On January 21, 2015, a pro-ISIS Twitter account reported that John Maguire, a 23-year-old university drop-out from the Ottawa Valley town of Kemptville, had been killed fighting Kurds in the Syrian city of Kobani. A few weeks before, Maguire had starred in a YouTube video threatening Canada for bombing ISIS forces in Iraq. He is one of the dozens of young Canadians who have chosen to fight in a vicious conflict that really had little to do with them and with Canada.
Why would young people choose to fight in other people’s wars, especially one as bloody and cruel as this one? Why has ISIS become so good at attracting foreign fighters?
This book examines the lure of this radical Islamist its religious beliefs, sophisticated propaganda, and vast social media networks. ISIS is now a go-to cause for alienated young people in the Islamic World and the West. Does it offer answers to troubled young people? Are ISIS’s crimes -- slavery, murder, rape, repression, and the destruction of heritage sites -- an attraction in and of themselves? What do we do about the people who take up ISIS’s cause but stay in their home country? What do we do with the ISIS recruits who come home?
The Killing Game examines what draws young men and women to join violent social/political movements. It looks at the psychology of young men and women today and the propaganda used by all sides in the Middle East conflicts, as well as the security laws and the political initiatives that have been designed to stop Canadians from being radicalized.
From the irresistible lure of Marxist-Leninism of the 1930s through the ‘60s and ‘70s, and including the appeal of Nazism to young Germans in the 1930s, this book also investigates what it is that draws young people to join and fight for causes as different as the Spanish Civil War of the 1930s and the Red Brigades of the 1970s, but with an emphasis on the attraction of ISIS and radical Islam in our own time.
Ok, everything was fine until the last page, where Bourrie mentions that if there would be a Caliphate in Syria that respects international norms and laws, they should be allowed to have it. Uhm, how about no? The entire point of a Caliphate is the same as it was in the Ottoman Empire, and it is based on expansion and conquest. Other than that, an informing read - although very Canada-centered even if it claims to be a study on the Occidental view on ISIS. Makes some really strong points for "prevention", as opposed to "prosecution", and I tend to agree with that view.
While the individual accounts of ISIS fighters who came from Canada and the effects of their radicalization on their families and themselves is fascinating, Bourrie's attempts to pull in thoughts about religion, technology, and the psychology of radicalization feels very flat and shallow. His excerpts often feel like he sat down and just wrote his thoughts out, found one or two books, grabbed a quote from each and moved on to the next story of an extremist. For example, all of his thoughts about how Canadian ISIS fighters are able to kill so easily are based almost exclusively on David Grossman's 'On Killing'. What should have been the heart of the book was Bourrie's accounts of Canadians who were radicalized and went to fight for ISIS in Iraq and Syria. How they came to be radicalized, their families reactions, and the consequences (most of the fighters were killed) of their actions was very interesting. But these stories end up being chapter introductions and endings, rather than being at the heart of the story. While the situation on the ground has dramatically changed since the book was published, this didn't bother me as much as Bourrie's disconnected and poorly researched sections that weren't anchored to the experiences of the Canadian ISIS fighters.
Not a comfortable read, but well-written and helpful. Very thought provoking on many levels—culturally, politically, and socially. Bourrie doesn't spare punches as he walks through the psychology behind what is going on at home and abroad.
As a Christian, it merely confirmed in my mind how the true solution is in the gospel and the Church being the Church. Our call is to reach out with love and compassion to our youth, the waves of refugees, and the Muslims next door.
In The Killing Game, Bourrie attempts to explain how ISIS so successfully got its foothold in the region of Syria and Iraq it currently occupies, and how the organization has been effective in attracting foreign fighters. He goes on to show historical similarities to the tactics employed by the self-described caliphate––how its messaging relates to Nazi and modern-day Canadian propaganda; how its recruitment efforts resemble those of the Communists of the Spanish Civil War; how its attempts to build bonds between fighters resemble those of urban gangs; and how its simple ideology relates to that of White Supremacists. This not only helps Bourrie show previous pitfalls when pushing back against these groups, but also gives him a historical precedence for the solutions he poses to help stymie the flow of foreign fighters from the West and to rehabilitate those who return.
The book’s definitely not perfect. While the examples from our past help to give Bourrie’s suggestions some credibility, most social programs in a similar vein currently being used across the EU have little to no systems in place to track their success, making it difficult to make such recommendations definitively. (Bourrie acknowledges this in the text.) That being said, he still makes a compelling argument that the status quo, with regards to Western tactics to combat ISIS, will likely be ineffective in the long-run, and he actually provides solutions that seem reasonable enough, to me at least. The bigger issue with The Killing Game is its tedious middle. With a strong start and great flow of discussion––merging stories about Western converts to radical Islam with examples of specific tactics ISIS employs and clear explanations of the point of it all––we linger on the subjects of propaganda on social media and the reliance of dreams to aid in decision making for the majority of these extremists. While I understand the importance of these topics, I just think some of the talk could have easily been trimmed to aid the overall flow. Thankfully, as we approach the end, we get to the point very concisely.
All in all, I found The Killing Game enjoyable and informative. Bourrie convinced me of the need for improved programs to help identify youth at risk for radicalization, to support them and their families, and to help them, as well as fighters returning from Syria, function and succeed in Western society. (I’m just a bit sad that we seem to be lagging far behind the rest of the Western world, here in Canada, where this is concerned.)
Interested to know about Canada and ISIS? GO for it.
This books talks about the mindset of Canada in fight with the world's terrorism, mainly ISIS. Some psychological evaluation has also been done on the mindset if the people fleeing to ISIS war zones. Overall, The killing Game provide a new point of view for the global peace. But only through Canadian mirror.
Eye-opening and informative, this book clarified and put into some context the ongoing ISIS war and it influences vulnerable young people the world over. Sometimes there was too much information for me to absorb but the big pictures became a little easier to understand.