This review originally appeared on Novel Ink.
I’ll admit that I have some conflicting thoughts about this book. This is the Story of You follows a teenage girl named Mira as the tiny island she calls home is unexpectedly struck by a devastating storm. I’m truly not sure where to begin with my thoughts on this book, because, well, nothing really happens in the story. I mean, a number of separate events occur, but the author fails to connect them in any way or provide context for the reader re: why we should care.
Most of my conflicting views on This is the Story of You stem from the fact that I LOVED Kephart’s writing. The prose is lyrical and so lovely. It almost makes the novel read like poetry; the author truly seems to have a mastery of the English language. However, I feel that this beautiful writing was often used to mask the glaring plotholes and lack of substance in the story itself. All of the characters, from Mira, to her family, to her “year-rounder” friends, are severely underdeveloped. I especially felt like Mira’s younger brother, Jasper Lee’s, chronic illness/disability was used as a plot device, which made me incredibly uneasy. Additionally, there were a few characters introduced toward the end of the book that seemed to add nothing to the story, even though I got the impression that they were supposed to hold some significance (though it was never clear what).
As for the plot itself, as I mentioned briefly above, it just doesn’t go anywhere. I was excited to read this book because my parents live on a small coastal island, so I could relate to the setting and to the devastation storms can bring to island communities. However, the storm was really all that happened in the book– which might work, if some character growth came out of it… but it didn’t. The characters were all affected by the storm, sure, but the author didn’t convey the ways in which it shaped their lives. It just made This is the Story of You a frustrating, unrewarding read, because 1.) the characters were two-dimensional to begin with, and 2.) there was virtually no plot and no character growth. At the moment, after finishing this book, my dominant emotion is confusion.
All in all, this had the potential to be a wonderful story– especially given the strength of Kephart’s prose– but in the end, both the plot and the characters fell flat.