The theme of the innocent person wrongly accused of a crime and desperately trying to prove his innocence is a common one in literature, but few people have as tough a time of it as does Clark Miller, the hero of W.D. Sherrill’s entertaining mystery, Murder U. The problem Miller faces is that the real killer is still out there, and the more Miller does to try to clear himself, the more dead bodies show up and the guiltier he appears.
As the title implies, Murder U is set at a small town college campus somewhere in the south, where Miller has been a rather obscure history professor until his wife and the schools’ football coach turn up dead in the locker room, having been killed while in the midst of a different sort of workout. Miller is the prime suspect, but much to the chagrin of the cop in charge of the investigation, there’s not enough evidence to charge him. In the time-honored tradition of obtuse cops in mystery fiction everywhere, he persists in trying to pin the goods on Miller by any means, fair or foul.
Murder U is a tough book to describe briefly, but the best word that comes to mind is amiable. Miller finds himself in deep trouble from the opening page in this book, but I never go a sense of real suspense here. Instead, the author is content to follow Miller around as he tries to extricate himself and the book winds up being rather amusing in a black comic way, as Miller stumbles across one dead body or bad situation after another.
Unlike many amateur sleuth murder mysteries, Miller doesn’t prove to be all that adept at ferreting out the real killer. Instead, readers will be pretty much on their own trying to solve the case, which adds to the book’s charm. The mystery is fairly good, and a lot of readers will have a tough time figuring this one out. I found myself trying to race through the last few chapters to satisfy my curiosity.
Sherrill is a skilled writer, and he manages to poke fun at today’s colleges, particularly the business and politics involved, without Murder U ever becoming downright silly, although the plot is admittedly far fetched. One thing I did not like was Sherrill’s use of the overdone gimmick of starting the book out at the end, with Miller being chased around campus by the killer, with the bulk of the book told as a lengthy flashback from a few days earlier. The attempts to build suspense in this prologue don’t match the considerably lighter later tone in the book, even when things get bad for Miller.
Murder U is a good, entertaining read for cozy mystery buffs. Despite what eventually becomes an enormous body count, the book never gets grisly or hard nosed, and mystery fans will enjoy trying to figure out the identity of the killer. Further, the eventual explanation of the crimes is actually consistent with some of the seemingly bizarre occurrences earlier of the book. Most important, although Clark Miller isn’t really much of a detective, he’s a fun character to build a book around. Murder U gets a passing grade with flying colors.