Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Match: The Situational Coaching® Approach to Meeting Leaders Where They Are

Rate this book
How do you know your coaching is actually helping someone get better?

That is the goal of coaching, after all. Help someone improve. Help them strengthen their leadership, performance, and behavior. Help them move forward with greater clarity, confidence, and effectiveness.

But how do you ensure that the way you’re coaching does that?

As coaching has grown, so have the methodologies and competing opinions about the “right” way to coach. Yet experienced coaches rarely describe their success in terms of rigid formulas. They talk about awareness, adaptability, and understanding what the person in front of them needs in the moment.

That’s what Marshall Goldsmith and Suzie Bishop call “making the Match.”

In Match, they introduce the Situational Coaching® Model, a framework built around a simple Effective coaching depends on matching the coaching approach to the person, opportunity, and moment. In interviews with top coaches across the industry, they heard a consistent This is what the best coaches do.

Drawing from decades of coaching experience and the principles behind the Situational Leadership® Model, Matchtranslates those ideas into a practical coaching framework. Readers learn how to identify coaching opportunities, assess what a coachee needs, adapt their approach as situations change, and adjust alongside the coachee’s growth.

Over time, the framework becomes much more than a process; it becomes a mindset for recognizing what people need and helping them get better.

283 pages, Kindle Edition

Published November 10, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Suzie Bishop

4 books

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
0 (0%)
4 stars
1 (33%)
3 stars
2 (66%)
2 stars
0 (0%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 2 of 2 reviews
Profile Image for Demetri Papadimitropoulos.
1,090 reviews165 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 6, 2026
When Being a Good Coach Becomes the Problem
Suzie Bishop and Marshall Goldsmith’s “Match” exposes the danger of professional habits that once worked beautifully – even as its own systematic answers invite harder questions
By Demetris Papadimitropoulos | November 5th, 2026

Doing what has always worked can be an elegant way to fail. Laura's questions come reliably: What would success look like? What matters most? How might she begin? Unfortunately, Renee cannot answer them. She needs someone to tell her what she has not yet learned, not another invitation to discover an insight hidden somewhere behind the panic. This is the small, almost comic embarrassment at the center of Suzie Bishop and Marshall Goldsmith's “Match: The Situational Coaching® Approach to Meeting Leaders Where They Are”: a person may be very good at coaching in exactly the wrong way. The problem is not a deficiency of empathy. In a profession that prizes being present, the authors ask a bracing question: present to whom, and for what?

Effective coaching, Bishop and Goldsmith contend, requires a fit among an identifiable opportunity, the individual's readiness for that opportunity, and the behavior of the person trying to help. They call the fit a Match, with a capital letter that must work rather harder than the ordinary noun. Their model has four steps: identify the opportunity, assess Performance Readiness®, match and communicate a coaching response, and manage the movement as ability or willingness changes. Four styles supply the available responses. Guiding offers direction; Teaching combines direction and encouragement; Participating emphasizes support and shared problem-solving; Delegating allows greater independence. Whether this taxonomy is as reliable as it is legible is another question, and the book does not always give that question the attention it deserves.

Marshall Goldsmith's connection to this scheme is not retrospective branding. He learned Paul Hersey's Situational Leadership® approach early in his career, taught it, and adapted it as executives began asking him to help them one-on-one. Bishop's connection is equally direct: Hersey was her grandfather, and she works at the Center for Leadership Studies, an institution devoted to that tradition. It translates a familiar leadership approach into the specific conditions of a coaching relationship, drawing on practitioner interviews, illustrative cases, and decades of professional experience. It also imposes a burden: what, beyond changing the setting and the names of the responses, does the adaptation reveal that the original framework could not? The book has a better answer in its scenes than in its declarations of universal usefulness.

Early in the introduction, Cheryl, a vice president of operations, is afraid of difficult conversations with underperforming employees. Her coach, Grant, invites her to explore the origins and texture of that fear. His questions are attentive; she feels understood. Then she must have an actual conversation, armed with little beyond the knowledge that her reluctance has been thoroughly appreciated. The encounter goes badly. It separates the emotional quality of a session from its practical consequences. The word support has been allowed to do too many jobs in the contemporary workplace: listening, reassuring, advising, equipping, approving. Sometimes an anxious person needs reflective space. Sometimes she needs a script, a rehearsal, or the uncomfortable mercy of instruction. That distinction is familiar in principle; here it becomes plain enough to sting.

Technical expertise receives a more complicated treatment in the story of Andrew, a brilliant designer who wants to lead rather than remain the colleague to whom everyone sends the difficult work. His strength has helped build the very arrangement that now constrains him. The organization can count on his output but cannot yet count on the interpersonal signals it associates with leadership. Feedback describes him as hard to read. Andrew grew up in an isolated religious group that restricted ordinary social contact and instructed him to distrust people beyond his immediate circle. He learned technical production work through his father's role in the group's broadcasts. He and the woman he would marry communicated secretly by blinking Morse code. It is a startling detail, and the book almost hurries past its implications.

Read closely, communication was once something Andrew had to conceal, ration, and encode in a bodily signal almost invisible to anyone else. In his adult workplace the demand runs in the opposite direction: he must make his interest, warmth, and attention readily visible to colleagues. The transition is not simply from poor communication to good communication, or from silence to speech. It is from one set of conditions governing what expression makes possible to another. They rightly reject vague instructions such as “Be more human” or “Show emotions.” A person cannot practice an adjective, and the first directive is especially cruel in its implication, even when offered carelessly rather than maliciously. The coaching task must become something observable: asking about colleagues' lives, opening conversations, attending to the signals by which interest becomes legible. Yet even a friendly gesture can be read differently.

In this transformation, the book does something genuinely valuable. It replaces a sweeping judgment about a person with a collection of actions that person can attempt, modify, or reject. The focus shifts from an alleged deficiency of humanity to the ordinary mechanics of professional contact. Yet a question survives the practical success: whose conventions determine what warmth should look like? An organization can make a legitimate request for clearer communication and still mistake familiar expressions for the only credible ones. Andrew wants to advance; his consent and ambitions matter. So do the expectations that make particular gestures seem indispensable. The narrative offers enough detail for this question to become visible, but prefers to resolve it through better coaching technique.

Part of the book's charm is this ability to make large developmental problems suddenly small enough to approach. A promotion becomes a conversation before a meeting. An overwhelming assignment becomes a set of immediate decisions. That reduction in scale can be liberating: it gives a person a first move without pretending a whole life can be redesigned in an hour. It also defines the book's stylistic limits. Cases begin in confusion and end in clarification; questions cue the next concept; short declarations settle what longer exchanges have raised. But it can use its own fluency to smooth away the remainder of a problem, as though whatever does not fit the coaching opportunity has merely not yet been sorted into the correct folder. Clarity is an achievement here, not quite an alibi.

At the center of “Match” sits a strong piece of instructional architecture. Part One establishes coaching as a form of influence and introduces the relationships and categories through which that influence operates. Part Two gives a chapter to each of the four steps, moving from the identification of an opportunity through diagnosis, intervention, and revision. Part Three expands the method into change, power, and professional identity. Especially effective is the decision to reserve movement for its own chapter. An accomplished executive may be ready for one task and entirely uncertain about another; yesterday's capacity may falter under today's demands. The book is at its best when its diagram becomes a provisional map rather than a portrait of a person's character.

Performance Readiness® combines demonstrated ability and willingness or confidence relative to a specific task. An enthusiastic novice does not need the same response as an experienced professional who knows how to act but has become reluctant or insecure. Bishop's own account of preparing for a public presentation shows how a person may possess considerable subject expertise while still needing to learn how to occupy authority without apologizing for it. What the model offers is permission to separate the whole person from the present difficulty. It asks a coach to refrain from treating anxiety as incompetence or expertise as universal preparedness. Those are useful disciplines, even when the boundaries between its categories are less clean in practice than on the printed page.

Alicia, a chief product officer in a period of organizational upheaval, is one of the book's better tests of those boundaries. She has been a capable communicator; now remote collaboration, shifting demands, pregnancy, and exhaustion have altered what meetings ask of her. In response to confusion, she provides more explanation, only to make matters worse. This is the humane side of task-specific readiness: a person does not become permanently deficient because the terms of a task change. But the episode also shows how difficult it can be to tell inability from overload, uncertainty from an altered workplace, and a developmental need from an institutional demand that has become unreasonable. It cannot determine by itself where the problem resides.

Directive and supportive behavior form the axes of the central model, and the names of the styles have been chosen to make their differences memorable. A coachee's willingness may be compromised by fatigue, disagreement, fear of retaliation, or lack of necessary resources. An employee who refuses an assignment may understand its implications better than the supervisor who calls the refusal resistance. An apparently confident leader may be performing confidence because the organization punishes uncertainty. Ability, willingness, and context are not independent variables waiting politely for the consultant to finish the questionnaire. The authors know enough to warn against assigning people fixed readiness identities; they are less rigorous about the uncertainty involved in assigning a readiness level at all.

It would be easy, and unfair, to condemn the framework for not containing an entire theory of organizations. Teaching requires selection. The model's four stages encourage practitioners to specify the task, collect evidence, respond intentionally, and keep checking whether the intervention still fits. These are not trivial accomplishments. They can function as safeguards against a coach's favorite technique and a manager's favorite explanation. A useful map need not reproduce every stone on the ground. The question is whether its user remembers that the stones are still there, particularly when an apparently tidy diagnosis serves a powerful institution's preferred outcome.

Measured against the book's own claims, its account of evidence is less reassuring. The authors interview distinguished practitioners and describe cases in which the right change of approach yields improvement. Neither is the same as independent evidence that matching a given style to a given readiness level reliably produces better outcomes than a sound alternative. The distinction matters because the model does more than recommend attentiveness. It assigns particular responses to particular classifications, and it sometimes speaks as though following the sequence brings dependable effectiveness. The reader can reasonably admire the method's explanatory power while asking what would count as a failed prediction, or how competing diagnoses would be resolved.

Independent research complicates the inheritance without settling the new book's fate. In a 2009 study published in “The Leadership Quarterly,” Geir Thompson and Robert P. Vecchio tested versions of Situational Leadership Theory using employees and supervisors at Norwegian financial institutions and found no clear overall support for the proposed relationships. Their study was not a test of Bishop and Goldsmith's coaching adaptation, so it would be careless to present it as a refutation of “Match.” It does, however, unsettle the implication that a familiar theory's elegant classifications arrive already validated. But an account that promises reliability inherits a responsibility to distinguish demonstrated results from plausible professional wisdom. The book is more accomplished at communicating the latter than establishing the former.

The strongest scenes also resist the reassurance of a ready-made classification. The authors sensibly observe that participants in the same dispute may need different forms of help. Yet their divergent needs belong to a shared relationship and to a workplace that establishes incentives, status, and consequences. An individualized coaching response may help each executive act differently without resolving the conditions sustaining their conflict. Likewise, when Andrew learns to display engagement more openly, he may gain freedom to pursue leadership while also absorbing the organization's assumptions about what leadership looks like. These cases ask us to consider what change has been agreed upon, who benefits from it, and who is entitled to call it improvement.

Relationships of influence are the book's earliest and most enduring subject. Alan Mulally's famous red-yellow-green reporting system at Ford provides a useful illustration. Executives hesitate to mark troubled projects red until a leader responds to candor without punishment. The signal of danger changes meaning because the person receiving it changes the consequences. Here the book momentarily escapes the idea that willingness is merely a property of the individual. People say what they can safely say. A coach who asks why someone is reluctant must also examine who made candor risky. The International Coaching Federation's 2025 Code of Ethics recognizes the potential conflicts among coach, client, and organizational sponsor. “Match” acknowledges these parties; it is less probing about what happens when their definitions of progress do not agree.

One limitation persists: the book frames influence as service, even when an employer shapes the engagement. A sponsor may want better performance; a coachee may want a different job, a less punishing workload, or permission to dispute the assigned objective. Not every disagreement can be translated into an issue of confidence or skill. At times the appropriate intervention may be to question the coaching opportunity itself. Bishop and Goldsmith are careful enough to insist that commitments be genuine and that coaching not become a theatrical prelude to an already decided dismissal. Their method nevertheless develops the mechanics of adapting a response more fully than the ethics of deciding which response is warranted and toward whose ends.

Precisely in Laura and Renee’s scene, one can see both why the method will appeal to readers and why its persuasiveness needs qualification. Laura's questions meet Renee's ignorance like a series of doors opening onto empty rooms. The language repeatedly asks Renee to imagine goals and priorities she has not yet learned to identify. It exposes a mismatch between the information the questions assume and the information she possesses. This is a sharp observation about the grammar of professional helpfulness: a question can sound empowering while quietly transferring responsibility to someone unable to carry it. Laura's courtesy becomes a demand disguised as freedom. The book does not need a grand theory to reveal that error; it needs only the uncomfortable rhythm of one answer after another failing to arrive.

On the second telling, the authors alter the intervention rather than the assignment. Laura names the practical requirements, identifies people and resources, and helps Renee sort what she can handle from what requires other assistance. Renee's small declaration, “I can do this,” supplies the emotional release withheld from the first scene. The paired versions operate like a miniature experiment in prose. It is also a controlled fictional demonstration in which the authors have written both the failure and the cure. The second outcome is therefore persuasive as an illustration of what direction might provide, not as proof of what reliably happens when coaches apply the model. The very feature that makes the passage formally successful makes it evidentially modest.

Underneath these scenes runs an unobtrusive argument about professional vanity. A coach enjoys being the person who asks incisive questions, provides courageous feedback, or offers a wonderfully patient silence. These identities become socially legible and commercially valuable. They also make it difficult to notice when one's performance of competence has replaced attention to the actual task. Each new situation asks whether the method selected reflects a coachee's needs or the practitioner's desire to remain recognizably themselves. Its least successful repetitions merely restate the answer. Its most successful ones return the question with a changed target: not what is wrong with this individual, but what am I still doing because it once earned praise?

Late in the book, Chapter 10 turns that question explicitly toward the business of being a coach. Yet, as the authors put it, a practitioner may begin to “protect a persona” rather than respond to the person across the table. The phrase is sharper than much of the surrounding motivational diction. Protect suggests an asset under threat; persona suggests a cultivated surface; neither necessarily has much to do with the coachee's progress. The relentless challenger may keep pushing when confidence needs rebuilding. The tender encourager may keep affirming when the person needs clear instruction. For a moment the book's criticism becomes genuinely self-implicating. The coach has to stop treating professional identity as an exemption from change.

One might push this insight back toward the authors' own enterprise. “Match” is the extension of a named leadership tradition, developed within an institution that teaches that tradition, and presented through a recognizable branded framework. The authors repeatedly insist that no one style fits every circumstance and that readiness must be reassessed. Still, Chapter 10 supplies a standard against which any professional system ought to be judged: can its advocates recognize when fidelity to the framework has become another form of protecting a persona? The book asks coaches to examine their habits more searchingly than it examines the predictive authority of its own classifications. That discrepancy is neither fatal nor negligible. It is where the review's admiration encounters its limit.

Some of the final pages seek to widen the Match beyond formal engagements, into family conversations, ordinary encounters, and the possibility of social transformation. A framework described as repeatable and reliable is precisely the sort of procedure technology might partly reproduce; the human judgment it cannot easily capture may be the part least reducible to four style-readiness pairings. The closing vision of attentive people improving one another's lives is appealing, but the language becomes more expansive just as the concrete evidence becomes thinner. Its best argument needs no such enlargement. “Match” is a practical, intelligently organized manual whose clarity exceeds its originality and whose demonstrations illustrate better than they verify. Yet its best cases make an important demand: stop performing a familiar virtue long enough to notice the actual difficulty. My rating is 73/100, equivalent to Goodreads 3.25/5. The map can help, provided the coach notices when it has ceased to resemble the person standing in front of it.
Profile Image for Book Bench.
844 reviews2 followers
November 13, 2026
Good coaching starts with the person in front of you, not with a fixed method. That's the simple claim at the center of this book, and the authors build a model around it. They call it Situational Coaching: match the coaching approach to the person, the opportunity, and the moment, instead of running the same play with everyone.

The steps are practical. Learn to spot a coaching opportunity, assess what the person actually needs and whether they are ready for it, respond in a way that fits, and keep adjusting as the person grows and the situation changes. I recognized this approach through my own experience with professional development and wellness strategies. The way the chapters are laid out is helpful, with coaching tips, sample responses, and reflection questions.

A reader new to coaching may find the framework language somewhat confusing at first, and someone experienced with coaching will recognize how coaching often crosses a line into word salad or gaslighting – this makes sense though since life and people have so many variables affecting us at any given time. I'll admit I'm a bit skeptical of many online coaches but there are a handful of good ones out there, and I always appreciate the psychology and marketing lessons. Overall, I found a few good ideas here.
Displaying 1 - 2 of 2 reviews