Here's an interesting conundrum: how do you rate a book which is witty and well-written, but just isn't for you? Do you focus strictly on the story itself and the skill of the writer? Or do you focus on whether or not you liked what you were reading?
I think I can leave a review and not a rating, so for now I'll do that.
I was intrigued by the notion of a high school-age boy who is part of a secret supernatural James Bond-type government organization. My curiosity was also piqued by the fact that the main character was gay, as there is a shortage of good stories/roles for gay male characters.
Unfortunately this book did not work for me, for a couple of reasons. It's nothing to do with the book itself - totally a "it's not you, it's me" moment if ever there was one. I personally am not interested in reading what I'll call "gay fiction" (or to be more politically correct, LGBTQ fiction--and before you can say I'm being prejudiced, for the record I bat for this team.) I am not interested in reading a gay-themed story where sexual orientation and sex in general is present in almost every page.
What I do like? Stories about events, situations, etc, where people happen to be gay, and where that is not the focal point of the story. Where you could interchangeably put either a gay or straight character, and with the exception of the love interest, everything pretty much goes the same. Because, gay straight or anything in between, what I don't really go for is a story which hints at sex in some form or another on practically every single page. That's boring to me (and a little cheap.) Sorry, that's just my opinion.
So this story starts out, right away, in a bedroom. In a bedroom scene, and though the characters aren't having sex, the description of perfect toned bodies ad nauseam was just that - enough to make me nauseous.
But I gave it the benefit of the doubt and stuck it out about 20% through the story. Until which I ascertained that not only the teenagers were acting like horny teenagers--the few adults were also acting like horny teenagers. Not to mention those attractive, muscular guys around every corner whom the protagonist is lusting after (while alternately singing his own praises for remaining "sort of" a virgin, whatever that means. I didn't stick around to find out.)
This will sound funny, I know. But when reading a book, too much sex (not just the act, but horny characters in general) is a huge turn-off for me. If it furthers the storyline, I have no problem with it. But when every page drips with sex, I'm out. It's too much.
What's interesting is that I read a lot of YA fiction, and now I wonder if, in general, most (other) characters in other YA novels are given a bit of adult common sense to appease reader older than 17 (sometimes not a LOT of sense; but usually some). I can't fault that Dagger and his friends are exactly like a gay guy and his friends in high school (I should know, right?) But I really dislike stereotypes (I mean, come on. Fighting with a female friend to compete for the attentions of the new guy in school? Bleh.) Some guys probably empathize highly with the characters in this book. Unfortunately, I'm not one of those people.
Take too much sex, add vapid/perpetually horny characters, and then put a secret agent lair in the basement of a school (?!) and I pretty much lost interest. Sorry. If the author happens to read this (hopefully not) please don't take it personally, and I am planning on giving this book a try again at some point in the future. I am confident it is rated highly for a reason. I just can't deal with the oversexed characters right now.