Magic takes more than blood. It demands your soul.
Under the iron fist of the Arcanum Order, magic belongs only to the elite. For Scythe Valethorne, survival isn’t enough. By day, she scrapes by in the city’s poorest district, by night she is an assassin to provide for her family. When one mission turns into a deadly gamble, Scythe risks everything to steal a place into the Arcana’s stronghold—the Guild.
But when Asher Kyrell, the Guild’s most enigmatic leader, chooses her as his apprentice, Scythe is pulled into a lethal game of power and deception. His red gaze pierces her lies, his touch threatens her control, and every lesson draws her deeper into his fire. Yet Asher keeps his own deadly secrets, and every spark she feels for him could burn her mission to ashes. For one glance too long could cost her everything, and one stolen kiss could destroy them both.
Through danger and desire, Scythe uncovers far more than she bargained for within the walls of the Guild; about herself, the other initiates, and the sinister fractures within the perfect Arcanum Order. Scythe must decide if her fate lies in enduring the regime—or breaking it. Because what if magic isn’t just gained… but is still born in the shadows, waiting to rise again?
She is an assassin who lives in poverty. She went on a mission that goes wrong and things get complicated when she runs into a mysterious leader of the Guild. He becomes her mentor, she's now his apprentice. One thing leads to another and now she has a difficult choice to make: to destroy or to risk everything?
Many thanks to NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for an early ALC! Narrator: Laura Horowitz and Michael Gallagher Duration: 15 hours Speed: 1.75-2x, varies
4.5⭐️ No spice Single/first person POV Book 1 in a trilogy
Spoiler free
Full transparency: I went into this book fully anticipating how much it’ll flop & I’ll end up dnfing. Why? Because I still get chills thinking about The Stars are Dying. I can’t begin to explain how utterly atrocious that book is to me🙈So I didn’t have high hopes for this one. Shame on me because boy was I wrong. I’m stumped at this being the same author. Granted, this isn’t a perfect read but she has improved immensely since then, it’s astounding because this book is actually good.
At the start I was impressed but still a little apprehensive. I like how almost nostalgic the premise is with the wand use & breakdown of the magic system & lore. But I was so shocked at how organized the storytelling seemed to be from the beginning that I had to keep reading. This is a slower book with minimal action until the end. It’s attempting that epic fantasy feel with the romance more of a side plot & kinda lands. The plot isn’t jumbled or messy or tough to follow like I assumed it would be. She really tries with the prose & even the dialogue is a step up & for the most part she delivers. The pace is slow & steady. everything unfolds clearly & it’s easy to understand; again for the most part.
The FMC is cocky but also compassionate. Even though at times she was giving bland, I think she’s still a fine lead. The MMC had me intrigued & that certainly delivered! Great enemies at the start & possibly…..no spoilers😉it surprised me how the romance became so earnest & touching as opposed to sexual. no spice in book 1?? Love that.
This has some of the most organic found family I’ve read in a while because sometimes it tends to feel forced. The dichotomy between the FMC & her sister is brilliantly written.
This isn’t perfect but it’s still a good addition to the genre. It very much is a first book. The FMC is a student so we’re learning as she goes along so there’s plenty of exposition. Some scenes ran on for too long vs others weren’t nearly long enough. I also feel like there’s a disconnect between certain elements. It’s so insanely predictable if you really truly pay super close attention to the FMC! Even though the plot has some depth & overall is compelling enough, I just felt like it’s missing that sparkle to push it to a 5⭐️
I can’t say it’s tropey but it does feel familiar both in that old school/childhood fantasy way & in the current typical romantasy sense. But I still enjoyed this. I’m not sure if everyone will like this but I think it’s still worth a try because I found something overall comforting about this world.
**A special thank you to Shelf Awareness & Bramble Publishing for a physical arc.
The Bloodfire Oath has so many classic fantasy elements, yet somehow makes them feel fresh and new. And honestly? It felt good to be back to magic wands! It’s a slower-moving story, but I was captivated the entire way. I needed to know what Scythe and Asher were hiding, what shaped them, and what was coming next. Somewhere along the way, I became invested in the whole cast. Rarely do I feel an interest in everyone.
The magic system was fairly easy to follow, although some similar names required a little extra attention. And that last 15%? Apparently, we were done taking our time, because a LOT happened.
And a pocket dragon AND a pocket phoenix?! Obviously, I was sold. My only complaint there is that I needed more Ignis and Scorch. You can’t give me pocket-sized companions and expect me to be reasonable about them.
soft DNF for me, because i just couldn’t understand FMC’s decisions. instead of simply giving that invitation back to the guy, she decides to get herself involved, then kills mage, signs a stolen document and ends up in prison.
and then she starts praying because she could almost orphaned sister and who would take care of her in the future… girl, maybe don’t create all these problems for yourself in the first place? 😭
i also struggled with ARC itself. it was barely edited and personally, it made book much harder to enjoy unfortunately, this one just wasn’t for me maybe i’ll give it another chance and finish it once official kindle version is published
Many thanks to NetGalley and Pan Macmillan for ARC.
I’ve read another trilogy by this author, so I simply couldn’t skip this book. It promised me everything I like and crave in fantasy: magic, political schemes, an attraction that shouldn’t happen, and an MMC with glasses. (Yes, I have my priorities straight.)
Scythe, as an assassin, makes for a very interesting main character. Her motivations are clearly established, and I could understand where her decisions were coming from, while not necessarily agreeing with them. Asher also didn’t disappoint as an MMC, and I definitely enjoyed their shared scenes. Sadly, there were moments when their chemistry felt a little off. Since this is the first book in a trilogy, I’m willing to give it a pass. I’d much rather have a slow burn than insta-lust in the books.
When it comes to the world-building, you can tell that the author has a specific vision and is working toward it. The plot was engaging enough to make me want to continue reading and find answers to all the questions that popped into my head along the way.
I’m aware that this book isn’t the final version yet, but the number of grammar issues and other inconveniences throughout the book made it difficult for me to fully immerse myself in the story and sometimes threw off the pacing. I can only hope that some (if not all) of these things will be fixed during the editing process!
Thank you Pan Macmillan | Tor Bramble and Netgalley for providing me with an ARC in exchange for my honest review.
This is another "new to me" author. While I HAVE seen many of her books online, I had never read anything from her. So I went into this basically blind without really having any expectations. I was very pleasantly surprised.
We are introduced to a unique world with two different sections - the poor and destitute (and magicless), and the very well off living side by side with the Guild of magic. The Arcanum Order. Those having magic are called the Arcana.
Our FMC is named Scythe and of course, she lives in the poorest district of the city. She is in her mid-twenties and lives with her adoptive family. By night she is also a paid assassin, helping to bring in much needed money for the household.
Things go off the rails when she completes a job and then suddenly realizes the consequences that might occur if she finishes her assignment. See, she has just stolen an Invitation to the Guild. This process is what occurs when the Guild selects 100 people to have the option to compete for admission into the Guild. To have MAGIC. Having magic is the thing that makes individuals EXTREMELY powerful. The man who she would be giving the Invitation to - the man who ordered the assassination of the original invitation holder - is already an awful man. He is the most powerful man in Scythe's district and she cannot imagine how bad things could possibly get if he were to also get magic. So, she makes a last minute decision and ends up killing him to take possession of the invitation. Unfortunately she also kills a man who was partnering with him - who happens to be an Arcana. THIS is punishable by death.
Things take off from there and all of a sudden Scythe finds herself smack dab in the middle of all kinds of craziness. It just so happens that the brother of the Arcana she killed is an Arch Mage. Yep, a VERY powerful mage who now HATES her and wants her dead. Long story short, he basically kidnaps her shy, quiet sister and throws her into the trials. While Scythe is doing everything she can to protect her sister, she is selected to be the apprentice of another Arch Mage - Asher Kyrell.
Honestly, the plot itself is engaging. There are so many things going on that it kept me entertained and definitely interested. My problem came from the fact that Scythe seemed to find herself in trouble, and by trouble, I mean issues that called for her death time and time again. It got to the point where I just kept thinking, "Seriously?? You were just almost put to death and you decide to do THIS??" "Really??"
Add to this that I listened to this on audio. Because this is an ALC, I didn't have the option to also read a print version. Why is that important? Well, this was narrated in a Duet Narration (which I love) by Laura Horowitz (whom I normally love) and Michael Gallagher. For whatever reason, I had a HUGE problem with the way she chose to narrate Scythe's character.
Yes, Scythe is an arrogant and angry character, but it felt like the female narrator (Laura) was constantly yelling her dialogue. It was a nonstop angry and screaming narration, even during times when I don't think she needed to be angry. It got to the point where it became so irritating that it began to impact the way I felt about Scythe herself. I also didn't have the option to take a break and just read a portion to see if I was getting the same impression from Scythe. So that unfortunately quickly turned to irritation.
Other than that, I did enjoy the story, but it never grew to the feeling you get when you are completely immersed.
Yes, this is the first book in the series so of course, there is quite the cliffhanger. I will be looking forward to reading book 2.
Thank you to NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for the opportunity to listen to and review this ALC. This book will be out for publication on December 2, 2026.\
'Power should never belong to those who can buy it'
This was my first book by Chloe C. Peñaranda and I really enjoyed it. The pacing was consistent throughout and it kept me reading, constantly wanting to know what was going to happen next. Twists throughout kept me really engaged, quite the rollercoaster at times and the twists towards the end were both heartbreaking and shocking.
I really enjoyed the relationships, particularly the tension between Skye and her sister and the ups and downs between Skye and Asha.There is a lot of yearning between the two of them, without the book being particularly spicy, which worked really well for me.
There are definitely some familiar elements here; The Hunger Games, Harry Potter and a little Fourth Wing came to mind, with the magic, academy setting, deadly trials and morally grey characters.
At times I did feel it lacked a little depth, particularly with some of the side characters. They stayed quite on the periphery and I would have liked to have seen more from them. I also found Skye frustrating, and I didn't always understand her but it wasn't a deal breaker.
One of my favourite parts was Adam, an autistic coded character who I really hope comes into his own in future books.
Overall, a really enjoyable read that kept me interested throughout, and I'm a little sad that I'm going to have to wait quite some time for the next one! Really appreciative to have had the opportunity to read this as an ARC thanks Netgalley and Pan Macmillan/Tor Bramble
Thank you to Book Break by Pan MacMillan for sending me a proof copy of this book before publication. It will remain one of my prized possessions. I am leaving this review voluntarily and all views are my own.
Pocket dragons. Pocket Phoenixes. An FMC called Scythe. A romantasy MMC who wears glasses. Honestly, Chloe C. Peñaranda said “let’s make these characters actually look and feel different from everyone else” and I respect it.
First of all, I bloody loved Scorch and Ignis. They were instant favourites of mine. I just wish we’d had more of them throughout because I was fully invested in my tiny magical creatures.
One thing I really appreciated was how unique the character descriptions felt. None of the main characters immediately brought another book to mind, which is surprisingly refreshing in a genre where everyone apparently has the same face, hair and six-pack. And as a neurodivergent lady, I particularly loved the representation we got with Adam. We also have a wonderfully diverse cast with characters of multiple ethnicities and disabilities that aren’t put across as disabilities at all, which is always a win.
Peñaranda's writing is, as always, thick. This woman does not believe in simply telling you what a room looks like when she could apparently describe the molecular structure of the curtains. However, I actually found the descriptiveness much less jarring here than I did in one of her other books, The Stars Are Dying. It flowed far better for me in this book and made the world feel incredibly cinematic, almost like I was watching a film unfold rather than reading it.
The amount of thought and attention that has clearly gone into the lore is genuinely commendable. There is SO much history and magic behind this world. My main issue was that some of those lore and history explanations came in fairly chunky doses rather than being sprinkled throughout the story. The pacing itself was consistent, but those heavier information dumps made the book feel slower to me than it actually was, which ultimately kept me at a 4 star rating. It’s just personal preference, but I prefer my info sprinkled in rather than dumped as it makes it easier to digest.
The trials at the beginning were particularly interesting and gave me “Squid Game but make it fantasy” vibes. However, I did find myself questioning how Scythe figured out the first fire-related section so quickly. There didn't seem to be much working out involved when the answer wasn't particularly obvious. I did notice that the people whose natural magical affinity eventually aligned with the Archmagus who chose them seemed to be more active in figuring out the trial connected to their eventual magic, so perhaps that's what was happening with Scythe too — but even then, it felt like there was very little actual figuring it out on the page when it came to hers, where as we saw the others figuring it out.
The banter between Asher and Scythe? Top tier. And the final 100 pages were firmly in 5 star territoryfor me. I predicted a couple of the twists, because apparently my brain has decided it needs to be annoying and suspicious about everything, but I absolutely did not predict how some of them would play out. My jaw was somewhere on the bloody floor with the Ignis twist I, for some reason, did not see coming, but I loved it. I also loved Talon, which is precisely why I'm still angry about his character arc. I am holding a grudge, thank you for asking.
One thing I will say, because I've seen people deducting stars for editing errors and typos: this is an uncorrected ARC that won’t be published until November. It literally tells you what it is. If you're choosing to read an uncorrected ARC and then getting irritated because it contains errors that will obviously be corrected before publication... respectfully, touch grass. Yes, there were a few mistakes that made me stumble. No, they weren't enough to take away from the actual story or my enjoyment of it, and if you’re unable to see past that in an ARC, perhaps you shouldn’t be reading uncorrected ARCs? Just a thought.
The Bloodfire Oath is an ambitious, incredibly detailed romantasy with a fascinating magic system, a cinematic feel, unique characters, brilliant banter and some excellent twists. I have approximately seventeen thousand unanswered questions now, so naturally I will be patiently awaiting book two while pretending I am a calm and reasonable person.
If you love books with corrupt power systems, imperfect morally grey heroines, unique magic, adorable pocket-sized creatures and twists that make you question whether your jaw is capable of remaining attached to your face, pick this one up. I wouldn’t recommend it for non-fantasy forward lovers of the genre though as the magic system and lore is heavy.
WELL, I WAS NOT EXPECTING THAT. And when I say that, I mean THREE things: THAT ENDING. HOW MUCH I ENJOYED THIS BOOK. AND HOW BADLY I NEED THE NEXT ONE. 😭🔥
I’ll be honest, I went into this one with mixed feelings. I’d previously read a book by this author that wasn’t quite for me, but the premise of The Bloodfire Oath sounded right up my street, so I decided to give it a chance. And honestly? I’M SO GLAD I DID. 🖤
Let’s talk about the characters because MY GOODNESS. Yes, they had their flaws, but they had me emotionally invested and completely hooked.
ASH. ASH. ASH. 🫠🔥 I need to know MORE about this man immediately. That’s all I’m saying for now.
Scythe definitely tested my patience at times (although, let’s be real, most FMCs manage to do that at some point 😂), but she’s still a badass, and the direction her story took? I AM SHOOKETH. I need answers, and I need them yesterday.
The world-building, the magic system and the creatures? I absolutely ate it up. I was hooked, and I’m so intrigued to discover more about this world and what lies ahead.
If you love elemental magic with a twist, demons, magical weapons, forbidden romance, mentor/student dynamics, lies, betrayal and characters who will have you feeling ALL THE FEELS, then this one deserves a spot on your TBR. 👀
Is it a flawless read? No. Did I have the time of my life reading it, get completely invested in the characters and finish desperate for more? ABSOLUTELY.
Sometimes a book reminds you that it’s worth giving an author another chance, and this was definitely one of those reads for me. I’m so glad I picked this one up, and I’m officially impatient for the next instalment!
⭐ 4.5 STARS
A huge thank you to Book Break UK and the publisher for the opportunity to read this one! 🖤📚
I was excited to read this book, so excited that I started reading it the day it arrived (ARC); however, I couldn't make it past the first few chapters. Call me picky, deranged, impossible to please, etc..., but the book was so descriptive that I was unable to envision the characters or place myself within the story. Everything down to the textures and shapes of fabric was described, which I understand may be appealing to many, but I found the level of detail suffocating to my imagination. The extensive details were also quite wordy, which lead me to lose focus on the scenes within the story. I tried skipping ahead to see if I could get past it, but the style of writing just didn't mesh with my tastes. I am sure this book would be appealing to many, but not for me.
Thank you to NetGalley and the author for the opportunity to read this ARC!
I really liked the premise of this book, and it got off to a really fast-paced start with Scythe, our FMC and an assassin, unexpectedly finding herself part of an elite academy. I was immediately intrigued by where the story was going to take her.
However, by around 30% in, I found that the pacing started to slow down a little, and I struggled to get past some of the more stereotypical fantasy romance tropes. For example, Scythe develops such strong feelings for Asher, despite the fact that it really feels like she barely knows him at that point! That said, I did really enjoy that the romance itself is a true slow burn, and I’m definitely here for that.
I also struggled quite a lot with the animosity between Scythe and her sister. I just didn’t fully understand where it came from or why their relationship was so hostile, which made some of those scenes difficult for me to connect with.
There were definitely things I really enjoyed, though. I loved the various girl-power elements throughout the story, as well as the cut-throat nature of some of the characters. At times, it gave me very much Game of Thrones vibes, which I was absolutely here for! I also really appreciated the autism representation.
Overall, I’d give this 3.5 ⭐️. I did struggle a little with actually reading the ARC copy itself, which may have impacted my reading experience, but there was still plenty here that I enjoyed and I’d be interested to see where the story goes next.
The Bloodfire Oath is a fantastic start to a new fantasy trilogy!
I really enjoyed getting pulled into this world. The worldbuilding and magic system were some of my favorite parts. There’s so much history, mystery, and detail behind the Arcanum Order, and I loved discovering how everything fits together. The trials added another layer of intrigue, and there was always something that made me question what I thought I knew.
The characters really grew on me, and I’m especially curious about Ash and all the layers we have yet to uncover. I also enjoyed watching characters evolve into new versions of themselves as they face challenges, learn, and grow. I’m invested in seeing where their journeys take them.
And those twists toward the end! Just when I thought I had things figured out, the story managed to surprise me again. The final stretch had me completely hooked, and that cliffhanger left me with approximately seventeen thousand questions.
This book definitely takes its time building the world, but I appreciated having that foundation. Between the magic, complicated loyalties, character development, and unexpected revelations, there’s plenty here to keep fantasy lovers engaged.
Now I’m just going to need book two immediately. Apparently patience is not one of my magical abilities. 🦄🪄😂
(Note: My apologies if I spell any names incorrectly; I listened to an ALC).
One of my dear bookish friends promised a slutty man with glasses in this book. Unfortunately, despite the intriguing MMC, this book is blunt with telling instead of showing. There is also use of “invite” instead of “invitation”, demonstrating the lack of proper editing. Our FMC, Scythe, reads much younger than the twenty-five she’s supposed to be, as does her sister Laura, who is an unfortunate example of the dumb younger sibling trope.
This is very similar to The Tarot Trials in both themes and writing style. The more I listened, the more I had a sense of deja vu remembering that book.
I enjoyed the duet narration, however, narrator Laura Horowitz’s tone for Scythe is a bit flat.
Trigger warnings for classism/prejudice, murder, violence.
Many thanks to Macmillan Audio and Netgalley for my free ALC! It has not affected my honest review.
4.5 stars. An action packed, tense, fun romantasy that does not slow down from start to finish!
I went into this book without any high expectations and not knowing what I would think - and boy did it exceed my expectations! We follow our fmc Scythe, an assassin from a disadvantaged background. who foils a plot of steal an invitation to compete in the Guild and be part of the Arcanum Order. This moment is the catalyst for many things to come for Scythe in the story and it doesn’t let up for a minute, there are so many twists and reveals you’re not bored for a second. We have a lot of fighting and action scenes, especially as there are a lot of physical trials the competitors go through to reach the next stages. The monsters they fought definitely upped that stakes, alongside trying to survive against other competitors who want you dead, meant Scythe didn’t catch a break! The magic system was interesting, and I thought the idea that they have to use a Scion and a magical stone to access and use their powers a fun idea. This is especially when it comes to being chosen by one of the magical powers, as they have to place the stone to see what colour is glows to tell you which power has accepted you. Of course we have flirting and romance between Schthe and her mentor Ash, which will have you giggling and kicking your feet! I did have to concentrate whilst reading this, as there is so much to understand from the world, the magic. the villains, the reveals and so forth so that I could properly understand it all. However, it was worth it as I had a really fun time and really enjoyed the story and can’t wait for the next book.
Perfect if you love demons, bonding oaths, deadly trials, magical academy setting, touch her and die
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with an arc in exchange for an honest review. .
I was immediately hooked from chapter one, and this turned out to be such an enjoyable read!
Scythe was a fantastic FMC for me. She made mistakes, fought like hell, and her inner dialogue made her feel genuinely relatable. I love an FMC who isn't always certain of herself, who struggles, questions who she's becoming and faces hardships, but ultimately refuses to let them define her. Scythe's determination to survive was outstanding. It never felt like simple plot armour; it felt like a woman who absolutely refused to succumb to death. And then there's Ash. HOT AS HELL. This is exactly how I want my enemies-to-lovers introductions to go. Actual enemies. Actual hatred. Trying to kill one another. Give me the hostility, the chase and the tension! The chemistry between these two was absolutely on fire, and I found myself practically squealing at their interactions. The push and pull was SO satisfying. The plot kept me on my toes, with twist after twist. I started becoming suspicious of certain characters around the 50% mark, but even then, some of the revelations genuinely shocked me.
I also loved the themes woven throughout the story, particularly how easily greed and the pursuit of power can consume people, and the importance of holding onto love and your values along the way. The pacing felt steady, the timelines were easy to follow, and I thought both the worldbuilding and magic system were explored really well. Also, can we appreciate the fact that they have WANDS?! I absolutely LOVE wands in fantasy, and it was such a fun addition to the magic system. Give me all the wand-wielding magic, please. Add in fighting demons, learning magic, blossoming friendships and found family, and honestly, what's not to love?
My only real criticism is that a few of the plot devices felt somewhat familiar and predictable, with certain developments being easier to guess than others. However, this never took away from my overall enjoyment or made me any less invested in the story. Overall, a really fun read with a brilliant FMC, a dangerously intriguing MMC and the kind of enemies-to-lovers tension I will ALWAYS show up for.
Thank you to NetGalley, Libro.FM, Macmillan Audio, Tor Publishing Group, and Chloe C. Peñaranda for the opportunity to read and review an Advance Reader/Listener Copy of this book!
When I started reading this, I knew it was going to be different from my other reads, and I was NOT disappointed. This was incredible!
From the plot and backstory to the trials, forbidden romance, corruption, and everything in between, there was SO much to love.
I really liked how well this book flowed and how easy it was to follow while still having some complexity to it. The magic system was incredibly interesting, and I loved seeing it develop throughout the story. Not only that, but each trial took us to a new area, and I absolutely LOVED getting to explore those different settings.
And the side characters! I loved the complexity of each one. I LOVED the friendships, as well as the enemies formed throughout the book.
OBVIOUSLY, THE FORBIDDEN RELATIONSHIP. UGHHHH. THE YEARNING, THE PINING, THE RANDOM TOUCHES. YES, GIVE ME MORE!!!
I also don't want to say too much about this, but I really loved the journals included in this book. Sometimes, journal entries at the beginning of chapters aren't something I typically enjoy, but WOW, this one worked so well. I think it was the way they were incorporated that made them feel like another perspective within the story. They added so much to each chapter because we got to see what that character was thinking, whether it was about past events or things that were about to happen.
I ended up crying A BUNCH toward the end of this book, and all I can think about now is how much I'm probably going to cry when I read book 2.
Thank you again to NetGalley, Libro.FM, Macmillan Audio, Tor Publishing Group, and Chloe C. Peñaranda for the opportunity to read and review an Advance Reader/Listener Copy of this book!
I tried to finish it, I truly did. But the start coloured my experience too much. I was lured in by the gorgeous character artwork I’d seen, but ultimately this just wasn’t for me.
I may try and pick it up again at a later date as I’m still intrigued by the historical journal experts at the beginning of many of the chapters. This, I thought was the best part of what I’ve read so far.
I also liked the idea of the tiny creatures, the pocket phoenix and pocket dragon, belonging to the FMC and MMC respectively.
There is also neurodivergent representation that I thought, from how much I read, was really well done in the way the character’s different way of seeing and doing things is held in esteem.
I feel like there was too much exposition when trying to set up the world, and this along with the inconsistencies and grammar made the writing feel a little clumsy to me.
I also struggled to understand the logic behind a lot of the FMC’s behaviour. And, excuse me if this changes later on, her sister is 21 years only but has the survival instincts of a dodo bird. She reads, to me, as a damsel only written as the object of Scythe’s motivations. Perhaps it’s just a personal thing for me to be annoyed by characters like this who do rely on others to protect them when there’s nothing stopping them from learning how to protect themselves.
The other side characters also fall flat so far, and they feel like tools to move the plot along instead of individuals with their own wants and needs. I hope this changes further into the story.
The Bloodfire Oath completely pulled me in, and I honestly struggled to put it down. I got to the point where I literally had to cover the page with my hand so I wouldn’t accidentally read ahead, while also forcing myself to slow down because I just wasn’t ready to leave this story yet.
The plot twists were SO good. Every time I thought I had things figured out, something happened that completely threw me off. I loved all the secrets, reveals & moments that had me questioning everything. I was desperate to know what happened next, but at the same time, I wanted the book to just keep going forever.
I also loved Scythe as a character, & the tension between her & Asher had me completely invested. Their chemistry, the slow burn, the banter & all the mystery surrounding them kept me turning the pages.
Add in the magic system, demons, danger & an addictive storyline, & I was completely hooked.
And because I read this as an ARC, the worst part was knowing I’d have to wait even longer for the next book.
If you’re looking for a romantasy that keeps you guessing, has you desperate to find out what happens next, & leaves you absolutely unwilling to say goodbye when you reach the end, keep this one on your radar.
I was OBSESSED.
Release Date: 1st December 2026 🗓️
Thank you @panmacmillan @brambleromance for sending me a copy to read & review!
This brutal and fast paced fantasy world pulled me in and swept me away. I could not put this story down! This was an excellent first book for a series and im so excited by the set up and where everyone will go.
Scythe Valethorn is, like all other residents of dimspire, just trying to survive, through albeit harsher means than most. She’s ruthless and strong and I love her fierceness. I am looking forward to learning more of her past as we go into the next book!
Asher is everything, the slutty little glasses had me weak from the start, but his layers peel like an onion and I need to know whats at his core. I love him and his complexities, through every twist!
The magic system is a mix of classic fantasy elements with new and fresh twists that keep things exciting while feeling grounded and intentional. There is Demons & other Realms, academy, trials , elemental magic, mentor/mentee dynamics and plot twists, all used with the right amount of restraint and intention. P.S. Magic wands are SO BACK BABY!
The world building is easy to understand and flows into the storyline without feeling clunky. The magical creature companions have my whole heart!!
The last quarter of the book really throws balls to the wall with reveals, tense battles and twists that slap you in the face, setting us up for some epic expansion, character complexities and depth going into the second book, which has me FERAL! The next book cannot come fast enough! I truly don’t know how to stop theorizing and dreaming up whats to come.
The Bloodfire Oath has all the familiar romantasy ingredients without feeling like another copy/paste version of them.
Scythe has an actual life beyond Asher. Her sister matters. The friendships matter. Even the messier relationships around her get enough attention for the romance to never carry the entire book. And Asher... glasses on a romantasy MMC? Love it 👓
The magic has depth without becoming a textbook, and the little creatures are basically begging for fan art and book swag. Pocket dragons. Pocket phoenixes. Chloe knew what she was doing.
And the ending... 😱
🎧 DUET NARRATION. Always an immediate plus. Laura Horowitz and Michael Gallagher are so well matched, and having them perform together gives the tension way more life. Gallagher especially gets put through the wringer with the male cast. Tiny shifts in personality could've gotten messy fast, but he nails them. The aggression, the quieter moments, all those little changes in delivery... chef's kiss. Horowitz gives Scythe exactly the right amount of bite to meet him there.
First Peñaranda book for me, and definitely not the last.
Thank you to NetGalley, Macmillan Audio, Laura Horowitz, Michael Gallagher, and Chloe C. Peñaranda for providing me this ALC in exchange for an honest review.
Unfortunately, this one just wasn’t quite clicking for me. It actually started off really strongly, and I was instantly intrigued by the world being introduced. The classist elements, elemental magic and an assassin-esque FMC had me really interested in seeing where the story would go. I also thoroughly enjoyed the trials. They felt genuinely unique and pretty brutal, which was definitely a highlight for me.
However, I just haven’t found myself compelled to keep picking it up. The pacing feels incredibly slow, and by a third of the way through I was expecting things to have started picking up a little more. Instead, I felt like very little had actually happened, and the story was falling a bit flat for me.
I think it’s best for me to put this one down before it sends me into a big slump. I might revisit it when the audiobook is released and see if a different format makes a difference, because there are definitely elements of the story I enjoyed.
Thank you so much to the publisher for the ARC. I’m sorry this one wasn’t quite for me this time!
This is my first impression of Peñaranda’s work, and the way I ate this up? 🤏🏽 The way the tropes were actually troping too? Love.
I was so in love w/ Scythe so early on, an absolute baddie if I’ve ever seen one 🫶🏽 And I have so many curiosities about her background. The characters overall were all v interesting!! I was fr falling in love with so many of the side characters, and I’m way way way too intrigued about what’s going on with Lara and… I fear I need more than a little diary entry about what’s going on the other side lol!!
AND ASHER AND HIS LITTLE SLUTTY GLASSES?! Oh, you already know he had me in the nassstiest chokehold lmfao. The forbiddances of it all!! It does it for me every time 😈 AND THAT TWIST!! Gagged.
I loved so many aspects about this story too, like? Deadly Games & Trials. Magical Academia. I fear this Chloe cooked with this one, chat.
And Laura Horowitz along with Michael Gallagher did a phenomenal job narrating this!! The way characters were embodied, and given their own voice. I almost thought this was full cast 🤏🏽 I. Am. A. Fan.
Magical Academy Deadly Trials Grumpy x Sunshine Touch Her and 💀 Forced Proximity Only One Bed Who Did This To You? Morally Grey Heroine Found Family
Duet narration - Laura Horowitz & Michael Gallagher Great narration. They performed this romantasy perfectly.
Book #1 The Arcanum Order series
I won't lie to you I struggled a little in the beginning to connect with the story, however by about 15% in I found myself hooked and not wanting to stop listening. The story is unique, captivating, and the characters are intriguing. The narrators brought this book to life in a beautiful way.
Scythe is a strong FMC who has landed herself in the middle of a magical world where only the upper class have magic. She is from the lesser class trying to prove herself. Asher is one of the arch mages and she becomes his apprentice. These two have wonderful banter and chemistry. I really enjoyed them both.
I would recommend this book to all fantasy fans.
Thank you Chloe C. Penaranda, RB Media, & NetGalley for this ALC.
This was an adventure and quite the read. ✨️ I was fully immersed in this world. While the magic system was initially hard to wrap my mind around, I loved the fresh, new, and uniqueness of it. I was so drawn to the characters and I loved the varied nature of each of our found family friends. The integration of the journal entires had me intrigued but unsure of the connection until the very end and when that came through I GASP -- to be honest I gasp A LOT near the end. 🤣
This was SUCH great read and I already NEED more.
As an audiobook, I will forever praise Laura Horowitz as a narrator, she is phenomenal and always does such an amazing job setting a scene! And Michael Gallagher did great too. My only qualm was two of our main male narrators were a bit easy to confuse with both of their 'M' names.
Thank you so much to NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for this ALC.
This is one of those books that makes me want to read everything else the author has ever written. I’m already itching for the rest of the series and this book isn’t even technically released 😩 I will definitely end up buying the special edition later this year.
Asher and his slutty little glasses is absolutely my type of MMC 🤩 Scythe’s journey is a little predictable but it wasn’t a detection for me and I can’t wait to see what tiny deathling does next.
Thank you to author Chloe C. Peñaranda, Bramble / Macmillan publishing, and Goodreads giveaways for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
I went into this knowing it was an arc, so I’m definitely taking that into consideration, but I do think it needs quite a bit of editing. There were moments where the writing and errors became quite distracting and, at times, pulled me out of the story.
That being said, I did enjoy the book overall. The plot was interesting, and I liked that pretty much everyone is morally grey. The FMC was definitely frustrating, and I think we’re supposed to feel frustrated with her choices, but there were times when I found it difficult to actually warm to her as a character.
I think my biggest suggestion would be to make some of the characters a little more likeable and easier to root for. If the FMC is going to be scheming and making questionable decisions, I think she needs enough charm or likeability behind those actions to make us want to follow along with her, even when we disagree with her choices.
The plot itself was good, though, and I’m interested to see where things go from here, especially as this is only book one. There’s definitely potential here, and I’ll be curious to see how the characters develop in the next.
Thanks to NetGalley and Pan Macmillan for my arc, I really appreciate it.
This was a really enjoyable read. It was fast paced and I was desperate to stay awake and finish it.
It hooked me in from the beginning. Our FMC, Scythe is an female assassin/spy sent on a mission to kill a target and steal the letter they have concealed on their person, I mean what's more gripping than that!
Throw in deadly trials to gain entry to an elite academy, a really interesting magic system and a brooding MMC who is also gentle (he tends to her wounds) and you're in for a treat.
I particularly liked the different types of demons, that was really interesting.
"Readers seeking a purely trope-guided story may find something to enjoy, but others should look elsewhere."
--Publishers Weekly
Oh, yes. High chances are I would be looking elsewhere.
Disclaimer: Review and rating of the sampler ONLY. Official full review to come if I read the full book, which is at this point 30% possible. Don't listen to me, I only read the first pages lmfao
However, I already have some (plenty) of thoughts about the sampler I've read last August. So, RTC, I guess.
Thank you to Tor Publishing Group and Goodreads for the physical ARC of The Bloodfire Oath by Chloe Penaranda. #GoodReadsGiveawayWinner
Much like Scythe, I tried to prolong this book for as long as humanly possible because I simply did not want it to end. And now that I’ve finished it, I would give anything to experience that ending for the first time again. The last 10% had me audibly gasping with every new chapter. Every time I thought I had finally figured something out… nope. I was wrong. Again. And again. 😂
It all begins with one thieving job gone very, very wrong. Scythe is supposed to steal an invitation. Simple enough, right? Except instead of handing it over, she keeps it for herself—and suddenly finds herself among the 100 candidates chosen to compete for a place in the Arcanum Order.
There is A LOT of world-building in this book, but I genuinely enjoyed discovering the magical system. Magic comes at a price: you have to bargain with your soul. If you are deemed worthy, your soul becomes bound to a crystal within your wand, which can then shapeshift into two different weapons.
There are six main affinities, and each Archmage is allowed to choose an apprentice from among the 100 initiates. But earning that coveted position isn't easy. The candidates must survive a series of trials, each governed by its own rules, laws, and dangers. And believe me when I say… you do not want to break the rules. #FifthLaw #BloodFireOath #ArcaneLink #AkashicLink
While the candidates are busy navigating the trials and the increasingly complicated magical world around them, there are also threats brewing at the borders from demons and the Akashic. This isn't necessarily the main focus of the story, but that looming threat is always there, creating this underlying sense of unrest.
The Twists 👀 Okay, not really—but I am trying very hard not to spoil anything. Every time I thought I had something figured out, the book basically laughed in my face and screamed at me NOPE. 😂 I was constantly questioning what was real, who could be trusted, and what was actually going on. The pacing kept me turning the pages, and once I hit the final stretch, there was absolutely no stopping me.
There is also some romance woven into the story, although I have a feeling book two is going to turn up the spice considerably. And considering how badly I need book two right now… I am READY.
There are dangerous creatures everywhere, but honestly? Sometimes the people are just as dangerous. You never quite know who—or what—is an ally.
One of my favorite aspects of the story was watching the apprentices begin to form a found family among themselves. I won't say much more because discovering those relationships for yourself is part of the fun. I also really enjoyed the characters individually.
The story is primarily told from Scythe's point of view, and she is our FMC. She is a rebellious spitfire, stubborn as hell, and seemingly incapable of staying out of trouble. Basically, trouble might as well be her middle name.
Then there's her sister, Lara, who is almost the complete opposite. She has such a compassionate, gentle nature, and I really enjoyed watching her grow throughout the story.
One thing that has been driving me absolutely CRAZY, though, is the mystery surrounding Scythe's lost memories. We still don't know what happened. I have approximately 47 theories floating around in my head. I will say absolutely nothing more because I refuse to spoil this for anyone.
And then we have Asher- The MMC. The broody, pyrospheric Archmage. There are plenty of rumors surrounding his past, how he earned his position, and—perhaps most importantly—his morals. And yes, he is morally gray. Honestly, almost everyone in this book seems to exist somewhere in that morally questionable gray area,which makes things even more interesting.
I also have to mention Magnus, Adam, Riku, and Talon. They each have very different roles within the story, but I absolutely loved having them pop up throughout the book. They brought so much personality to the different scenes and quickly became some of my favorite male characters.
My Final Thoughts - I swear I am almost done! That ending? You will find your jaw on the floor and the book across the room. (Mine was thrown so hard!)