~~From Red Adept Reviews~~
I received Déjà Vu, by Ian Hocking, as a review copy submitted to "Red Adept Reviews" by the author.
Overall: 5 Stars
Plot/Storyline: 4 3/4 Stars
This futuristic technothriller grabbed me right at the start--when Saskia Brandt's vacation memories, broken office A/C, and missing secretary conspired to tell me that there were, in fact, two entirely different beginnings to this novel: the one Saskia remembered, and the one she'd forgotten. Buckle in tight, Dorothy, because Kansas ain't just a memory...it never existed.
Implanted memories and personality erasure, and the ramifications thereof, make the concept of identity a strong theme in this book. Reality itself is called into question, through the search for lost identity and memory and by the creation of an AI world where reality is malleable. If you like Avatar or I, Robot or Battlestar Galactica (the reimagining), you'll enjoy this novel.
Any instance of time travel in a novel has the potential to wreak havoc on a plot's logic, and this one has a fair amount of time travel--or at least, its shadow. The book's science embraces the causal loop, which basically says that events can't be altered by going back in time...no matter what. The author did a fantastic job of keeping things interesting despite this predestination effect, though toward the climactic end a couple of near-death experiences traded believability for theory adherence. I only noticed one plot hole, when a password is found in a note, then later the same character goes back in time and writes the note for their past self to find in the future, and at no point other than in the first note does the character research or discover the password.
The terrible consequences of failure to protect Saskia's brain chip from damage, which she was informed of early on, felt overblown when the plot twisted once again and revealed a simple solution with no apparent downside. Though there could be a valid argument that the character who told her of the chip's fragility had every reason to lie, it still carried a whiff of deus ex machina.
The scene transitions are crisp and match the fast-paced tone. The writing is smart, leaving the reader to either keep up with the plot advances and twists or be constantly surprised. The end is similarly brilliant, leaving the reader with a handful of loose ends and some hints as to what sort of bow they'll form when Saskia is done with them.
Character Development: 5 Stars
Thanks to the twists and turns of erased identities and time travel, this book works its plot magic using surprisingly few characters. The alternate roles characters will assume are hardly predictable. I was kept guessing, but within a coherent world.
Saskia enjoys a metric ton (or rather, tonne, as Mr. Hocking is British) of character development during the course of the story, since she begins from a point that's worse off than a blank slate: the little she knows about her current life is a lie. As the plot progresses, she worries who she truly is, and if she'll be lost to the resurfacing of her body's violent personality. By the end, she's far outstripped everyone else in complexity and sheer awesomeness.
David Proctor, the other main character, has a completely different set of issues. Instead of learning about his present circumstances during the course of the book, his plot focuses more on revealing what has already happened to him in the past, and what that means for his future, if he has one. As a researcher with a beloved, estranged daughter and a secret of his own, he made for fascinating reading.
Beckmann, Saskia's employer, was deliciously sociopathic, making me wonder if he had a base personality too, and if it had bled through, or if he was just "following orders". Jenny Proctor, David's genius daughter, seemed to add more dimension to David than she kept for herself, probably due to being mentioned as a child in David's thoughts and memories at least as often as she had scenes as an adult scientist. Jago and McWhirter, Hartfield and Bruce added rich background to the story, each in their own way. Bruce was a favorite of mine, for going native and embracing his lust for life.
Writing Style: 5 Stars
Every scene is a good houseguest: it arrives only at your request and leaves before you're tired of its company. Mr. Hocking's descriptions and turns of phrase are delightful. His sentences are crisp and tight. Dialogue was intelligent and minimalistic, giving it a futuristic, snappy feel. The use of key phrases in Saskia's search for her true identity--Shakespeare, Greek myths--forms an irresistible trail of bread crumbs for the reader and Saskia alike, leading us through the mystery of the present and into the shadow of the past, without giving away their true importance until the very end. A truly delightful reading experience.
Editing: 4 3/4 Stars
Along with a nauseous/nauseated mixup and changing a minor character's name by one letter partway through the story, I discovered a handful of missing words.