What do you think?
Rate this book
Enter if you Dare - Part Three
The night everything fell apart, I learned what Cave was willing to sacrifice to keep me safe and what it cost him. He lied to me. About my brother, what he’d done to protect me, and the line he crossed when he thought I was gone. When he burned the cornfield to the ground, I finally understood what losing me would do to him.
Now he is gone, but not by choice. He was taken by people who view a man in a scarecrow suit as someone who needs to be fixed. They don’t understand that Cave isn’t broken; he simply loves in a language most people don’t speak.
Noa holds us together the way he always does, loudly, stubbornly, and with his whole heart, yet even he is starting to go quiet. Cipher hasn’t stopped working on the music box since the night they took Cave, like if he keeps his hands busy enough, the rest of him won’t fall apart. Meanwhile, I am doing the only thing I showing up every single day for those I love.
Cave once told me that the Scarecrow protects the things he cares about. I now have to make sure he knows he is worth keeping too.
There may not be a cornfield any longer, but enter if you dare.
Now he is gone, but not by choice. He was taken by people who view a man in a scarecrow suit as someone who needs to be fixed. They don’t understand that Cave isn’t broken; he simply loves in a language most people don’t speak.
Noa holds us together the way he always does, loudly, stubbornly, and with his whole heart, yet even he is starting to go quiet. Cipher hasn’t stopped working on the music box since the night they took Cave, like if he keeps his hands busy enough, the rest of him won’t fall apart. Meanwhile, I am doing the only thing I showing up every single day for those I love.
Cave once told me that the Scarecrow protects the things he cares about. I now have to make sure he knows he is worth keeping too.
There may not be a cornfield any longer, but enter if you dare.
182 pages, Paperback
Published September 22, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 105 reviews
November 3, 2026
Cave you big, beautiful, sweet, traumatized man! My gosh his story is really incredible! Don't get me wrong, this book is just as twisted and spicy as the previous ones, but the depth of these characters is amazing!
The author put the dynamic of Valli, Cave, Cipher and Noa into words so well.
In the words of Noa, "I guess when the big man grunts we all just follow.". I would in fact follow the Scarecrow anywhere!!
The author put the dynamic of Valli, Cave, Cipher and Noa into words so well.
In the words of Noa, "I guess when the big man grunts we all just follow.". I would in fact follow the Scarecrow anywhere!!
October 10, 2026
Enter If You Dare - Part 3 by Jaye Pratt
Rating - ⭐️4.5 🌶️2.5
That cliffhanger had me absolutely DESPERATE to find out what happened next, and let me tell you, Jaye Pratt did NOT disappoint! 😭🔥
Just when I thought I couldn’t get any more invested, things got even better!
I absolutely loved watching the characters grow and develop throughout the series. Each evolved in their own unique way, both individually and collectively. Seeing how they changed, grew closer, and influenced one another made their relationship all the more compelling and deeply rewarding to follow.
🏠♾️
Noa
Cipher🔨
Cave🌽
Valli🌼
♾️🏠
Rating - ⭐️4.5 🌶️2.5
That cliffhanger had me absolutely DESPERATE to find out what happened next, and let me tell you, Jaye Pratt did NOT disappoint! 😭🔥
Just when I thought I couldn’t get any more invested, things got even better!
I absolutely loved watching the characters grow and develop throughout the series. Each evolved in their own unique way, both individually and collectively. Seeing how they changed, grew closer, and influenced one another made their relationship all the more compelling and deeply rewarding to follow.
🏠♾️
Noa
Cipher🔨
Cave🌽
Valli🌼
♾️🏠
September 15, 2026
After THAT cliffhanger from Part 2, I was really worried about Cave and what we were about to walk into. Part 3 introduces a few new players, bringing with them more questions than answers as we try to figure out who is on Cave’s side… and who isn’t.
But Part 3 also gave us so many sweet moments. Without spoilers… I loved the new communication style, the family connections, and getting more insight into Cave as his inner monologue throughout the parts has become clearer.
Seeing Valli & her men find their home, start their life together and finally be truly happy was everything. 🤍
I’m also intrigued by Nixie and her past, as well as Leni & Khodi, and I’m definitely wanting more from them!
Overall, a great read and such a satisfying end to Enter If You Dare!
Thank you Jaye for this ARC 🫶🏻
Happy reading!
😊🎄
But Part 3 also gave us so many sweet moments. Without spoilers… I loved the new communication style, the family connections, and getting more insight into Cave as his inner monologue throughout the parts has become clearer.
Seeing Valli & her men find their home, start their life together and finally be truly happy was everything. 🤍
I’m also intrigued by Nixie and her past, as well as Leni & Khodi, and I’m definitely wanting more from them!
Overall, a great read and such a satisfying end to Enter If You Dare!
Thank you Jaye for this ARC 🫶🏻
Happy reading!
😊🎄
September 25, 2026
✨ Advanced reader copy
Rating ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice 3.5/5
🖤This entire series has kept me wanting more every book!!
The obsession I have with Valli, Cave, Cipher & Noa’s relationship is something I couldn’t control. I was so invested in them surviving whatever they went through. Especially Cave. Oh man did I love Cave more & more each book. They are misfits all in their own ways who find each other and the chemistry between each of them couldn’t be better. The character development is really good, the story flows really well! The banter Noa gives us 24-7 kept me laughing out loud. He is one of a kid. The touch them & die vibes between all 4 of them is chef’s kiss 💋
I wasn’t sure where things were going to go with Cave, and I was surprised with how things did end up but I absolutely LOVED it. So many surprises along the way with Cave in this book. I loved my unhinged men of fear island!
Rating ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice 3.5/5
🖤This entire series has kept me wanting more every book!!
The obsession I have with Valli, Cave, Cipher & Noa’s relationship is something I couldn’t control. I was so invested in them surviving whatever they went through. Especially Cave. Oh man did I love Cave more & more each book. They are misfits all in their own ways who find each other and the chemistry between each of them couldn’t be better. The character development is really good, the story flows really well! The banter Noa gives us 24-7 kept me laughing out loud. He is one of a kid. The touch them & die vibes between all 4 of them is chef’s kiss 💋
I wasn’t sure where things were going to go with Cave, and I was surprised with how things did end up but I absolutely LOVED it. So many surprises along the way with Cave in this book. I loved my unhinged men of fear island!
September 15, 2026
After the cliffhanger we were left on in part 2, I had no idea how Jaye would be able to wrap up Cave's story in just one final installment. Not only did Jaye manage to tell Cave's story in a way that provided amazing insight into his inner turmoil but she also provided some beautifully heartfelt scenes of Christmas on Fear Island including a broad range of different characters which may provide some insight on future upcoming series...
I can't wait to see what Jaye writes next!
I can't wait to see what Jaye writes next!
October 11, 2026
I feel this was more of a softer feel good version compared to the previous. I'm glad overall it went the way it did but would have liked a bit more drama in the lead up
Review of advance copy received from Author
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🌶️🌶️🌶️
I honestly did not want this series to end! I’ve become so incredibly attached to Cave, Cipher, Noa, and Valli, and I truly love the unique dynamic of their relationship. Their connection is chaotic, emotional, beautiful—and when all four of them are together, the spice is definitely spice-ing! 🥵🔥
My heart broke for Cave in Part Two, and that heartbreak continued into Part Three. But we finally see that his pain is part of a journey he needs to take to discover who he truly is beneath the mask of the Scarecrow. His story was emotional, raw, and so beautifully handled.
Part One made me fall in love with this foursome. Part Two ripped my heart straight from my chest. Part Three helped me gather the pieces and put them back together again. It was truly the perfect ending for Cave, Cipher, Noa, and Valli—even if I wasn’t ready to say goodbye. 🖤
Now I’m dying to know whose Fear Island story we’ll get next! Could Khodi be involved? Maybe Khodi and Leni? And if Leni takes after her sister like I hope she does, perhaps we’ll even get a little Leni, Khodi, and Nails action? 👀 Who knows—but regardless of whose story comes next, I absolutely cannot wait. I have loved every moment on Fear Island, and I’m nowhere near ready to leave! 🎃🖤
🌶️🌶️🌶️
I honestly did not want this series to end! I’ve become so incredibly attached to Cave, Cipher, Noa, and Valli, and I truly love the unique dynamic of their relationship. Their connection is chaotic, emotional, beautiful—and when all four of them are together, the spice is definitely spice-ing! 🥵🔥
My heart broke for Cave in Part Two, and that heartbreak continued into Part Three. But we finally see that his pain is part of a journey he needs to take to discover who he truly is beneath the mask of the Scarecrow. His story was emotional, raw, and so beautifully handled.
Part One made me fall in love with this foursome. Part Two ripped my heart straight from my chest. Part Three helped me gather the pieces and put them back together again. It was truly the perfect ending for Cave, Cipher, Noa, and Valli—even if I wasn’t ready to say goodbye. 🖤
Now I’m dying to know whose Fear Island story we’ll get next! Could Khodi be involved? Maybe Khodi and Leni? And if Leni takes after her sister like I hope she does, perhaps we’ll even get a little Leni, Khodi, and Nails action? 👀 Who knows—but regardless of whose story comes next, I absolutely cannot wait. I have loved every moment on Fear Island, and I’m nowhere near ready to leave! 🎃🖤
September 18, 2026
Complete Series Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4 Stars) — A wildly fun, macabre Reverse Harem with amazing mental health rep, Halloween vibes, and elite character dynamics! 🎃🔪
"A man who takes a bullet for you and spends what might be his last thought deciding he’d do it a hundred times over? That’s not a red flag; it’s 100% a romantic gesture. A scarecrow who recites poetry while handling your family drama is not unhinged. He’s protective. And a gravedigger who loves so hard he has to ration his own text messages? Find us that in the wild—we’ll wait. We’re making all the right choices over here: morally gray men, corn swords, and free body disposal with every relationship."
I devoured this entire 3-book series in one day. Was it a literary masterpiece? No. It had a few plot issues, a couple of editing hiccups, and some flow problems. Still, I had such a fun ride!
The Setup & The FMC: 🗺️
This series follows Valli. She is working her butt off to not only take care of her younger sister's college costs but also pay off her older brother's gambling and drug debts—all while trying to pay her normal cost of living. She's incredibly independent. One night, a man kidnaps her as payment for yet another debt her brother owes. She is eventually able to get away and ends up on Fear Island... Enter if you dare.
The MMCs: 👥
She meets our three guys here, and things progress as they do!
• Cave (The Scarecrow): A giant of a man with selective mutism. When he does speak, it's usually in riddles. He's volatile at the best of times (especially if someone enters his cornfield), but he is so unbelievably protective of those he deems as "his." 🌽
• Noa (The Zombie Gravedigger): The very definition of overexcited golden retriever energy! He talks non-stop and loves having a good time. He's sweet and wants to mother-hen his loved ones to death. Digging holes together is a love language! 🪦🤣
• Cipher (The Tinkerer): He doesn't talk much and always has his hands busy. He loves taking things apart, seeing how they work, and putting them back together. He's also a caregiver type, just in a much more silent way. ⚙️
What Worked (The Representation): 🧠
I have to give major props to Jaye Pratt for her mental health rep in this series. These men are all unhinged, but she really shines a light on the fact that they are all on the spectrum in some capacity. They aren't just crazy for the sake of being crazy. They all have their own love languages, their own methods of communication and coping skills, and their own specific needs to feel safe in a relationship.
The way Valli was able to see what each of her men needed and adapt accordingly to each of them was honestly beautiful. Likewise, the relationship between the three men was just as beautiful. They loved each other differently than they loved Valli, but just as fiercely.
Final Thoughts: 💭
Like I said, I had a lot of fun with this series. I've read a few books from Jaye Pratt before, so I knew I was going to have a good time with this one. If you like an RH with sword-crossing (MM) and macabre Halloween vibes, definitely pick this series up!! 📚🏃♀️💨
"A man who takes a bullet for you and spends what might be his last thought deciding he’d do it a hundred times over? That’s not a red flag; it’s 100% a romantic gesture. A scarecrow who recites poetry while handling your family drama is not unhinged. He’s protective. And a gravedigger who loves so hard he has to ration his own text messages? Find us that in the wild—we’ll wait. We’re making all the right choices over here: morally gray men, corn swords, and free body disposal with every relationship."
I devoured this entire 3-book series in one day. Was it a literary masterpiece? No. It had a few plot issues, a couple of editing hiccups, and some flow problems. Still, I had such a fun ride!
The Setup & The FMC: 🗺️
This series follows Valli. She is working her butt off to not only take care of her younger sister's college costs but also pay off her older brother's gambling and drug debts—all while trying to pay her normal cost of living. She's incredibly independent. One night, a man kidnaps her as payment for yet another debt her brother owes. She is eventually able to get away and ends up on Fear Island... Enter if you dare.
The MMCs: 👥
She meets our three guys here, and things progress as they do!
• Cave (The Scarecrow): A giant of a man with selective mutism. When he does speak, it's usually in riddles. He's volatile at the best of times (especially if someone enters his cornfield), but he is so unbelievably protective of those he deems as "his." 🌽
• Noa (The Zombie Gravedigger): The very definition of overexcited golden retriever energy! He talks non-stop and loves having a good time. He's sweet and wants to mother-hen his loved ones to death. Digging holes together is a love language! 🪦🤣
• Cipher (The Tinkerer): He doesn't talk much and always has his hands busy. He loves taking things apart, seeing how they work, and putting them back together. He's also a caregiver type, just in a much more silent way. ⚙️
What Worked (The Representation): 🧠
I have to give major props to Jaye Pratt for her mental health rep in this series. These men are all unhinged, but she really shines a light on the fact that they are all on the spectrum in some capacity. They aren't just crazy for the sake of being crazy. They all have their own love languages, their own methods of communication and coping skills, and their own specific needs to feel safe in a relationship.
The way Valli was able to see what each of her men needed and adapt accordingly to each of them was honestly beautiful. Likewise, the relationship between the three men was just as beautiful. They loved each other differently than they loved Valli, but just as fiercely.
Final Thoughts: 💭
Like I said, I had a lot of fun with this series. I've read a few books from Jaye Pratt before, so I knew I was going to have a good time with this one. If you like an RH with sword-crossing (MM) and macabre Halloween vibes, definitely pick this series up!! 📚🏃♀️💨
September 19, 2026
"We are going to have so much fun."
I need more!
The story and characters are so compelling that it’s incredibly easy to get completely sucked into the book and stay hooked until the very last page.
This is the last book for these MCs, but there are still so many others I’d love to read about, and who also deserve their time in the spotlight.
Okay, I’m going to be honest—as always, LOL—of course, one of the things I love most about these books is the steamy part. It’s so enriching and wonderful.
But, right after that comes the dark humor.
The characters in these books, both the MCs and the other characters—and here I’m only referring to the ones on the island and the people they interact with, because, to me, those are the ones who matter—are deliciously unhinged.
They think above, around, along the edges of… the box—or should I say coffin? Thinking outside the box is only for those who don’t want to be ordinary.
These fabulous characters think and function in a very particular way: their own way. They are intense, loyal, and wonderful.
Thank goodness there is an island where everyone can be who they are without feeling like they have to fit into whatever society considers “right.”
What is right for them—and for me—is being who we want to be, loving with the intensity we know how to love, saying what we think even when it might seem out of context or make absolutely no sense, and acting according to our feelings.
Third on the list of things I love most in this books—and in a way connected to the point above—are those moments, situations, feelings, and words that make us wonder whether there shouldn’t be more islands like Fear Island.
The way these books show how easily human beings, in their inability to accept what is different, can become so inhuman; the way certain people can hurt others—and sometimes hurt them deeply—especially those who share their blood and/or those who are more vulnerable.
Our MCs make their thoughts about these people very clear, and I can’t say I don’t find the way they deal with these despicable beings rather poetic.
Take this sentence as an example—just one of many, with certain words left out to avoid too many spoilers—of how powerful and beautiful the island’s inhabitants’ way of seeing things can be:
"...there are no words that will change how...trauma presents, so all we can do is show...with our actions, and...will learn in time that...can rely on us. Trust is not given; it’s earned."
The next book in this wonderful world—which I absolutely wish I could belong to—can’t come soon enough. Tomorrow wouldn’t be soon enough. LOL.
I need more!
The story and characters are so compelling that it’s incredibly easy to get completely sucked into the book and stay hooked until the very last page.
This is the last book for these MCs, but there are still so many others I’d love to read about, and who also deserve their time in the spotlight.
Okay, I’m going to be honest—as always, LOL—of course, one of the things I love most about these books is the steamy part. It’s so enriching and wonderful.
But, right after that comes the dark humor.
The characters in these books, both the MCs and the other characters—and here I’m only referring to the ones on the island and the people they interact with, because, to me, those are the ones who matter—are deliciously unhinged.
They think above, around, along the edges of… the box—or should I say coffin? Thinking outside the box is only for those who don’t want to be ordinary.
These fabulous characters think and function in a very particular way: their own way. They are intense, loyal, and wonderful.
Thank goodness there is an island where everyone can be who they are without feeling like they have to fit into whatever society considers “right.”
What is right for them—and for me—is being who we want to be, loving with the intensity we know how to love, saying what we think even when it might seem out of context or make absolutely no sense, and acting according to our feelings.
Third on the list of things I love most in this books—and in a way connected to the point above—are those moments, situations, feelings, and words that make us wonder whether there shouldn’t be more islands like Fear Island.
The way these books show how easily human beings, in their inability to accept what is different, can become so inhuman; the way certain people can hurt others—and sometimes hurt them deeply—especially those who share their blood and/or those who are more vulnerable.
Our MCs make their thoughts about these people very clear, and I can’t say I don’t find the way they deal with these despicable beings rather poetic.
Take this sentence as an example—just one of many, with certain words left out to avoid too many spoilers—of how powerful and beautiful the island’s inhabitants’ way of seeing things can be:
"...there are no words that will change how...trauma presents, so all we can do is show...with our actions, and...will learn in time that...can rely on us. Trust is not given; it’s earned."
The next book in this wonderful world—which I absolutely wish I could belong to—can’t come soon enough. Tomorrow wouldn’t be soon enough. LOL.
Review of advance copy received from Author
🖤 WELL… I DID IT.
Jaye chased me all the way to the end of the trilogy and DESTROYED ME… then somehow put me back together in the process.
Now I’m left panting at the prospect of more because these four are officially embedded in my little black heart. 🖤
Enter If You Dare – Part Three
Masked Men of Fear Island: The Next Attraction 3
What a way to finish my very first ARC journey with Jaye.
And thank the gods… we pick up right where Part Two dropped us off the cliff. 😂
This one isn’t quite as dark as the others, but it’s still totally Jaye Pratt right up until that very last scene.
And honestly?
WOW. JUST WOW.
The character development was beautiful, intense and completely consuming, and I inhaled this in one sitting.
No notes.
Cave… 🥹
Finally getting more of his story, seeing what he was willing to sacrifice for Valli and watching everything unfold after he was taken absolutely broke me.
And Valli?
She found herself, fought for herself and fought for her new family too. Omg. 😭
She refused to give up on Cave and loved him exactly as he was. The Scarecrow has always protected the things he loves, but this time someone needed to remind him that he was worth protecting too.
Yeah… little black heart = officially battered.
And NOA. 😭
My loud, sweet golden retriever finally feeling the weight of it all and going quiet because Cave was gone?
I WAS NOT OKAY.
Then there’s Cipher, stoic and distant, burying himself in that music box and keeping his hands busy because apparently that’s how we’re coping now.
These men. Honestly. 🤦♀️🖤
But do you know what I loved most?
It wasn’t just Valli loving three men.
It was all four of them loving each other.
Valli. Cave. Noa. Cipher.
They’re strange, messy, intense, complicated and completely obsessed with one another…
…and somehow they just FIT.
The hurt.
The devotion.
The protectiveness.
The found family.
THE LOVE.
And that cornfield…
Cave burning it down and the meaning behind it?
That absolutely gutted me.
But then came the ending… the new growth. 🥹
I’ve loved Fear Island from the beginning, but this was the ending these four deserved. I didn’t want it to end, but I couldn’t have asked for a more perfect conclusion.
My first Jaye Pratt ARC journey is officially over…
I ENTERED.
Can you? 🌽🎭🖤
Jaye chased me all the way to the end of the trilogy and DESTROYED ME… then somehow put me back together in the process.
Now I’m left panting at the prospect of more because these four are officially embedded in my little black heart. 🖤
Enter If You Dare – Part Three
Masked Men of Fear Island: The Next Attraction 3
What a way to finish my very first ARC journey with Jaye.
And thank the gods… we pick up right where Part Two dropped us off the cliff. 😂
This one isn’t quite as dark as the others, but it’s still totally Jaye Pratt right up until that very last scene.
And honestly?
WOW. JUST WOW.
The character development was beautiful, intense and completely consuming, and I inhaled this in one sitting.
No notes.
Cave… 🥹
Finally getting more of his story, seeing what he was willing to sacrifice for Valli and watching everything unfold after he was taken absolutely broke me.
And Valli?
She found herself, fought for herself and fought for her new family too. Omg. 😭
She refused to give up on Cave and loved him exactly as he was. The Scarecrow has always protected the things he loves, but this time someone needed to remind him that he was worth protecting too.
Yeah… little black heart = officially battered.
And NOA. 😭
My loud, sweet golden retriever finally feeling the weight of it all and going quiet because Cave was gone?
I WAS NOT OKAY.
Then there’s Cipher, stoic and distant, burying himself in that music box and keeping his hands busy because apparently that’s how we’re coping now.
These men. Honestly. 🤦♀️🖤
But do you know what I loved most?
It wasn’t just Valli loving three men.
It was all four of them loving each other.
Valli. Cave. Noa. Cipher.
They’re strange, messy, intense, complicated and completely obsessed with one another…
…and somehow they just FIT.
The hurt.
The devotion.
The protectiveness.
The found family.
THE LOVE.
And that cornfield…
Cave burning it down and the meaning behind it?
That absolutely gutted me.
But then came the ending… the new growth. 🥹
I’ve loved Fear Island from the beginning, but this was the ending these four deserved. I didn’t want it to end, but I couldn’t have asked for a more perfect conclusion.
My first Jaye Pratt ARC journey is officially over…
I ENTERED.
Can you? 🌽🎭🖤
September 11, 2026
📚Book Review📚
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Enter if you dare - Part three
Jaye Pratt
🗓️15/09/2026
Spoiler free Review!!!
This series has had me by the throat, I was a giddy girl yesterday when this arrived in my inbox. I have not been able to stop thinking about it since Part two. I am loving the series which includes I’m not scared PART1-3 Now Enter if you dare part 1-3 who's up next I wonder, who ever it is I can see there's a couple of options, I cannot wait.
This Book and the entire series is just for me SOOO much Fun!. What is it with Dark Romances that make me laugh, is it a problem? 🤔Am I the problem? Oh well either way I am here for the long haul.
This is a lighter Dark romance in my opinion, But Jaye is lovely enough to supply a very detailed menu oh I mean Trigger/ content List so please do check them out.
Ahh What Can I say, I love being here, Fear island is just such a fun place to be.
After the cliffhanger from part 2 We pick straight back up right where we left off. And all the guys are still amazing, and although there was nothing wrong with Cave before (matter of perspective, but you do you boo) Talk about character development I love the new Cave. This was a fitting ending to this leg of the series and I can wait to see where Masked men of fear Island goes next. It is going somewhere right Jaye, cause I may cry, no I definitely will if that was the end of Fear Island.
This is why Choose, We have Cave, Cypher, Noa and Valli, there is primal play, possessive and Obsessive MMC’s.
I highly recommend visting fear Island, but before you do check your trigger warnings. ⚠️. And I highly recommend starting at the beginning and reading Jayes READ ME! MUM Me says and AUTHOR ME says, these always make me have a wee giggle.
If you do intend to visit Fear Island, I suggest starting with I’m not scared part 1-3 then moving onto Enter if you dare part 1, 2 and then 3
Such an amazing read.
Thank you for the opportunity to read and review this ARC.
All opinions are my own,
First off thank you to Jaye Pratt for the opportunity to review this Arc. I was so excited when this arrived in my inbox yesterday.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Enter if you dare - Part three
Jaye Pratt
🗓️15/09/2026
Spoiler free Review!!!
This series has had me by the throat, I was a giddy girl yesterday when this arrived in my inbox. I have not been able to stop thinking about it since Part two. I am loving the series which includes I’m not scared PART1-3 Now Enter if you dare part 1-3 who's up next I wonder, who ever it is I can see there's a couple of options, I cannot wait.
This Book and the entire series is just for me SOOO much Fun!. What is it with Dark Romances that make me laugh, is it a problem? 🤔Am I the problem? Oh well either way I am here for the long haul.
This is a lighter Dark romance in my opinion, But Jaye is lovely enough to supply a very detailed menu oh I mean Trigger/ content List so please do check them out.
Ahh What Can I say, I love being here, Fear island is just such a fun place to be.
After the cliffhanger from part 2 We pick straight back up right where we left off. And all the guys are still amazing, and although there was nothing wrong with Cave before (matter of perspective, but you do you boo) Talk about character development I love the new Cave. This was a fitting ending to this leg of the series and I can wait to see where Masked men of fear Island goes next. It is going somewhere right Jaye, cause I may cry, no I definitely will if that was the end of Fear Island.
This is why Choose, We have Cave, Cypher, Noa and Valli, there is primal play, possessive and Obsessive MMC’s.
I highly recommend visting fear Island, but before you do check your trigger warnings. ⚠️. And I highly recommend starting at the beginning and reading Jayes READ ME! MUM Me says and AUTHOR ME says, these always make me have a wee giggle.
If you do intend to visit Fear Island, I suggest starting with I’m not scared part 1-3 then moving onto Enter if you dare part 1, 2 and then 3
Such an amazing read.
Thank you for the opportunity to read and review this ARC.
All opinions are my own,
First off thank you to Jaye Pratt for the opportunity to review this Arc. I was so excited when this arrived in my inbox yesterday.
September 18, 2026
Tropes:
Dark Romance
Why Choose
Found Family
Misfits who belong
Mental Health rep
Enter if you Dare part three is the conclusion to Cave, Valli, Cipher and Noa's story and i loved every minute of it!!
OMG after book 2 i was on the edge of my seat waiting patiently for what happens next and Jaye did not disappoint! This series taking you on an emotional rollercoaster with these characters. Each one is so different, so complex yet they work so seemingly well together. This series isn't just a dark romance with sexy misfits, no this story takes you on their journey. You get to see their struggles, their loyalty, their devotion, and it makes you fall even more in love with these characters.
Cave, he had my heart from book one. The way he couldn't speak only saying riddles yet Cipher, Valli and Noa just understood him. They never tried to change him, never forced him to be someone he wasn't, they just loved him for him and it was so pure to read. Throughout this story specifically you see the lengths they all go through to bring Cave back home to them where he belongs. Valli shows up everyday so Cave knows he isn't alone and that they are fighting to bring him home. Noa and Cipher even though you could see them breaking on the inside with everyday that passed without Cave which was so heartbreaking you saw them never give up because they knew Cave wouldn't give up on them.
From the very beginning their attraction was undeniable, their chemistry was off the charts but to see the devotion, see the loyalty, see the depth of how deep their connection really went was truly something incredible. Cave, Valli, Cipher and Noa were some of the most emotionally complex and intense characters yet they brought out the best in each other. These misfits who never belonged formed their own family where there was so much love and adoration towards each other and it made you feel giddy inside.
I absolutely loved this series and all the characters. If you are looking for a series that has a found family who will do anything for each other than this is the series for you!!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Enter If You Dare, Part 3 by [Author] ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
I genuinely don’t even know how to put into words what this book did to me. I went into Enter If You Dare, Part 3 knowing I was emotionally invested, but I was absolutely not prepared for the roller coaster of emotions this story took me on.
I loved every single second of it.
This book was heartbreaking, intense, beautiful, and completely consuming. The emotional depth, the characters, the sacrifices, the love, and the way everything comes together had me feeling everything. There were moments where I wanted to scream, moments where I wanted to cry, and moments where I just had to sit there and process what I’d read.
Cave’s story especially broke my heart. Seeing what he was willing to sacrifice to keep the people he loved safe, and understanding the cost of everything he’d done, made him such a complex and unforgettable character. He may be seen as broken by some, but the way he loves is so deeply his own, and that’s what makes him so special.
And the relationships in this book? Absolutely everything. The loyalty, the pain, the devotion, the way these characters continue to show up for one another even when they’re falling apart themselves… it was so powerful. Noa, Cipher, and everyone else brought so much emotion to the story, and I loved watching their individual struggles and the way they held each other together.
This felt like such an emotional culmination of everything that came before it. Every moment mattered. Every feeling hit harder because of the journey we’d already been on.
And now I’m sitting here with that very specific feeling of finishing a series you’ve completely fallen in love with. I’m emotional, I’m not ready to say goodbye, and I’m genuinely so grateful I got to experience these books.
If you love dark, emotional, unforgettable stories with characters who get under your skin and stay there, you need to enter if you dare.
I loved this series. I loved these characters. And I loved every second of this final book. 🖤
I genuinely don’t even know how to put into words what this book did to me. I went into Enter If You Dare, Part 3 knowing I was emotionally invested, but I was absolutely not prepared for the roller coaster of emotions this story took me on.
I loved every single second of it.
This book was heartbreaking, intense, beautiful, and completely consuming. The emotional depth, the characters, the sacrifices, the love, and the way everything comes together had me feeling everything. There were moments where I wanted to scream, moments where I wanted to cry, and moments where I just had to sit there and process what I’d read.
Cave’s story especially broke my heart. Seeing what he was willing to sacrifice to keep the people he loved safe, and understanding the cost of everything he’d done, made him such a complex and unforgettable character. He may be seen as broken by some, but the way he loves is so deeply his own, and that’s what makes him so special.
And the relationships in this book? Absolutely everything. The loyalty, the pain, the devotion, the way these characters continue to show up for one another even when they’re falling apart themselves… it was so powerful. Noa, Cipher, and everyone else brought so much emotion to the story, and I loved watching their individual struggles and the way they held each other together.
This felt like such an emotional culmination of everything that came before it. Every moment mattered. Every feeling hit harder because of the journey we’d already been on.
And now I’m sitting here with that very specific feeling of finishing a series you’ve completely fallen in love with. I’m emotional, I’m not ready to say goodbye, and I’m genuinely so grateful I got to experience these books.
If you love dark, emotional, unforgettable stories with characters who get under your skin and stay there, you need to enter if you dare.
I loved this series. I loved these characters. And I loved every second of this final book. 🖤
Review of advance copy
OMG THIS WAS THE PERFECT ENDING 😭🖤
I honestly don’t even know how I’m supposed to say goodbye to Noa, Cave, Cipher and Valli because I am SO attached to these four. Jaye Pratt absolutely destroyed me with this final book and then somehow put my heart back together again.
CAVE 😭😭😭
Watching everything unfold after he was taken absolutely BROKE ME. Cave loves so differently and so completely, and seeing Valli refuse to give up on him had me emotional as hell. She showed up. Every. Single. Day. She fought for him and loved him exactly as he was. The Scarecrow has always protected what he loves, but this time he needed someone to remind him that HE was worth protecting too 😭
And NOA!!! My loud, chaotic, whole-heart man slowly going quiet because Cave was gone… NOPE. I was not okay. Then Cipher burying himself in that music box because keeping his hands busy was basically the only thing holding him together. THESE MEN 😭😭
But what I loved most was that it wasn’t just Valli loving three men. It was all FOUR of them. The connection between Noa, Cave, Cipher and Valli is what makes this series so freaking special. They’re strange and messy and intense and completely obsessed with each other and somehow they just FIT.
The hurt. The devotion. The protectiveness. The found family. The absolute insanity. THE LOVE!!!
And Cave burning the cornfield??? That whole meaning behind it and what losing Valli would do to him absolutely gutted me.
I have loved the Masked Men of Fear Island from the beginning, but this was hands down the BEST possible ending for Noa, Cave, Cipher and Valli. I didn’t want it to end, but I also couldn’t have asked for anything more for them.
Jaye Pratt, I need compensation for the emotional attachment I now have to fictional masked men because WHAT AM I SUPPOSED TO DO NOW?! 😭😂
I devoured it. I loved them. I’m obsessed. I already miss them.
🎃🖤 ENTER IF YOU DARE 🖤🎃
Review of advance copy received from Author
Ah the time for waiting is over and the final instalment o Enter if you Dare Part 3 is now complete.
A perfect ending, tbh!
As Cave was admitted back to the institution where he had spent time before, one that brought Cave into existence, has everyone on edge.
Cipher, Noa and Valli rally around to try and get to see their man, but its a no go!
He was admitted for burns to hospital and ends up back in the Psychiatric Hospital, unknowing if he will ever be discharged!
He has been institutionalised by the very same Doctor that held him the last time, Dr Evan Turner.
They all fear that he will lose himself once again within the system.
But he has Nixie in his corner and she is determined to ensure he is discharged as quickly as possible.
She has inside help in Dr Seth Fairchild, a Psychiatrist and a great Lawyer, Vincent Devereaux.
She reassures the trio that all is being done to help Cave.
I loved how Cave evolved in this story and how all good things come to those who wait.
Also plenty of Island action happening all around as the Island inhabitants prepare for Christmas festivities. And visits from their families!
And then Valli's sister, Leni pays an extended visit to see her sister on the Island and harnesses the attention of Khodi! Khodi is the security detail for the Island.
Ah yep, could there be another book heading our way, I hope so!
And as with all great "dark" romances, this does eventuate in a HEA for Cave, Valli, Noa and Cipher. Even if Cave does comes back a different version of himself from before when he let himself and his cornfield be destroyed thinking he had lost Valli!
Burns heal, heartbreak repairs itself when it realises the one woman that you had thought had walked away from you is still standing right in front of you, and the emotional overload is helped with seeing Dr Seth. All things that Cave didn't know he needed....until he did!
And who knew, there is a surprise twist to this story which made my heart melt!
A perfect ending, tbh!
As Cave was admitted back to the institution where he had spent time before, one that brought Cave into existence, has everyone on edge.
Cipher, Noa and Valli rally around to try and get to see their man, but its a no go!
He was admitted for burns to hospital and ends up back in the Psychiatric Hospital, unknowing if he will ever be discharged!
He has been institutionalised by the very same Doctor that held him the last time, Dr Evan Turner.
They all fear that he will lose himself once again within the system.
But he has Nixie in his corner and she is determined to ensure he is discharged as quickly as possible.
She has inside help in Dr Seth Fairchild, a Psychiatrist and a great Lawyer, Vincent Devereaux.
She reassures the trio that all is being done to help Cave.
I loved how Cave evolved in this story and how all good things come to those who wait.
Also plenty of Island action happening all around as the Island inhabitants prepare for Christmas festivities. And visits from their families!
And then Valli's sister, Leni pays an extended visit to see her sister on the Island and harnesses the attention of Khodi! Khodi is the security detail for the Island.
Ah yep, could there be another book heading our way, I hope so!
And as with all great "dark" romances, this does eventuate in a HEA for Cave, Valli, Noa and Cipher. Even if Cave does comes back a different version of himself from before when he let himself and his cornfield be destroyed thinking he had lost Valli!
Burns heal, heartbreak repairs itself when it realises the one woman that you had thought had walked away from you is still standing right in front of you, and the emotional overload is helped with seeing Dr Seth. All things that Cave didn't know he needed....until he did!
And who knew, there is a surprise twist to this story which made my heart melt!
September 16, 2026
ARC Review — Thank you so much Jaye for letting me read Enter if you Dare Part three.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
I absolutely loved Part Three! After the cliffhanger in Part Two, I was really hoping this book would pick up right where we were left, and it did. I loved being thrown right back into the story and getting to continue watching these characters and their relationships grow.
One of the biggest things that stood out to me in this part was the family and community aspect. I really loved seeing how everyone on the island comes together when one of their own needs help. There is such a strong sense of “these are our people, and we don't leave them behind.” That ended up being one of my favorite parts of the book.
And Cave…His storyline absolutely broke my heart. There were moments involving him that genuinely got to me, especially seeing things from his perspective and hearing how he viewed the people around him. His story made some of the emotional moments hit so much harder.
I also really loved the way Valli continues to fit into this group. She isn't just building relationships with the three MMCs individually. She’s becoming part of something bigger. I really appreciated how she cares for each of them in different ways and shows them that she can love them for exactly who they are. That emotional connection was just as important to me as the romance.
And the Christmas moments were SO CUTE. Cave being released on Christmas Eve and then Valli being given a key to their new house on Christmas was such a sweet moment. And turning the cornfield into a Christmas tree maze for the holidays?! I thought that was absolutely adorable.
Overall, I really loved this. It had the romance, emotional moments, found-family vibes, and those little wholesome moments that made me smile. And after everything these characters have been through, I was really happy with the way the book ended.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
I absolutely loved Part Three! After the cliffhanger in Part Two, I was really hoping this book would pick up right where we were left, and it did. I loved being thrown right back into the story and getting to continue watching these characters and their relationships grow.
One of the biggest things that stood out to me in this part was the family and community aspect. I really loved seeing how everyone on the island comes together when one of their own needs help. There is such a strong sense of “these are our people, and we don't leave them behind.” That ended up being one of my favorite parts of the book.
And Cave…His storyline absolutely broke my heart. There were moments involving him that genuinely got to me, especially seeing things from his perspective and hearing how he viewed the people around him. His story made some of the emotional moments hit so much harder.
I also really loved the way Valli continues to fit into this group. She isn't just building relationships with the three MMCs individually. She’s becoming part of something bigger. I really appreciated how she cares for each of them in different ways and shows them that she can love them for exactly who they are. That emotional connection was just as important to me as the romance.
And the Christmas moments were SO CUTE. Cave being released on Christmas Eve and then Valli being given a key to their new house on Christmas was such a sweet moment. And turning the cornfield into a Christmas tree maze for the holidays?! I thought that was absolutely adorable.
Overall, I really loved this. It had the romance, emotional moments, found-family vibes, and those little wholesome moments that made me smile. And after everything these characters have been through, I was really happy with the way the book ended.
Read
September 12, 2026🖤💀 ARC REVIEW 💀🖤
📖 Enter If You Dare — Part 3
✍️ Jaye Pratt
💀 Jess’s Skeleton Rating:
💀💀💀💀💀 — I'm not ready to say goodbye. 😭🖤
Firstly, a massive thank you to Jaye Pratt for allowing me to be an ARC reader for this ENTIRE series. Being able to follow this story from beginning to end has been such a ride. 🖤
💭 My Thoughts
I genuinely don't know how I'm supposed to say goodbye to Cave, Cipher, Noa and Valli. 😭
I've become SO attached to every single one of them, and this book had my emotions absolutely ALL OVER THE PLACE. Happy tears, sad tears... sometimes I didn't even know which ones I was crying. 😂😭
Part 3 jumps straight back into the chaos after that KILLER cliffhanger we were left with in Part 2. No easing us back in — we're straight into it!
And finally getting more of Cave's background and understanding more about him... 🥹🖤 I loved getting those extra pieces of his story.
But one of my favourite parts had to be seeing their families come together and love Valli just as fiercely as they all love her. It was so damn heartwarming and added another layer to the found-family feeling I've loved throughout this series. 🖤
I seriously cannot get enough of this world.
Jaye Pratt, you just keep leaving me wanting MORE AND MORE. I'm sad this chapter with Cave, Cipher, Noa and Valli is ending, but I'm already ridiculously excited because...
I CANNOT WAIT FOR VESPER'S STORY. 👀🖤
If you haven't already, you NEED to read 📚 the I'm Not Scared series AND the Enter If You Dare series.
Trust me... enter Fear Island. You won't want to leave. 🎟️🖤
Thank you again, Jaye, for letting me be part of this entire journey. 💀🖤
#EnterIfYouDare #JayePratt #ARCReview #WhyChooseRomance #JesssSkeletonRating
📖 Enter If You Dare — Part 3
✍️ Jaye Pratt
💀 Jess’s Skeleton Rating:
💀💀💀💀💀 — I'm not ready to say goodbye. 😭🖤
Firstly, a massive thank you to Jaye Pratt for allowing me to be an ARC reader for this ENTIRE series. Being able to follow this story from beginning to end has been such a ride. 🖤
💭 My Thoughts
I genuinely don't know how I'm supposed to say goodbye to Cave, Cipher, Noa and Valli. 😭
I've become SO attached to every single one of them, and this book had my emotions absolutely ALL OVER THE PLACE. Happy tears, sad tears... sometimes I didn't even know which ones I was crying. 😂😭
Part 3 jumps straight back into the chaos after that KILLER cliffhanger we were left with in Part 2. No easing us back in — we're straight into it!
And finally getting more of Cave's background and understanding more about him... 🥹🖤 I loved getting those extra pieces of his story.
But one of my favourite parts had to be seeing their families come together and love Valli just as fiercely as they all love her. It was so damn heartwarming and added another layer to the found-family feeling I've loved throughout this series. 🖤
I seriously cannot get enough of this world.
Jaye Pratt, you just keep leaving me wanting MORE AND MORE. I'm sad this chapter with Cave, Cipher, Noa and Valli is ending, but I'm already ridiculously excited because...
I CANNOT WAIT FOR VESPER'S STORY. 👀🖤
If you haven't already, you NEED to read 📚 the I'm Not Scared series AND the Enter If You Dare series.
Trust me... enter Fear Island. You won't want to leave. 🎟️🖤
Thank you again, Jaye, for letting me be part of this entire journey. 💀🖤
#EnterIfYouDare #JayePratt #ARCReview #WhyChooseRomance #JesssSkeletonRating
Review of advance copy received from Author
A perfect and emotional goodbye to Fear Island! (or maybe not) 🥹🔥
Even though I waited anxiously for the final book in this trilogy and started reading it the exact moment I received the ARC, I realize now that I am completely unprepared to say goodbye to Valli, Noa, Cipher and especially Cave...
The second book ended on a cliffhanger that gave me severe anxiety! Cave had already been through so much and yet he still had to face this final challenge. But surprisingly, it ended up helping him. Through his time in the facility and his interactions with Dr. Seth, he finally realized just how vital he is to the people of Fear Island. Cave has easily become my absolute favorite character Jaye Pratt has ever written.
But it’s impossible to only talk about Cave, all the characters are so amazing. Noa, with his desperate need to show emotion and love with his whole being; Cipher, the calm, grounding force who fiercely protects and cares for them; Valli, who went from wandering through life without a purpose to becoming incredibly strong and finding her true family on Fear Island.
(Also, the final scene in the “new cornfield” between all of them… wow. That was HOT!! 🥵)
I am really hoping Jaye Pratt writes more books set on Fear Island because there are so many characters I need to see again! Not only the previous character of Fear Island books but I also want to see more of Leni and Khodi (they have so much potential!), I’m dying to know more about Nixie’s backstory and above all Jester, who honestly seems crazier than the rest of them combined!
Ultimately, this beautiful conclusion shows us a powerful message: there is nothing better than being loved exactly as you are.
Thank you so much to the author for this ARC! 🖤
Even though I waited anxiously for the final book in this trilogy and started reading it the exact moment I received the ARC, I realize now that I am completely unprepared to say goodbye to Valli, Noa, Cipher and especially Cave...
The second book ended on a cliffhanger that gave me severe anxiety! Cave had already been through so much and yet he still had to face this final challenge. But surprisingly, it ended up helping him. Through his time in the facility and his interactions with Dr. Seth, he finally realized just how vital he is to the people of Fear Island. Cave has easily become my absolute favorite character Jaye Pratt has ever written.
But it’s impossible to only talk about Cave, all the characters are so amazing. Noa, with his desperate need to show emotion and love with his whole being; Cipher, the calm, grounding force who fiercely protects and cares for them; Valli, who went from wandering through life without a purpose to becoming incredibly strong and finding her true family on Fear Island.
(Also, the final scene in the “new cornfield” between all of them… wow. That was HOT!! 🥵)
I am really hoping Jaye Pratt writes more books set on Fear Island because there are so many characters I need to see again! Not only the previous character of Fear Island books but I also want to see more of Leni and Khodi (they have so much potential!), I’m dying to know more about Nixie’s backstory and above all Jester, who honestly seems crazier than the rest of them combined!
Ultimately, this beautiful conclusion shows us a powerful message: there is nothing better than being loved exactly as you are.
Thank you so much to the author for this ARC! 🖤
Review of advance copy received from Author
✨✨✨✨ARC Review✨✨✨✨
✨✨Release Date: September 15, 2026✨✨
Enter if you Dare - Part Three (Masked Men of Fear Island: The Next Attraction Book 3)
Jaye Pratt
‼️Check Trigger Warnings‼️
⚠️⚠️⚠️
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🌶️🌶️🌶️
It is not always the people you were given,
It’s the people who showed up.
The man who digs holes,
The man who fixes things.
The woman who loves me regardless,
It’s everything worth coming home to. ~ Cave
✨There may not be a cornfield any longer but enter if you dare. ✨
I’d be lying if I didn’t say this was the perfect conclusion to the series; Cave has absolutely stolen my heart. After the cliffhanger in book two, I’m so glad this installment picks up right where we left off.
Cave has been institutionalized at the same facility where he spent time when he was younger. There is a real fear that he might lose himself while undergoing his 30-day observation, and the outlook seems bleak at first as he struggles with being combative. Thankfully, a visit from Valli puts him at ease, reassuring him that everything is being done to bring him home.
The character development between the three MMCs and the FMC is outstanding. Their growth through their love for one another is perfectly written; especially for a dark romance novella, which is something Jaye absolutely excels at.
I also loved getting to meet their families, and I’m keeping my fingers crossed for a follow-up book because, hello—Khodi and Leni!
You can enjoy this dark, spicy romance and its perfect HEA when it releases on September 15.
✨✨Release Date: September 15, 2026✨✨
Enter if you Dare - Part Three (Masked Men of Fear Island: The Next Attraction Book 3)
Jaye Pratt
‼️Check Trigger Warnings‼️
⚠️⚠️⚠️
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🌶️🌶️🌶️
It is not always the people you were given,
It’s the people who showed up.
The man who digs holes,
The man who fixes things.
The woman who loves me regardless,
It’s everything worth coming home to. ~ Cave
✨There may not be a cornfield any longer but enter if you dare. ✨
I’d be lying if I didn’t say this was the perfect conclusion to the series; Cave has absolutely stolen my heart. After the cliffhanger in book two, I’m so glad this installment picks up right where we left off.
Cave has been institutionalized at the same facility where he spent time when he was younger. There is a real fear that he might lose himself while undergoing his 30-day observation, and the outlook seems bleak at first as he struggles with being combative. Thankfully, a visit from Valli puts him at ease, reassuring him that everything is being done to bring him home.
The character development between the three MMCs and the FMC is outstanding. Their growth through their love for one another is perfectly written; especially for a dark romance novella, which is something Jaye absolutely excels at.
I also loved getting to meet their families, and I’m keeping my fingers crossed for a follow-up book because, hello—Khodi and Leni!
You can enjoy this dark, spicy romance and its perfect HEA when it releases on September 15.
September 16, 2026
This finale was such a satisfying, emotional end to the trilogy — Jaye Pratt delivers exactly what I was hoping for, and then some. Picking up right where Part 2 left off, that cliffhanger had me on edge for Cave from the start, and the story wastes no time diving back into the tension, mystery, and heart that makes this series so addictive. New characters add fresh layers and plenty of new questions, keeping the pace tight and the stakes high throughout.
Valli is such a fantastic lead — watching her find herself, fight for her family, and refuse to give up on Cave was so powerful. And seeing the bond between all four — Valli, Cave, Noa, and Cipher — grow into something so messy, intense, and deeply loving is the heart of this book. It’s not just one woman and three men; it’s four people who fit together perfectly, each bringing their own scars and strengths to the family they’ve built. Noa’s quiet grief, Cipher’s quiet devotion, Cave’s sacrifice — all of it hit hard, and that cornfield scene? Absolutely gutted me.
It’s slightly less dark than the earlier books, which felt like a natural shift rather than a loss — the emotional weight is still there, and the character development is beautiful, intense, and completely consuming. The ending felt earned, hopeful, and perfect for these four. I’m already missing them, and I loved getting little teases of Nixie, Leni, and Khodi — definitely hoping for more from this world! A fantastic, heartfelt conclusion that left me both happy and sad to say goodbye. 🖤
Valli is such a fantastic lead — watching her find herself, fight for her family, and refuse to give up on Cave was so powerful. And seeing the bond between all four — Valli, Cave, Noa, and Cipher — grow into something so messy, intense, and deeply loving is the heart of this book. It’s not just one woman and three men; it’s four people who fit together perfectly, each bringing their own scars and strengths to the family they’ve built. Noa’s quiet grief, Cipher’s quiet devotion, Cave’s sacrifice — all of it hit hard, and that cornfield scene? Absolutely gutted me.
It’s slightly less dark than the earlier books, which felt like a natural shift rather than a loss — the emotional weight is still there, and the character development is beautiful, intense, and completely consuming. The ending felt earned, hopeful, and perfect for these four. I’m already missing them, and I loved getting little teases of Nixie, Leni, and Khodi — definitely hoping for more from this world! A fantastic, heartfelt conclusion that left me both happy and sad to say goodbye. 🖤
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 21, 2026
I did not think that Jaye could make this any better but bam book 3 is exceptional.
If you want a dark romance that will have you hooked from the first word to the very last then this is the author for you.
The only thing that I hate is that it is the end for this set of MCs. When an author writes amazing story after amazing story like Jaye does its the only bad feeling you have.
You get the whole range of emotions from dark humour, spice, suspense, tension, sadness and you are thankful for every one of them.
The dark humour is always my favourite cause its dark and very unhinged and my kind of humour. I laughed out loud a few times to myself during this book.
These fabulous characters think and function in a very particular way: their own way. They are intense, loyal, and wonderful.
Thank goodness there is an island where everyone can be who they are without feeling like they have to fit into whatever society considers “right.”
It is one of the things that i love about this series. We are all different and what is normal for one isn't normal for someone else and this series looks thoroughly into that and portrays it in a spectacular fashion.
My favourite quote of the entire 3 books is:
"...there are no words that will change how...trauma presents, so all we can do is show...with our actions, and...will learn in time that...can rely on us. Trust is not given; it’s earned."
Jaye could now write anything and I will be there with my heart on my sleeve and hands out ready to receive. I cannot wait for the next book that Jaye will write.
If you want a dark romance that will have you hooked from the first word to the very last then this is the author for you.
The only thing that I hate is that it is the end for this set of MCs. When an author writes amazing story after amazing story like Jaye does its the only bad feeling you have.
You get the whole range of emotions from dark humour, spice, suspense, tension, sadness and you are thankful for every one of them.
The dark humour is always my favourite cause its dark and very unhinged and my kind of humour. I laughed out loud a few times to myself during this book.
These fabulous characters think and function in a very particular way: their own way. They are intense, loyal, and wonderful.
Thank goodness there is an island where everyone can be who they are without feeling like they have to fit into whatever society considers “right.”
It is one of the things that i love about this series. We are all different and what is normal for one isn't normal for someone else and this series looks thoroughly into that and portrays it in a spectacular fashion.
My favourite quote of the entire 3 books is:
"...there are no words that will change how...trauma presents, so all we can do is show...with our actions, and...will learn in time that...can rely on us. Trust is not given; it’s earned."
Jaye could now write anything and I will be there with my heart on my sleeve and hands out ready to receive. I cannot wait for the next book that Jaye will write.
Review of advance copy received from Author
THIS IS A DARK UNHINGED ROMANCE WITH TRAUMATIC BACKSTORIES - READ THE TRIGGER WARNINGS!
Part 3 of Enter If You Dare was everything I needed it to be. I was screaming at the end of book 2, Jaye Pratt loves a cliffhanger so be prepared for these if you haven't read the series yet, and I just needed to know what happened next.
Cave is the Scarecrow and when he thought he was losing the most important thing in his life, the creature came out, to protect him from the pain. The story follows what happens after he is admitted to hospital and everything falls apart. (I will not say more as I am not one for spoilers)
His found family are prepared to do whatever it takes to get him back, some want to go down the more unhinged route but this has to be done the right way.
I love the characters, I fell in love with them all from book 1 and I need to go back and read the I'm Not Scared Trilogy ASAP.
Jaye somehow manages to give you every single emotion while reading these books and I will not hesitate in saying there were times I wanted to scream, times I actually cried and times where I wanted to just hug them all.
It was a beautifully emotional and heart-warming end to this chapter on Fear Island with just the right amount of spice and banter. Noa is still my favourite - I think I just identify with him a lot.
Cannot wait to see what else comes from the crew at Fear Island and I hope we get to delve into Nixie's story a bit more as well as Leni and the Jester.
Absolute smash from Jaye Pratt, seriously, go read it!
Part 3 of Enter If You Dare was everything I needed it to be. I was screaming at the end of book 2, Jaye Pratt loves a cliffhanger so be prepared for these if you haven't read the series yet, and I just needed to know what happened next.
Cave is the Scarecrow and when he thought he was losing the most important thing in his life, the creature came out, to protect him from the pain. The story follows what happens after he is admitted to hospital and everything falls apart. (I will not say more as I am not one for spoilers)
His found family are prepared to do whatever it takes to get him back, some want to go down the more unhinged route but this has to be done the right way.
I love the characters, I fell in love with them all from book 1 and I need to go back and read the I'm Not Scared Trilogy ASAP.
Jaye somehow manages to give you every single emotion while reading these books and I will not hesitate in saying there were times I wanted to scream, times I actually cried and times where I wanted to just hug them all.
It was a beautifully emotional and heart-warming end to this chapter on Fear Island with just the right amount of spice and banter. Noa is still my favourite - I think I just identify with him a lot.
Cannot wait to see what else comes from the crew at Fear Island and I hope we get to delve into Nixie's story a bit more as well as Leni and the Jester.
Absolute smash from Jaye Pratt, seriously, go read it!
October 5, 2026
A wild and crazy ride to happiness 😊
Part Three picks up with all the chaos, darkness, emotions, and unhinged energy I’ve come to expect from Fear Island, and WOW… what a way to finish this story.
Cave absolutely broke my heart in this one. Getting deeper into his past and seeing the struggles behind the Scarecrow persona gave this book so much more emotional depth. And watching Valli, Cipher, and Noa stand beside him and fight for him? 🥺🖤 My heart!
I freaking LOVE these four together. Their relationship is messy, unconventional, spicy as hell, and somehow completely perfect for them. The chemistry, possessiveness, found family, dark humor, and morally gray chaos had me hooked from beginning to end.
And can we talk about Fear Island?! 🎪🎃 This creepy, twisted little island continues to be one of my favorite settings. It’s horrifying, hilarious, dysfunctional, and somehow feels like home. 😂
This trilogy has been one hell of a ride, and Part Three delivered the emotional payoff I was hoping for. I’m sad to say goodbye to these characters, but I have a feeling Fear Island isn’t done with us yet. 👀
Jaye Pratt, you beautiful menace… I’ll gladly follow you back onto Fear Island anytime.
🖤 Dark romance
🖤 Why Choose
🖤 Masked/unhinged MMCs
🖤 Possessive/protective men
🖤 Found family
🖤 Morally gray characters
🖤 Dark humor
🖤 Trauma/healing
🖤 Spice
🖤 Fear Island chaos
Definitely read the trigger warnings—and read the trilogy in order!
Part Three picks up with all the chaos, darkness, emotions, and unhinged energy I’ve come to expect from Fear Island, and WOW… what a way to finish this story.
Cave absolutely broke my heart in this one. Getting deeper into his past and seeing the struggles behind the Scarecrow persona gave this book so much more emotional depth. And watching Valli, Cipher, and Noa stand beside him and fight for him? 🥺🖤 My heart!
I freaking LOVE these four together. Their relationship is messy, unconventional, spicy as hell, and somehow completely perfect for them. The chemistry, possessiveness, found family, dark humor, and morally gray chaos had me hooked from beginning to end.
And can we talk about Fear Island?! 🎪🎃 This creepy, twisted little island continues to be one of my favorite settings. It’s horrifying, hilarious, dysfunctional, and somehow feels like home. 😂
This trilogy has been one hell of a ride, and Part Three delivered the emotional payoff I was hoping for. I’m sad to say goodbye to these characters, but I have a feeling Fear Island isn’t done with us yet. 👀
Jaye Pratt, you beautiful menace… I’ll gladly follow you back onto Fear Island anytime.
🖤 Dark romance
🖤 Why Choose
🖤 Masked/unhinged MMCs
🖤 Possessive/protective men
🖤 Found family
🖤 Morally gray characters
🖤 Dark humor
🖤 Trauma/healing
🖤 Spice
🖤 Fear Island chaos
Definitely read the trigger warnings—and read the trilogy in order!
September 17, 2026
✨ ARC REVIEW ✨
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Enter If You Dare: Part Three by Jaye Pratt 🖤
😭 I’m SO sad that it’s over!
What an absolutely perfect ending to this trilogy! 🖤 I feel like we got to see so much more of Cave in this book and finally got a deeper look into his past and what goes on inside that mind of his. And the love between Cave, Cipher, Noa and Valli? 🥹 Absolutely EVERYTHING.
I loved seeing the new communication style, discovering more of the family connections, and getting even more insight into Cave’s inner monologue. It added so much depth to the story and to the characters I’ve become completely obsessed with. 🫣🖤
Watching Valli and her men finally find their home, start their life together and, most importantly, get to be truly happy was EVERYTHING. 😭💕 They have been through so much, and seeing them finally get their happy ending had my heart so full.
BUT… I’m still left with SO many questions! 👀
I’m incredibly intrigued by Nixie’s past, and I need to know more about Leni and Khodi! And then there’s The Jester and Vesper… 👀🫣
Yes. Please. I NEED MORE. 😂🖤
Overall, this was such an amazing read and a fantastic ending to the trilogy. I’m completely obsessed with these characters and this chaotic, dark little world Jaye has created.
I’m just not ready to say goodbye. 😭🖤
Another 5 ⭐️ read from Jaye Pratt! If she writes it, I WILL read it. 🫣💕
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Enter If You Dare: Part Three by Jaye Pratt 🖤
😭 I’m SO sad that it’s over!
What an absolutely perfect ending to this trilogy! 🖤 I feel like we got to see so much more of Cave in this book and finally got a deeper look into his past and what goes on inside that mind of his. And the love between Cave, Cipher, Noa and Valli? 🥹 Absolutely EVERYTHING.
I loved seeing the new communication style, discovering more of the family connections, and getting even more insight into Cave’s inner monologue. It added so much depth to the story and to the characters I’ve become completely obsessed with. 🫣🖤
Watching Valli and her men finally find their home, start their life together and, most importantly, get to be truly happy was EVERYTHING. 😭💕 They have been through so much, and seeing them finally get their happy ending had my heart so full.
BUT… I’m still left with SO many questions! 👀
I’m incredibly intrigued by Nixie’s past, and I need to know more about Leni and Khodi! And then there’s The Jester and Vesper… 👀🫣
Yes. Please. I NEED MORE. 😂🖤
Overall, this was such an amazing read and a fantastic ending to the trilogy. I’m completely obsessed with these characters and this chaotic, dark little world Jaye has created.
I’m just not ready to say goodbye. 😭🖤
Another 5 ⭐️ read from Jaye Pratt! If she writes it, I WILL read it. 🫣💕
September 23, 2026
What an amazing final book in the Enter If You Dare series. After that heartbreaking cliffhanger in Part Two I wasn't sure what the followup would look like. But Three was everything I could have wished for and more. Valli, Cipher, and Noa are trying to keep going even though they are missing Cave. But Christmas is coming so everyone is busy preparing for the upcoming festivities and their loved ones coming. I love Valli. She is perfect for those guys. She is intelligent, patient, caring, and knows exactly how to care for each of them. Noa is absolutely precious. He is in charge of the Christmas prep. I completely lost it with the Christmas tree situation (IYKYK). Noa is just so sweet, personable, and happy go lucky. The smallest things excite him and I love it. I also enjoyed seeing the special friendship he has with Leni. Cipher is still bae. He prefers silence and isolation except for his people. But he is willing to step out of his comfort zone for Valli. And then of course there is Cave. He is so intelligent and protective of his people. The changes in Cave are astounding. The characters, spice, plot, humor, honestly everything is perfection. I fell in love with the Fear Island books starting with I'm Not Scared. I did not think that Vero and my man Brawley could be topped. But then Jaye proved me wrong. I can't wait to see where Jaye goes with this next!
Review of advance copy received from Author
This is the last book in this mini series. We follow as Cipher, Noa, and Valli try to process Cave being admitted to the psych ward, worrying what this might mean for him and them as a family.
This isn’t Cave’s first admittance, having been in when he was younger. Nixie was the one who originally helped him get out the first time and that is how he found his home as the Scarecrow on the island.
The book starts with Cave’s POV and it was absolutely heartbreaking. The fear and pain that resurfaces as he finds himself somewhere he never wanted to end up again, is truly devastating. The thing that really pulled at my heartstrings was understanding that in order for him to be released, he would need to center himself, otherwise every outburst would be a notch against him. Luckily, Valli is given visitation and is able to talk to him about holding on while they work to get him home.
While he is inside Valli’s sister visits, followed by Cipher and Noah’s families. I loved seeing who might be in the next three books. Will it be Leni, Valli’’s sister of Nixie’s chance at rekindling old flames?
I truly loved Cipher, Noah, Cave and Valli’s story and look forward to what Fear Island has in store for us next.
This isn’t Cave’s first admittance, having been in when he was younger. Nixie was the one who originally helped him get out the first time and that is how he found his home as the Scarecrow on the island.
The book starts with Cave’s POV and it was absolutely heartbreaking. The fear and pain that resurfaces as he finds himself somewhere he never wanted to end up again, is truly devastating. The thing that really pulled at my heartstrings was understanding that in order for him to be released, he would need to center himself, otherwise every outburst would be a notch against him. Luckily, Valli is given visitation and is able to talk to him about holding on while they work to get him home.
While he is inside Valli’s sister visits, followed by Cipher and Noah’s families. I loved seeing who might be in the next three books. Will it be Leni, Valli’’s sister of Nixie’s chance at rekindling old flames?
I truly loved Cipher, Noah, Cave and Valli’s story and look forward to what Fear Island has in store for us next.
Review of advance copy received from Author
ARC Review
Enter If You Dare Part 3
Jaye Pratt
I was so excited to finally get to read the final book and it got me right in the feels! This one definitely wasn't what I thought it was going to be like but I'm okay with it. It wasn't as dark as some of the other books but I felt like it really wrapped up nicely.
Cave does well being institutionalized after Valli visit him and tells him to behave so he can get out. Once hes out, he really is like a different person but is still fiercely protective of his people. Noa is the sweetest. Seeing how closely he gets to people so fast and just cares for everyone has my heart melting for him. I felt bad for him after reading the last book because all he wanted was some Cave action and this book finally delivered that for him! Cipher makes me want to wrap him up and hug him. Hes so sweet and quite but is so happy to find these people who love him. And I'm so happy Valli finally figured out who she is and how she belongs on the island with her men.
Good amount of spice between characters as pairs and all together.
This book had me trying to figure out who's going to get the next series! Leni, Nixie, Vesper?! I would love to see what happened in Nixies past. She seems so interesting.
Overall, i would definitely recommend this series!
Enter If You Dare Part 3
Jaye Pratt
I was so excited to finally get to read the final book and it got me right in the feels! This one definitely wasn't what I thought it was going to be like but I'm okay with it. It wasn't as dark as some of the other books but I felt like it really wrapped up nicely.
Cave does well being institutionalized after Valli visit him and tells him to behave so he can get out. Once hes out, he really is like a different person but is still fiercely protective of his people. Noa is the sweetest. Seeing how closely he gets to people so fast and just cares for everyone has my heart melting for him. I felt bad for him after reading the last book because all he wanted was some Cave action and this book finally delivered that for him! Cipher makes me want to wrap him up and hug him. Hes so sweet and quite but is so happy to find these people who love him. And I'm so happy Valli finally figured out who she is and how she belongs on the island with her men.
Good amount of spice between characters as pairs and all together.
This book had me trying to figure out who's going to get the next series! Leni, Nixie, Vesper?! I would love to see what happened in Nixies past. She seems so interesting.
Overall, i would definitely recommend this series!
September 29, 2026
Series review:
3 book series (but only around 150 pages each so basically one normal book). Completed series.
If you need a Halloween book then this is the PERFECT series! It felt SO Halloween in the best way without being scary and had such a nice found family vibe to it.
The fmc was okay, not loads about her but she loved her men and never questioned why they were the way they were. We love unconditional love!
The MMCs were great, each sweet in their own way. Although cave was the main focus it was Noa who stole the show for me! He was so funny!
The MMCs didn’t have much character description which meant that I pictured them all quite oddly - with cave being a mix between a scarecrow and Lennie from of mice and men, Noah I pictured as the boogeyman from nightmare before christmas and cipher I imagined as an old man who only wore flannel shirts 😂 despite this they were all super cute.
The plot was good but it was the cool Halloween town vibe that kept me reading. I also love the jester and can’t wait for his story! Overall, good writing and good book. 3 stars! I can’t give it 4 as it didn’t have the same depth as a regular novel and I rate comparatively but my enjoyment was 5 stars!
3 book series (but only around 150 pages each so basically one normal book). Completed series.
If you need a Halloween book then this is the PERFECT series! It felt SO Halloween in the best way without being scary and had such a nice found family vibe to it.
The fmc was okay, not loads about her but she loved her men and never questioned why they were the way they were. We love unconditional love!
The MMCs were great, each sweet in their own way. Although cave was the main focus it was Noa who stole the show for me! He was so funny!
The MMCs didn’t have much character description which meant that I pictured them all quite oddly - with cave being a mix between a scarecrow and Lennie from of mice and men, Noah I pictured as the boogeyman from nightmare before christmas and cipher I imagined as an old man who only wore flannel shirts 😂 despite this they were all super cute.
The plot was good but it was the cool Halloween town vibe that kept me reading. I also love the jester and can’t wait for his story! Overall, good writing and good book. 3 stars! I can’t give it 4 as it didn’t have the same depth as a regular novel and I rate comparatively but my enjoyment was 5 stars!
Review of advance copy received from Author
ARC REVIEW
I was dying to read this after the second one's cliffhanger. I feel the focus on Cave being locked up isn't enough. I love some good smut but I felt some of the scenes could have focused more on Cave and his mental health. I have questions still. I was hoping to find out more about his past but we didn't learn much. I wanted to know so much more about him.
I absolutely loved the Christmas and meeting the guys families. The moms were absolutely the best and reminded me of my mom. I am also now. Very curious about Leno and Khodi. There was some serious chemistry. I hope they make appearances in future books. I was sad to say goodbye to this set of characters. I really connected with Cipher and Cave. Noa is adorable too. Total golden retriever energy. Hope to get glimpsesof them in the future. I enjoyed seeing Kayla and Vero. Overall I'm happy with this book and the ending.
I also enjoyed seeing Noa getting to interact with Cave and Cipher. Everyone being part of this couple was really great to see. Noa finally got what he had been wishing more. The happiness they all have was very heart warming. You definitely need to check this series out
I was dying to read this after the second one's cliffhanger. I feel the focus on Cave being locked up isn't enough. I love some good smut but I felt some of the scenes could have focused more on Cave and his mental health. I have questions still. I was hoping to find out more about his past but we didn't learn much. I wanted to know so much more about him.
I absolutely loved the Christmas and meeting the guys families. The moms were absolutely the best and reminded me of my mom. I am also now. Very curious about Leno and Khodi. There was some serious chemistry. I hope they make appearances in future books. I was sad to say goodbye to this set of characters. I really connected with Cipher and Cave. Noa is adorable too. Total golden retriever energy. Hope to get glimpsesof them in the future. I enjoyed seeing Kayla and Vero. Overall I'm happy with this book and the ending.
I also enjoyed seeing Noa getting to interact with Cave and Cipher. Everyone being part of this couple was really great to see. Noa finally got what he had been wishing more. The happiness they all have was very heart warming. You definitely need to check this series out
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 16, 2026
I can't even put into words how much I loved this book! Honestly, this whole trilogy is my favorite out of all of these masked men books. The dynamic between these characters is so cute and perfect. I found myself smiling or chuckling while reading this far more often than not.
Noa is for sure a golden retriever character. He's funny, sweet, has big feelings, and says what's on his mind. Cipher is quiet, calm, and shy. Cave...he's so unique. He is hands down one of my all-time favorite mmcs. You will love the character development for him in this book and be so happy for him by the end. Valli is the final puzzle piece for these guys. She's strong, understanding, and never judges a book by its cover.
The story progressed beautifully and has some great full-circle moments. We meet some more Fear Island residents as well as family members and Nixie's past guys. There are so many more stories I want from all of these characters, and I can't wait to see whose story we get next! If you love masked men books with primal play, found family, spice, humor, and tons of great characters, then you'll love this!
Noa is for sure a golden retriever character. He's funny, sweet, has big feelings, and says what's on his mind. Cipher is quiet, calm, and shy. Cave...he's so unique. He is hands down one of my all-time favorite mmcs. You will love the character development for him in this book and be so happy for him by the end. Valli is the final puzzle piece for these guys. She's strong, understanding, and never judges a book by its cover.
The story progressed beautifully and has some great full-circle moments. We meet some more Fear Island residents as well as family members and Nixie's past guys. There are so many more stories I want from all of these characters, and I can't wait to see whose story we get next! If you love masked men books with primal play, found family, spice, humor, and tons of great characters, then you'll love this!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 105 reviews