I’ve always liked the novella length, and I know I’m not the only one, but it’s been a while since they were considered commercially viable, though plenty of “short” novels published in the 50s and 60s were actually novellas.
This collection pulls nine, including some nominated for Nebula and World Fantasy Awards last year. The balance comes close to the middle with five stories I really like and four I really didn’t. This surprised me a little as I’d normally expect more of a cross section of things that worked for me to different degrees, but every collection is different.
Oddly, only one of the four fantasy novellas worked for me and only one of the five science fiction ones didn’t. The stories that worked, worked very well:
-> Yesterday’s Kin by Nancy Kress, which I actually read in the 32nd Annual collection by Gardner Dozois, but is a good story regardless.
-> The Lightning Tree by Patrick Rothfuss, which makes me want to pick up the first of the Kingkiller Chronicles.
-> Claudius Rex by John P. Murphy, which was a nice blend of science fiction and noir, with an AI I’d like to classify as benevolent.
-> In Her Eyes by Seth Chambers, which I didn’t expect to like when I started, but the main character’s love interest proved both to be a shapeshifter and really complicated.
-> The Churn by James S.A. Corey, which gave me some great background on a character I really liked in the first season of The Expanse TV series, and I’m slowly making my way towards the novels.
As for the stories that didn’t work for me, I’ll just leave it here that they didn’t. your mileage may vary.
Overall rating: using my satisfying mathematical weighting of stories by length and rating, I come up with just a hair under 2.9 stars, which I’ll round to three. Some love, some hate, and enough things I didn’t get to read elsewhere that I might put this year’s volume on my reading list.