Five strangers step into a private capsule on the London Eye, but when it completes its rotation, all five are dead. Reverend Eve Brennan was supposed to be the sixth passenger, only a migraine kept her at home. The Secrets We Shared has such a solid setup, and I needed answers straight away. How the heck did this happen? Who killed whom? Talk about chaos at close quarters.
Given Eve’s narrow escape, she ends up working alongside the police and speaking to the people closest to each victim, hoping something in their lives might explain why they were all brought together. Getting to know each of them outside of that night, through the people who knew them best, was one of the more intriguing parts for me. There are plenty of details in their pasts that raise questions, but it does get quite busy once family members, partners and friends are added into the mix, and there were definitely times I had to stop and remind myself who belonged to who.
The middle does slow down a little as Eve goes from one person’s story to the next, and some of the backstories felt more detailed than I personally needed. The writing can be fairly descriptive at times too, although I did enjoy the changing locations, particularly Brighton, Newquay, Belfast and, of course, the London Eye itself, which helped give the investigation a broader feel.
The more we learn about Eve, the more obvious it becomes that she’s got her own can of worms waiting to be opened. There had to be a reason she was meant to be in that capsule too, so I was just as curious about what she was hiding as I was about what connected the five victims. I liked the way the book builds that web of lies around her past, especially with all the guilt, half-truths and things that have been kept buried for years.
Things really start flying once the bigger reveals kick in, and there is a lot packed into the last part of the book. A few things stretched believability for me, and it does get pretty tangled, but the story answers the questions it sets up. By the end, I knew why these people had been chosen and, most importantly, what really happened inside that London Eye capsule. Piecing it all together was half the fun, and even with a few wild turns, I thought the payoff was satisfying.
Thanks to BookSirens for providing me with a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.