From author of Sontag, Benjamin Moser, comes a deeply researched history of the Jewish anti-Zionists from the nineteenth century to the present.
For over a century, Zionism has often been treated as inseparable from Jewish identity—a natural response to antisemitism, exile, and genocide. But in Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History, Pulitzer Prize winner Benjamin Moser uncovers a largely erased tradition of Jewish dissent. Spanning nearly two hundred years, this powerful book traces the lives of rabbis, writers, and thinkers across the globe who viewed Zionism not as liberation, but as a dangerous form of nationalism—and a betrayal of Jewish ethical values.
Figures such as Edwin Montagu, who condemned the Balfour Declaration, and Jacob Israël de Haan, assassinated for his anti-Zionism, are among many who challenged the dominant narrative. Their resistance often came at great personal cost, yet their warnings and ideals remain strikingly relevant in today’s fractured political landscape.
Moser writes with urgency and compassion. He offers not a rejection of Jewish identity, but a reclamation of a different tradition—one rooted in human rights, moral clarity, and fearless dissent. At a moment of rising global tension and growing censorship, Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History opens a long-suppressed conversation that continues to shape the present.
Benjamin Moser is a writer, editor, critic, and translator who was born in Houston in 1976 and lives in the Netherlands. After attending high school in Texas and France, he graduated from Brown University with a degree in History. He earned his M.A. and Ph.D. from the University of Utrecht.
He worked at Foreign Affairs magazine and Alfred A. Knopf in New York before becoming an editor at the Harvill Press in London. He was the New Books columnist for Harper's Magazine before becoming a Contributing Editor on visual art and a regular contributor to The New York Review of Books. His work has appeared in many publications in the United States and abroad, including Condé Nast Traveler, Newsweek, and The American Scholar.
His first book, Why This World: A Biography of Clarice Lispector, was published by Oxford University Press (USA), Haus Publishing (UK), Cosac Naify (Brazil), and Civilização (Portugal). Editions are forthcoming in France and Germany. He is the Series Editor of the new retranslations of Clarice Lispector to be published in the United States by New Directions and in the United Kingdom by Penguin Modern Classics.
this author is not someone you want to have as an ideological opponent as their writing is so lyrical and evocative they can really paint a compelling picture. this is indeed a damning portrait of Zionism as one of the past century’s most violent race-based ideologies. The story is told through the lives of Jewish dissidents against Zionism who today as he notes are becoming more numerous
(Doubleday did me an incredible solid sending me this book five months before publication. While I understand the implicit motivation for doing so, I’m also not beholden to what we industry types call ‘circle-jerkery.’ No big whoops. No whoop at all, in fact. Whoopless.)
First, I am going to dispel any suspension: Benjamin Moser’s Anti-Zionism is an incredible read, and there is also no way that Benjamin Moser is going to escape the raft of shit reactionaries hail down based on his title alone. To which, and I say this to the actual and royal Moser, fuck ‘em. Too many thin shelled exomorphs posing as humans nowadays anyway; a corpus populi primed to instantly launch into histrionic, performative simulacra of agony and ecstatic empathy that I, existential survivalist, carry the sacred cruciform of my middle finger readied to greet. Because let’s face facts—no one can truly care about EVERYTHING all the time. I understand the guilt complex inflicted upon the woebegone soul to feel terrible about themselves if they should fail to ascend the nearest telephone pole and start hammering palms to pine, but I also see the guilt industry preying upon these well-meaning empaths. Whether on the Yae or Nay or, like me, Too Uninformed on Hyperspecifics to Augur Future Findings, one cannot read Anti-Zionism as a non-political act by the racquetball logic that dictates reading Anti-Zionism IS a political act. Why? Because so much of the battlefronts now being assailed are psychic—parasitic morality ‘news,’ shaped remarkably like a chyron—that all informations intentionally ingested are, by default, psycho-militaristic; and that even includes us well-rounded and mature motherfuckers. It’s true.
Moser does what Moser is known for: he extricates a narrative history, one composed with wit and verve, from an impossibly complex history. At no point does he claim absolute authority, neither does he tend to linger too long in one epoch to the detriment of others. One COULD say that Anti-Zionism, as a title, is intentionally jarring, all the better to nab the eye and its attached consumer. In fact, I just said that. The term ‘confirmation bias’ will surely be batted around like a shuttlecock, too, so I readied my racquet for replying musical puns with a lineup of skronk’s finest (welcome Laura Logic).
From my familiarity with academic writing forms and best practices, I suspect that the LCD will bitch and moan of selectivity on Moser’s part; lack of footnoting; frankly wild fucking events relayed with no attributed source material; &c. This same familiarity impels me to encourage the reader balking at this to do some of their own heavy lifting. Moser is not posing as Gibbon or Vollmann, and he has written a narrative history of Judaism’s incompatibility with Zionism. For the source material, that is, and long has been, at the eager ends of your own fingertips. Database away; stare at scatterplots of Diasporic dilution; seek out what compels you. Otherwise, trust Moser; he’s earned it.
I recognize this sounds pedantic, but you have to go into this process as neutral as possible. Being (oh, I just love having to make this none-more-bullshit distinction) a ‘cradle Catholic’ (fuck you, neo-cons), whatever skin I have in this game is theoretical, viz. by the dumb luck of random chance and geography. I do know the Bible, Torah, and Qur’an, and I find each to be near perfect examples of fantastical fiction. And, yes, that is the luxuriated loucheness of a middle-aged cracker from the California coast. The point, and Moser’s larger thesis? Zionism is not congruent to Judaism, a fact as plain as the day as long. Ergot, Israel, as a nation-state of consolidated power, is not a cognate for a Jewish proposition born out of the traditional, sixteen-exiled-centuries of statelessness which holds that the ‘state’ of the Jew is, get this, ‘statelessness!’ This commonly held interpretation, which is to say the orthodox, traditional, non-revisionist take, is that God emancipated the Jews through their expulsion, forevermore freeing them from the yoke of being terrible kings and/or tyrant queens. This conceptualization defines ‘freedom’ as the perpetual suspension of responsibility from the playing at God which nationhood grants its elite few. From my seat, it’s a pretty healthy worldview, a sort of theological ‘Fuck Art, Let’s Dance’ spirit that’s always imbued the wonderful spirit of Judaism that I know first-hand. The ‘there’s no Hell/there ain’t shit/life is the gift’ scaffolding. This is reductive, but my Jewish friends have always held to a ‘there’s no afterlife, let’s get another keg and a schemozzle of psychedelics’ tonight.
To boil it down, clarify like the butter I see clarified on TV’s I walk past and wonder why anyone would watch someone do something they themselves could do a room or two away; here, without any bullshit armor or ‘apology stuffed animal arm’ extended; now, as far as I can substantiate given Moser and the stereo-optic lenses of my own eyes; is, as the kids all say, the facts.
JEW IS TO ZIONIST AS ‘VOTER’ IS TO MAGA
That’s it, folks. Following Moser’s framing, it’s zealotry used as a smokescreen to reclaim power, enjoin the global order of hierarchical statehood; amassing enormous power using Judaism as a signal flare to hoodwink the fucking British (thanks again, chaps) into the Balfour Declaration and the subsequent 110 years of the repercussions. Modern Zionism, the very same you hear screamed about from the same phone you read the stupid shit I’ve written, is the creation of Theodore Herzl, a ‘utopianist’ quack author that used the vehicle of science fiction to extemporize and theorize what a hypothetical Jewish nation-state would require, and what its national essence must be. This is his story, as well as the guy that took his musings and ran with it; the next dude (always a dude) in Parliament with a complex and fuckdumb brain. It’s his story just as much as his peers, generally rabbis, that angrily shouted down ‘this cannot be done in our name;’ and the UN’s genocide committee becoming really fucking familiar with then-new Israel committing atrocities against the Palestinians within one year of being granted statehood. It’s all them bastards, right up to this one, me, talking to you; me telling you that, like it or not, to test these waters one must drink the ocean/there are no half-measures here. To remind you that to offer your two cents on Israel is to enter a complicity far more fucked and interwoven than any rational, single person could possibly hold equal and true simultaneously, and the necessity for just that. And my imploring that Zionism is not tantamount to but a euphemism for nationalism. And I say, “fuck that noise.” I defer to the military’s most respected NCO, the stalwart Capt. D.V.V. Beefheart, and carve on our common wall, “None of my women have tears in their eyes.” And to whatever Hell Dante on premium LSD could have mustered, I banish: MAGA & National Zionism (and, to forestall idiot boys, Islamic State/Hezbollah/etcetera-ite radicalized mountebanks)— Any and all actors killing and dying for a God disgusted by your telemetry, industries of death, and screamings across the sky.
You can’t have me. Nor you, reader (if you’ve read this far), unless you surrender to their infernal, blackhole/cathode transmissions, and forget that you are alive now only and it’s haymaking & hi-fives.
Moser is a Pulitzer winning biographer and he brings that care, level of research, and exceptional writing to this book. In this book, Moser lays out and chronicles the lives and beliefs of Jewish people - rabbis, artists, lawyers, activists- who have been anti-Zionist and challenged the Zionist project and belief system, at great cost to themselves. They lost income, received death threats, one was murdered, but they all stood strong that their faith was against apartheid and genocide. This Jewish history is often overlooked and suppressed and I know many anti-Zionist Jews who have felt alone in their beliefs and stance. But Moser beautifully lays out that they are not alone, and they have been working towards what’s right for decades.
I usually binge my books but this one I took my time and highlighted alone the way. There’s so much good information and history in it. Strong recommend.
This is joining The Hundred Years' War on Palestine and Perfect Victims as my top books to recommend for people trying to come to terms with a lifetime of American programming on Israel and Palestine.
For people who already feel secure in their antizionist beliefs, the author provides a century plus of backup for defending against doubts internal and external about Israel’s settler colonial origins and apartheid present.
Yes, it’s true that once most Jews were anti-Zionist. Myself, and the party I support, the Socialist Workers Party and the ‘Militant’ newspaper were anti-Zionist. I have not become a Zionist--Jewish nationalist, or an American patriot. I’m an internationalist. I’m not going to call myself an anti-Zionist when the term "Zionist" has primarily become a euphemism for Jew, and it has. It is necessary to identify people by what they’re for, not what they’re against. It is reactionary to blame the working class for what the rulers do. I was against tarring all Germans with the brush of Nazism just as I am against blaming all Israelis, much less all Jews with guilt. The founders of Zionism and Israel were scoundrels, but I find that true of most capitalist politicians, which is why I’m a communist.
Some of the portraits in this book are of people I have huge respect for, some not. I also see Felicia Langer as a heroic figure. Maxime Rodinson's Israel: A Colonial-Settler State? was useful once, but with thousands of over-privileged and over-mis-educated anti-Semites incoherently babbling about settler colonists, not so much. But he refused to take sides between Jews and Arabs.
Moser mentions Einstein, who called himself a Zionist, but wasn't for a Jewish state, He was naive politically, first supporting pacifism, then the US imperialist war. For the SWP's stance, see Socialism on Trial: Testimony at Minneapolis Sedition Trial. Einstein, after the war played a hugely progressive role in explaining the dangers of nuclear weapons, opposing Jim Crow, which was the major source of apartheid, and opposing the anti-communist witch hunt, which was undermining civil liberties in the US. Joe McCarthy was a genuine fascist, see Notebook of an Agitator: From the Wobblies to the Fight against the Korean War and McCarthyism.
Moser, in cancel-culture style discards Marxism because “[Marx] was born more than two centuries ago, and lived in a world that in many ways is unrecognizable today.” In many ways it is unrecognizable from the world I was born into, a year after Israel was formed, but we are still living under the dictatorship of capital. In fact, an ever-smaller number of billionaires in the US control most of the wealth of the world. And the real wages of working people in this country have been falling; unemployment (the statistics leave out people too discouraged to look for work) is on the rise. Life expectancy too is falling among the working class, and large numbers are still living with their parents even after getting married and can’t afford to have kids. The Democrats are only interested in their right to not have kids, which I support too, although we need to win a majority.
Moser has rejected Marxism without knowing anything about it. I doubt that he has read the definitive Marxist book on the Jews and anti-Semitism, The Jewish Question: A Marxist Interpretation, despite the fact that Maxime Rodinson wrote an introduction to a French edition of it. Moser doesn’t know anything about Lenin, who after Marx and Engels was the most important communist. He just takes a wild guess and writes about the “Leninist belief that nationalism was a bourgeois distraction from working-class internationalism.” Has he ever heard the phrase “prison-house of nations” applied to the Russian Empire? Lenin wasn’t the first to use it, but he was the first to attempt to smash it and grant self-determination, especially language rights to all the oppressed nationalities. Moser talks about the death of Stalin but seems to view Stalinism as simply the cult of personality and mass murder, which Khrushchev admitted. Not knowing anything about Lenin, he doesn’t have a clue that Stalin reversed virtually all of Lenin’s policies, including trying to restore Russian as the sole language. This is important in understanding why Putin, a Russian chauvinist invading Ukraine, hates Lenin but has a soft-spot for Stalin. Does he know that Lenin expected the workers of Germany to follow the Russian example--- see The German Revolution and the Debate on Soviet Power: Documents, 1918-1919; Preparing the Founding Congress. Stalin thought you could achieve “socialism in one country,” a utopia, although of course it could and did start in a single rather underdeveloped country. The Russian Revolution cannot be understood without reading |History of the Russian Revolution,
Not knowing Marxism, Moser has missed gaining an understanding of what fascism is—See The Struggle Against Fascism in Germany and Fascism and Big Business. He doesn’t have a clue that if the policies formulated by Lenin and the Communist International had been in effect, rather than Stalin’s "theory" that the social democrats were worse than Hitler, it is likely that Hitler would have never come to power. But to Moser this is all just petty squabbles. In 1939 Trotsky wrote “now more than ever the fate of the Jewish people — not only their political but also their physical fate — is indissolubly linked with the emancipating struggle of the international proletariat.”
Much of what Moser writes about the downfall of apartheid is incorrect, because it leaves Cuba out of the picture, and claims the boycott played a central role. But acknowledging that would not help him much with his middle-class audience. See, Cuba and Angola: Fighting for Africa’s Freedom and Our Own, and Cuba and the Independence War in Guinea-Bissau and Cape Verde: The Fall of the Last Colonial Empire In Africa by Cuban hero Víctor Dreke Cruz, who had the opportunity to collaborate closely with Amílcar Cabral, one of the most outstanding African revolutionaries. He wasn’t Jewish and supported Israel’s right to exist, but I have a lot more respect for Nelson Mandela than the Stalinist Ronnie Kasrils. Yes, he played a role, but he presents a whitewashed version of Spear of the Nation, which Mandela founded. In fact, contrary to what it was formed to be, there was much outright terrorism with many civilian deaths. And there was Joe Slovo (also Jewish) popularizing “kill the Boer, the farmer.” uMkhonto weSizwe had a symbolic value, which is why Mandela wouldn’t dissolve it before the ANC had won real gains. I attended the large anti-apartheid marches in New York, and many, if not most of the chants were for Cuba! But BDS et al has consciously hid all this history of the one revolution since the Russian with world class communist leadership--Fidel Castro and Ernesto Che Guevara.
One of the last things Fidel Castro did, which he couldn’t have done as president (because Cuba’s trade with Iran was important), was to give an interview to Atlantic magazine. In 2010, after then-Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad had proclaimed the Holocaust — the murder of 6 million Jews by the Nazis — was an “unprovable and mythical claim,” Castro invited Atlantic magazine writer Jeffrey Goldberg to come to Cuba and interview him. Castro had huge disagreements with Israel, but told reporter (now editor) Jeffrey Goldberg “I don’t think anyone has been slandered more than the Jews. I would say much more than the Muslims,” Castro told Goldberg. “They have been slandered much more than the Muslims because they are blamed and slandered for everything.” Goldberg asked Castro, “Do you think the State of Israel, as a Jewish State, has a right to exist?” “Yes, without a doubt,” Castro replied. “True revolutionaries never threaten to exterminate a whole country,” Castro had told Le Monde in September 1967, in response to Arab governments and others calling for Israel’s destruction.
Here is Nelson Mandela in Cuba, on the anniversary of the Cuban Revolution, July 26th, 1991: “The crushing defeat of the racist army at Cuito Cuanavale was a victory for the whole of Africa! The overwhelming defeat of the racist army at Cuito Cuanavale provided the possibility for Angola to enjoy peace and consolidate its own sovereignty! The defeat of the racist army allowed the struggling people of Namibia to finally win their independence! The decisive defeat of the apartheid aggressors broke the myth of the invincibility of the white oppressors! The defeat of the apartheid army was an inspiration to the struggling people inside South Africa! Without the defeat of Cuito Cuanavale our organizations would not have been unbanned! Cuito Cuanavale was a milestone in the history of the struggle for southern African liberation! Cuito Cuanavale has been a turning point in the struggle to free the continent and our country from the scourge of apartheid!” --See How Far We Slaves Have Come!: South Africa and Cuba in Today's World.
After that the central part of the struggle was the exceptional leadership of a mass movement of organized workers, farmers and students by Nelson Mandela, see Nelson Mandela Speaks: Forging a Democratic, Nonracial South Africa. Boycotts helped but were never central.
Contrary to what Ronnie Kasrils said, Hamas are the ones with genocidal intent, backed by the Iranian rulers who are Holocaust deniers and their other proxy forces — Hezbollah in Lebanon, the Houthis in Yemen and others. Hamas traces its origins to ultra-reactionary Arab forces that formed a yearslong alliance with Hitler’s Nazi Party in the 1930s based on a common desire to carry out the “final solution” — the slaughter of Jews worldwide. These forces include Amin al-Husseini, who became the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem in 1921, and the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt, the forerunner of Hamas. They emerged out of the deepening worldwide capitalist crisis and the revolutions and counterrevolutions that would lead to World War II.
I don't support the war in Iran. It has nothing to do with the Jews or Israel. Israel was only involved in trying to wipe out Iran's nuclear fuel. It is a war for oil and to make the rich richer. This is leading to a potential third world war, see New International no. 7: Opening Guns of World War III: Washington's Assault on Iraq. I do support the protestors in Iran who hate Iran's intervention in other countries, and fight for rights for women, for workers and retirees, and for the oppressed nationalities. The largest nationality in the world without a state is the Kurds, not the Palestinians. They are divided between Iran, Iraq, Syria and Turkey. Question: Why is there no solidarity movement for them? Answer: They're not oppressed by Jews, who for two thousand years have made the best scapegoats for everything.
I wasn't for a Jewish state, but it's not a bad thing that it exists. It isn't apartheid, as Nelson Mandela knew. Israeli Arabs can work in any profession. They don't have to join the IDF, but increasing numbers do. Hamas is for killing anyone who in any way works with Jews. As Trotsky explained, only world socialist revolution will end Jew-hatred for all time. I am also for a Palestinian state. Killing Jews doesn't increase the chances. And unlike the early reactionary practices, today all the trade unions have Jewish, Arab, and immigrant workers.
Israel’s existence is a result of political developments before, during and after World War II. Stalinist parties headed by Moscow betrayed promising revolutionary situations, in Germany, Spain and elsewhere in Europe. This opened the door to the rise of Hitler and his “Final Solution” for the Jews. Imperialist “democracies” in the U.S., United Kingdom and elsewhere shut their doors to all but a few Jews fleeing from the Holocaust. Where else were they to go? This made the creation of Israel inevitable.
At one point the SWP called for a democratic, secular Palestine. There is almost nobody advocating that today, But, take a long hard look at the whole region, and Israel is actually the closest thing to democracy and secularism that you will find.
It is a strange form of "genocide" where the Palestinian population keeps increasing, civilians are warned about where bombings will occur, food is given (this is the first time I've heard the claim about oxycodone in it and I don't believe it). And the number of Arabs who don't have to serve in the IDF but choose to has increased. Hamas is a death cult--their aim is to get as many civilians as possible killed, and hysterical middle-class elements claim Israel is the one committing genocide. These people with their lies are on the road to fascism. Sherman was right, "war is hell." But he was also correct in seeing the war against the Confederacy as necessary. So is the war against Hamas.
Boy George sings "I don't feel brave, I just need to behave like a human."
My grandparents were the only members of their families to survive the Holocaust. The Judaism I knew for the majority of my life I now recognize as Zionism, a word I didn’t know the meaning of until I began to research the history of Judaism and its near-total capture by Zionism. I was skeptical of everything I learned. It seemed impossible that the world I knew was so disconnected from the reality that created it.
Moser tells the story that I uncovered myself over these last few years and communicates it with a clarity and detail I have not previously encountered. Judaism has a rich, diverse history, much of which was erased during the Holocaust. As painful as it is to recognize, Zionism has continued that erasure. The effects on the Jewish world have been catastrophic and yet pale in comparison to what Palestinians have been subjected to for over a century.
It’s important that people learn history told from outside Zionism. If I could only read one book on the subject, this would be it.
A book I hope everyone picks up. There is so much history here that many have been actively trying to erase, rewrite, and forget- it is worth your time to read and remember.
I appreciate the choice Moser took to write about this history through the biographies of individuals, to hone in on specific people and their experiences in mini biographies is really powerful and engaging. I also appreciate that Moser treats each person with care and as whole people, complicated and flawed, maybe they didn't always get it "right," but they knew something was wrong and fought against that wrong.
I wish that I had spent more time highlighting/annotating, but the writing style can get a bit dense so it was already a slower read for me, so I didn't stop to highlight, but I did grab a few quotes:
"I was radicalized in the archives." Day after day, he saw that the story he had been taught was a lie. "I didn't have any radical ideas or revisionist ideas. It was the material that I was reading which completely, flatly contradicted the official line." (Shlaim)
If Palestinian perspectives were taught in schools, young Israelis would no longer feel proud of their country, nor believe in the justice of the Zionist cause. "In effect," Shlaim wrote, "they said that in education one has to lie for the good of the country."
Langer saw the devastation of the hundreds of towns that Israeli forces had blown up during the Nakba of 1948. Later, she visited Lidice, near Prague, destroyed by the Nazis in 1942... On the wall of the museum commemorating this crime, she saw a plaque with the words of Albert Schweitzer: "The victims of Lidice are immortal. The memory of the victims of Lidice must live on in the memory of mankind." She recalled three villages near Latrun- Yalo, Beit Nuba, and Emmaus- wiped off the face of the earth and replaced with a park funded by a Canadian Jew. The entirety of Palestine was dotted with Lidices. The map of the country showed how empty the vows emblazoned on the walls of the memorial had proven.
Moser, on speaking up for a free Palestine "What we can't know in advance is whom, exactly, we will lose- and this is a sickening surprise. The morons and the racists are one thing. The people we respected and loved are another. They can be people we imagined were kind and civilized and decent- and who, over the last years, have revealed themselves to be far more comfortable with infanticide and ethnic cleansing than we ever would have wished to suspect, about them or about anyone else. It is odious to lose friends. But as time passed I saw that I did not lose them. They lost me."
The book’s dedication reads, “To the Palestinian people.” Beneath is the line, “Grant to them the Fatherland of their desire.” Right away, Moser declares himself a maximalist, a nationalist whose concept of nationalism extends to Palestinians, but not to Israelis. Great start!
His thesis is that Judaism is a religion and Zionism made it a race. Moser cites the Pittsburgh Platform of 1885 (it seems a favorite of writers of his political ilk): “We consider ourselves no longer a nation, but a religious community.” Zionism, Moser claims, adopted “the same definition the antisemites used.”
Fine. Then what is Benjamin Moser, by his own definition? He tells us that he grew up in a home with “a cultural allegiance to Judaism…” By rabbinic standards, he’s a Jew who’s abandoned the commandments and has no standing to rule on Torah. But by his Pittsburgh standards, a non-believer who doesn’t practice doesn’t belong to a religious community at all. Only one thing makes Moser a Jew--descent--the definition he calls antisemitic. Sigh. The 95% of Jews he writes against don’t have to issue a kherem; he’s issued himself one.
I don’t know where to begin with this book. It is so full of vitriol, so one-sided, so unwilling, or unable to see nuance. It’s truly a horrid piece of work.
Moser uses descent whenever it suits him. Ahmad Sadiq Saad converted to Islam in 1957; nevertheless, he earns a whole chapter in what the title twistedly calls a “Jewish history.” For Moser, Ronnie Kasrils is “so obviously Jewish in mannerisms and appearance.” …So race is antisemitic when Zionists use it… and a compliment when Moser does??
The book covers a ragtag hodgepodge of strange fringe figures: a random Orthodox pacifist, a British cabinet minister, a convert to Islam, a Reform rabbi in Houston, Hannah Arendt (of course), and an American photographer, Nan Goldin. Moser, a man who seems able to write only in the key of a biographer, has put together a dozen portraits and called them a history.
But the omissions are GLARING to anyone who knows the bare modicum of Jewish history. The Bund, the largest Jewish anti-Zionist movement in history, doesn’t appear once. Though internationalist, Bundists did regard Jews as a nation, and of course, this goes against Moser’s thesis.
There’s a section on Zionism and the Nazis in the Arendt chapter, which revives the old Soviet lie that Zionists and Nazis were partners, told, in Moser’s hands, as a neat moral fable of evil aligned with evil. It’s obscene.
The Iraq chapter is the worst. Moser writes that the 1941 Farhud “had no precedents” and that afterwards “the violence was not repeated.” …. conveniently leaving out the hanging of Shafiq Ades in 1948 and the nine Jews publicly hanged in Baghdad in 1969. Moser presents “documentary proof” that Zionists “deliberately plotted to drive the Iraqi Jews from their homeland.” The source for this is, and pardon my French, a fucking fragment of an Iraqi police interrogation from 1951--under a regime that had just made Zionism a capital crime. What kind of “history” is this? An undergraduate knows this is deeply flawed evidence.
The book mentions the Iraqi denaturalization law but never tells you that 90,000 Jews registered to leave Iraq long before then. Shlomo Mansour survived the Farhud as a child in Baghdad and was murdered at Kissufim on October 7, aged 86. That’s a story! But instead Moser focuses on Avi Shlaim’s article arguing that Zionism failed him (though god knows how, Shlaim has made a fortune from hating on Zionism). The book has nothing to say about the Iraqi community in Israel today, nothing about the Babylonian Jewry Heritage Center in Or Yehuda, nothing about the amazing contribution Iraqi Jews have made to the modern state.
On Hebron in 1929, when sixty-seven Jews were murdered, Moser writes “dozens” and calls it “the first… Arab Jewish community destroyed in the age of Zionism,” conveniently hiding the perpetrators in a passive verb. And on the topic of October 7, Moser lists “deliberate mass rape” among “claims that were never sourced or verified.” The UN envoy Pramila Patten found reasonable evidence that rape and gang rape took place at three or more sites. There’s also the Dinah Project report (but don’t believe all that, Moser… it was the work of pesky Zionists, after all).
People are falling over themselves to praise this nonsense. Just this week a piece in the Guardian fawned over it. In LARB, Shaul Magid praises the “deft writing style.” FFS. The serious press seemed less impressed. The New York Times saw straight through his infantile binaries, and in the New Yorker, Isaac Chotiner finds multiple errors and exaggerations, concluding that Moser has “an unfortunate tendency to misrepresent the authorities he enlists.” The rave reviews come from useful-idiot readers who already agree with him.
This is a lazy piece of work that fails to probe anything beyond the few marginal figures that fit Benjamin Moser’s own puerile politics. The man is an intellectual black hole.
Thank you Doubleday for my free ARC. These Opinions are my own:
Wow. Just…I can’t consume it fast enough. And I find myself sitting with it at intervals, pausing to absorb it. I’m the daughter of an ethnically Jewish, Zionist father, and I freely admit that my mind was already made up (pro-Judaism, anti-Zionist) before opening this book. I am a humanitarian worker by profession and believer in justice and universal human rights what Israel is doing and has done in Palestine is horrific. Moser writes clearly and engagingly, laying out fact and opinion as a biographer and writer who is also a Jew. I understand this is a much bigger subject with many more dynamics than can be contained in his book, but I found I to do a good job at what it set out to do.
I came across this book on the shelf in the a bookstore where Moser was set to do a book talk about it in LA at Sky Lights in September. The bluntness of the title stopped me, I thought -- this author means serious business. In the literary canon of writing about Zionism and the issue of Palestine, this book refreshingly looks at the interwoven histories of individuals who showed that being against Zionism used to be the norm, until it was not. Each powerful story of each actor builds on top of one another, reverberating and building resonance, a rising tide of refusal and disavowal of a genocidal ideology. The book comes at a time where the pendulum is swinging the other way, where being pro-Palestine is no longer seen as the fringe opinion but the accepted one, where the death toll is no longer something you can "both-side" about, where we have been seeing massacres televised on our individual phone screens for the past three years.
In the acknowledgement section, Moser starts with an anecdote that "a friend suggested, half jokingly, that I include in the acknowledgements a list of people I have lost while writing this book. [...] It is odious to lose friends. But as time passed, I saw that I did not lose them. They lost me." This is the reality of any Jewish person (or really any person) working towards a free Palestine. It encapsulates the themes in the book. Moser, too, will probably face a cost for this book.
I have always been an admirer and reader of those who have the vision to construct alternate histories, the ones that have been removed, erased, systematically and violently repressed. There is so much at stake here and Moser writes with the clarity and lyricism of someone who writes out of love -- (in the penultimate chapter of Ronnie Kasrils) "As Che Guevara said, revolution is an act of love, [...] It's love really that motivates us all." Each chapter paints a picture of Jewish scholars, writers, activists, artists who fought against Zionism, could see its racial ideology and its raw violence of suppression and erasure of the people of Palestine for what it was. Some of the book is hard to swallow, and emotionally devastating. Moser writes to capture those who spoke out against the imperial, settler-colonialist project as it was backed by the British and American military force and resources. Those who did not fall in line often paid a heavy price, losing their livelihood, living in exile, separated from their family, ostracized by the very community that they loved and believed in. It's in part, the story of the Jewish diaspora told at a personal scale, re-writing the myths of Zionism with a deft simplicity that cuts through the propaganda we have all been fed: a land without a people, for a people without land.
When you think that you cannot learn more about the immoral crimes of the Israeli settler state enacted on generations of Palestinian people who would not just roll over and disappear, Moser presents these stories of resistance from the outside. It tells us a story that it did not have to be this way, this was not inevitable and there is still possibility to change it now. Moser lovingly brings the stories of past and present dissenters and freedom fighters into the fold of our collective imagination for liberation. If there is ever a time where the veil has thinned, and people can now clearly see what the Zionist project has been since its inception, it is now.
Pros of the audiobook version: the author narrated it on his own and he sounds like Adam Driver
Cons: I found myself reversing to re-listen to certain parts much more than usual. Between the heavy subject matter, new (to me) information I had to sit with for a bit (did you know Iraq had a thriving Jewish community since 500 BCE, and Mossad agents deliberately targeted and bombed them to incite them to leave their ancestral homes to flee to Palestine??), often not being able to tell when a quote ends and the author’s narration resumes, and pretentious sounding French idioms/loan phrases scattered throughout, I probably would have gotten more out of this by reading the regular way. That said, important and fantastic book either way.
Cataloguing a rich history of Jewish anti-Zionism through the ages, Benjamin Moser’s new book “Anti-Zionism” is a landmark piece that fills a glaring gap in the literature about pro-Palestinian politics and history. He features a dozen different Jewish anti-Zionists, ranging from a Hasidic rabbi in the late 19th century to a British government official during the British mandate to journalists and activists and artists. His subjects are diverse and largely unfamiliar to the modern American audience—voices who have been lost to history or erased from the narrative.
In his moving introduction to the book, Moser describes Zionism as “a native language.” He writes. “What anti-Zionists have in common is not that we have passed a purity test. It is a willingness to try to unlearn that native language.” This book aims to recontextualize Jewish anti-Zionism not as an aberration or a fringe belief held only by those who “aren’t real Jews,” but by Jews of all backgrounds at every moment since Zionism’s beginnings and up to this day. Moser wants the reader to know that “during every period of Zionism’s history, Jews had risked their livelihoods and lives in order to insist that Zionism was not speaking in our name.”
This book is at times devastating, affirming, dry, and inspiring. It’s meticulously researched yet retains a fierce point of view. It is already controversial, because of course it is. But it’s also something I’ve never read elsewhere, something that so many people, Jews and otherwise, can turn to as a source of strength in the righteousness of the fight for Palestinian liberation. It’s an incomplete text written in the midst of the worst catastrophe Palestinians have faced since the Nakba. And it powerfully insists on the Palestinian people at its core. I’m so glad I got to read this book.
“What would have changed if I had known about the people in this book? What would have changed for me if, instead of being erased from history, such heroes had been honored as the moral aristocracy of the Jewish people?”
“I would have learned that to oppose Zionism did not mean amputating a part of myself. It meant placing myself in an alternative tradition—a hidden tradition […] of people who, though long dismissed and despised, were ultimately proven right.”
Thank you to NetGalley and Doubleday for a free aARC in exchange for an honest review.
Door dit boek kan ik het niet meer niet durven zien en kan ik me niet meer niet uitspreken. Het zionisme is een vorm van vestigingskolonialisme met als doel de oorspronkelijke bewoners van Palestina te verdrijven en te ontmenselijken met alle denkbare gewelddadige middelen. Het enige perspectief is dat er een grote antizionistische massa ontstaat om het via democratische weg te laten stoppen. En daar draagt dit boek aan bij.
Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History by Benjamin Moser offers a sweeping exploration of Jewish thinkers who challenged Zionism across different eras, communities, and political traditions. Through portraits of rabbis, writers, activists, scholars, and other figures, Moser highlights a lesser-known strand of Jewish intellectual and political history. The book is especially interesting in the way it connects individual lives with larger questions about nationalism, Jewish identity, ethics, and political belonging. Moser presents a strongly argued perspective, and recent reviews have both praised the book's recovery of these overlooked voices and questioned aspects of its historical interpretation.
A thought-provoking book for readers interested in Jewish history, Zionism, political thought, and the different perspectives that have shaped these debates.
Een essentieel boek! Ook daarom geef ik een 5 maar het is ook gewoon goed. Ik las het in het (origineel) Engels en bijwijlen was het wat lastig (want Moser is een gesofisticeeerde intellectueel) maar zijn keuze om zijn thesis voor te stellen en te schragen via de levensverhalen en levensdoelen van zo’n 12 belangrijke figuren is gewoon geslaagd. Na lektuur van dit boek kan je niet anders dan het Zionisme afwijzen - en dat is niet anti-semitisch!! Het is merkwaardig hoe lang de wereld dit al weet, hoeveel goede/slimme mensen dit al aangetoond hebben via hun boeken, hun activisme, hun engagement (met gevaar voor lijf en leden) maar het is even merkwaardig (en misdadig) hoeveel en hoe lang Westerse landen deze conclusie doodgezwegen hebben. By the way, de twaalf figuren die beschreven worden zijn stuk voor stuk uitzonderlijke mensen: intellectueel briljant maar ook eerlijk, onwaarschijnlijk moedig in het aanschijn van de terreur van het wereldwijde Zionisme tegen hun persoon en hun gedachtengoed en gewoon schitterende mensen. De merkwaardige conclusie die zich na lektuur van dit boek opdringt is: het Zionisme is anti-semitisch, racistisch en bijna nazistisch… Een laatste bedenking: de verantwoordelijkheid van het Britse imperium voor deze calamiteit is gigantisch, … begrijpelijk dat de UK zich in dit debat merkwaardig ‘koest’ houdt!
Grateful to have had the chance to read this early via NetGalley.
When this comes out in September, the reaction will be... interesting.]
A fascinating, fascinating book. Moser outlines this particular history by profiling specific individuals and their experiences within and outside Zionist activism. The time range is significant, extending from the late 19th century until the current day -- as is the nature of each individual's Jewish identity, extending from religiously observant rabbis to those whose Jewish identity is wholly secular. I had only heard of a few of these individuals before this book (Hannah Arendt is probably indisputably Moser's most famous subject).
Moser's writing was occasionally a little hit-or-miss -- sometimes, considering the gravity of the topic and the profile of the figures he was documenting, his writing felt a little colloquial for my taste. But the scope of the writing is really impressive.
Reading history: Normally I keep this in my private notes section, but I'm moving it. Yay!
Reading history was not added on Goodreads, but was instead kept on a small piece of paper that I lost like five times and kept rediscovering. No physical copy was consulted.
Started April 26th, 2026. Finished July 13th, 2026.
April 26th, 2026: read introduction via ebook ARC.
April 27th, 2026: read chapter 1 via ebook ARC. (Rabbi Aaron Samuel Tamares)
June 14th, 2026: read chapter 2 via ebook ARC. (Edwin Montagu)
June 17th, 2026: read chapter 3 via ebook ARC. (Jacob Israël de Haan)
June 19th, 2026: read chapter 4 via ebook ARC. (Ahmad Sadiq Saad)
June 23rd, 2026: read chapter 5 via ebook ARC. (Hyman Judah Schachtel)
June 25th, 2026: read, like, a couple paragraphs of chapter 6 via ebook ARC. (Avi Shlaim)
June 27th, 2026: restarted chapter 6; read whole chapter 6 via ebook ARC. (Avi Shlaim)
July 4th, 2026: read chapter 7 via ebook ARC. (Hannah Arendt)
July 5th, 2026: read chapter 8 via ebook ARC. (Maxime Rodinson)
July 9th, 2026: read chapter 9 via ebook ARC. (Felicia Langer)
July 11th, 2026: read chapter 10 via ebook ARC. (Helena Salem)
July 13th, 2026: read chapters 11 & 12 + acknowledgments via ebook ARC. (Ronnie Kasrils & Nan Goldin)
Basically, he just recycled the 1990 book by Thomas A. Kolsky "Jews Against Zionism."
Shouldn't the criticism of Jewish Supremacy (Zionism) first and foremost be directed towards the aim of liberating Judaism and Jewish Institutions from Zionism?
Shouldn't he, at the very least, be campaigning to have Zionist messed up education system completely overhauled?
Why is Moser suddenly being parachuted in from out of the blue to dictate the terms of the discussion?
Why is the Palestine movement at the mercy of the whims of some exclusivist book tour circuit?
I had never heard of Benjamin Moser before, but within a few dozen pages is clear that he is a Marxist (I use this descriptively rather than pejoratively). His judgments, which suffuse the book, are animated by the familiar ideological sympathies of Marxism. He writes exceptionally well, which only renders his characteristic combination of confidence and occassional polemical force more conspicuous.
For this reason, I did not love the book, though I didn't hate it either. I was unfamiliar with the writings of Avi Shlaim and Hannah Arendt, whose analyses of Israel and Palestine are striking, particularly in the way they illuminate the destructive history of Zionism. I was also unaware of the relationship between South Africa and Israel. Insofar as Moser’s account is accurate, his contention that Israel supported apartheid is helping in understanding the context to South Africa’s recent filings before the ICJ. The chapter on Eichmann is disturbing.
That said, the enduring conflict between Israelis and Palestinians is among history’s most contentious and fraught subjects. The topic is crowded with podcasters, grifters, intellectuals, professors, lobbyists, and assorted loudmouths, many of whom either chase attention or align themselves so theatrically with one side that nuance becomes impossible. Moser has written an accomplished book, but his Marxist proclivities deprive it of the possibility that this could have been a much stronger book.
This deficiency is characteristic of much writing on the conflict, especially from hardliners. Moser rightly acknowledges that Arabs opposed Zionism vehemently from the outset, and that they had every right to do so. Yet, consistent with his intersectional mentality, he presents the Arab experience primarily as one of dispossession, without sufficiently interrogating his own summaries of various anti-Zionist accounts. A reader could therefore underestimate both the depth of antisemitism in the Arab world and the extent to which religion, particularly Islam’s conception of Jewish history, has served as a potent animating force behind it.
Because Moser refuses to challenge either his readers or himself, the book will likely be received, uncritically, as a contribution to the Marxist canon and therefore a smaller readership. The history is undeniably grievous for Palestinians, and the United States has repeatedly shielded criminal actors within the Israeli government. But the notion that Palestinians and Arabs are devoid of agency is just silly. They are not merely passive participants in a historical drama dictated by Israel. The refusal to recognize the immense power Israel possesses over them, and their failure to accept territorial and political losses are themselves consequential choices. But to Moser, none of this is worth mentioning.
In the years 1897-98, three political movements were formed which fashioned the destiny of the Jews during the 20th century. The socialist General Jewish Labour Bund was founded in Vilnius in October 1897 and advocated cultural autonomy in the areas of the great empires in which Jews were concentrated. The Russian Social Democratic Labour Party was founded in Minsk at the beginning of 1898, later splitting into Mensheviks and Bolsheviks and finally evolving into the Communist Party under Lenin. And, in August 1897, the Zionist movement held its first congress in Basel. Theodor Herzl opened the proceedings with a lacklustre speech, followed by the social critic Max Nordau who paid tribute to ‘the great men of 1792’ – the sansculottes of the French Revolution who had overthrown the monarchy. Despite their eventual differences, both communists and Zionists looked to the French Revolution as ‘the dawn of humanity’ when racism would vanish and justice prevail.
In 1917 the October Revolution and the Balfour Declaration took place within days of each other. One spoke about repairing the world, the other of a Jewish home in Palestine. The former appealed to the universalism within Judaism while the latter spoke to its particularism. Both communism and Zionism coloured the paths of multitudes of Jews. Jewish communists looked to Marx and Lenin, who had condemned all forms of nationalism. Jewish Zionists looked instead to Mikhail Bakunin, Pierre-Joseph Proudhon, and the advocates of constructivism and anarcho-communism who advocated the importance of identity within a nation. David Ben-Gurion, born in 1886 and regarded as the founding father of Israel, admired Lenin for his pragmatism and ability to create a revolution with few resources. In January 1924 he gave a eulogy in Hebrew on Lenin’s passing. Many of the early Zionist pioneers in Palestine in the 1920s admiringly looked to Moscow for inspiration in building socialism in Palestine. Some remarkably remained loyal to the Kremlin even during the Stalinist show trials of the 1930s.
I’ve sat with this for a week now to try and gather my thoughts on this book. It’s a 5 star read for me and I am recommending this. It was interesting to learn about Zionism and what different Jewish people thought about it throughout its inception. I think in today’s society, the word Zionism gets thrown around a lot without people knowing what the word means. This book is valuable because it gives a Jewish perspective of Zionism and shows what it means to be an anti-Zionist. I think sometimes, as a society, we tend to lump groups of people together as if they think the same things just because they have one identifying characteristic e.g. all Jewish people being Zionists. This book shows the complicated history of Zionism and the Jewish people who had important things to say about it.
What I liked about this book is that not all of the Jewish people discussed in this book had the same beliefs around Zionism and Israel. They all had different lives and that impacted how they viewed Zionism. Chapter 7 on Hannah Arendt was really impactful and I think a lot of that can be applied to today’s society regarding the way people are viewed when they are loudly against Zionism. Chapter 2 on Edwin Montagu was also really good and I just enjoyed reading this book. It was compelling and kept me interested throughout. The Holocaust is also discussed in this book and I think that’s very important because of its importance to Zionism and the belief that Jewish people are at risk because at one time they were. I’ve read a few books on Zionism and they don’t mention the Holocaust much so I appreciate that this does. This book is very good, well researched and a valuable addition to the conversation on Zionism and Israel/Palestine.
This book completely radicalized me. I've been reading about the Palestinian cause for a long time, have been watching the undeniable genocide that's been live-streamed since 2023, and have been firmly pro-Palestine, but still held reservations and sympathies for the state of Israel and for Zionists. I had been seeing the genocide as the excesses of a postcolonial nation gone awry, a result of unconditional Western aid, and of a war between two irreconcilable peoples wherein one has access to way more resources than the other who would also exterminate them if given the chance. And of course, there was a strange intellectual fascination with Israel, with the miracle of its exceptional existence, of its claims to singularity, of its deliberate engineering, and of its contemporary power drawn from religious-historical roots that the world has accepted as fact. I wished for a more humane Israel, a more peaceful place, a place I could visit to fulfill my morbid curiosity about the divisions and unities that plague the Abrahamic faiths.
And reading this, I realized I was wrong. It simply has nothing to do with faith, and to the extent that it does, it is an alternative reading of history, a twisting of facts and a social manipulation that has nothing to do with reality. It is a nationalist project-- a tale of the most successful militants and terrorists of our time, of a violent out-group that achieved legitimacy through international law. Anti-Zionism has nothing to do with anti-Semitism and to the extent that it does, it's because Zionists have made it so that they are the only real Jews.
Dit is een heel persoonlijk en aangrijpend boek. Voor deze verrijking van mijn bestaan dank ik de schrijver.
Wat stijl en gedrevenheid betreft doet het me denken aan https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/2... The Age of Surveillance Capitalism : The Fight for a Human Future at the New Frontier of Power / Shoshana Zuboff.
Moser zet het onderbelichte judaisme (binnen het jodendom) (onverenigbaar met zionisme) op het toneel. Een twaalftal levensbeschrijvingen geeft een samenhangend overzicht van deze ongekende gruwel.
Dit lijkt mij een boek dat noodzakelijke helderheid geeft in een totaal uit balans verkerende wereld. https://openlibrary.org/works/OL44272... Wat mij betreft: de grootst mogelijke aanrader.
Much needed exploration of true cause and effect in Palestine
I fully expect the gaggle of predictable warriors for Zionism in the media and elsewhere to savage this book in their reviews. This book has the audacity to call a spade a spade. It has the audacity to explore the inherent non-Jewishness in what has been done to the Palestinian people. That is sure to be an irritant to many, who would like the world to look the other way when unspeakable atrocities are committed in the name of…greed, disguised as historical and religious entitlement. Kudos for Benjamin Moser for not only not allowing himself to be mislead into zombiesque acquiescence with preposterous premise of Palestine being “A land with no people for a people with no land”. This book truly embodies the best in objectivity and in the authentic, enlightened legacy of Judaism. Wonderful book, long overdue.
A couragous book that breaks many clichés about the history of anti-zionism and its main protagonists over the years. As his prior works, it is thoroughly reasearched and documented with a selection of characters from different parts of the world. It is composed of twelve chapters that give us a comprehensive understanding of the movement itself and the efforts made by Zionist intellectuals and politicians to defeat it. Although the topic is not exactly entertaining, it reads well and is never annoying. In the notes at the end of the book, Moser reveals that he lost friends writing this book. In the current political context where everything touching Israel is easily caricatured, this is an important work, that everybody, zionists and anti-zionists, should read.
This is not a quick or easy read, in part because of the topic-history Benjamin Moser tackles here but also at times due to his writing style, which can take a reader down rabbit holes. But what an amazing journey he will take you on! This is a brilliant, important, perceptive, deeply thought about and at times very moving account in which Moser questions/challenges/rethinks much of what he had been told/believed/assumed about his faith from childhood on. That said, you don't need to be Jewish or a Zionist or anything other than a fellow human being with your own past story and an open mind to appreciate what he delivers in this book.
Benjamin Moser’s new book, Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History, is appearing in half a dozen languages. I reviewed it in German for Junge Welt ("Die ausradierte Kritik") and in English for Left Voice ("Anti-Zionism Hits the Mainstream: A Review of Benjamin Moser’s New Book"). My politics are different than Moser’s but I learned a lot from his book and I hope it finds a very wide audience. A right-wing German newspaper published a review denouncing all anti-Zionist Jews as “weirdos” and “psychopaths” — because they believe that the only “real” or “good” Jew is one who does not want to live in the diaspora. If this book enrages the Right like that, you know it’s worth a read!