Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Witch Among Us

Rate this book

"Witch Among Us is a magical, atmospheric story that feels like a beautiful, dark dream. With plenty of spine-tingling chills, twists and turns, and buried secrets to keep you guessing, this book will have you questioning everything you think you know, right along with Eliza. Absolutely perfect for fall and Spooky Season reading!" — Ginny Myers Sain, New York Times Bestselling Author of DARK AND SHALLOW LIES, SECRETS SO DEEP, ONE LAST BREATH, and WHEN THE BONES SING

"A darkly fun murder mystery with an impeccably witchy aesthetic and a big heart, WITCH AMONG US explores friendship and sisterhood, blending tragic historical connections with the unhealed pain of more recent trauma. Brutal yet cozy, it's a solid choice for anyone who dreams of Salem in autumn." — Jill Baguchinsky, Author of SO WITCHES WE BECAME and MAY THE DEAD KEEP YOU


Eliza Loft is a freshman at Salem State who just wants a normal college experience after spending her senior year of high school unmasking the monstrous serial killer who terrorized her small mountain town in Whitehall, NY. Unfortunately, her dreams of normalcy get dashed when a mysterious girl with eerily accurate knowledge about Eliza's past invites her to join a coven.

Guided by equal parts curiosity and the desire to understand the strange and increasingly premonitory dreams that have plagued her since arriving on campus, Eliza agrees to join, only for the coven's high priestess to turn up dead shortly afterward. As more members of the coven fall victim to mysterious illnesses, injuries, and threats on their life, Eliza is forced to overcome her past trauma and face her fears, unmasking yet another killer before it's too late, and she's the next to get burned at the stake.

The perfect book for anyone who loves a gripping thriller that's equal parts mystery and magic.

322 pages, Paperback

Published October 6, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

K.T. Carlisle

7 books47 followers
K.T. Carlisle is the pseudonym for a Vermont-based murder mystery writer. As far back as she can remember, Carlisle has dedicated her life to the written word. Earning her B.A. in Writing Arts with a concentration in Creative Writing in 2015 from Rowan University, Carlisle received the Excellence in Writing Arts Award. Out of more than 3,500 students, Carlisle was selected for the award based on her exceptional skill as a writer and teacher of writing.

After graduating from Rowan University, Carlisle briefly served as an intern for a literary agency in Manhattan where she was responsible for reviewing incoming submissions and passing them on to suitable agents. Later called westward to Salt Lake City, Carlisle was hired as a copywriter and editor, crafting various ghostwritten articles on behalf of prominent executives within Silicon Valley’s tech industry. Her work has appeared in publications such as Forbes, VentureBeat, Entrepreneur, Inc.com, and USA Today, to name a few.

In late 2018, Carlisle started her own marketing agency, specializing in copywriting, website development, and social media management. Since starting the niche agency, she has had the privilege of developing unique voices for small business owners all over the country, publishing thousands of webpages and blog articles each year.

When she is not busy crafting custom content for clients, Carlisle devotes all of her creative energy towards writing her next novel, as well as spending her days enjoying all the natural beauty that the Green Mountain State has to offer alongside her incredible husband, four crazy dogs, and flock of chickens.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
25 (78%)
4 stars
6 (18%)
3 stars
1 (3%)
2 stars
0 (0%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 28 of 28 reviews
Profile Image for Lori Alden Holuta.
Author 21 books74 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
August 26, 2026
Witch Among Us is a horrifying, yet surprisingly heartfelt spin on the classic "one of us is a killer" tale that will keep you guessing right up to the gasp-inducing conclusion.

The story takes place at Salem State and is told by newly-arrived Freshman Eliza Loft, in first person present tense, placing the reader right next to Eliza. We are privy to her feelings, fears, expectations, and confusion as she tries to make sense of all the events, clues, and people swirling around her.

I appreciate that the author is comfortable letting her characters show genuine affection for one another. Best friends regularly hold and comfort each other without any suggestion of sexual innuendo. This is a genuine, grounding force in light of all the horrific stuff going on.

The LGBT+ community is well represented. In fact, many types of diversity can be found in the large cast of characters. None of it feels as if it has been forced into view. Everyone simply experiences events as their authentic selves.

The author's done her homework regarding the history and practices of witchcraft. It's released into the story so effortlessly one might think that author is a witch herself. Is she? I don't know. Hmmm.

Much of the story is relayed through conversations among the teenagers. These aren't rushed. They play out in detail at a pace that feels real, yet never sinks into boring babble. The plot moves forward at a satisfying pace with each chapter revealing something new while advancing the plot. Clues, news, and events are given to us at every turn, making it fun to try to figure out who the murderer is. Did I manage that? Nope, I thought I knew who it was, but was quite impressed at the reveal.

The author's love of writing and word crafting is evident throughout the story. Her sentences are expertly, lovingly crafted. The mystery itself is well thought out. Tension builds slowly, there's plenty of surprises. Readers will be constantly on the verge of thinking they might have the mystery figured out, only to run headlong into yet another delicious twist.

Read this book in a dimly lit room, preferably with a cup of herbal tea or a deep red wine. Candles would be nice, but be mindful of open flames. It's probably not the best idea to start reading on a night when you need to get enough sleep for school or work the next day. And when the story is done, lean back, close your eyes, and think about those friends and family that are near and dear to you. Fling out a text to remind one of them that they are loved. Now that is not the takeaway you'd expect from a murder mystery, is it?
Profile Image for Camille Singer.
12 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 28, 2026
✨Huge thanks to K.T. for the ARC✨

Witch Among Us is a spooky, thrilling murder mystery that keeps you guessing until the end. 

"Because that’s the thing about sisterhood: We share everything. Grief. Guilt. Secrets. Lies."

The story begins with Eliza trying to overcome the trauma brought on by the events in book one. The plot kicks into gear when Eliza, who has premonitions, is invited to join a coven of witches...a typical experience for most college students, I'd imagine.

"Someone is trying to manipulate you."

Everything intensifies as Eliza struggles to deal with her past while trying to find her place in the present. And it all takes off when we get a glimpse behind the killer's eyes.

“There is no escape.”

First, Eliza. 

"I peer nervously around the room, trying to fight the urge to retreat into my dress like a turtle."

A charming, relatable character who was so fun to read about and follow. More than that, her trauma and self doubt sings on the page, really bringing her to life. 

"All this time, I thought I could keep the worst parts of myself protected, hidden where no one could see them."

Second, the mystery.

"Eight are alive. Seven more will die."

Honestly, what more needs to be said? A perfectly haunting and eerie threat that made me sit up and fly through the book. 

"Because for the first time, I'm not the only one who's scared. And that terrifies me more than anything." 

I really enjoyed this story. A perfectly spooky tale for autumn, complete with all the secrets and melodrama I desperately want from my YA mysteries. The second half had me absolutely hooked. I could not put it down. Not gonna lie, I'm a little upset I didn't get to experience this book on audio for my first read, because this is exactly the sort of story you want told to you. A dark, sinister voice in your ear just as the weather gets cold and the monsters start crawling out of the woods. 

Highly recommend!
Profile Image for Pranav Bhatnagar.
506 reviews5 followers
October 15, 2026
Witch Among Us by K.T. Carlisle was such an engaging mix of dark mystery, witchcraft, suspense, and emotional moments! Eliza Loft’s journey into the strange world of Salem and the Sisterhood of Salem immediately caught my attention. What begins as an attempt to find her place in a new environment slowly becomes something far more unsettling, especially as her disturbing dreams and unusual abilities begin to take on a deeper meaning. I loved the eerie atmosphere, the secrets surrounding the coven, and the feeling that there was always something hidden beneath the surface. Eliza is a compelling character because she is not fearless or certain of herself all the time. She carries grief, guilt, and the fear of being too late to save someone, which makes her struggles feel deeply human even as the supernatural elements grow darker. Her friendships and the people she learns to trust add warmth to a story filled with danger and uncertainty. The mystery kept me curious, and the increasingly tense events made it difficult to feel completely at ease. I also enjoyed how the book explores belonging, responsibility, loss, and the courage it takes to face things that seem bigger than yourself. The witchcraft and Salem setting give the story a distinctive identity, while the twists and unsettling moments keep the suspense alive. This is a great choice for readers who enjoy paranormal mysteries, secretive covens, supernatural abilities, and strong emotional stakes alongside their darker fantasy. I especially appreciated the sense that Eliza’s story is about more than discovering the truth; it is also about discovering her own strength. A wonderfully atmospheric read that kept me invested in the mystery and left me curious about what might come next.
Profile Image for Shida Ketzer.
Author 1 book17 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
August 30, 2026
Note: Though I received an ARC, this review & rating are my honest opinions & made voluntarily. I haven't yet finished the book & might add more thoughts here.

It hooked me from the start. The MC is very relatable, and I can feel her anxiety in my bones.
As a writer, it's not easy keeping oneself from constantly thinking of "how I'd write that differently." But it helps to know that the author fixes other writers' texts (grammar, style, word choice, etc.) for a living. It helps knowing there's more than one expert way to develop the prose. So I get to quell my internal editor, sit back, and enjoy the story... that is, if I wasn't already at the edge of my seat, biting my lips bloody as I (virtually) turn page after page, my heart pounding almost in my throat. Some run through a burning building to get their adrenaline pumping; I read K. T. Carlisle!
I went into reading this book knowing it had a prequel I hadn't read, knowing that s good author can make it work. And I was rewarded as the book sprinkles in vital info (which I should have learned had I read the first one), so the reader wouldn't get lost. It made me appreciate her work so much more that I'm reading the first book as soon as I finish this.

Favorite lines:

"....With my luck, I would’ve gotten paired up with some, like, cosplaying mega-nerd with a dead insect collection.”
“Don’t talk about my boyfriend like that.”

...the man who scarred me for life. Literally.

The yawning pines clawing at a smoke-filled sky. The flames licking at fishnet stockings bound to blackened tree trunks. The screaming. The cackling. The stench of death.
Profile Image for Karen Eisenbrey.
Author 27 books54 followers
September 8, 2026
If you’re looking for an eerie, witchy mystery for spooky season, be sure to grab this one.

Eliza Loft has traumas and losses in her recent past (if you want the details, read I Know What I Saw) that she’s dealing with by going away to college with her two best friends. Her thinking is so true to her age as a late teenager: I’m an adult now so I should be able to handle things on my own; I can’t share what’s happening because my friends will think I’m crazy. (Her attitude exasperated me while wringing my parent heart; classic college freshman.) Getting invited to join a coven of college witches freaks Eliza out and intrigues her in equal measure, especially when her premonitory nightmares draw her deep into a mystery concerning the sisterhood. I love how all of the sisters are plausible suspects and potential victims, with lots of clues and red herrings for Eliza and the reader to collect and follow. Through a cascade of perils and twists, Eliza tries and fails and tries again to prevent further harm even as she is bearing the burden of her own troubles. I think her friends Kate and Simon are saints for putting up with her, while helping with the investigation and providing most of the comic relief. These three are a fun team who deserve their own show.

I received an advance-reader ebook from the author.
57 reviews1 follower
October 1, 2026
Eliza is in her first year at college. Her best friend is her room mate and her boyfriend is in some of her classes. Everything should be perfect. But it’s not.

Crippling anxiety means she hasn’t left her room in 6 days. The reason? She was the last victim of the Beast that hunted girls in her home town. She managed to escape thanks to her boyfriend, Simon and her best friend, Kate. However she was stabbed in the stomach in the process.

Eliza and Simon had a podcast about the paranormal, which lead to her being targeted. She also has dreams that come true.

After not leaving her room for 6 days, Kate and Simon drag her to an org fair, where she meets Lizzie, a self declared witch from the Sisterhood of Salem, a coven of witches attending the college.

After being invited to join the Sisterhoods mixer, strange things start to happen and their high priestess is killed.

Eliza must learn to trust her dreams and save the Sisterhood so she doesn’t feel she’s to blame for not being able to save another life.

The twists and turns. Who is the murder and can they be stopped? A paranormal thriller with an ending I was not expecting!

Profile Image for Cassie Cooper.
Author 1 book6 followers
November 12, 2026
Witch Among Us is a thrilling murder mystery set in Salem, Massachusetts. It follows Eliza Loft as she attempts to lead a normal life as a college freshman at Salem State with her best friend Kate and her boyfriend Simon. After nearly being killed by a crazed murderer the year before, Eliza struggles to overcome her fears when she is invited to join the Sisterhood of Salem, a coven of practicing witches who are hiding a dangerous secret. When one of the sisters turns up dead, Eliza must overcome her fears and master her gift of dreaming about the future before the Sisterhood of Salem is no more.

__

This was a compelling read. I found myself picking it up every chance I got and telling myself "just one more chapter" despite having to get up at 6:15 am the next day. I thought I could see what was gonna happen next (channeling Eliza, of course) but time and time again, Carlisle subverted my expectations with a plot twist I didn't see coming. The story's conclusion was satisfying, but left me wanting just a little bit more. Perhaps a prequel about the early days of the Sisterhood of Salem? ;-)
Profile Image for booksy.tx.ana.
1,094 reviews11 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 29, 2026
Witches burn.
Eliza is now in college, seemingly moved past the terrors of the Sasquatch killer. But still, she’s plagued by nightmares now containing new horrors. This creates a new fearfulness and anxiety that permeates the pages. Eliza finally finds a group of witch-minded girls with whom she feels a connection. Her nightmares predict a killing; now she must do all she can to save others. Feeling Eliza’s apprehensions and desperation with every page turn and suspecting every new friend builds amazing suspicion and unease. Eliza’s friend and boyfriend create a safe space that feels healing in her time of questioning. A spookily crafted mystery that enchants you to the very end.

I don’t think it’s absolutely positively necessary to read “I Know What I Saw” first, but I do think it’ll help get to know the characters and Eliza’s traumatic history better.

Come read with me @booksy.tx.ana
ARC from author
Profile Image for Ashlee Tharman .
309 reviews9 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 6, 2026
**ARC REVIEW**

Eliza feels lost after everything that happened in the past year. Hoping for a new start, she starts college at Salem State and at the urging of a friend and her boyfriend, attends an activities fair where she meets the members of the Salem Sisterhood. Shortly after initiation, however, the dreams the plagued Eliza before return, followed by bad things happening to members of the Sisterhood. This time, Eliza is determined to figure out who is behind it all before its too late for anyone else.

As always, what an amazing story by Carlisle!! I am in love with her ability to give her readers a thriller that keeps us on the edge of our seats and begging to know more. I didnt figure out the true villain until about 85% of the way, and it was done so slyly and masterfully. I loved getting into Eliza's world, getting to know her and truly understand more about her. Amazing characters, fantastic story telling, and brilliant plot make this book the perfect Halloween read!
Profile Image for Tess  B Martin.
2 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 2, 2026
I received a free copy of this book from the author as an advanced reading copy.

In “A Witch Among Us,” K.T. Carlisle gives us that rare thing: a sequel that improves upon the original. The legacy characters are consistent and deeply explored, and the new characters are interesting and mysterious. Eliza is a relatable protagonist and the reader really gets to know her. Carlisle also does an admirable job keeping up both the suspense and the “who done it?” guessing game: at times implicating various people for the crimes in a believable way. I was happily along for the ride and occasionally nervous that one or another character I had become fond of—inordinately quickly—would be revealed as the killer. It’s four stars from me. It would be five, but I just can’t stand the romantic interest character. And that’s a personal problem. Nothing to do with the way the characters and story are crafted. So: definitely read it. If you haven’t read the first one you can still enjoy this one, but I recommend you also grab “I Know What I Saw” if you haven’t already.
Profile Image for Veronica Faline.
Author 3 books18 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 3, 2026
This book is such a great read! I was totally engrossed from beginning to end, I could not put it down. Eliza is such a relatable character and her story is so incredibly human. The mystery kept me guessing, everytime I thought I figured it out it would throw me for another loop! I loved the setting in Salem that gives the book an extra creepy vibe. It breaks the mold of your typical Witch story, turning preconceptions on their heads and breaking a lot of stereotypes along the way. It works as a fabulous follow up and as a stand alone story, either way you will be glad you picked it up. I highly recommend this for any fans of horror, fantasy, or thrillers.
98 reviews7 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 3, 2026
Another fantastic read by author K.T. Carlisle. This book is slightly heavier than the first in the series, but it is understandable as the main character is dealing with PTSD. That being said, it is handled remarkably well and you never feel bogged down by that fact. The story is lively and creative with endearing characters that keep you turning the pages to root for them.

This is also going to be an audiobook and I highly recommend you get your grubby little paws on that, because this is seriously good storytelling.

I don't normally read YA, but this is done in such a way that it would appeal to a wide age-bracket.
Profile Image for Lexi Heathermoor.
9 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 9, 2026
I was lucky enough to be invited as a beta reader on this book, and I honestly can't say enough good things about it. The tension, the suspense, the atmosphere, all packed in to a witchy Salem setting? It's the PERFECT book for spooky season while also being crammed full of twists and turns I delighted in attempting to sus out, the other elements (i.e. found family, a touch of romantic b plot, and a pleasantly surprising amount of evocative emotions) take this from being just another thriller/paranormal mystery and turn it into something spectacular. It's got everything you could ask for and more. I know personally, I'll be diving in for a reread as soon as my copy arrives.
Profile Image for Sarah Karasek.
Author 3 books14 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 15, 2026
It was such a joy to read an advanced copy of Witch Among Us. I don't typically read YA, but I love paranormal stuff and was especially drawn in by the college environment this book takes place in. It's a delightful witchy thriller/who-dunnit perfect for spooky season. For me, it was a great warm-up before I start moving on to scarier things as it gets closer to Samhain. Carlisle has a gift in weaving gorgeous descriptors into her prose, comparing voices to crisp autumn leaves and other such atmospheric treats. I would've been all about this in middle school.
Profile Image for Adele.
Author 21 books33 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 4, 2026
This is the 2nd part of a duology that can be read as a stand-alone. Having enjoyed the first one, I was really looking forward to this, and it did not disappoint. Such a fun read with lots of witchy wickedness, and I didn’t see the killer coming, which I love. My guess was way off! My only issue was how often Eliza reminded readers of the first book. It seemed like she was constantly referring back to her previous experience, and it got really distracting for me. I look forward to more K.T. Carlisle thrillers!

Thanks to the author for this ARC.
Profile Image for Dawn D. Bengel-Britten.
1 review
October 6, 2026
I haven't read the first in this series, I Know What I Saw. This edition to the series took care of that. Not knowing all the details, I gathered enough to get the gist.
This book immerses you in the college life of Eliza. She's dealing with trauma from the previous book, anxiety for the changes of college life, and a potential new trauma haunting her dreams.
No spoilers here, but definitely worth the read and makes you want to go back and read the first one to fully understand the depths of Eliza's trauma.
Profile Image for Sam Verba.
54 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
August 27, 2026
I had the opportunity to read this book early and I DEVOURED it in three days! I couldn’t stop. I ate, slept, dreamed, *lived* for what Eliza was going through. Such a brilliant follow up to I Know What I Saw, which I also adored. Such a wonderfully delightful cast of characters, I was so stoked to visit with them again and see what they were getting themselves into now. I can’t wait to get my physical copy of this book and add it to my self!
Profile Image for Alice Fleury.
194 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 10, 2026
I believed these teens were real. That this story could be non-fiction. And the story is written in first person present. I loved that. I didn't read the first book but it wasn't a problem reading this as a stand alone. The heroine refers to what happened before now. And it wasn't a problem enough for me to understand her fears and dread of what is happening now.

A spooky whodunnit for The haunting season.

Thank you KT Carlisle for trusting me as one of your readers.
3 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 3, 2026
Witches, Big foot, and a girl walk into the forest.... and this story is what they make. If you like books that make you want to stay up late reading pick this one up. The way this author writes just grabs your attention and doesn't let go. I was so pleasantly surprised by how entertaining and engaging this book is.
Profile Image for N.C. Madigan.
Author 6 books8 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 18, 2026
Review of an advanced copy received from Author.

Witch Among Us by K.T. Carlisle is a delight. This book is the perfect segue from summer beach reads to spooky-season thrillers.

K.T. Carlisle writes with such a clear, beautiful style that I have enjoyed since reading Reasonable. The way her characters' anxieties and emotions come through on the page is so wonderful. I felt close to Eliza throughout the novel and could feel and understand her pain. Some of the descriptions of Salem in the fall and the witchy sorority house helped form vivid pictures in my mind.

If you're ready to jump into spooky season with a witchy thriller, pick up Witch Among Us!
Profile Image for Chelsea  Lentz.
Author 4 books39 followers
October 23, 2026
Huge thank you to KT for the arc read for Witch Among Us!

There were so many parts of this book that had me literally at the EDGE OF MY SEAT! The prose was immaculate and beautifully written, and the craft of writing is so evident in KT! There were so many aspects of it that had me realizing that I had found representation in the characters.
Profile Image for Steve Hostetler.
24 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 19, 2026
This book is a must-read for fans of witchy thrillers. It's well written and easy to read for long stretches of time. The characters are believable, and the storyline holds your interest the entire way through. Think The Craft meets Pretty Little Liars.
Profile Image for Susie Kline.
121 reviews9 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 23, 2026
Please let there be more to this series! I love the characters. The storytelling is superb. Perfectly paced. I can’t say one bad thing about this book.

I did read the previous book (I Know what I Saw) first to catch up and that one is just as good.

Thank you for the ARC.
Author 3 books1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 30, 2026
So I was lucky enough to snag this book before release! I dont want to give any spoilers but if youre looking for a spooky fun amazing witch book for this fall! Look no further! Amazing read. Cant wait to read more of her work!
Profile Image for MK Allen.
5 reviews
October 20, 2026
SUCH A GREAT BOOK! My tween daughter and I share books, and this is one that we both agree on being one of our favorite reads of the year.
1 review
November 12, 2026
Really, really strong thriller-horror from KT Carlisle. This writer normally focusses on Y/A, but in the second of the Eliza Loft series, she has aged her characters - and her writing - up beautifully. It's unputdownable and addictive like all her books, but is also beautifully written in parts. For anyone interested in witchcraft , the Occult, or general Salem-type hi-jinks, this is a must.
84 reviews
October 20, 2026
WOW. I was rapidly reading as I couldn't put the book down. thank goodness that Eliza HAD dreams.

Profile Image for Trish A..
5 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
August 30, 2026
A “can’t put down” witchy YA mystery! Suspenseful story with the elements of sisterhood and friendship along with exploration of powers/growth in powers. Workable as a stand alone, but highly recommend reading “I Know What I Saw” to fully appreciate Eliza’s journey and the bonds of her relationships with Kate and Simon that continue to deepen as they experience their freshman college year in Salem. The author does an amazing job of showing the raw emotions and effects of experiencing trauma. The redemptive power of healing and emotional growth is central to Eliza’s journey to face her fears and learn how to trust herself as she works to save her friends and herself!
Displaying 1 - 28 of 28 reviews