While I absolutely fell in love with Hannah in Summer Circuit, Winter Circuit left much to be desired. Hannah is no longer in Vermont; she's in college now and away from Chris. The self-assured woman I felt she had become in Summer Circuit was long gone in Winter Circuit. This Hannah was just a shell, she had become so insecure. Instead of being excited that she has this gorgeous guy in love with her, she spends almost the entire book trying to figure out what makes her so special. Why her? It just dragged on too much for my comfort. Instead of being in wonder, she was agonizing so much she needed a counselor. All of her sessions focused on Chris, who talked to her absolutely whenever he could, while working on his career. Instead of her doing the same thing with college, she just clammed up and obsessed over his ex, whom he has zero interest in rekindling things with. I would have loved to see her characterization grow from how much of a strong ending Summer Circuit was. In one part of the book, a trainer had asked her if she was on the riding team at her college. Why wouldn't Hannah sign up for something like that? After falling in love with the process in Vermont, I would have thought that would be something she would have instantly looked for at her college. It just didn't make sense to me. I still devoured the book, I just grew to not like the person Hannah had become. Something else that was different from the first is I felt like this one was a little less centered around horses. Definitely OK, there are still a lot of horses! But there's no need to learn the process that Hannah had previously learned before. I just missed her learning to ride better (which is why I would have loved to have read about her joining the school team). Besides Hannah, all of the other characters are wonderful. Dakota, the girl Hannah is hired to look after, is a riot. It's still an enjoyable read and I can't wait for the next one--heard it'll be about Zoe this time around.