A Wonderful Voice; an Overlooked Gem
There are lots of books out there that are supposed to read and feel like the first person narratives of 11/12 year old girls contemplating their step up into middle school. Some are heavily plotted or in some way fantastical, and some focus on the slightly exaggerated problems of everyday life. The tone can be wistful, or snarky, or angsty, or precocious or played mostly for laughs. The "problems" they address can be over-the-top, gritty in an after-school special sort of way, humorous, or romantic and boy-centric.
This book is a bit more emotionally grounded than that, and is one of the few books I've read that scores consistently high marks for the characters that have been created, authenticity, plotting, the honesty of the problems addressed, deadpan humor, and, for want of a better word, wholesome decency. Each character is reasonably complex; each has a reasonable balance of good and bad traits, and each is revealed, at some level, to be basically sound. The result is that the book feels earnest and real, addresses common problems and issues with honesty, and somehow comes out on top with a feel good resolution that doesn't at all seem phony.
Our heroine Amber isn't perfect, but she's as good as she needs to be and better than most. Her Mom, grandmother and sister feel like real family members. The adults in her life are adults, with all of the pros and cons that go with that. Amber's sister, Bella, is a classic annoying little sister, but she has surprising depth and is allowed to be more than a cliche. The affection that binds Amber's family seems real. And this is balanced by the sadness that weighs down everyone as a consequence of Amber's father's absence. The author has taken a real chance - the family was simply abandoned by the father, and Amber's yearning to have a Dad or at least to know why her Dad left is heartbreaking. But of course this is the central event that gives power, energy and meaning to everything else that happens in the book.
The author has a delicate touch and pulls off the whole exercise without ever drifting into the maudlin or precious. As you might expect, Amber often narrates with a wisdom and eye for detail that's way above what you'd expect from an eleven year old, but I'm happy to suspend disbelief on that point in order to allow the author to slip in some sly, edgy, deadpan or vinegary comments, through Amber, that liven up the narrative. Almost every author has to do that sort of thing with adolescent narrators, and here it's done almost seamlessly.
So, all in all this turned out to be a touching, funny, upbeat and insightful work that had numerous rewards, big and small, on almost every page. A very nice find.
Please note that I received a free advance ecopy of this book in exchange for a candid review. Apart from that I have no connection at all to either the author or the publisher of this book.