When fate thrusts a young man into hell, who must he become to claw his way out?
After the Providence sank beneath the ocean, blacksmith Tayen washes up on the shore of an unknown island as the only survivor. Haunted by the drowning screams of his crewmates, his only desire is to block out those traumatic memories and return home. But there’s something else on the island, lurking in the shadows and roaming free at night, intent on keeping him there. His mother knew them as yee naaldlooshii. He knows them as wolves. But not just any wolves—skinwalkers.
From his Navajo ancestors, who come to him while he dreams, Tayen learns that his destiny on this island isn’t simply to survive; he’s destined to kill an evil that has endured for centuries. Drawing on his late mother’s teachings and his own wit, Tayen must find the courage to fight for his soul, whatever the cost.
Thank you to NetGalley and River Grove Books for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Unfortunately, this book just didn't work for me. The premise was intriguing but the execution was lacking in multiple areas. I appreciated the Navajo culture and First Nations history incorporated into the story and I really wish I had liked the book more than I did.
The prose is simultaneously clunky and lacking depth. I felt more like I was reading a summary of events than a fully fleshed out novel. There was a lot of "telling" without a lot of "showing." It almost felt like I was reading a sequence of events such as "Tayen did this. Then he did this. He thought about this and then he did this," and it was very exhausting. Due to this, Tayen felt hollow—almost as though he was an outline or concept—lacking the intricacies that make up a well thought out character.
The novel also somehow discussed every mundane banal thing Tayen was doing while also exhibiting severe pacing issues where it felt like both nothing and everything was happening at once. There were moments at a time where one paragraph was everything Tayen was doing in short, choppy sentences, and then the next paragraph we would skip weeks of time. This was incredibly jarring and deeply affected the immersion of the novel.
I never once felt any suspense or foreboding on behalf of Tayen. From the start, it felt as though he not only conveniently had every necessary tool at his disposal, but knew how to use them as well. He seemed to have all these skills: fishing, sailing, hunting, building, crafting, and so on and so forth, that just allowed him to survive on this island for months. It is not only incredibly unrealistic, but removes any kind of suspense that would have been present. There wasn't one time that I felt like he was ill equipped or really in any danger, which given the fact that the island is inhabited by skinwalkers, you would think the reader would have some sense of danger. Not only did Tayen have all the knowledge needed to survive flawlessly—with him even building his own castle—the skinwalkers are not that threatening. Most nights they sit and watch him from afar, other nights they may swarm his boat or his castle, but not often are they really coming head to head with him and attacking him. Things just seem too...convenient.
With all of these things said, they made the book seem both too long due to its mundanity, and too short due to its pacing and continuity issues. I hate giving a poor review to an indie ARC, but I also want to ensure I am honest. I can see the bones of what could've been a great novel, but unfortunately this one seems like it needed a lot more editing.
Thanks to NetGalley and River Grove Books for the ARC!
A Knight On Wolf Island was disappointing, as it had a really intriguing concept, but the execution just wasn’t up to par. The plot moves fast, and there are moments of interesting action, but overall, the clunky prose and lack of connection with the main character hamstring what could have been a great book.
A Knight On Wolf Island follows the adventures of Tayen, a blacksmith lately employed on the whaling ship Providence, after he’s stranded on an island and discovers he’s not alone - terrifying skinwalkers stalk the island in the form of wolves, threatening to kill him every night. This is a great concept, and I really liked the First Nations history and culture the author incorporated throughout this book. I also loved Tayen blending his mother’s Navajo heritage with his father’s German background when he forged himself armour and made himself the Knight of the title. The moments of action in this novel often move fast, and gripped me much better than any other sections. I also really enjoyed Tayen’s friendship with the Trickster coyote, though I wish we could’ve actually seen them interact while Coyote was in human form and learned a bit more about him and his story.
Unfortunately, this novel is really let down by its prose. The writing is incredibly clunky and wooden the vast majority of the time, reading more like a brief summary of what’s happening than novel-worthy prose. I very nearly put this down several times near the beginning on account of hating the prose so much, so I suppose it’s a testament to strength of the plot that I didn’t; it just could’ve been a much better novel with some sentence variation, more description and lingering on atmosphere, less summarising every little thing Tayen is doing…
Tayen himself ends up feeling like he has very little interiority as a result of this clunky summarising style. He makes decisions and makes mistakes throughout the book, but it often feels like the author is just telling me “Tayen made this decision, and then this one,” rather than letting the audience fully inside his head to let us see his decision making and thought process in detail. This is somewhat mitigated in action scenes where we get close focus on what’s happening moment to moment, but it’s not totally fixed. I felt like the text was lacking any sense of Tayen’s emotional complexity throughout; we get very basic reactions to things, e.g. “Tayen felt scared of the wolves” or “Tayen was sad when his mother died,” but these are so basic that Tayen feels massively underdeveloped. His backstory gets info-dumped on us all in one chapter, which feels more like reading a Wikipedia page about Tayen rather than a novel. We don’t really get insight into how Tayen feels about that backstory; we don’t get flashbacks to his previous life scattered through the text, or much sense that he misses (or is even thinking ‘good riddance’ to) his comrades from the whaling ship. (Also I’m pretty sure at one point his mother is said to have died when he was eight, and at another his age when she died is said to be eighteen. These aren’t the kind of mistakes that should make it into a published novel!)
What makes this even more frustrating is that in the middle of the book there are several interlude chapters which aren’t from Tayen’s perspective, and, unfortunately, I found these characters to be far more interesting and vibrant than Tayen even in their brief appearances. The prose here flows better, the action is more focused, and Kimi is a more well realised character even in the brief POV we get from her. It left me wondering what happened in the rest of the novel that Tayen ended up so boring (or why Kimi wasn’t the protagonist, honestly).
There’s also the problem that the narrative lets a lot of things conveniently go Tayen’s way, when it feels a bit unrealistic that they would go so well. For example, it’s very convenient that when he’s drifting in the small boat, unconscious or asleep, several nights in a row, the boat never drifts out to sea or hits a rock or, y’know, runs into the reef that we know is right there, since the bigger ship already hit it! Tayen also seems to be conveniently good at things without any explanation being given for his skills. I can see him being able to sail and fish since he’s lived near the sea and is a sailor, but he sure knows an awful lot about woodworking for a blacksmith! And some serious woodworking, too, as he’s cutting down fully grown trees and turning them into a full wooden palisade within his first few days on the island. We’re given no explanation for this prowess. I guess it’s to fit in with the “knight” thing, since he frames it as building a castle, but it stretched credulity that he would be able to do that, at least for me.
On a related note, there were so many moments while reading this that I was questioning how the skinwalkers weren’t doing super obvious things to hinder Tayen. There were so many moments they could’ve set fire to things, or lain in wait to ambush him, or just set upon him in human form - it seemed odd that they didn’t just do any of these things. The reason they didn’t was sort of gestured at - they didn’t remember how, or something? - but it didn’t make a whole lot of sense. It felt more like their cunning/intelligence level was dictated by the needs of the plot throughout the novel.
Another big problem was that the novel spends a lot of time focused on describing Tayen doing every. little. thing. I cannot count how many times we were told he checked his fishing lines and set fires or made tea or manned the battlements against the wolves, again and again. Instead of just focusing on what was different/new and therefore interesting, we keep getting clunky blow-by-blow accounts of absolutely everything he’s doing, bogging down the forward motion of the plot. At a certain point, we can assume that’s he’s doing the things he needs to do every day, like fishing, without the narrative needing to explicitly tell us he’s doing them!
I’m disappointed in this novel because I can see the bones of what it could have been, and they’re really interesting. With several more rounds of heavy edits, we could’ve got that novel, but the one we have, while still an interesting read in parts, also ends up being a bit of a slog to get through.
I received a digital copy of this book through the publisher on NetGalley for an honest review.
A Knight on Wolf Island follows the story of young Tayen and his quest to escape this cursed island, conquering the evil skin walkers that follow his every movement at night. In this book, you learn how he comes to wash up on the shores of this island, how these creatures came to be, and you see Tayen learn to inhabit the island while he comes up with a plan to destroy these creatures. I found this aspect of this book fascinating because it helps set up the world Tayen inhabits and helps me, as the reader, understand the choices he makes in order to survive in his struggles against the skin walkers.
What I also enjoyed reading in A Knight on Wolf Island was reading the story about how the skin walkers first appeared on the island. I felt like that interlude was great to include because it gave insight into how these creatures first came to the island and how they were able to survive for so long. I also enjoyed reading about the skin walkers because they sounded like fascinating creatures, so I was curious how Tayen would deal with them on the island once he settled into surviving there. I especially enjoyed it when you see the relationship he develops with the one he calls Trickster because they end up having an understanding with each other that he doesn’t have with the rest of the skin walkers that inhabit the island.
What I also enjoyed reading in this book was seeing his dreams and learning more about Tayen’s ancestry through them. They felt like they were a transformative experience from when he first appeared on the island and were an eye into letting him know what he was getting into when it came to fighting the skin walkers. A way for him to become the warrior he needed to be to fight these adversaries. Because I feel like from the first dream to the last, he transforms into a different man on the island as he realizes what he really needs to do in order to defeat the skin walkers so he can escape.
If there was anything in this book I didn’t particularly enjoy, it would have to be the ending. Mostly because after everything Tayen goes through, I expected it to be different. I was hoping that in this book, there would be an epilogue for his story once he gets off the island to see where he goes and find out what happens to the island overall, but that was missing here, so it felt almost like his story wasn’t complete to me because of it. Like I was missing a chapter in his story that should’ve been there.
I also found it strange too that he knew exactly what to do to survive on the island. I understood him knowing how to forge weapons and armor due to his experience as a blacksmith. But him just knowing right off the bat how to get items together to build a fortress in the forest so he could have somewhere to live away from the skin walkers didn’t particularly make any sense to me. I felt like with that aspect of the story, there should’ve been way more struggle for him and mistakes in getting things together than there was. Or, if he knew how to get those things together, more information about Tayen’s character that could explain it to you in a logical manner.
However, I enjoyed reading A Knight on Wolf Island as I enjoyed learning about this cursed island and how Tayen survived it. Also, enjoyed reading about the skin walkers and seeing Tayen fighting against them, and seeing the connection between his dreams and what he was going through while on the island. I recommend this book to anyone who enjoys reading fantasy books, especially books with an element of survival in them, along with anyone who enjoys reading about creatures like these skin walkers. A Knight on Wolf Island is scheduled to be published on October 20, 2026, for anyone interested in reading this book.
I'm sad to say that I expected something slightly different from what I got. Tayen is stranded on an island. I don't know exactly how he got there or what happened (besides the obvious). He immediately switches into survival mode and learns that he shares the island with skinwalkers, evil spirits that he needs to take down. He needs to build a safe space, hunt for food, and wait for the day he can leave.
That is basically all I needed to know, and it came with so much potential, but I never felt like I really connected with the story, especially the main character. While I can appreciate Tayen's skills and how easily he managed to survive, it felt a bit as though he had a solution for every problem and was able to overcome everything. Although I understood why he became the one person who had to fulfil this mission (aside from not getting killed), I still wasn't fully convinced.
I simply didn't care enough about what was happening. It was an easy read overall, and there were some moments I enjoyed, particularly the explanation of why people are sent to the island, but overall, I wanted more from it emotionally. It lacked the depth needed to make me interested in the main character and invested in what was happening to him.
I received an advance review copy, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
An immersive adventure in the tradition of Edgar Rice Burroughs, A Knight on Wolf Island is a showcase for the author's ability to craft a propulsive story populated by familiar archetypes with completely original mythology.
Fans of seafaring fiction will not be disappointed in this authentic view of castaway life, in which the reader finds themselves on the deck of a foundering ship in the first few pages of the book. The novel's supernatural mythology is convincingly based on American Indian lore, the exposition is perfectly balanced to deliver only necessary detail and the suspense never lets up in this tale of survival. Readers who demand the realism of survivalist stories like those by Tim Weed and Michelle Paver will also be pleasantly surprised as the author takes no shortcuts in delivering the gritty detail of the ordeal on every page.
Distinguishing itself from the long shadows cast by books like The Buffalo Hunter Hunter and Lord of the Flies, A Knight on Wolf Island (and hopefully, the whole trilogy) has the power to stand on its own two (four?) feet. If you're a fan of carnivorous lunar activities or castaway and survival stories, this is required reading.
A chivalrous thank you to the author, NetGalley and River Grove Books for the ARC.
A Knight on Wolf Island was such a cool mix of survival horror, adventure, and supernatural horror. Tayen surviving a shipwreck only to end up stranded on an island where the wolves are definitely NOT just wolves had me hooked. I loved the isolation of the island and that constant feeling that something was watching him from the trees.
The skinwalkers added a whole other level of creepiness, especially as Tayen begins to understand that surviving the island is about more than finding food and shelter. I also really enjoyed the connection to his Navajo ancestry and the way his dreams become part of his journey.
There were some genuinely tense moments, and I loved watching Tayen slowly become the person he needed to be to face what was hunting him. If you like survival stories with a supernatural twist, creepy creatures, and a mysterious island where you definitely do NOT want to be caught after dark, this one is worth picking up.
I was intrigued by the subject matter of this book. Think Robinson Crusoe meets the Wolman, meets Castaway, meets I Am Legend. Who could resist? Shipwreck survivor, Tayen, spends most of his time on Wolf Island preparing shelter and stocking his food cache while being harassed by night visits from the skin walkers. Sounds like a great story. Unfortunately, the delivery didn't live up to the pitch. I found the tie-in to native American skin walker mythology interesting and wish it was developed further. The detailed description of Tayen's prep work reminded me of the slow parts of The Illiad describing war prep. A little more action and an added vantage point could have made this more appealing to me. As is, it left me wanting. Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for this e-arc.
I really liked this. For such a short story (less than 200 pages), I felt like I had so much context and information. I never felt that usual flatness from short stories, where you feel like you are missing information and it all gets to flat and blah. That definitely didn't happen here.
This is a Native American-centered story that has a focus on skinwalkers and white men coming. I really liked the overall tension that was created due to those two elements.
And I am so down for more skinwalker stories. They're such an effectively spooky kind of creature.
Thanks to NetGalley for the e-ARC of this book in exchange for my honest review!
Thank you to Net Galley and River Grove Books for the ARC in exchange for a review.
While the concept of indigenous creatures and help from ancestors was extremely appealing to me, I feel this story fell a flat. It was written in a very straight to the point feel, with a lot of this happened, and then this. And next. And then Taryn thought this so he did that. I did struggle through this short story for this reason.
DNF at 5%, unfortunately. A Knight on Wolf Island is very much an example of “tell”, rather than “show”, combined with a lot of “and then, and then, and then”. Not my preferred way of storytelling (as it doesn’t allow you to get close to the (M)MC’s inner thoughts), even though the premise sounded amazing.
A big thanks to River Grove Books and NetGalley for this ARC.