Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Molly Is Missing: An absolutely jaw-dropping psychological thriller packed with twists

Rate this book
It’s every mother’s worst nightmare…



Kim arrives early at the school gates, bursting with excitement to see her daughter, Molly, after a week-long history trip. Shy and a little anxious, time away from her loving parents is a big deal for Molly – but the emoji-filled texts Kim’s been receiving all week prove her daughter has been having the time of her life. But when the bus pulls up, Molly’s seat is empty. Her teachers say she never went on the trip…

As the search for Molly begins, distraught Kim feels like the police are dragging their feet and the school is acting a little too defensive. And with each precious day that passes, the secrets that bind Kim’s tight-knit community begin to unravel. Why isn’t Kim’s best friend by her side? And why is her husband acting so shady?

Nothing matters to Kim but bringing Molly home safe. With nowhere to turn and no one left to trust, only Kim can find her. And she’s running out of time…

324 pages, Paperback

First published October 26, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Samantha Hayes

85 books1,529 followers
Hello!

Thanks for stopping by my Goodreads page!

My latest psychological thriller THE ENGAGEMENT is out on 10th January 2023 from Amazon, available in ebook, paperback and audio formats. I do hope you love it!


If you love a good 'domestic noir' thriller that will mess with your mind and keep you turning the pages, then my books are for you! You can check out all my titles on my Amazon page here:

https://amzn.to/3jZ83zU

I do hope you'll love getting stuck into my books and enjoy reading them as much as I love writing them. And do let me know what you think - it's great to hear from readers! You can get in touch via my website where you'll find lots of info about me and my books - www.samanthahayes.co.uk or come and 'Like' my Facebook page at www.facebook.com/SamanthaHayesAuthor or follow me on Twitter too @samhayes or @samanthahayes.author on Instagram.

Happy reading!

Samantha xx

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
86 (30%)
4 stars
131 (46%)
3 stars
47 (16%)
2 stars
12 (4%)
1 star
4 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 118 reviews
Profile Image for Alya | short TBR clearance era .
763 reviews275 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
October 18, 2026
✨️ ARC REVIEW ✨️

Molly Is Missing by Samantha Hayes
Publication date: 26th October 2026


Thoughts | 2.75⭐️
This was another invested till I wasn't, I really don't like nit picking in my reviews but there are parts in the plot where the mum came across like an absolute bellend like how are you not putting two n two together with the information you're receiving?? The plot pacing was decent and come to think of it the premise had so much potential but somewhere down the line I just lost interest which is a shame because it started off so well and could've ended in another way but unfortunately the ending was a tad far fetched for my liking I mean the "disbelief" was running thin by the end 💔🥲🙄

This was my first reading experience with this author but I would like to give her writing another try

Plot Summary
Kim can’t wait to see her daughter, Molly, after a week away on a school trip. When the bus arrives, Molly is nowhere to be seen, and her teachers insist she never went. Who was sending those text messages? As Kim desperately searches for answers, she begins to lose faith in the police and notices strange behaviour from the people closest to her. With secrets coming to light and trust falling apart, Kim must find out what really happened to her daughter before it’s too late

Many thanks to NetGalley and publishers for the ARC
Profile Image for Kristina Anderson.
403 reviews148 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 29, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley and Bookouture for the ARC (Advance Reading Copy) of Molly is Missing by Samantha Hayes. This psychological thriller keeps you reading. Just one more chapter is what I kept saying. I have read several books by this author and she did not disappoint me. The pacing was good and the short chapters are great. All these secrets, oh my! The ending certainly got me! I highly recommend this one. A 4 star rating from me. #NetGalley #Bookouture #SamanthaHayes
Profile Image for Tia.
334 reviews17 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 18, 2026
RATING: 4 ⭐
GENRE: Psychological/Domestic Thriller
PUBLICATION DATE: October 26th, 2026

When Kim’s daughter Molly, a shy, anxious sixteen-year-old, doesn’t come home from a week-long school trip to France, Kim is confused and panicked. Where is Molly? When it comes to light that Molly never went on the trip, Kim is dumbfounded. How can that possibly be, when Molly was sending her mother daily updates from the trip? Nothing makes sense, but it quickly becomes clear that Molly is missing. A desperate and frantic search begins for the young girl, but they are already 5 days behind. With time quickly running out, and with every clue uncovered, Kim soon realizes that everyone around her is harboring secrets, and she will need to rely on her instincts if she is ever to see her daughter again.

This was my first foray into the writing of Samantha Hayes, and I was quickly drawn into this tense, gripping and harrowing thriller.

🥳 What I loved

Atmosphere: Talk about suffocating and intense! The ever-present feeling of dread and paranoia left me breathless.

Pacing: This was one of those “just one more chapter” kind of reads, with its short chapters and dual timelines that gave just enough tidbits to keep you reading without stalling the momentum.

Mystery: Hayes did an amazing job making me question everyone. Everyone! There is not one character that is not suspect at some point, and I loved that I couldn’t quite figure out the who/what/how!


🤔 Things to consider

Suspension of disbelief: So, yes, there are some logic leaps and convenient timings that need to happen in order to pull this together, which made this a 4-star for me.

TW: Gaslighting and manipulation, anxiety and paranoia, parental panic and distress.

Final Verdict

A very gripping, tense and claustrophobic domestic thriller that, although requires some suspension of disbelief, will keep you flipping the pages! Very entertaining and highly recommend! I will be adding this author to my auto-read list for sure!

Thank you to NetGalley, Bookouture and Samantha Hayes for providing an advanced reader copy in exchange for an honest review! All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Gary.
3,207 reviews444 followers
November 5, 2026
Kim arrives early at the school gates, bursting with excitement to pick up her daughter, Molly, after a week-long history trip. Because Molly is naturally a bit shy and anxious, time away from home is a big step for her, but the cheerful, emoji-filled texts Kim received all week reassured her that Molly was having the time of her life. However, when the bus finally pulls up, Molly’s seat is completely empty—and the teachers deliver the chilling news that she never even went on the trip.

As the frantic search for Molly begins, a distraught Kim feels like the police are dragging their feet and the school is acting far too defensive. With every precious day that passes, the hidden secrets of Kim’s tight-knit community start to unravel. Questions pile up: why isn’t Kim’s best friend by her side, and why is her husband acting so shady? With nowhere else to turn and no one left to trust, Kim knows she is running out of time to bring her daughter home safe.

This is an addictive novel that had me completely gripped right till the final page. It’s a proper page-turner that moves at a fast pace, making it a wonderfully quick and absorbing read. The story is packed full of suspense and clever twists that keep you guessing as the mystery deepens. The mounting tension within the community and Kim’s desperate race against time make it impossible to put down.

Molly is Missing is a tense, gripping, and thoroughly entertaining thriller that delivers on every front. If you love a fast-moving mystery with high stakes and plenty of twists to keep you hooked, this is definitely worth picking up. A solid four stars!

I would like to thank both Netgalley and Bookouture for supplying a copy of this novel in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Mark.
1,878 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 21, 2026
You know some authors do twists and then some do twists on twists and Samantha Hayes does them x3

Right from the start this was intriguing and emotive……

Molly doesn’t return home from a school trip to France, you can feel the excitement her Mum has waiting for her turn to anguish and shock as it becomes clear she never went

And then as the hunt for Molly starts you get the feeling some of the players are not entirely as we think they are

It turns into a web of deception, lies and dark happenings

The endings are brilliant and just when you think its done whoosh we get another

Trust no one, believe them less is my advice for this new take on a theme psychological thriller
Profile Image for Louise Wilson.
4,029 reviews1,714 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 16, 2026
Kim arrives early at the school gates, bursting with excitement to see her daughter, Molly, after a week-long history trip. Shy and a little anxious, time away from her loving parents is a big deal for Molly - but the emoji-filled texts Kim's been receiving all week prove her daughter's been having the time of her life. But when the bus pulls up, Molly's seat is empty. Her teachers say she never went on the trip. As the search for Molly begins, distraught Kim feels like the police are dragging their feet and the school is acting a little too defensive. And with each precious day that passes, the secrets that bind Kim's tight-knit community begin to unravel. Why isn't Kim's best friend by her sice? And why is her husband acting shady? Nothing matters to Kim but bringing Molly home safely. With nowhere to turn and no one left to trust, only Kim can find her. And she's running out of time.

Everyone has secrets and I never knew who I could trust in this gripping rad. I was pulled into this story after reading the first chapter. When Molly doesn't return from a week-long trip to France, her mother, Kim, is frantic and time is running out to find her. I could not put this book down. Where was Molly? Who had taken her? All I could do was to keep reading and guessing.

Published 26th October 2026

I would like to thank #NetGalley #Bookouture and the author #SamanthaHayes for my ARC of #MollyisMissing in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Teresa Nikolic.
992 reviews131 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 25, 2026
Sixteen year old Molly has been on a history trip to France with her school for the last week, Kim has understandably been worried about her as Molly is an anxious child but, the texts and photos that Molly has been sending her show she's been having a great time and Kim is looking forward to hearing all about it, arriving at the school early to wait for the coach but, when it pulls up and all the children get off, Molly is nowhere to be seen and the teachers say she never went on the trip. The police are informed and the search for Molly begins but, as the investigation continues, Kim feels there are too many anomalies and, with a little detective work of her own, secrets are revealed and the truth comes out, but will they get to Molly before it's too late...

Molly is Missing is the latest thriller by Hayes and it captured me from the first page, told across a dual timeline of Before and the present day and mainly from the perspectives of Kim and Molly. This is the stuff of every parents nightmare, how would you cope if your child went missing? This story is fast paced, the author knows how to draw her readers in and keep them invested in the tales she tells. It's a dark and intriguing read with some great characters, people that Kim and Joel were certain they could trust, but sometimes those closest to you are the ones you really shouldn't trust at all and there's no wonder Kim became very paranoid with the whole thing when she'd seen with her own eyes that Molly was in France, but apparently never got there! It got to a point where I couldn't trust any of the characters, even then it was still a surprise to me when they discovered the identity of the perpetrator but, in true Hayes style that's never the end because then she hits you with a curveball that you would never have guessed and shocks you all over again, this is why she is one of my go to authors and why this story deserves a full five stars in my opinion. Hayes, you knocked it out of the park AGAIN!!

I'd like to thank Bookouture and Netgalley for the auto approval, I will post my review on Goodreads now and Amazon on publication day.
Profile Image for Jen.
1,268 reviews111 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 23, 2026
This was a really good book with a strong mystery. It centers on Kim, whose 16-year-old daughter Molly goes missing when she is supposed to be on a school trip. Kim’s quest to find out what happened to Molly and get her home safely at any cost uncovers a whole lot of secrets that everyone around her, including Molly herself, was keeping. The book is told mostly from Kim’s POV, but there are also some chapters from Molly’s POV, as well as chapters from previous years that set the stage for the current situation.

One thing that worked so well in this book is that the author provided a good number of viable suspects, which left me unable to trust anyone- you got just enough information on every person to cause some suspicion. I really liked Kim in that she was willing to do anything to keep Molly safe, including forgiving some pretty bad decision-making, but at the same time I was frustrated with her because she seemed to let people walk all over her. She definitely has an ability to forgive people that I do not possess! The book is fast-paced and there is always something happening that brings it closer to the truth- I couldn’t put it down because I couldn’t wait to see what happened. I was kind of right when I guessed the twist, but it was actually much more complex (in a good way) than what I had been thinking. On one hand, I liked how the book ended because it packed some good surprises up to the very last page; on the other hand, I remained a little frustrated with Kim.

Overall, this was a gripping mystery that kept me guessing, and I would recommend it to anyone who enjoys a suspenseful page-turner. Thanks to Netgalley for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Rhea.
180 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 1, 2026
⭐⭐ 2 stars

This is labeled a psychological thriller, but I kept waiting for the psychological depth and suspense to show up. There were some promising ideas, but the story felt flat and one-dimensional. The characters had so little development that I never felt connected to them or invested in what happened.

My biggest issue was the kidnapper. There wasn’t enough groundwork to make me believe this person would actually kidnap someone. The motivations and connection to the story needed much more development. I can suspend disbelief when reading a thriller, but the author has to give me something to work with.

The twists at the end were interesting, which made the rest even more frustrating. With stronger suspense, fully developed ideas, and meaningful details, those reveals could have been riveting and completely shocking. Instead, they felt like interesting concepts that the story hadn’t done enough to support.

Too much time went to details that added nothing, while the parts that could have made this a compelling thriller were barely explored. By the end, I was more frustrated by the missed potential than surprised by the twists. Unfortunately, this one didn’t work for me.

Receiving a gifted copy made me hesitate to give such a low rating, but I have to be honest about my reading experience. I appreciate the opportunity to read it early, and my rating needs to reflect how I actually felt about the book.

I hope my honest feedback won’t discourage future review approvals. I love reading, and when I find a book I love, I will shout it from the rooftops! That enthusiasm comes from the same place as my criticism: I want people to trust that I mean what I say.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an advance review copy. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Concha.
670 reviews9 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 17, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley and Bookouture.
Molly went on a school trip, but when her mum, Kim, goes to pick her up, it seems she never actually got on the bus.
Parents and friends of the family launch a desperate search, as she has been missing for days without anyone noticing. Is this a case of a teenage runaway, or something worse?
As we read on, we see how everyone has secrets; there are misunderstandings and deceptions that leave us wondering what might have happened and who to trust.
From the very first page, I felt immersed in the story, with a narrative pace that made me feel the characters’ anguish, urgency and helplessness.
Without a doubt, a psychological thriller that’s a real page-turner.

Profile Image for Jennifer Denise.
210 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 24, 2026
Highly predictable and not well written.
Profile Image for Christine M in Texas (stamperlady50).
2,282 reviews292 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 29, 2026
Molly is Missing
By: Samantha Hayes
Pub Date: October 26, 2026
Publisher: Bookouture
As a mother, this novel and premise terrified me. When Molly goes missing, her mother is devastated. She thought her daughter was on a week-long history trip. She thinks she has been on the trip of a lifetime, because she has been getting updates from her “daughter”. But was she really the one leaving texts?
The community is brought in and Molly’s dad is acting strange. Time is running out. The is fast-paced and so plausible in todays world of electronics.
Profile Image for Sarah Bloomfield.
331 reviews20 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 12, 2026
Many thanks to netgalley, the author and the publisher for approving my request to read this book.

Kim eagerly arrives at her daughter Molly's school to collect her from her school trip to France keen to hear all about her adventure. To her utter horror Molly is not on the coach and her best friend swears she didn't go on the trip with her. When Kim questions the headteacher he insists he received a message from Kim herself saying Molly was unwell and wouldn't be attending the trip. Left reeling from this news Kim begins her urgent quest to locate her beloved daughter and bring her home.

This book reeled me in from the get go and the tension just kept ramping up, as a mother myself I could really feel Kim's panic and devastation and my heart went out to her. I thoroughly enjoyed the multiple twists that were thrown my way, they most certainly kept me entertained and on my toes and I loved the ending.

If you're a psychological thriller fan I suggest you pop this one on your to be read list, you won't be disappointed!
339 reviews2 followers
November 7, 2026
This is one of the best Samantha Hayes books that I have read. Gripping, addictive, and I just couldn’t stop reading it. So much action, a twist at the end and good character Development.
Profile Image for Julianne Harkleroad.
839 reviews5 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
October 9, 2026
Ghastly opening! Sixteen year old Molly is missing and has been FOR DAYS. Her mom, Kim Newton, finds neither hide nor hair of her when she shows up to collect Molly after their weeklong, out of country field trip. Molly kept in touch as any teen would, sporadically, letting her parents know she was having a good time. So where is Molly??

Charlie, the field trip teacher, says Kim emailed him on Monday, saying Molly wasn't well enough to join that week. But Kim adamantly denys ever sending that message - even though Charlie shows her. What is going on?! With conflicting stories, and no sight of Molly all week, Kim, rightfully, starts to panic. How could Molly have texted Kim all week from France if she was never on the bus??

Together, they report her as missing to authorities as pressure, fears, and anxieties mount. Who's lying, who's keeping secrets, and who has evil intentions? Molly mom begins her own investigation, refusing to sit on her hands and wait for the authories to do something. What she uncovers along the way is heartbreaking, exhausting, shocking, and life changing.

Molly's POV is frightening. She awakens and gives readers a slow blow by blow as her memories surface from her slumber. She's suffering from a bit of amnesia and doesn't quite remember what happened just before she was came to reside where she is...

Personally, I hated everyone but Molly and Kim. I could never make the choices Kim does in the end- but can we talk about the ending? It doesn't make sense until the epilogue- DO NOT READ IT UNTIL YOU'VE READ THE WHOLE BOOK. I wish the whole book was as exciting as that last chapter. It seems like the entire plot happened there, and the book would have benefited from some aspects being addressed earlier to create more intrigue, confusion, and mystery along the way.

Tropes: dual POV, missing child, amateur sleuth, investigation, family secrets, amnesia, big reveal
Spice: 1/5 🌶️
Gore: 2/5 🩸
Language: 5/5 👀
Triggers: kidnapping of a juvenile

Thank you to Bookouture and NetGalley for this ARC!

PS, Dear Samantha, what did Tom do? I want to know why toooooo 🤣
Profile Image for bookedupnurse.
207 reviews2 followers
November 2, 2026
‘When you don’t know where something is, you show how want it so much more …’

Kim arrives at the school gates to welcome Molly, her sixteen year old daughter, back from her week long trip to France. But when the bus pulls up, Molly’s seat is empty and her teacher insist she was never on the trip. But how is it that possible? Molly has been texting all week, telling her parents all about her experiences. Where on earth can Molly be?

As the frantic search for Molly begins, Kim feels all those around her are acting strangely and not the way she believes they should while her daughter is missing. The life that Kim, husband Joel and Molly know suddenly collapses around them and dangerous secrets rise to the surface, threatening to ruin everything they have ever known.

What on earth has happened to Molly? What risk is she facing? Will they find her before she comes to harm?

Told across a dual timeline - ‘before’ the disappearance and ‘present’ - and mainly from the perspective of Kim and Molly, this is a story filled with deception, lies and twists, as well as a sense of claustrophobia, this story highlights a mum’s desperate fight for answers, no matter the cost.

Whilst this is described as a psychological thriller, it is definitely more a domestic drama. This is a typical popcorn thriller: fast paced, atmospheric, tense and full of secrets! An easy read, this is perfect if you are a fan of Daniel Hurst and Emily Shiner!

With thanks to NetGalley, Bookouture and Samantha Hayes for the ARC in return for an honest review.
Profile Image for Cozy Crystal Chapters.
25 reviews5 followers
November 12, 2026
Thank you to @netgalley, the author @samanthahayes.author, and @bookouture for gifting me this book in exchange for my honest review.

​Molly is Missing
Author: Samantha Hayes
Pub Date: Oct 26, 2026
Publisher: Bookouture

​I couldn’t put this one down. Omg, the twists and turns! Mind Blown!

Perfect for anyone who loves Freida McFadden.

​It’s every mother’s worst nightmare…

​Think:
A Mother’s Worst Nightmare
A Missing Child
A Shady Inner Circle
A Twisty Mystery
A Shocking Ending

​Blurb: Kim arrives early at the school gates, bursting with excitement to see her daughter, Molly, after a week long history trip. Shy and a little anxious, time away from her loving parents is a big deal for Molly but the emoji filled texts Kim’s been receiving all week prove her daughter has been having the time of her life. But when the bus pulls up, Molly’s seat is empty. Her teachers say she never went on the trip…
​As the search for Molly begins, distraught Kim feels like the police are dragging their feet and the school is acting a little too defensive. And with each precious day that passes, the secrets that bind Kim’s tight knit community begin to unravel. Why isn’t Kim’s best friend by her side? And why is her husband acting so shady?
​Nothing matters to Kim but bringing Molly home safe. With nowhere to turn and no one left to trust, only Kim can find her. And she’s running out of time…
Profile Image for Laura.
1,057 reviews49 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 15, 2026
The premise of this intrigued me - an anxious mum lets her 16 year old daughter go alone on a school excursion overseas, only to pick her up to find out she never made it onto the excursion after all. I do not have children, but I imagine this would be every mums worst nightmare. As someone who was premmie and has anxiety, this did a great job at making me anxious, getting right there in Molly and Kim's head. This was the perfect popcorn thriller, and if I was not working, I would have easily read it in one day. I loved the short chapters that continuously ended on cliff hangers. I found it a bit predictable, but enjoyed following the characters discover things along the way. Only shortfall was that it lost me towards the end as I feel it resolved way to quickly. Saying that, I really enjoyed this and am keen to pick up more of Hayes' backlog in the future.
Profile Image for Frankie Bean.
87 reviews12 followers
September 16, 2026
Thank you NetGalley and Bookouture for sending this book for review consideration. All opinions are my own.

Okay - WOW.
I flew through this, literally couldn’t put it down.
The pacing was well done, not dragged out where some books can make the reader feel like the author is trying to get a word count in.
There were plenty of red herrings and false leads to keep you guessing and interested.
When I tell you the ending had me shocked & my blood boiling!!!!!

I can see fans of Freida McFadden really enjoying this one.

HIGHLY recommend!!
Profile Image for Maja.
667 reviews11 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 3, 2026
Thank you Bookouture for this ARC!

Could be I am biased with my rating because I do enjoy reading Samantha Hayes's books. But they always have something I enjoy, like all the twists I am never able to guess when I try.

Molly Is Missing was a bit more of a slow-burn, but still I had to keep reading. I felt so sorry for Kim even when not bring a parent myself and of course wished things would end well for her and Molly in one way or another. Overall, I am giving this one well-earned 4,5 stars.
Profile Image for Nicola “Shortbookthyme”.
2,687 reviews134 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 25, 2026
✅My thoughts:
A mother’s worst nightmare….sending her daughter off on a school trip only to find out four days later, the daughter never went on the school trip.
I had a feeling about one of the characters which actually did turn out to be a correct feeling. Though many times during the story, I second-guessed myself so many times!
I have to jump right to the end of the book with a 😳 face. I absolutely felt like things had been resolved and all was going to be as ok as it could be. Then…that ending left me aghast!
Definitely a read for fans of a twisty-psychological domestic thriller.
40 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 3, 2026
If you like books that paint many characters as the possible “bad guy,” spin your head with surprises, and drop bombshells in the last few pages, this one’s for you. Samantha Hayes never takes her foot off the pedal. Be prepared for a bumpy ride as you join the chase looking for Molly!
Profile Image for Kim McFall.
438 reviews9 followers
October 26, 2026
This was a solid, twisty read!

A missing girl
Everyone has a secret
An investigation
A mom that won’t give up
Twist after twist

I was hooked from the beginning and really enjoyed the story as everyone’s secrets and deceptions were uncovered. However, the pacing slowed in the middle and I started to lose interest.

Luckily, the pace picked back up towards the end and I really liked the way this one ended!

Thanks you Net Galley for the advanced reader copy!
Profile Image for Vanessa.
3,603 reviews30 followers
November 12, 2026
Molly is Missing by Samantha Hayes was another excellent psychological thriller and so addictive, I ended up reading it to the early hours of the morning until I had finished! What a roller coaster ride this book was, it was full of twists and turns my head was spinning and WoW I did not see that coming! Superb book.

WoW . . . . . This book was a great page turner and another excellent read.
I highly recommend this book 5 ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️

Big thank you to NetGalley and Bookouture for my ARC.
Profile Image for Cobalt's Son.
200 reviews1 follower
September 30, 2026
The difference between an American thriller and a non-American one is very noticeable. Here we follow a story with a much slower build, but once it gets going, it hooks you and makes you keep turning the pages. I felt so much empathy for Kim and Molly. I feel like the author did an excellent job with their characterization. I especially liked how the investigation unfolded in small, realistic steps. Kim’s sheer willpower kept me engaged—she goes after it, asks questions, and messes up just like any normal human being would in her situation. The chapters were short and always left you wanting more; Samantha knows exactly how to keep the reader on the edge of their seat. I didn't think there would be a massive plot twist, but there kind of is. It's not like the whole book was built solely around this twist. It didn't feel like a senseless twist just for the sake of shock value. It wasn't mind-blowing, but it was an ending with a very interesting tone. Joel is easily top-tier for most spineless/useless husbands I've ever had to read about, seriously. Aside from that, it was a beautifully constructed, highly enjoyable thriller. I'll be watching out for this author's next books.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the E-ARC.
Profile Image for Erika.
985 reviews15 followers
October 27, 2026
Thanks to Netgalley and Bookouture for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Molly was supposed to be on a school trip to France but when the bus returns, she isn't on it. The other participants say she was never on the trip, but she was texting her mom France the whole time, so where is she?

This was a quick and entertaining read. What I liked about it is that new and incriminating info kept popping up which kept my interest. So many people had shady things going on. I was entertained and I look forward to the next novel from this author..
Profile Image for Jen.
415 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 17, 2026
A missing child thriller lives or dies by its momentum, and Samantha Hayes definitely keeps the urgency dialed high from the jump. The story alternates between Kim and Molly's perspectives, mostly staying grounded in the present timeline. While there are only about four flashback chapters throughout the book, they felt unnecessary - none of the details shared in the past were essential, and every bit of that information could have easily been revealed naturally in the present without pausing the forward drive of the story.
The pacing also gets bogged down by casting the net a bit too wide. The sheer volume of secondary characters and possible theories starts to clutter the central mystery rather than deepen it. Certain subplots felt more like filler than tension builders, particularly the sudden reappearance of Molly’s estranged father, Bryan.
As for the resolution, I definitely didn't see the ending coming, but it walked a fine line. The final reveal was almost too twisty for its own good, requiring you to suspend quite a bit of disbelief regarding how normal people would actually behave in that situation. Still, if you can roll with the slightly far-fetched logic of the climax, it wraps up the central mystery in an entertaining way.
If you like dual-perspective suspense, missing person mysteries, and twisty domestic drama, then you will enjoy this book.

Want to see spoilers or trigger warnings? Check out: https://www.spoiltheplot.com/books/mo...
Profile Image for Thamy.
665 reviews29 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 5, 2026
Every mother's nightmare is doubled in this story when Kim's daughter, Molly, isn't among the students returning from a school trip to France. That's when she finds out Molly never even boarded the bus and has been missing for days. They say the first hours are critical searching for a missing person and that the likelihood of finding them plunges after that, but Kim has already lost four whole days.

It's been perhaps a decade since I last read a Hayes book (and not because I didn't like what I read!), so I can't compare it to her usual style. Still, this is a solid thriller that keeps you guessing, even if you have an inkling of what lies behind Molly's disappearance.

However, as gripping as it is and despite being hard to predict, I don't quite see this as a 4-star book. It's far above your average 3-star, but not quite enough to warrant rounding up, so let's call it a 3.5.

One aspect that bothered me was the police work. I'm sure the author wanted Kim to be the star of the investigation, which leaves us seeing little of what the real detectives are doing. Still, they sound competent enough that I'm not sure how they didn't find Molly or at least the right course of investigation by themselves. With Molly missing and no clear indication that she's dead, I feel the police should have been more proactive rather than just collecting evidence for a future trial, which is how it felt most of the time.

I’d say the same for Kim. She keeps some clues and inconsistencies up her sleeve, whereas I'd be throwing them in everyone's face until I understood exactly what they meant, or really until I had my baby back. I do think she would still have missed the most important clue, but holding onto the others happened way too frequently. It felt a bit too convenient for pushing the plot along at just the right moment.

The last bit that annoyed me was the climax, which felt a bit underwhelming. Especially taking into account everything going on, I expected more of a BANG. I don't mean Kim's reaction to her discoveries, which might divide readers, actually, but rather that the delivery itself could have been far more high-stakes.

Besides a few characters behaving suspiciously solely so we suspect them, I think we got a solid flesh-out of Molly and Kim's world. The characters felt very real, almost as if they're still out there living their lives. Plus, the core premise of the mystery was definitely clever. As I mentioned at the start, it's every mother's nightmare doubled up, and I can't fathom being in Kim's shoes. Also, I'm glad the story took a more grounded, clear-eyed approach to Molly's disappearance, as there was plenty of room to waste time agonizing over whether Molly was somehow to blame.

Recommended to anyone in the market for a good thriller about a mother who'll do anything to get her daughter back.



Honest review based on an ARC provided by Netgalley. Many thanks to the publisher for this opportunity.
Profile Image for Rachael.
915 reviews13 followers
November 3, 2026
★★★½☆
Molly is Missing – Samantha Hayes

Molly is Missing is the second book I've read by Samantha Hayes, and once again, she's delivered a gripping psychological thriller with an intriguing premise, plenty of secrets and enough twists to keep me guessing. While I enjoyed the suspense and found it difficult to predict, a few frustrating plot decisions stopped this from being a four-star read.

When Kim arrives at school to collect her daughter Molly after a week-long history trip, she's excited to hear all about her adventures. The messages Molly has been sending throughout the week suggest she's had a wonderful time. But when the bus arrives, Molly is nowhere to be seen. Even more disturbingly, her teachers insist she never went on the trip in the first place. As Kim desperately searches for answers, she begins to question everyone around her, including those closest to her.

One of my biggest frustrations was how little consideration was given to the possibility that Molly hadn't been sending those messages willingly. Once it became clear she hadn't been on the trip, surely the obvious assumption would be that someone else had been sending them, or that Molly had been forced to send them under duress? I found it difficult to believe that nobody seemed to seriously consider this possibility.

The story also included a handful of flashbacks, perhaps three or four, which I didn't think were particularly necessary. The information they provided could easily have been incorporated into the present-day narrative without interrupting the flow. Similarly, some of the subplots felt like unnecessary distractions, particularly those involving Kim's family. Rather than adding meaningful depth, they seemed to clutter an already complicated storyline.

And while I appreciated that the mystery was difficult to unravel, I felt the final reveal took things one step too far. Sometimes an additional twist doesn't necessarily make a story better, and in this case, I think a little restraint would have made the ending more convincing.

That said, there's plenty to enjoy here. The short chapters and alternating perspectives between Kim and Molly kept the pace moving, and I frequently found myself wanting to read just one more chapter. The suspense was maintained throughout, and I genuinely struggled to work out where everything was heading.

Ultimately, this was an entertaining and addictive thriller that kept me invested despite its flaws. It's considerably better than an average three-star read, but the unnecessary subplots, questionable character decisions and slightly overcomplicated ending prevent me from giving it four stars. A solid 3.5 stars feels like the right balance between how much I enjoyed reading it and the frustrations I had along the way. Despite my criticisms, I'd happily pick up another book by Samantha Hayes.

Thank you to Samantha Hayes, Bookoture and NetGalley for providing me with an advance copy of this book.
Profile Image for Emma Alvey.
1,114 reviews45 followers
October 29, 2026
16-year-old Molly has been in France on a school trip since Monday. It’s her first time abroad without her parents and her mother, Kim, has tried not to let her anxieties about it show. But she knows Molly is fine thanks to the regular updates she’s been sending by text. So, when Kim arrives at the school to collect Molly and she doesn’t get off the coach, Kim is confused. That confusion only grows when Molly’s headteacher tells her Molly didn’t go on the trip and he received an email from her on Monday morning saying Molly was poorly and couldn’t attend. Kim feels like the ground has fallen from under her feet. Where is her daughter?

Wow! This heart-pounding, twisty and bingeable thriller was one hell of a ride. Samantha Hayes never disappoints and this is one of the best I’ve read from her so far. Skillfully written, deftly choreographed and intricately interwoven, it held me in a chokehold from the first page. As addictive as a can of pringles, once I started there was no way to stop and I devoured it in just two sittings, staying up well past my bedtime to finish it.

But while it is a first-class thriller, what also shines through in this book is the emotion as Samantha makes you feel everything alongside Kim and Molly. As a middle-aged mum I felt a strong connection with Kim and my heart broke as this ordinary mum was plunged into every mother’s worst nightmare. I felt every moment of her heartache and fear as she searched for her daughter and cheered her on as she went rogue by conducting her own searches. As a mother I don’t know if I could sit around waiting for the police either even though I know it is what you’re supposed to do.

Molly’s chapters perfectly captured her confusion, terror and determination, making me feel like I was right there with her in the dark. She doesn’t remember what happened or where she is, which ramps up the tension and puts the reader in the same position as everyone but the culprit. As Molly tried to piece it all together I was on the edge of my seat, incapable of putting the book down until I knew what happened.

There are a number of suspicious characters and we are never quite sure who we can trust. This made me question everything and there were a few people I thought might be behind Molly’s disappearance. But as I followed the clues that were dropped like breadcrumbs, I could never be completely sure and was kept guessing right up until the jaw-dropping moment when all was revealed.

A must-read for all thriller lovers.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 118 reviews