Captain America gets the critically acclaimed Marvel Knights treatment! In the aftermath of 9/11, Captain America - already a man out of time - must adjust once again to a terrifying new global landscape. From the ruins of the World Trade Center to the horrors of a small town rocked by terrorism, the star-spangled super-soldier is forced to consider what it means to be the Sentinel of Liberty in an age of incomprehensible new threats. Meanwhile, the man named Redpath has his own American dream, and he orders his Extremists to cleanse the country by force. Only a true patriot, the living embodiment of the United States, can stop them.
Starts off really strong. In fact, the first 6 issues might have been the best 6 issues in Cap's history. The first issue where Cap deals with the aftermath of 9/11 is heart wrenching. The next story arc, Cap deals with terrorists on U.S. soil. He discovers a larger conspiracy that never gets resolved satisfactorily. Unfortunately, at this point something happened and the creative team of John Ney Rieber and John Cassaday left the book. Chuck Austin comes in and pretty much ruins everything Rieber was building towards. He starts up some nonsensical story about an old friend of his that gets wind powers. The last story brings in this back story about how Americans actually froze Cap in WWII.
Beautiful art and a decent story. Cap has always been one of my favorites and this set of comics asks some interesting questions only a Captain America comic could ask. The first set of books are my way better than the last set thus the 3 Stars.
This collection contains the first 4 story arcs in the Marvel Knights era of Captain America comics (which ran from 2002-2004). The first arc, Enemy, is about Captain America dealing with the aftermath of the 9/11 attacks and ties directly into the second arc Warlords. These six issues are the best of this era and set the tone for the rest of the Marvel Knights era of Cap facing the blurred lines of what's right and wrong with blind patriotism in the post 9/11 world. The other two story arcs (Extremeists and Ice) really suffer from a lack of cohesive narrative combined with an unique art style that is very well done while doing the confusing narrative no favors. The artwork in this collection is the real standout here, it's some of the best you'll see in any Captain America comic.
In a way, going from the prior Captain America comic to this one was like going from cartoons to live action, as this series started out with more realistic stories and art. But eventually the quality dropped a little, in story if not in art. It's not bad, but started out strong and then fizzled a bit.
I honestly can't believe anyone wouldn't find this incredibly relevant.
One of the ongoing dilemmas for Steve Rogers has always been that he is NOT a Boy Scout. He's the son of immigrants, and has always firmly clung to the ideals of what America *should* be and can be. Naive? Not at all. It doesn't mean he doesn't see where America goes wrong -- just the opposite. What it means is that he doesn't compromise those ideals...even when the way to uphold them becomes murkier and murkier thanks to today's society.
This isn't a two-dimensional portrayal of Steve Rogers blindly mouthing patriotic platitudes. In the beginning, he shares the grief everyone felt after the Towers fell, even as he works around the clock helping with rescue efforts. As the story goes on, however, he confronts the leader of a terrorist cell -- but also, the actions of our country, past and present, that have sparked such a level of hatred.
One of the things I like best about Steve Rogers is that while he holds the ideal of what *should* be in his mind, he is brutally honest about what is actually happening and stops at nothing to find the real truth. He is anything BUT a Boy Scout. What's more, although he has no compunction about jerking the powers that be back to their senses or holding feet to fires until he gets the truth, he never steps over the line into holier-than-thou territory. It's one of the many reasons Steve's my favorite comic character and likely always will be.
At his heart, Steve is, for all his power, a citizen and a soldier, nothing more. What he does do is what we should all do -- ask uncomfortable questions, stand against what we know to be wrong, and not allow ourselves to be lied or manipulated.
One final note: I'm actually very glad that Reiber drew in parallels with the firebombing of Dresden and how Steve viewed it differently after 9/11. Unavoidable as it was given the technology of the time, he's learning still that even in his day, things weren't as black and white as they appeared to be. If I had wished anything be included that wasn't, it would have been for Reiber to draw a parallel between the attack on New York City and that of Pearl Harbor, both of which Steve had seen.
A reprint from books written soon after 9/11. And yet these read as absolutely current and in a scary manner. In general I'm not a big fan of Captain America or Steve Rogers. He's too much of a boy scout, everything is cut and dry. But in this volume it works. I doubt that if I had read this back in 2002 I would have appreciated it as well. But at this point it is pretty clear that the US government not being the good guy in some manner is plausible. The art adds a lot to the story as well especially in shades of grey. The creators of this book clearly know and love the character, something I've come to expect from Marvel Knights.
Starts off very promising but the issues collected here run out of steam quickly. Captain America loses a lot of qualities that make him such a great character in this run. I think with better writing these themes could have been explored in a more interesting way. As it stands, this was overall a disappointing collection. Those first couple issues are really great, however.
One of the most powerful comics I’ve ever read. How I let this get by me originally, being such a big Captain America fan, I have no idea.
So more than halfway through, a new artist and author take over, and quite honestly their story is a bit mediocre. But, I don’t care, because Rieber and Cassaday produced absolute magic on their pages. From illustrations, to direction, to writing, everything is perfect. This isn’t just Captain America defending citizens, this is him questioning his world, his government. This is Captain America period. This is how he is meant to be written. He’s the symbol of us at our very best, and us as we try to be better than what we think we are capable of. It doesn’t matter that some other way might be easy, do what is right.
The first half of this is must read material for new and old Captain America fans.
This is by far the worst Captain America run I've read. It's hard to even know where to begin in this 16-issue collection that ultimately feels disjointed, disorienting, and succeeds only in derailing what could have been an interesting commentary on American politics into a directionless mess. The trade begins with "Enemy" and "Warlords," with Rogers literally picking up the pieces in the wreckage of the Twin Towers before running off to avert a series of terrorist attacks across the U.S. From there, it continues with "The Extremists" and concludes with "Ice," devolving into a convoluted fever dream that I can barely make sense of.
The first half of the book revolves heavily around issues in the political zeitgeist following 9/11: xenophobia, America's involvement in foreign regimes, and the military-industrial complex. Themes like these are perfect for Rogers—low-hanging fruit. Problems our boy in blue was made to tackle. But he doesn't. Each issue introduces a new crisis but never sees a real resolution aside from some preachy platitudes about war or freedom as Rogers effortlessly takes down enemy after enemy. A writer would have to put in effort to make these matters feel distant, dull, and devoid of humanity. You won't see Rogers defending an innocent family against Islamophobes, or comforting a soldier with PTSD, or trying to pacify the misguided anger of a grieving widow. There are merely hints of what could have been a poignant narrative that unfortunately culminated in a forgettable attempt at breaching issues beyond the writer's scope.
The latter half of the book is an anomaly. It starts with Rogers up against a rogue S.H.I.E.L.D. agent John Redcorn, who sends him on some kind of vision quest while he plots to destroy the world one spirit-tornado at a time because, uh, colonization, or something? This all connects, inexplicably, to mass-produced Bucky and Cap clones, an angry Native American storm god, a bargain-bin Atlantean version of Sharon Carter, the King of Atlantis, and Thor (’cause, well, why not at this point?). This confusing mess is compounded by the equally confounding art of Jae Lee. At first, I thought all of the characters looked like zombies with haggard expressions and wrinkled faces simply because Rogers was on a bad trip and having nightmares of sucking face with an 80-year-old Atlantean. But no. That is simply the photo-bashed style where every wrinkle and laugh line was traced without any discernment to the characters' actual ages. In terms of writing, Reiber continues to fill each speech bubble to the brim with exposition, trying desperately to make sense of his own convoluted plot, having characters blurt out summaries that span the entire page. Characters often speak in verse, as if they are delivering monologues instead of having real conversations, adding to the ungrounded and often didactic approach to Rogers' disillusionment with the country he swore to protect. I slogged through this cover to cover in the hopes that I would find something redeeming, but instead I was simply left astounded by how thoroughly this missed the mark. Reiber's Rogers feels at best pompously pontificating, and at worst indifferent, inhuman, and untouchable.
Marking this as spoilers even though none of it really matters to later Captain America. This is a really interesting, messy collection of comics. My understanding of some brief background is that this was a nightmare because 9/11 caused Rieber to completely change his plans causing the first arc to be written. By the time he got to actually writing what he originally planned to, editorial changed and he left the title passing what would be his original arc to Chuck Austen who also wrote the final arc in this collection. I’ll rate each arc separately:
The New Deal (1-6): This is by far the strongest arc in the collection and seems to be controversial to this day. The fact that it seems to have upset people on both sides of the post-9/11 aisle tells me it’s doing something interesting. Giving al Tariq a very grounded motivation for his actions, but having Cap maintain his ideals was bold for 2002. Cassaday’s art is consistent, and fairly easy to follow. Honestly, the only portion of this collection that I’d consider must read. 4 stars.
The Extremists (7-11): Feels very pre-9/11 with its government/SHIELD conspiracy, internal threat to cleansing America. I feel like most of this chunk slipped out of my brain almost as soon as I finished it. Jae Lee taking over art duties is the only upside, as his heavy use of shadow really works for a conspiracy thriller story. 2 stars.
Ice (12-16): This is a mess. A bold, pointless retcon of Captain America’s modern origin. The government intentionally froze Cap and implanted memories of his fateful plane adventure, so he couldn’t stop the US from using Nukes? What? And there is some weird stuff about an alien hand that attaches to a scientist and politicking from Lemuria. There are several heavy-handed monologues to the audience about things like sexual freedom, trust, and the illusion of freedom that clang within the context of the story. Jae Lee’s art is really the only positive. 1 star.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Edit 12/10: changed this some. *4.5 stars So this was mainly good, I loved the story, also that they mentioned Cap missing his old friend Bucky and looking sad about it.
Putting trigger warnings on this because: -contains post-9/11 content (I’ve heard of a lot of people being sensitive to this so adding just in case, that was an extraordinarily terrible event) -absolutely gruesome deaths (you need a tolerance of visual mature content for this to not make you nauseous) -some pretty graphic violent scenes (I’ve read at least a few comics before, more than the ones I logged on here, and this one was extra heavy on the violence)
So I wouldn’t recommend this unless you really like the character of Captain America. Also that if it won’t bother you too much to see him feeling emotionally beaten down and physically going through really hard times, since I did nearly cry at times and it takes me a lot to do that. There was a lot of character depth in this, and I liked that so, so much.
In una parola: Bellissimo. Il fatto che sia ambientato dopo l'11 Settembre lo rende assolutamente toccante - il volume si apre proprio con Cap che aiuta i pompieri a cercare le persone seppellite sotto le macerie delle Twin Towers - ma il merito va anche alla sceneggiatura molto introspettiva, che centra alla perfezione Steve Rogers, tutto quello che il personaggio è e rappresenta. Inoltre porta luce - non necessariamente positiva - a certi eventi che riguardano il risveglio di Capitan America dal ghiaccio e danno un po' più senso alla faccenda. I disegni sono spettacolari, specialmente nella prima parte del volume. Hanno un'aria maestosa, che Steve sia in costume o no, lo fa sembrare una statua celebrativa senza che appaia messo in posa. Trasudano autorità e un senso di cordoglio comune che in quel periodo ha colpito non solo l'America, ma tutto il mondo.
The art by Cassaday is good in some places, but for me this book just falls flat. I didn't much care about the story, or the art overall. Cassaday is a really good artist, but I mostly think if him as being a "Cover" artist. I just don't think he is able to show movement from panel to panel. Cap is a fighter and when I read hos adventures I want to get a sense of that movement, of him fighting a room full of people by being this unstoppable force. With Cassaday it all seems like Posters. Can't say I cared for Jae Lee on this book, either. His style just isn't a good match for Cap. Also, he made Cap look pretty skinny. The two storylines didn't interest me that much. I just couldn't get in to them. I also thought that Cap was coming off kind of Smug and Shitty when he was talking about how great America is supposed to be. It just reads kind of arrogant. Overall, not a very good book.
This started off really well. Coherent story. Awesome art. A heart wrenching tale of when Americas most patriotic soldier is not around at the 9/11 bombing. The guilt he feels is palpable.
Then we get into his moral code of honor and his code against killing. Then it starts getting weird. Clones. Magical native Americans. Hallucinogenic "bitters" and a Lemurian plot to trick him into killing someone. Did I mention clones?
Not to mention plot hole would could toss Jupiter through. And I'm not a huge fan of Jae Lee's art.
Aside from that ... An seriously great read.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
It starts with 9/11 which was ok. Nicely done, stark art and story. Ok. Good stuff for the time it was written in.
It ends with Cap fighting a Lemurian who speaks through his hand...I think...???
In between it's all antagonists I'd never heard of, and a plot line that has the U.S. government being responsible for the crash that takes him and Bucky out at the end of the war.
The whole Lemurian thing made ZERO sense to me. I suppose if I really wanted to figure it out I could re-read it...but I'm just not that interested.
Some nice art, but nothing else really grabbed me.
Captain America enters the war on terrorism What happens when the embodiment of America encounters the fuzzy grey world of modern warfare? Captain America shines a bright light on the unpleasantries that America has made itself comfortable with in the post 9/11 world
Soooo bad. The first story arc is a well intentioned but very bad reaction to 9/11, and then Chuck Austen comes in and the story becomes almost incomprehensible. None of the writers here seem to understand who Captain America is. These are some really bad comics.