Return to Tawney for the second-chance romance of a lifetime!
A BRAND NEW sequel novella to the bestselling Tomes & Tea series! Lord Wylan of Tawney isn't happy. After years in a relationship with Feo, Wylan thought he knew what to expect in a partner. But as Feo's new alchemy school begins to consume their life, Wylan finds himself being pushed aside in favor of spells and coursework.
Feo isn't at all surprised when Wylan suggests it's time to end their relationship. This sentiment has been simmering on the surface for years... ever since Feo became the Alchemicor. They're busy, successful, powerful, and Wylan can't handle it. Good riddance.
But four years later, the status quo is disrupted again when a new lord arrives in Tawney. Lord Dren is charming and eager to learn from Lord Wylan... and Feo watches in horror as a new love story builds without them. To distract themself, Feo tries to reengage with Tawney's thriving community. But as they interact with old friends, Wylan takes notice... and old feelings resurface.
Soon, both of them have to face a vital can a love once lost be rediscovered, or is it best to let old romance fade?
~ Enemies to lovers ~ Second-chance romance ~ Magic and dragons ~ Return of favorite characters ~ A conniving spy child ~ Cozy cups of tea
Rebecca Thorne is a USA Today, Indie, and Sunday Times Bestselling author, specializing in fantasy and sci-fi with romantic subplots.
She is a proud member of the LGBTQIA+ community, lives near Denver, Colorado, and uses her ADHD as a superpower to write multiple books a year. When she’s not writing (or avoiding writing), Rebecca can be found traveling the country as a flight attendant, hiking with her dogs and lovely wife, or basking in the sun like a lizard.
I love this series. I wasn't a huge fan of the ending of Alchemy and a Cup of Tea. But I liked most of it and loved the first three books.
The opening of this book is honestly pretty devastating. And it left me with a pretty bad taste in my mouth where Feo was concerned. They were brutal and ignorant and cold. And while the novella does a decent job of giving them a character arc, I found myself more rooting for Wylan and Dren than anything.
I didn't want Wylan and Feo to get back together. I wanted them to admit they failed and explore Wylan's relationship with a this earnest, charming new lord.
When the book ends, I guess I didn't find myself hating the inevitable reunion, but I wasn't really cheering or jumping for joy. It's fine. Just fine, really.
The best parts of this book came from Quinn's POV. She was legitimately fun to read from. And I look forward to further books with her POV in the future. I'd especially love it if she ended up being an alchemy student under Feo's teaching, just to see how Kianthe handled that. I'm sure there'd be great bickering between the Alchemicor and the Mage of Ages.
Anyway, I'll be happy to read future novellas. Or a new quadrilogy. This one was fine enough.
This was a lovely visit back into the Tomes and Tea world through the perspective of Feo and Wylan. I appreciate so much how the novella showed that it was both of their insecurities and struggles that caused the relationship to fail the first time, and how some healing and growing was needed on both sides to come back together.
Reyna and Kianthe were meddling per usual, this time with the addition of their daughter, Quinn. Dren was a really sweet, emotionally mature character that served as a great foil for both Wylan and Feo. It would have been easy to make a villain of him, and I loved how his brief relationship with Wylan was handled.
It sounds like there may be some more books coming in this universe, which I'm looking forward to!
I had no idea this book was coming so I was THRILLED when I saw it. It was so sweet to return to Tawney and get a glimpse of how everyone is doing several years down the road since the series left off. I really enjoyed getting to know Feo and Wylan a bit more through their own lenses and I LOVED getting to meet Quinn.
Just as sweet and cozy as the original series. I’m so looking forward to returning to this universe soon as it seems more is coming 🙌🏼
✨️ One sentence review: Returning to Tomes & Tea for Feo and Wylan's story felt like coming home after a long trip, and I couldn't have asked for a better addition to my favorite cozy fantasy series.
I adore the Tomes & Tea series, so I was SO excited to see Feo and Wylan get their own story! Set four years after the original series, this novella was the perfect excuse to catch up with old friends while getting to know some new faces.
I loved seeing how much Feo and Wylan had grown while still being the same people who somehow haven't figured out their relationship. 😂 Watching them work through everything was absolutely perfect. And getting to see Quinn and Pill Bug (who is clearly her dragon at this point) play a role in the story made it even better!
This was an easy five-star read for me, and I'm already ready to return to this world again.
✨️ Would I recommend? Absolutely! If you've read Tomes & Tea, this novella is a must-read. And if you haven't read the series yet, what are you waiting for?!
What to expect: • Second-chance romance • Cozy fantasy • Character growth • Baby dragon shenanigans • Old friends, new faces
I wasn't a huge fan. No real major issues, as I did still love the writing style, I still loved each character individually, I still loved the setting, I loved the gryphons, I loved the kiddo, I loved everything surrounding the main plot, but the main romance? Yeah, it didn't click at any point. I get this is sort of a 'sort yourself out' style of drama but I don't think it was ever rectified. The end just sort of happens seemingly out of nowhere and all is well. I DO believe there's a full novel length's version of this book that gives the romance and retribution more time to cook and it works, but in its current form? Nah.
Basically, our two main characters don't really work. One's a workaholic and kinda emotionally distant, the other is a bit emotional and borderline dependent. They part ways, in what I feel is mostly an amicable 'I care but we can't be together' kind of way, and the rest of the book is our protagonist trying to continue living and loving in proximity to their ex while dealing with other small scale issues in their life. Which is great! That setup works! And I think the fling is cute, and the characters involved were cute, but then the original couple just sort of...end up together despite not doing much of anything to mend their old issues or growing or learning.
The ending didn't feel earned. It feels like an entire act 2 and most of act 3 were just omitted entirely where the romance at the heart of the story repaired itself over time and with a lot of work. And because it was never earned, I just sort of resented them both for being so....frustrating and never getting better. I wouldn't say I disliked either of them as individuals (As an Aro-Ace person myself I 100% understand the one who is a bit more involved in work than love, I do not blame him at all), and I agreed they didn't work as a couple...yet that was still the end game without ever truly reckoning with what made them split up.
The setup is good. The world continues to be great. I loved the side stories here. But the main plot was one I could never get behind. The main romance just didn't work, it was shown to not work, and it never fixed what broke it, so them getting back together honestly just felt like it's heading for another break up and I don't think that's healthy at all.
Gay/nonbinary relationships are my jam but this isn't a good one, I'm sorry to say.
Take a Chance on Alche‑me is everything I love about this series, wrapped up in a shorter, sweeter, wonderfully cozy package. It has all the heart, all the charm, and all the warmth that make the main books so delightful — just delivered in an incredibly tight, satisfying novella that never feels rushed or thin.
The emotional beats land beautifully, the humor sparkles, and the relationships feel just as rich and comforting as they do in the full‑length installments. It’s the kind of story that reminds you exactly why this world is so special: soft magic, gentle growth, and characters who radiate sincerity and joy.
Despite its length, it never sacrifices depth. Instead, it feels like a concentrated dose of everything that makes the series shine — a perfect little treat that fits seamlessly into the universe while offering its own unique charm.
Warm, whimsical, and wonderfully crafted. A total delight.
I didn’t hate this … it was ‘fine’. But it is absolutely my least favorite thing by the author.
I remember an interview with the author saying that she wished she’d better fleshed out the world building in the Team & Tomes series. And in retrospect it was true, but because I love the character of Kianthe and Reyna so much and their story arc across four books, none of that bothered me.
But when you center a book around minor characters? Suddenly everything else draws attention, and not in a good way. Things are really lackluster and lack personality - I don’t know what happened even to the Tawney I fell in love with in Can’t Spell Treason Without Tea … but it feels like it is missing here. There are other critiques, but ultimately this book suffers from being offensively average from an author who I have loved for challenges, twists and turns … and who also gave me perhaps my favorite book of the year so far (Moss’d in Space).
Got to read this as part of the Patreon, and I’ve loved it.
Now I’m a self professed Tawny Fan Girl, and so it’s not a hard sell to me. But i absolutely loved this novella, it’s just so wonderful.
I love seeing the world through eyes that aren’t Kianthe and Reyna. Not really a spoiler but for us New Leaf Girls we do get to see our ladies and the tea shop.
But back to the story, it’s just a lovely tale and full of wonderfully complex feelings. I found myself gut punched a few times, and just as frequently feeling endeared by the akward stumbles of our secret not so secret potential couple.
I really related to many facets of Wylan and Feo in this story, especially Feo. I won’t get too deep into it but much of my own personal fears were mirrored in them.
Overall it’s another wonderful read from Rebecca, and just further reminds me that Tawney is my happy place.
A very sweet novella about how after having broken up four years prior, Lord Wylan and Alchemicor Feo get a chance to fix their relationship. There is a bit of a heartbreak since another lord (Dren) enters stage right and charms Wylan by being earnest and honest and handsome, and this leads to Feo sulking. Wylan sulks less because he did a lot of sad pondering when they were still dating.
Reyna and Kianthe are meddling as per usual (this time sort of through their child who absolutely should not be about the county this willy nilly) and thankfully it leads to something sweet. I can understand why Feo was exhasperated even if the results were to their benefit. Maybe they can get Kianthe and Reyna back in a next book!
a wonderful addition to the tales of this magical land
Reading the previous books, you fall in love with the main characters, laugh with, and at, the side characters, and enjoy the magic and adventures in the tales. This book takes the reader along to later times, ties up some loose ends and reminds you why you loved the stories. Also it explores the subject of old loves, romances that happened at an inopportune time, and how the characters might rekindle a different type of mature romance. There is much wisdom here among the humor and banter. Truly a joy to read.
This was a nice slice of life low stakes addition to the Tomes and Tea universe. Seeing Feo and Wylan come back together and recognising what went wrong with their relationship in the first place.
I liked seeing the dynamic between Wylan and Feo in the original series, and I don’t know if they gave the same energy in this. Starting with a break up and then having an immediate time skip meant that we didn’t get to see them happy together and then didn’t see them post break up. I think I would have been more impactful if we felt like we stakes in their relationship.
This witty, well-written addition to Rebecca's 'Tomes and Tea' world is full of interesting new character details and emotions. 'Feo' and Wylan's P.O.V.s are beautifully written and emotionally tense. The explanations of both characters states of mind, in their last and present relations read as real living people. Each addition of Rebecca's book series are showing an increasing skill and eloquence in her writing, and creative, abilities. Rebecca is an author to be watched and read!
A sweet slice of life novella to check in on our fave characters a few years after the conclusion of the Tomes and Tea quartet. I always loved the bits and pieces of Wylan's and Feo's relationship throughout the series and I love how they got their own novella! For such a short book, Thorne continues to do an amazing job weaving a meaningful and deep cozy story that explores so many new areas of life in and out of Tawney. Also squealing with how she sets up potential new books in the epilogue!
As a novella in progress Rebecca further develops the characters in her Tomes and Tea world, focussing on the relationship, and problems of Lord Wylan and the Alchemicor Feo. The problems are well illustrated and the character reactions are very true to life. This is a great addition to Rebecca's talent for characters, pacing, world-building, and humour.
Interesting love story. Not the most exciting thing in the world, but I enjoyed it. Again, the pronouns for the nonbinary main character were messed up several times...once the cis lead was called by they instead. It's not a big deal, but it definitely leaves a sour taste in my mouth as a nonbinary person.
I loved that we got more story for the chracters in the Tomes and Tea Series and learned more about Feo and Wylan. I was so interested in their story from the orginal series and got what I wanted in a way I was not expecting. This was cool to see how the world is doing and how Feo and Wylan think. I can't wait for more from this author.
loved getting to re-visit this world - and with new POVs - and Quinn!!!! my favourite <333 + the end saying that there will be future novellas and even maybe a new quartet??!?!? yes please <3
A great spin off of the Tomes & Tea quartet that focuses on the relationship between Feo and Wylan. I enjoyed seeing more of our favorite power couple while also seeing a side of Feo and Wylan that we didn't get to explore in the quartet. The interlude chapters with Quinn were the best!
4.5 i did not know this book was coming today, so the notification from my audiobook provider was a happy surprise this morning! of course i immediately dived in, i love Rebecca Thorne and really enjoyed the Tomes&Tea series. it was very nice to dip back into this world, this time focusing more on other characters but with our main sapphic power couple still present, and seeing how they're all doing a while after the events of book 4. i hope Thorne writes more of these novellas, it's a nice smaller peek into a beloved world/series! the audiobook narration by Jessica Threet was great (as always).