Re-read Dec.2024
I'll just start by saying I was an insufferable elitist when I first read this book and I have thus changed the rating of this gem where it belonged the first time. (I liked the book just fine back in 2017, but I was a prick. I also don't think it's chick-lit. I'll leave the previous review here because it's proof that people can grow if they want to.)
I still stand by everything I wrote back in 2017 except for "doesn't bring up any philosophical questions". Because Care Santos definitely included themes that made me ponder. Female resilience is one of these, and it shines through all three stories, as each of the protagonists is confronted with unique challenges shaped by the societal norms of her time.
Also, I just want to mention that Care Santos was the first author (through this book, in particular) who sparked my desire to see Barcelona. So she will always hold a dear spot in my heart.
The book is made up of three stories, each relevant for a particular time period. The stories are tied together by an object - a porcelain chocolate pot that is thought to have belonged to Madame Adélaïde de France, the fourth daughter of King Louis XV. More than just a functional object, the pot represents continuity, legacy, but maybe also the unspoken bond between generations of women. Its presence in each story weaves a thread through time, carrying with it memories and desires, not only the rich history of chocolate itself. As for chocolate, it also serves as a central concept, seen both as pleasure and temptation, but also as a symbol for the bittersweet complexities of life.
Sara's story (present)
Sara Rovira is a chocolatier in Barcelona who struggles to balance her career and her marriage, while harbouring a guilty secret she thinks no one knows about. I admired Sara for her will to obtain everything she wanted - be it her family, her business or (less morally desirable) her love life. There's a love triangle issue I don't usually approve of, or even enjoy in a novel, but the way this story is told - including the erotic passages - is quite delicate and non-judgemental, so I ended up not judging her either. For Sara, the chocolate pot becomes a source of inspiration, but mainly a symbol of the strong friendship that ties her to her husband and her best friend, a love triangle born during a chocolate course all of them attended in their 20s and that lasted over 20 years.
Aurora's story (19th century)
Aurora is a maid in the home of an industry magnate during the Industrial Revolution, a time when the art of chocolate-making was being transformed by technological advancements. Despite her lower status, she becomes a vital figure in the household due to her birth and subsequent condition of "milk sister" to Candida Turull, the family's only daughter. The Turull family marks the transition from artisanal chocolate-making to large-scale industrial production, which defined the era. Her story - a heartwarming one, in the end - explores class divides, but points out that status and wealth do not always bring happiness. While the first story may just be my favourite one, because I love strong women who know exactly what they want, this second one features one of the most delicate, touching love stories I've read about.
Marianna's story (18th century)
Marianna is the wife of a chocolatier in pre-revolutionary Barcelona, living in a time when chocolate was an artisanal luxury consumed primarily by the wealthy elite and only men could pertain to a guild and exercise this occupation. Together with her husband, she invented a machine that would efficientize chocolate making, an object much desired by the guild, but also by representatives from the courts of France and England. Marianna’s story highlights the struggles and resilience of women who supported their husbands’ work in an era when their contributions were often overlooked. The chocolate pot, which she receives as a gift from Madame Adélaïde de France, becomes a symbol of liberation from the gender constraints of those times. While I loved this story as well, mainly because of its historical context, I don't feel Marianna was truly the protagonist. The story (about her, but where her role is a rather muted one) is told from the perspective of Victor Guilllot, Madame Adélaïde's secretary and spy. This story reminded me of old cape and sword novels such as "The Three Musketeers", as it features many action scenes that include duels, spying and the good old "save the damsel in distress" trope.
In fact, one of my favorite things about this novel is the way it's written. Each story features a different style, somewhat matching the era it describes. The last part even includes one chapter written as a play, an homage to the art form that was so beloved during those times.
While it is mostly a character-driven prose, I appreciated the way Care Santos anchored each tale in the realities of their times, by inserting historical details that make it possible to accurately place them where they are supposed to be. Whether describing the pre-revolutionary aristocracy of Barcelona, the industrial advancements of the 19th century or the modern-day challenges of running a business, Santos grounds her narrative in well-researched context. Barcelona changes through the eras, is dressed up in consumes that reflect the times, but chocolate remains the common element that ties it all together.
Moreover, what this novel does well is to give voice to women from different historical periods, exploring how they navigate societal constraints while finding strength and purpose in their roles.
-----------------
To start, I just want to say that I didn't give it 4 stars simply because it cannot compare to classics and other authors that I've given 4 and 5 stars to, but I really liked this book. I'm actually surprised that I liked it so much, given that it's basically chick-lit.
It's an easy read, it doesn't require much effort and doesn't bring up any philosophical questions. However, the mixture of history, real persons and fiction is so well managed, that I found this book highly enjoyable. The characters are well defined and relatable and I found the stories well written and easy to engage with. The first one more so than the others, maybe because it happens in our times.
I liked the infusion of eroticism in the first story, it wasn't too over the top, just enough to give the reader a kick. And I found myself having chocolate cravings while I read the book (not that I don't crave chocolate on a daily basis), which means to me that the author was well-informed about the history and process of chocolate-making and she managed to put it all in writing in an engaging way.
Summer read, I picked it up because of the title, but I'm happy I did.