall for Sam but not the Sam on the app but Sam folds and reinstalls the app and Landon takes him back with the condition of meeting in person in 2 months! Landon now has his boyfriend back and Sam as his best friend! So we all know it’s gonna come out obviously but I didn’t expect it to happen like it did! When Sam said Landon’s screen name in front of him! The scream I scrumpt! The resulting fight was so bad and I hated the tension!
They managed to work through everything but it wasn’t easy because Landon couldn’t meld the two together just yet
I loved them both so much! I love that we got to see more of Ash and Thayer!
Ash was so unhinged and I loved that so much! I like that ash and Sam became friends because ash didn’t have anyone in book 1 and Sam really didn’t In this one!
I can’t wait to read the rest of the books!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Holly Deacon.
254 reviews5 followers
October 2, 2026
✨️ARC REVIEW ✨️

I loved the whole anonymous-messaging setup in this one! 😍 Sam and Landon are teammates who don’t exactly see eye to eye in real life, so when they unknowingly match on Mixr, neither of them has any idea that the person they’re flirting with is the guy standing right beside them every day. And honestly… watching that slowly unravel was SO much fun. 😂

Sam and Landon completely stole this book for me. Their relationship starts with all those anonymous messages, teasing, flirting and late-night conversations, and I loved how they gradually became comfortable with each other without all the pressure that comes with knowing exactly who they were talking to.

I especially loved seeing their relationship develop from something casual and anonymous into something genuinely meaningful. There’s plenty of yearning, awkwardness and please just realise who you're talking to already! moments 😂, but underneath all of that is a really sweet emotional connection.

Landon was absolutely adorable, and his little “Baby” moments with Sam? 🫠 I was DONE. And Sam’s journey of figuring himself out and understanding what he wants added another layer that made their romance feel much more personal.

I also loved all the little things that made them them—the nerdy Star Wars conversations, the teasing, the growing trust and that feeling of slowly becoming each other’s safe place. 🥹

I loved watching them grow and develop feelings for each other as Sam and Landon, not just Metal and Knight.

Looking forward to what's next.
Profile Image for Heather O'Dell.
97 reviews8 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 10, 2026
---SUMMARY:
Sam has been traded back to the Sharks: his fifth trade in five years, back to the team where he started. Embarrassing as it is to never have a team to call home, it’s made worse by Sam’s loner nature. Not to mention, he doesn’t have a love life because whenever he’s been with women before, it’s never been anything special. But he is awfully lonely.

Sam ends up living with Ash, one of the team’s goalies, an openly bisexual man who is in a public relationship with a retired player on the team, Thayer. Sam had known Thayer when he played with the sharks before, and was surprised to hear that he was gay and in a relationship with a current player. But none of that matters to Sam; he isn't homophobic. He and Ash start a tentative friendship, which is not easy with Sam being such a loner by nature.

That said, he is awfully curious about how his new roommates realized that they were into guys, and he is lovelorn at the way the two men seem to love each other so much.

Landon is in his second year as a defenseman with the Sharks. He thinks Sam, the new defense player, is hot, but he won’t do anything about that. Only his immediate family knows he is gay and he is not coming out while playing pro sports; it’s just too much attention off his game and on his private life, which he prefers to keep quiet. That said, he too is getting lonely.

One night, both men are on Mixr (the series’ Grindr pseudonym). Thayer had suggested that Sam try it out, but when it came time to choose between straight and bisexual, bi felt more real, even though he had never even thought of being with a guy before. But something about seeing Ash and Thayer’s love was hitting him hard. Somehow, fate has Sam and Landon chatting on Mixr, though they are using fake names, and though Sam is nervous and kind of clueless, he lets himself enjoy the conversation. And the conversations continue and get steamier over time.

Will Landon ever want to meet his chatting partner in person since he feels like he has to stay in the closet while he is in pro hockey?
Will Sam ever find himself comfortable with the attraction he is feeling for a man on top of being a pro athlete and all the collateral trouble that could cause?
And what would happen when they found out that they were actually teammates?

---REVIEW:
This was a quick read: one night, several hours, and I was thrilled with it. I couldn’t put it down, though my eyes were burning! And it made me cry twice. The characters are multi-layered and interesting for such a short read, and the drama that unfolds kept the pages turning for me well into the night. There was medium spice, quite a bit of hurt, and a happily ever after that made me RELIEVED! The first book in this series is the story of Ash and Thayer, and now I need to read that, but this book was just awesome.

This novella is a winner! 5/5
170 reviews5 followers
October 25, 2026
This book is an MM romance between Sam, a hockey player recently traded back to his first team and Landon, a closeted hockey player who is tired of feeling so alone

Tropes/Highlights:
-MM
-Open Door
-Teammates To Lovers
-Dating App Flirting
-Injury Recovery
-Secret Identity
-Slow Burn
-Friends To Lovers
-Hockey Romance
-HEA


Likes:
-Texting convos
-Star war references
-Not so meet cute as teammates
-Praise
-Caretaking
-Ash
-Tattoos
-Sam's sound effects/shy nature
-Away game
-Flirting
-Epilogue


Quotes:
-"I hated that I kind of needed a babysitter for something as basic as making friends"
-"You're such a good boy for me, Metal. I'm so proud of you"
-"Now was so not a good time for my dick to be joining the conversation, but it was fighting"
-"Your show, baby. I'm just...completely fucking yours at this point, so use me however you want"
-"I'm going to baby you until the end of time because I like doing it–no injury required"


This is the first time book I have read from this author and it was so cute! I couldn't stop gigging at these two and how sweet they both were. I loved watching them slowly fall for each other and the drama of realizing who they were in real life was so entertaining. If you want to read about one MC who is lonely but comfortable in the closet and not looking for anything more than a good time and another MC who is definitely straight (wink) who struggles to make friends and is just looking for connection, then you will love this book.
22 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 16, 2026
OMG, this was so cute. I’ll be honest., slow burn is not usually my jam. But I actually really enjoyed watching these two get to know each other through messaging. Watching them form their emotional connection before they found a physical connection. The way they fell for each other in all those text messages was beautifully written. I also really enjoyed the way they navigated through reality crashing through their anonymous bubble. It was messy and heartbreaking, but the emotional payout was absolutely worth it. This was genuinely just such a sweet read. 🩷
Profile Image for Tasha Thrall.
312 reviews1 follower
October 20, 2026
Oh my gosh, what an amazing shirt paired with a lovely book! I really enjoyed how they connected through the app. I could see why he desired that link, but it was tough to read as it caused strain on their relationship and trust.

I also appreciated how they remained discreet together while being open with their families and, now, their teammates.
Profile Image for Mikki.
19 reviews
November 12, 2026
This is book 2 in the Penalties Series and like book 1, I was not disappointed. I read a lot of books with dark themes but sometimes I need a good fluffy, heart-warming read. This was that for me. It’s a slow burn and I love that for this series. No over-the-top spice but when it’s spicy…. It’s spicy! It is super fun and easy to read and this series is a must for your TBR.

Patiently waiting for book 3 because I know it will be just the perfect read when I need fluffy.

💕🏒🥅🌶️🌶️
Profile Image for Mal.
81 reviews
November 13, 2026
I liked Sam and Landon, really, but in what world would it ever be ok to lie to your partner like that? I obviously knew the whole plot like 30 pages in, with this trope it's easy to guess what's going to happen immediately which I don't love but I ate it up. Genuinely, the pacing was perfect and the characters were good, I liked seeing Ash and Thayer and I'm excited for the next book.
Profile Image for S__books__.
368 reviews2 followers
October 10, 2026
Landon (knight) & Sam (metal)
Cute
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for J*ay*yo*J.
687 reviews14 followers
Did Not Finish
October 28, 2026
Interesting tropes but the story was kind of underwhelming and boring. It didn’t help that both MCs were rather bland to me.

Reverse tropes: smaller top/bigger bottom

Profile Image for Shelle Pennington.
807 reviews3 followers
November 10, 2026
So I kinda read this book out of order but I don't think it's going to change anything in my mind about this book. Landon and Sam spent the whole book figuring themselves and final them as a couple. Everything else was sprinkles on the cake. I didn't need the read Ash bc I was happily in the Landon-Sam-verse. Very low angst. Nice palette cleanse after a hardcore heartbreaking tale.
Profile Image for Erica.
310 reviews1 follower
October 3, 2026
Man, I really wanted to like this and I just didn’t. I feel like the reveal could have been done better? The time jumps were odd. I loved the anonymous texting and all the Star Wars references, but it just was amiss for me.
Profile Image for M.E. Byrd.
180 reviews1 follower
November 8, 2026
I really enjoyed this read and it was 100% the characters and their balance. However, the books almost lost me 56% in when Sam makes an unexpected bad decision that didn't feel true to him. I get desperation and fear of loss but it just didn't feel right from him. Additionally, the climax and ending felt a little rushed--still enjoyable but I would have liked it to be a little more developed.

Still highly recommend this read! I would reread!
4 reviews
October 5, 2026
This felt very rushed to be written. I felt like I was missing so much I had to go back to make sure I didn't skip pages or something. Nothing was even happening in this book. It just fell so flat for what it could have been. The concept is good but the execution was just really poor.
Profile Image for Natalie Reed.
62 reviews1 follower
September 13, 2026
⭐️⭐️.5

This one just wasn’t for me. It wasn’t a bad story and the concept was good but something was off for me.
I didn’t really like either MC. Sam was a liar who made all of the wrong choices. Landon was just kind of a pushover weenie with no backbone. Neither of them attempted to use their critical thinking skills and not having strong social skills doesn’t mean you’re a dummy head who can’t determine right from wrong. Also multiple break ups in a romance novella wasn’t something I enjoyed. The book was too short for that kind of drama.

The character art on the authors instagram is killer though. I really wanted to like this one based off of the art but it just wasn’t my cup of tea.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Agata Cieciuch.
18 reviews
October 12, 2026
Did I start it at 1 a.m. and stay up until almost 4:30 because I’m a slow reader? Yes, I did. Did I drink two Monster energy drinks the next day to get through work? Yes, I did. Was it worth it? Yes, it was.

I really, really liked the first book about the goalie (because I’m obsessed with goalies), and this one was also such a fun read.

This is Sam and Landon’s story, and they’re both pretty much loners on their San Jose hockey team. Landon is gay, but only his family knows, and he’s scared that coming out could ruin his career. Sam keeps getting traded from team to team, never staying anywhere long enough to settle down. I really felt for him. Coming back to San Jose means returning to a familiar place, but also to the team that traded him away in the first place. I liked that he was happy and miserable about it at the same time.

After seeing Ash from book one with his boyfriend, Sam realises he wants that kind of closeness too. He’s never really felt attracted to women or men, but decides to try something new and downloads a dating app. There, he starts talking to Knight, who is actually Landon. Neither knows who the other is.

Their conversations were probably my favourite part. They’re two lonely, socially anxious guys who suddenly have someone to talk to about Star Wars and nerdy stuff. I really liked watching them get comfortable with each other and build that friendship. Meanwhile, they’re paired together on the ice and struggling to work together because they barely talk. Knowing how close they’re getting online while they can’t seem to click in person made it even better.

It’s a pretty slow burn, with more focus on the emotional connection than the physical side of their relationship. That worked really well for me. I just wanted them to have that closeness they’d both been missing.

Spoilers ahead!

There is a happy ending, thankfully, but you have to go through some heartbreak to get there. A lot happens in around 200 pages, and I really enjoyed it, even when it made me sad.

Two books in, and I’m definitely looking forward to more from Marina Bennett. Next time, I should probably start earlier in the evening.

P.S. Full disclosure: I’m very dyslexic, and English isn’t my first language, so I use ChatGPT to help with spelling, grammar, and organising my thoughts into clearer English. All the opinions, feelings, and late-night reading decisions are mine. 🖤
Profile Image for Camille.
42 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 16, 2026
ARC Review
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐.75/5
Spice: 🌶️🌶️

If you haven't read The Penalty series yet, do yourself a favour and go read Goalie Interference, then jump straight into this one next. The books are interconnected even though they are standalones, and are definitely best read in order.

Sam and Landon are so freaking cute together and their love story is a little unconventional at first. You can expect a queer-awakening, demi-rep, online dating app, a lot of nerdy Star Wars references and some great banter.

Sam is my wittle baby that I want to protect from the world for ever and ever. He is not great at making friends, definitely struggles with social anxiety and finds sexual attraction a mystery (at first). Luckily he makes friend with Ash (and Thayer by association) and discovers a great app called Mixr that allows him to make a connection with a really sweet guy called BaskarKnight.
Turns out Sam is actually falling for his hockey teammate Landon. What?? No one saw this coming right?!

Landon is the guy who keeps everyone at a distance and despite knowing he's been gay his whole life, he's never dated another man and only had meaningless sex with strangers he met on Mixr. Everything changes when he meets MetalMonkey and he realises this might be the first meaningful connection he makes with another man.

What ensues is a lot of flirting, falling in love without having never met the person on the other side of the app, and then the inevitable moment when everything comes crashing down on you when you realise who the love of your life really is.

Would I have made the same choices as Sam comes THE time? Probably not, but I'm also 15 years older than him and I understand what being young and inexperienced and overwhelmed feels like.
And you might yell "Sam this is a bad idea!" at the book, but rest assured that in the end everything works out, and our boys get their HEA.

The (minor) reasons why I didn't rate this a full 5-star:
I felt the first 2 or 3 chapters didn't have the pace of her previous book and I struggled a little bit to connect with the MCs at first, but from chapter 3 onwards I was hooked. So if you feel the same at first when you pick up this book, give it a chance anyway and you won't regret it.
And the epilogue kinda left a bit to be desired but I'm sure we'll get to see Sam and Landon again in the next books of the series.

I had the chance to chat with the author while reading her book and drop my live reactions on our chat, which was a lot of fun. Thanks Marina for entertaining my crazy commentary 😆
Profile Image for Anisha Choudhury |  A Literary Autopsy.
362 reviews8 followers
October 24, 2026
Disclosure: I received a complimentary eARC of Offside by Marina Bennett in exchange for an honest review.

Offside by Marina Bennett is a steamy M/M hockey romance releasing as the second installment in The Penalty series. The story follows Sam Karter, who downloads an anonymous hookup app looking for distraction from the pressures of professional hockey, only to accidentally match with his defense partner, Landon Marks. While Landon has always known he is gay—supported by his family, though privately guarding his personal life from the intrusive sports media lens—Sam has always believed he was straight, until his conversations with Landon change everything. After Sam discovers Landon's identity, a brief web of anxious secrets, a deleted app, and a month of hesitant friendship lead to a confrontation when the truth finally comes to light.

Bennett delivers an exceptionally smooth, breezy read that refreshingly skips any heavy-handed angst regarding sexuality. Landon is entirely comfortable in who he is, and Sam's journey beautifully culminates in wonderful demisexual representation by the epilogue. The primary conflict is grounded in communication missteps about when Sam recognized Landon, leading to a brief, understandable fallout before they work it out like adults.

The book shines by keeping the focus on the sweet, cozy chemistry between a grumpy/sunshine pairing that is undeniably adorable together. The banter is sharp, the close proximity creates delicious tension, and the resolution is handled with emotional maturity rather than manufactured drama.

Offside is a joyful, low-stress triumph of sports romance. If you love secret app matchmaking, teammates-to-lovers, zero-angst queer acceptance, and demi rep, this is a must-read.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Paige.
80 reviews1 follower
October 9, 2026
Offside by Marina Bennett

Offside follows Sam and Landon, two professional hockey players who are both struggling with loneliness in their own ways. When they start talking anonymously on a hookup app, they find a connection neither of them expected. But things get complicated when their online relationship starts crossing into real life, and figuring out what they want isn't as simple as it seems.

I really liked how different Sam and Landon are, while still understanding each other in ways they struggle to explain. Sam's awkwardness and uncertainty made him easy to sympathize with, while Landon's guarded personality had me wanting to know what was going on in his head. Their connection was sweet, messy, and sometimes genuinely frustrating to watch unfold.

What stood out to me most was the loneliness beneath all the banter and flirting. I liked that the story explored identity, vulnerability, and the fear of letting someone get too close. There were moments when I wanted to shake both of them and tell them to just TALK, but honestly, that's part of what made their relationship feel complicated.

The writing is casual, funny, and easy to get into, with dual POVs that let us understand both sides. The pacing kept the story moving, although some of the emotional back-and-forth felt a little drawn out.

Overall, this was a mix of hockey romance, secret identities, awkward feelings, and two people trying to figure themselves out while falling for each other. If you enjoy M/M sports romance with emotional tension and plenty of banter, this one might be worth picking up!
Profile Image for Niki L.
172 reviews
October 8, 2026
ARC read!

Two helpless nerds. One online connection. Zero ability to recognize their own feelings.

Honestly? I love when characters are their own worst enemies. 😂

A fun MM sports romance because Sam and Landon have that perfect “everyone else sees it except them” energy. They meet online without realizing who the other person is, and then proceed to fall directly into feelings while somehow missing the giant flashing neon sign saying “HELLO, YOU ARE IN LOVE WITH YOUR TEAMMATE.”

Like boys. Please. The call is coming from inside the house.

I loved the balance between them. Sam’s grumpy-on-the-outside-but-secretly-a-total-softie energy paired so well with Landon’s sweet cinnamon roll vibes. They both have their own insecurities and fears, but their connection feels natural rather than forced. The yearning is there, the chemistry is there, and watching them slowly figure themselves out was such a good time.

I loved the demisexual rep here and how naturally it was woven into the story. The bi awakening also felt genuine rather than like a checkbox moment, which I always appreciate. Also, somehow making sexting an actual interesting plot element should earn a medal because I was absolutely invested.

A sweet, spicy, slightly ridiculous romance about two men who needed approximately 47 business days to realize what everyone else who looked at them knew.
Profile Image for Brooke Ishly.
82 reviews9 followers
October 9, 2026
Offside by Marina Bennett

Offside follows Sam and Landon, two professional hockey players who struggle with loneliness, relationships, and being honest about their sexuality. When they connect through an anonymous app, their conversations become something more, but keeping their online identities separate from their real lives creates complications.

I liked how both characters have their own insecurities and reasons for keeping people at a distance. Sam is awkward and guarded, while Landon hides behind a tough exterior because he is afraid of what being open could cost him. Their connection develops through playful messages and honest conversations, making their relationship feel personal. I also enjoyed the humour, especially in the banter between the characters.

Marina Bennett’s writing is casual, funny, and easy to follow. The dual perspectives help us understand both sides of the relationship, although some emotional struggles and misunderstandings are repeated enough to slow the pacing. At times, the characters' decisions can be frustrating, particularly when a simple conversation could prevent a lot of hurt.

Overall, I enjoyed the mix of hockey, humour, and emotional conflict. It isn't always a smooth romance, but the focus on trust, identity, and the fear of being known makes it an engaging read for fans of M/M sports romance.
Profile Image for Aster.
72 reviews
September 13, 2026
Thanks to the author, Marina Bennett, for providing an ARC.

This took me by surprise. Truth be told, for a good 50% I expected it to be another 3 star read, and so it was until we got past that middle portion and inching closer and closer to the end and the resolution fo the overall conflict at hand (and basically reading unfold twice, at that, something that I also didn't expect to enjoy as much as I did) that it struck me that I spent the entire day reading this and couldn't put it down at all. It executed the premise in a way that felt appropriate for our characters and their overall personalities, as well as it tackle the whole "to come or not to come out" conversation as it relates to professional sports and one such as hockey at that.

However, this book needed another fifty to a hundred pages. There are things that could've been fleshes out a lot more in order to add considerable depth to the relationship of our protagonists in all of the phases that they went through, and it all ends rather abruptly and almost confusingly.

Regardless, this is a very fun and easy read to recommend! If you like the "will they/won't they" dynamic and seeing how long a pretense can go on (and extend!) until it all goes crashing down, this is definitely a book for you!
Profile Image for Kenz Rosewood.
200 reviews9 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 15, 2026
Ugh Lando and Sammy are just the ABSOLUTE CUTEST

What could go wrong when you unknowingly match with your teammate on a hookup app? Well a lot when you realize he IS your teammate, but theres also so many beautiful moments of you falling in love with each other!

Lando loved and cared for his Sammy so much before he even knew who he was, watching the giant vampire (as Sam would describe him haha) hockey player unknowingly help his teammate discover his sexuality and slowly fall in love was SO beautiful.

Sam is just a bundle of socially anxious nerves after being traded back to the team that drafted him, but baby boy is just the sweetest! He wants so much to make a good impression on Lando, which turns into him hitting him in the face with a puck as a first impression haha. Watching him discover his identity slowly was so perfect cause for some people it doesn't happen overnight, and the way Lando took time to get to know Sam before anything sexual happened 🤌🏻 i love them so much!

If you love

🏒 teammates falling in love
📱 demi representation
🏒 secret identities (anonymous messaging app)
📱 secret relationship
And
🏒self discovery

Then pick up Offside by Marina Bennett October 26th!

For the best reading experience read Ash and Thays story in Goalie Interference
Profile Image for Crowofstories .
8 reviews
October 8, 2026
Offside by marina Bennett

🏒MM Romance
📱Hockey Romance
🏒Teammate to Lovers
📱Secret Identity
🏒Friends to Lovers
📱Dating App Romance
🏒Demi Rep

Sam Karter knows better than to hook up with a teammate.
But after a lonely night on the road, Sam downloads Mixr looking for something uncomplicated. No names. No expectations. Just a little distraction from the pressure of hockey, the endless travel, and the parts of himself he's never been brave enough to explore.
Then he matches with Landon. His Defense partner.
At first, neither of them knows who is on the other side of the screen. The messages are easy. The flirting is addictive.
And the chemistry is impossible to ignore.

Offside is a steamy MM hockey romance about secret hookups, forbidden desire, teammates who should know better, and two men discovering that the person they can't stay away from might be the one person they can't afford to lose.

These two had me in heart eyes throughout the book. Their easy banter, both via text and on the ice just hits perfectly. Both boys are socially awkward and do not make friends easily and it shows 🤭 Sam slowly figuring out what label works best for him is super adorable and the boys nerding out over Star Wars was so cute to read 😍😍
Profile Image for maila.
100 reviews
October 13, 2026
Loving these cute little novellas

Definitely my favourite of the Penalty Series so far
After an accidental match on an app, unknowingly, Sam and Landon, teammates who can’t seem to connect on the ice, end up connecting through anonymous messages. What begins as flirty and ends up becoming steamier, neither know the other is a teammate …until they do and lines are crossed and things get complicated

Sam was such a sweet and innocent guy, he struggled to make connections with people and had a longing to have a special someone beside him. Seeing Ash/Thayer (book 1), there was a longing to have that, a relationship but not with a man as Sam was so sure he was straight. Appearances from Ash were amusing, and his growing friendship with Sam was nice to see.
Landon was closeted, had no interest of coming out, especially in the hockey world, but used the app to find some anon hookups when travelling with the team. He was much more sure of himself and his life than Sam. Both complete opposites yet somehow, they worked. They bonded so beautifully; they shared laughs, geeked out over Star Wars and even the anonymous transition from friends to more, it was so natural, didn’t feel forced. It was just a nice little read.

Profile Image for 369Pages.
1,001 reviews91 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 13, 2026
3.75⭐️
Landon and Sam are new teammates, and don’t get along great on the ice. It takes a lot for them to warm up to each other. Meanwhile, both are anonymously texting someone on the Mixr app, and catching feelings for a guy they don’t even really know.

This book has:
-hidden identities (anon apps)
-secret relationship
-first times and self discovery
-hockey teammates
-Demi rep

I definitely enjoyed this book even more than the first, and the hidden identity aspect of it made it tense! The majority of the book has both of these guys completely not knowing who they’re talking to online, which just makes it all the more interesting. If you love a good hidden identity and anonymous texting/relationship, kind of book, then you’re really going to eat this one up.

Compared to the first book, I feel like there were some improvements with the pacing of the story, but I still feel like these books could be better if the relationship and characters were hash out a little bit more.

If you want some quick and easy hockey romance books, then definitely don’t miss out on this One.
Profile Image for Connor.
6 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 30, 2026
Okay, I need to start by saying that coming straight off the high of the first book and diving into this one could not have been more perfect. The way this story, despite focusing on two new male stars, completely melts into the first book is just SO good.

We also get a continuation of Ash and Thayer’s story from Goalie Interference. Yes, it’s more in the background this time, but I’ll take it! And seeing Ash grow into the best friend and sidekick we get here just shows how much his character has developed since we first met him.

Then we have two new characters you can’t help but instantly fall for. Sam, aka Metal, is honestly so relatable to me in so many ways — shy, nerdy and introverted. And then there’s Landon… sexy, mysterious, covered in tattoos and very much a loner. 😍 Say less.

I absolutely loved the online romance aspect of this book, especially having experienced that world myself. Even down to the fictional app Mixr, which I love to hate… or is it hate to love? 👀

The chemistry between these two goes head-to-head with Ash and Thayer’s in the first book, and trust me, there is spice. A LOT of it. You do not, I repeat, DO NOT want to miss that.

But what I loved most was the underlying theme of self-acceptance and discovery. There’s so much more beneath the heat, and I really enjoyed watching both characters navigate that alongside everything else.

I don’t want to say much more without giving the entire story away, so I’ll leave the rest for you to discover yourselves.

And if you haven’t read Goalie Interference yet, it's a must!

In the meantime, I’ll be over here waiting… not so patiently… for part three. 😈
Profile Image for Heather.
80 reviews
October 3, 2026
I always enjoy coming back to hockey romance, and this novella was no exception. Sam and Landon are extremely cute together, and I would have loved to have had more of their story in a longer book.

Sam and Landon are hockey players on the same team, and although they are friendly, they don’t really gel as friends or teammates. But what they don’t realize is that they are messaging with each other anonymously on a hookup app while starting to fall for each other.

I enjoyed the premise of Sam and Landon falling in love over an app without realizing who they were messaging. Through their messages, you really get to see Landon’s softer side and see Sam being vulnerable and open about his questions about his sexuality. And the banter between them is lots of fun. There were definitely times I wanted to grab Sam and shake him for the choices he made, but things work out in the end and they get their HEA.

Now I need to go back and read Ash and Thayer’s story in the first novella in this series. And I hope to see more of Sam and Landon in future books.
Profile Image for Jay T.
86 reviews1 follower
October 6, 2026
This was such a surprisingly good read and I genuinely had a great time with it.

The anonymous texting between Sam and Landon was easily one of my favourite parts. I loved how they could be more honest with each other through their aliases.

The fact that they were teammates in real life but didn't realise who they were texting was hilarious 😂

The slow burn and anticipation of them connecting the dots had me hooked. I also really appreciated the demisexual representation because this was my first time reading it in an MM romance 💖🥺

The hockey storyline was well balanced with the romance, friendships (absolutely love Sam and Ash's friendship 🫶🏾 I didn't know I needed that) and emotional struggles.

Sam's journey with his sexuality, loneliness and learning to lean on people really got to me 🥹 I loved the hurt/comfort, communication and the beautiful connection these two built.

This was a beautiful, angsty hockey romance with a clever structure that I would definitely recommend ❤️

Gonna miss Knight and Metal by the way 🤭
Displaying 1 - 30 of 79 reviews