It is the autumn of 1892. Sherlock Holmes has been missing, presumed dead, for over a year.
Sherlock’s elder - and still more brilliant - brother, Mycroft (read by Rory Kinnear), is too busy to grieve this apparent loss. Working as an agent for the British government, Mycroft is tasked with the politics of maintaining an empire on the verge of collapse.
But on the streets of London, a killer is on the loose. A sequence of bloody bodies litter the East End, murders which echo those of Jack the Ripper four years before.
Against his better judgement, Mycroft is forced to step out from the shadow of his brother, and join the hunt for the truth. With his new maidservant, Liberty Bliss, by his side, Mycroft follows the scent of a conspiracy that will lead him to an organisation which sets to threaten everything – and everyone – he holds dear.
Meanwhile, the full truth about what happened to Sherlock has yet to be told...
Well, apparently Whitechapel wasn’t done with murder! 😂 Four years after the Jack the Ripper murders, we’re back in London and someone is killing again. Because clearly Whitechapel needed MORE problems. 😬
And this time, Sherlock Holmes is dead. 😱 So his brother Mycroft is left wondering… Should I actually try to solve these murders myself? 🕵️♂️
I loved the idea of stepping into Mycroft’s world and seeing what happens when the Holmes brother who usually stays behind the scenes has to take center stage. Add Victorian London, a string of murders, the shadow of Jack the Ripper, and plenty of mystery, and you’ve got a pretty fun murder-mystery setup. 🕯️🔍
But now I need to know… would YOU have figured it out? 🤔🧐 Or would you have been standing in Whitechapel like, “Well, good luck to everyone involved. I’m going home.” 😂
🩸 Murder mystery club question: Who do you think makes the better detective—Sherlock or Mycroft?
A freebie from Audible. I do seem to love everything Sherlock-relayed but this book did not really hook me. It was a weird plot with unbelievable social mixing and lots of annoying over-done English. (One simply must research the author to find if he or she is actually English, or merely some poor colonial sod writing their best approximation of an aristocratic speaker in Victorian England and over-egging the pudding in the process. - cue eye roll)
I found the “Jack the ripper” solution presented in this book plausible but grew tired of the actual interactions with the character. And I was disturbed how the book ended with a Machiavellian revenge causing the deaths of the innocent with the guilty as “all hands perished”. (classic ends justifying means? Or the same depraved indifference shown by the “bad guys”?) Mycroft was portrayed as not just rude, but mean ,and quite unlikable and unhealthy. I found myself hoping Sherlock would appear, and the book had a “to be continued” element to it. Guess I’d have to take on another series to see what happens, but I don’t think I enjoyed this enough to do so.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Fits well within Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes Universe
I very much enjoyed the book. I'm a big Sherlock Holmes fan and I read a lot of books that are set within the universe. This author did very well aligning the story with the original feel of Sherlock Holmes. The dialogue style was very much on point. The existing character of Mycroft Holmes was recognizable in manner of speech and habit. The existing character of Inspector Lestrade was given a bit more depth in this story. (Also very much appreciate the narrator's pronunciation) I felt like the character was a somewhat different than the Lestrade of Conan Doyle's novels, but as the story played out, I think he took all the correct actions that the true Lestrade would have done, so the differences read a bit like character development versus just being uncharacteristic of the subject. The narration was beautifully done. And the music added so much to the story for me. Bravo
This was an enjoyable read! It was a good Holmes-world story. I thought the writing was good, but not amazing—the plot felt a little wild at the end, and there were plot elements that seemed to have little-to-no bearing on the overall story. Perhaps they’ll come up in sequels? Regardless, I liked the characters, I liked the twists, and the storytelling was good!
This was an easy listen with a good enough story to keep you interested. I enjoyed it even though it felt a bit convoluted at times. But overall I enjoyed the plot which had both murder and political intrigue. I was always curious about Mycroft and this describes him perfectly.
“The state cannot bend the rich to its will by the sheer exercise of muscle. There are other, subtler, and above all more productive ways. Change is at its most effective when it is scarcely noticeable."
Liberty Bliss is a good character. She did not have the pleasure of meeting Sherlock Holmes, but like many other people, she has read about his cases. She is Mycroft Holmes’s housemaid and is intelligent, so Mycroft Holmes enjoys talking over the clues they have discovered with her. In this case, we see Mycroft Holmes returning to Saint Simeon’s College, where he studied as a student. Mycroft Holmes is solving the murder of Arthur McGowan, an author who worked in Mycroft's department and had left the department the previous year. The killer’s modus operandi is to cut out his victims' hearts and lay them beside their bodies in the form of a sacrifice, and this has been done to Mycroft's colleague. As the book progresses, questions are asked: did he have theories on the Jack the Ripper case? J.S. Barnes manages to create a Sherlockian character which is, in one breath, familiar, yet manages to remain unique and likable even though it differs from Conan Doyle's depiction. The killer seems to be haunted by the god Pan. This story is told over a week in 1892, during which time Sherlock Holmes is believed to have fallen to his death with Professor Moriarty at the Reichenbach Falls. Each chapter represents a day. The revelation that Liberty Bliss is a spy and what Fog Bank is used for is satisfying. It is a good addition to the Sherlock Holmes canon and gives Mycroft a chance to take center stage. It is probably my favorite Mycroft Holmes story that I have read, along with the series of books centering around Mycroft written by Kareem Abdul-Jabbar. I also enjoyed how Sherlock Holmes was mentioned throughout the story without making an appearance. It leaves you wondering what is going to happen in the next book, and I am sure I will listen to it.
I have mixed feelings about this one. There were parts i liked and others not so much. Firstly what i didn't like. Mycroft a bastion of British civil service would throw aside Victorian norms to not only allow his maid to drink tea with him, but to say she looked intelligent so made her his deputy investigator. Victorian norms aside it felt forced. It is unlikely should would be able to read properly let alone do most of what they author had us suspending disbelief to accept, but she was just so timid. She was accutely aware that Mycroft was her boss, the partnership just didn't work. Then the reveal of Jack the Ripper. Oh boy why use a tired used up conspiracy theory to push? The theory of someone in the aristocracy or royal family being the ripper has been pretty conclusively ruled out. It suited the authors opinions on class rather the spirit of Holmes. The reality is Whitechapel was extremely poor area with common crime everywhere. People minded their business so there wouldnt be witnesses. Then the police in Whitechapel at the time were more bouncers than detectives, the evidence was all gone by the time the actual detectives were there. It all felt like a convenient cop out. Then Mycroft himself is portrayed as a jealous glutonous man and is thoroughly unlikeable. It just doesn't have the joy of Sherlock and felt a little bit of a disservice too.
However, despite these things that i didn't like, I did enjoy the overall story. It flowed well and i was entertained throughout (i didn't really like the ending but that is a me thing.) I am not sure i would recommend this to a Sherlock fan but maybe to someone who enjoys a who dunnit.
This was a book included in my Audible membership. I’ve always loved Sherlock Holmes and was interested in a story centring on his brother Mycroft . This is during the time when Sherlock has believed to have died over the Reichenbach falls along with Moriarty. Lestrad beseeches Mycroft to use his knowledge and connections to help solve some murders in Whitechapel. Mycroft is uninterested as he feels that those already murdered are rather lowly and not worth his time until Lestrad mentions that an old colleague was a victim.
Is this person reenacting the Jack Ripper murders from just a few years ago? Is there something else that play ? There is some deep conspiracy -no spoilers but a few familiar characters are present. I’m giving this really high marks because their narrator was fantastic. I found the story to be engaging, characters were Interesting.
Admittedly at times bordering on a little confusing but by the end, I felt enough had been explained to understand. I presume there will be more stories from the world of Mycroft Holmes. if you are a fan of the world of Sherlock Holmes and the time and place in which the story is set I think you’ll quite enjoy it -if not, you might want to skip it.
Absolutely LOVED this. Highly recommend. So hope that there will be a sequel.
I am very much in my Sherlock era at the moment, so anything centred around that universe has me at the very least checking it out.
We don’t know heaps about Mycroft from the ACD OG stories, which means that there’s room for the character to grow. The fundamentals were there to keep him true but it was nice stepping into the world from Mycrofts PoV and truly understanding just how integral he is to basically everything.
His relationship with the housekeeper is golden. As a man in his, I’m assuming late 40s/early 50s to get frequent telling off but also mollycoddling by her was brilliant. You see that he has a softer side too around her, which I suspect is super rare…and adored his requirements around blankets for travelling.
The story is set in that period between the return of Sherlock after his tumble off a cliff with Moriarty, so he’s also grieving the loss of his brother and kind of stepping into his shoes in aid of solving the murder of a civil servant, known to Mycroft, in a Ripper style killing in Whitechapel. Lestrad approaches him for assistance and so the story unfolds.
We have a new character in the universe- a recently employed housemaid in the Pall Mall residence, in whom Mycroft sees ‘something’ and takes her under his wing to help solve the crime.
There are some truly excellent twists and turns in this book and a cameo from the one and only Dr Watson, all in the name of uncovering the meaning of Fogbank.
Yes, it’s yet another Sherlock Holmes spinoff, but I thought it was very well written. Bought as a light listen to distract me from a hard hike. Ended up really enjoying it and looking forward to the next one, which will hopefully be written soon.
I really really appreciated this one! I love getting some POV from Inspector Lestrade and some insight into his character that Conan Doyle never really gave him. Mycroft is an awesome foil to Sherlock while being similar enough to keep the feeling of the original books. If you've read Sherlock Holmes I'd highly recommend this.
A fun listen! I appreciate that there isn’t a barrage of fan appeasement with familiar characters, although Easter eggs abound for seasoned Sherlockians. The feature characters are well developed and Mycroft is true to his canonical (Conanical?) self. Not sure when the next one will come out, but the well-executed ending is a proper tease for a sequel. This is Holmes done quite well.
Really enjoyed this post-Reichenbach Falls imagining of Mycroft stepping into his brother's shoes to investigate Ripper-like murders in Whitechapel. Plot was a bit bonkers, but to be fair, so were some of the original Conan Doyle stories. Rory Kinnear's narration is wonderful and had me gripped from the beginning. Really hoping for a follow-up story.
Excellent interpretation of the character and the world, first 2/3rds truely delightful. Last third a bit more awkward as elements of what is probably the overplot come into play and threads are left for future books, but still a very fun read for fans of Holmes.
I enjoyed this book as I am a keen Sherlock Holmes fan and this story and style seemed to have the same feel as the original Conan Doyle prose. I listened to the audio version and Rory Kinnear was a pleasure to listen to.
I thoroughly enjoyed this - it feels like it should be made into a special TV programme. It was stylish, fun listen and I thoroughly enjoyed the twists and takes. The author built a layered story with interesting trusts to the storyline as it builds on the storytelling around the Holmes family.
A very well-written addition to the Holmes brother’s stories. Has all that is expected of such a story. Great characters, as well as as some of the usual suspects, surrounded by suspense and misdirection. Delightful.
Loved the world and Mycroft as a character. He had enough 'Sherlock' tendencies without being a direct copy. Was underwhelmed by the motive at the end and the conclusion.