Spoilers
I initially enjoyed the first three Bloodlines books but I think I've gone off them… On rereading I found them all rather uninspired and cheesy, especially the numerous romances which seem to dominate every story arc. I was hoping The Fiery Heart would reestablish my love for the series but if anything it just made me dislike it even more. Maybe, I'm just tired of vampires, YA, and silly-forbidden-tropey romances.
-I didn't really find the plot interesting. Most of the book was spent on Sydney/Adrian's mushy-and-dull-and-of-course-forbidden relationship, the rest was focused on Sydney replicating the Alchemist anti-ink, and finding a solution to the stirgoi problem. It all felt like filler and everything was dragged out, it wasn't until the very end when things really started to kick off.
I have to say I wasn't impressed with the cliffhanger - I think it's obvious that Sydney will be rescued from the Alchemists/reeducation centre, she'll be traumatised for a little while but her wuv for Adrian will heal her, they'll get it on, and Sydney will vow to take down the Alchemists. If there's going to be a cliffhanger then I want to be surprised by what's to happen. Why have a cliffhanger when its clear what's to come?
-The series was initially about Sydney and co trying to protect Jill but that's been more or less been forgotten about. There was a quick conversation with Lissa telling Adrian that Jill could come out of hiding because she managed to change that silly every-monarach-must-have-a-family-member rule/law. So yea, the arc that was the foundation of the series was tied up in a very rushed and unsatisfying way. I'm not sure what the series is about anymore — the books have gone off into different tangents and seem to more about Sydney's magic, the Alchemists, Adrian's perfect HEA, and the stirgoi problem. I wish there was just the one overarching storyline throughout, I guess future books will be about taking down the Alchemists. But since I find them irritating and dull, I'm not looking forward to that.
-I'm not interested in the Alchemists whatsoever, I don't find them compelling antagonists at all. They're just a bunch of stuck up, hypocritical, boring, righteous, racist humans who hate vampires for no real reason other than them thinking they're impure. The Alchemists don't have the allure, power or danger of the stirgoi… So yea, they make rubbish bad guys.
-In earlier installments, I thought I preferred Sydney over Rose but not so much in this one. I finally realised how uninteresting Sydney is, she's had such a boring life, she mostly always follows rules, she's never had a relationship before Adrian, and she's never had a life before Adrian… And that makes Sydney boring. I didn't notice her flat personality in the first 3 books because I was kept entertained by Sydney's character development — she changed her principles, she embraced vampires and love, she rebelled against the Alchemists, and she accepted her magic. And now she's done all that, she has nothing else to offer, except her boring personality and her boring duties and her banging on and on about her wuv for Adrian.
-I really didn't like Adrian. He was an annoying, self-pitying, useless, irresponsible, drunk loser. Yea, I know he's a Spirit user which messes with his emotions but it was hard to feel sorry for him when he got drunk whenever he felt down in the dumps. What can he really offer Sydney? She'd just be picking up after him and having to support his many ups and downs all her life. Sydney has enough to worry about (Jill, her sister, her magic, not getting caught out by the Alchemists) and Adrian just makes her life even more difficult. She'd be better off without him.
Also, I was really tired of Adrian's whole nobody understands me routine. Get over it.
-Sydney/Adrian's relationship/love seemed so forced. I used to like them together but not anymore — their relationship comes across as fake and contrived. There was too much of Sydney/Adrian banging on about how perfect they were for each other and how they were made for each other. I wasn't convinced, I wanted to 'see' their love for myself instead of being repeatedly hit on the head with it. They just weren't natural together, every action and thought between them was contrived so that they'd seem like a 'meant to be' couple.
-I hated how much Sydney's friends/Adrian took advantage of her. She was always the one who was left with sorting things out.
-I was disgusted that Sydney losing her virginity meant she'd lose half her magic. WTF?! It really pissed me off, why do so many fantasy/supernatural type books have heroines that can't lose their virginity without losing their power or strength. Because a girl who loses her virginity needs to be punished or is somehow less than before?! Ugh. It's a disgusting and sexist trope.
-What was with Adrian calling Rose the love of his life? Really? Sure, he might think it's Sydney now but if he thought it was Rose at one point, and now thinks it's Sydney then what's to stop it from being someone else in the future?
-I wish Adrian would get a job. He's 21 and living off his dad. He could still work whilst taking classes, he's got plenty of time.
-I'm getting tired of all these virgin heroines who can't fathom having sex with anyone apart from the love of their life. Yet all YA heroes/male love interests are cool with having sex with anyone and everyone regardless of feelings. The double standards and sexism in YA are disgusting.
-I rolled my eyes at Adrian saying he was inexperienced because he'd never been with a virgin before. Ugh, I'm sick of that line — it's in every YA book and it's not romantic, its cringey. Adrian was an experienced manslut, he knew exactly what to do, his whole 'I'm inexperienced' nonsense was tropey bullshit.
-It was Adrian's fault that Sydney was caught out by her sister/dad/the Alchemists at the end. Adrian kept pushing her to sneak out and pressuring her to spend time with him even though he knew Zoe was getting suspicious. Sydney was risking it all to be with him, he was risking nothing whatsoever. I didn't like how willing he was to put Sydney at risk just because he was greedy and selfish. I'm not convinced that he loves her all that much, everything was about him and his needs. He never once thought to back off in order to protect her.
-Also, I hated how Sydney paid for so many of Adrian's things… Like the bed and breakfast, Adrian's ruby, and Adrian's car repairs. He was such a loser boyfriend.
-I find it funny how Adrian emptied out his bank account for Rose and gave expensive gifts to all his other girlfriends yet he couldn't do the same for Sydney when he claims to love her. It was really off putting how she was bank rolling him, no wonder he's in 'love' with her.
-I was disgusted at how easily Adrian gave up on Sydney when she was taken by the Alchemists after they found out about her relationship with him. She'd only been missing a few days, and he stopped trying to find a way to rescue her, and instead decided to get drunk because that would make him feel better. Never mind about Sydney and the fact that she needed help, it was all about him. If it was the other way around, Sydney would stop at nothing to save him. It's a shame Adrian doesn't love her as much as she loves him.
-There was way too much recapping of earlier books.
-I still don't understand why every moroi king/queen has to have a sibling/family member to rule. It's not like the throne can be passed down to relatives, it's all election based… It's a ridiculous law that makes no sense.
-Why does every character have to paired off with someone? There were too many couples/potential couples… Adrian/Sydney, Jill/Eddie, Angeline/Trey, Neil/Olivia, not to mention past teen couples. It's unrealistic that every teenage character has managed to find their twu wuv.
All in all, it was disappointing. Sydney was boring, Adrian was whiny, the romance was another cliched run of the mill YA romance, and the plot wasn't exciting.