First off, I sort of bristle at a “Christian Guide” to much of anything, tho I know they’re probably meant well and could be useful to some. As I was reading, I realized that I am not the intended audience for this book, which is fine. Ryken spends a lot of time advocating for the reading of classic books in general, which is not a proposition of which I need to be convinced.
I also think that he organized the book in a decent manner - why to read/how not to read/how to read/ Christian vs. Secular classics/here is a list. I don’t really have a problem with the book as a whole, but maybe some nitpicking in general.
Overall the book felt pretty vague, which is kind of odd, because he gave definitions, he introduced and summarized all his chapters, and was very organized and clear in general. Perhaps it was just toward the end, when he was talking about secular or anti-Christian classics and chose not to name any as examples. He did name some Christian classics, but just the most obvious ones - the Bible, for example, or Pilgrim’s Progess, or Paradise Lost. But as someone who has been working their way through a number of classics in the last few years, I am not sure if I could name an anti-Christian classic (I could name several anti-Christian books, but I wouldn’t also label them classics). Now I’m curious and have been left hanging.
I also appreciate how he extolled the virtues of the Bible as the ultimate classic, but I wish he would have done a little more to explain how best to read it. It is trustworthy and true, but lots of people have read it and come away confused or even interpreting it terribly. I understand that this in particular isn’t the purpose of Ryken’s book, but to not mention that and perhaps point to where one could learn more seems short sighted, especially when your audience would seem to be people who haven’t had much experience with literature or classics before.
There are other things, but that was my biggest issue. If I had a friend looking to learn more about why or how to read classics, I’m not sure this would be my first suggestion.